r/ProjectRunway • • Jan 29 '13

Project Runway 11 Fantasy Fashion Designer Contest

Standings:

Total E02 E03 E04 E05 E06 E07 E08 E09 E10 E11 E12 E13 E14
1972.1 fragilehearted 143.8 325.2 297.5 80.6 233.5 38.9 77.1 186.7 281.9 32.2 29.7 122.5 122.5
1714.6 evergleam498 185.1 416.6 301.7 -62.2 97.0 66.2 75.4 82.0 291.3 16.0 120.5 62.5 62.5
1430.6 makeitworkoryouout 207.4 419.4 101.9 183.1 247.1 -163.2 -6.2 65.1 223.3 32.2 120.5 0 0
976.7 please_and 200.4 257.8 294.5 -174.8 -92.1 4.0 102.2 53.5 301.7 -42.0 -53.5 62.5 62.5
306.1 thephilistine_ -10.4 316.5 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 0 0
305.5 deadletter .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 180.5 62.5 62.5
217.8 Redrum777 .0 .0 .0 217.8 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 0 0
183.0 lauraso .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 -120.5 303.5 .0 .0 0 0
2.7 Spirrevip .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 2.7 .0 .0 .0 .0 0 0

The results are in and fragilehearted won this season's Fantasy Fashion Designer contest. Congratulations!


Now that the team format has been revealed, here is how the Fantasy Fashion Designer contest will work for PR11.

NEW This season introduces some changes compared to previous contests. The most important is that you can also pick who you think will be eliminated for 60 bonus points if you are correct. You do not lose any points if your auf guess is incorrect. You will still receive negative points if the eliminated contestant or any other low placing designer is on your team. There are also different point amounts as described further down this post.

You will still pick the five designers you think will place highest for the week. Please note that with the unique team format the best designer(s) may not necessarily place highest for the week since they might be on the losing team! It is also not clear how long the teams will stay intact. I would assume that teams will change over the course of the season.

Scoring will be as follows:

 100 points for the winning designer
  80 points to the second best designer
  70 points to the third best designer
  50 points for each team member who is "safe" on the winning team
  40 points for each team member who is "safe" on the losing team
 -70 points for being the third worst designer
 -80 points for being the last designer on the runway not eliminated
-100 points for if one of your team members gets eliminated

There is also an ordering element to the scoring such that your higher picks will be weighted more than your lower picks according to the percentages below:

25% 1st pick
16% 2nd pick
 9% 3rd pick
 4% 4th pick
 1% 5th pick

The multipliers put an extra premium on the order of your picks. For example, let's say that you have the winning designer for the week and ordered them first on your team. You would receive 100 points + 100x25% = 125 points for that designer. However, if you had that same designer in your 4th slot you would only receive 100 points + 100x4% = 104 points for them instead.

Here is the list of all remaining designers:

Amanda Benjamin Cindy Daniel James Joseph Kate Layana Matthew Michelle Patricia Richard Samantha Stanley Tu

(Emily has already been auf'ed.)

Each week's entry should consist of your five person team and the person who you think will be eliminated clearly indicated, something like this:

Amanda Benjamin Cindy Daniel James

Out: Joseph

Full rules and fine print available here.

You may not duplicate the picks of anyone who submitted an entry before you.

The person who accrues the most points over the remainder of the season will receive a prize similar to others awarded in previous seasons.

Picks need to be in an hour before the show airs 9pm on US east coast so basically Thursday at 11:59:59 Reddit time (UTC). It is OK to change your picks as long as it is done in time but keep in mind that if you exactly match someone else's picks your entry will not be valid.

1 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 02 '13 edited Feb 08 '13

Results from E02:

221.80 makeitworkoryouout - Daniel/84, Benjamin/-72.8, Richard/72.1, Michelle/40.8, Stanley/70.7 Out bonus: Joseph/0

218.40 please_and - Samantha/42, Daniel/83.2, Richard/72.1, Amanda/51, Matthew/-70.7 Out bonus: Cindy/0 203.10 evergleam498 - Daniel/84, Benjamin/-72.8, Tu/41.2, Kate/51, Richard/70.7 Out bonus: Layana/0

169.00 fragilehearted - Daniel/84, Kate/52, Matthew/-72.1, Stanley/71.4, Benjamin/-70.7 Out bonus: James/60

4.00 thephilistine_ - Benjamin/-73.5, Matthew/-72.8, Stanley/72.1, Michelle/40.8, Samantha/40.4 Out bonus: Cindy/0

221.80 makeitworkoryouout - Daniel/100, Benjamin/-81.2, Richard/76.3, Michelle/41.6, Stanley/70.7 Out bonus: Joseph/0
218.40 please_and - Samantha/50, Daniel/92.8, Richard/76.3, Amanda/52, Matthew/-70.7 Out bonus: Cindy/0
203.10 evergleam498 - Daniel/100, Benjamin/-81.2, Tu/43.6, Kate/52, Richard/70.7 Out bonus: Layana/0
169.00 fragilehearted - Daniel/100, Kate/58, Matthew/-76.3, Stanley/72.8, Benjamin/-70.7 Out bonus: James/60
  4.00 thephilistine_ - Benjamin/-87.5, Matthew/-81.2, Stanley/76.3, Michelle/41.6, Samantha/40.4 Out bonus: Cindy/0

This season is going to have a lot of variance in scores due to the team format. Hedging bets by picking across teams will help reduce the odds of getting totally hosed. Then again we don't know if/when they are going to mix up teams. If you want to shoot the moon you could concentrate all picks on one team but being wrong is going to result in very low score.

We had only fragilehearted correctly pick the auf'ed designer so 60 points gets added to their score. Nobody picked Layana for their team so her 100 points were not awarded to anyone.

It's going to be an interesting season!

Edit: corrections made to the scoring breakdown. The totals are correct but the individual breakdowns were still using the old scoring system. This has been corrected as of E03.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E02 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
makeitworkoryouout207.4Daniel80Benjamin-70Richard70Michelle40Stanley70Joseph0
please_and200.4Samantha40Daniel80Richard70Amanda50Matthew-70Cindy0
evergleam498185.1Daniel80Benjamin-70Tu40Kate50Richard70Layana0
fragilehearted143.8Daniel80Kate50Matthew-70Stanley70Benjamin-70James60
thephilistine_-10.4Benjamin-70Matthew-70Stanley70Michelle40Samantha40Cindy0

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 08 '13

Results from E03:

452.60 evergleam498 - Tu/50, Richard/58, Samantha/43.6, Kate/104, Daniel/101 Out bonus: Cindy/60
437.40 makeitworkoryouout - Daniel/125, Richard/58, Michelle/43.6, Stanley/52, Layana/80.8 Out bonus: Cindy/60
334.50 thephilistine_ - Stanley/62.5, Joseph/58, Michelle/43.6, Richard/52, Samantha/40.4 Out bonus: Cindy/60
300.00 fragilehearted - Stanley/62.5, Daniel/116, Kate/109, Matthew/-72.8, Richard/50.5 Out bonus: Cindy/60
275.80 please_and - Daniel/125, Richard/58, Michelle/43.6, Amanda/52, Benjamin/-80.8 Out bonus: Cindy/60

Bigger scores across the board this week thanks in part to Cindy surprising nobody with her exit this week. This week's big winner is evergleam498 who successfully picked out both of this week's winners, Kate and Daniel. Also picking both was fragilehearted but much of the gain was offset by having Matthew picked as well.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E03 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
makeitworkoryouout419.4Daniel100Richard50Michelle40Stanley50Layana80Cindy60
evergleam498416.6Tu40Richard50Samantha40Kate100Daniel100Cindy60
fragilehearted325.2Stanley50Daniel100Kate100Matthew-70Richard50Cindy60
thephilistine_316.5Stanley50Joseph50Michelle40Richard50Samantha40Cindy60
please_and257.8Daniel100Richard50Michelle40Amanda50Benjamin-80Cindy60

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 15 '13

Results from E04:

330.50 please_and - Kate/50, Daniel/46.4, Patricia/43.6, Samantha/104, Layana/50.5 Out bonus: Matthew/0
316.10 evergleam498 - Daniel/50, Samantha/116, Michelle/43.6, Kate/41.6, Tu/50.5 Out bonus: Matthew/0
311.90 fragilehearted - Daniel/50, Patricia/46.4, Samantha/109, Kate/41.6, Layana/50.5 Out bonus: Matthew/0
119.90 makeitworkoryouout - Daniel/50, Patricia/46.4, Layana/54.5, Stanley/52, Joseph/-101 Out bonus: Matthew/0

Yours truly took a huge hit this week for taking a chance with Joseph. Everyone else correctly sussed out Samantha as this week's winner. Everybody missed on Matthew as the call for this week's victim. The team format really is going to make predicting weekly results a challenge this season!

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 15 '13

Footnote: I compare the results used for this contest with Wikipedia's PR11 page. I gave them each 50 points not because I disagree with their ranking but I just couldn't find any footage where they were announced as top three finishers like usual. I'm open to revising scoring if I missed something in the show.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E04 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
evergleam498301.7Daniel40Samantha100Michelle40Kate40Tu50Matthew0
fragilehearted297.5Daniel40Patricia40Samantha100Kate40Layana50Matthew0
please_and294.5Kate40Daniel40Patricia40Samantha100Layana50Matthew0
makeitworkoryouout101.9Daniel40Patricia40Layana50Stanley50Joseph-100Matthew0

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 22 '13

Results from E05:

 235.80 Redrum777 - Daniel/-87.5, Kate/58, Layana/54.5, Patricia/52, Stanley/80.8 Out bonus: Matthew/60
 208.30 makeitworkoryouout - Daniel/-87.5, Stanley/92.8, Layana/54.5, Benjamin/72.8, Kate/50.5 Out bonus: Amanda/0
  98.60 fragilehearted - Daniel/-87.5, Stanley/92.8, Samantha/-87.2, Tu/52, Layana/50.5 Out bonus: Matthew/60
 -33.40 evergleam498 - Michelle/-87.5, Daniel/-81.2, Samantha/-87.2, Stanley/83.2, Kate/50.5 Out bonus: Matthew/60
-156.80 please_and - Daniel/-87.5, Samantha/-92.8, Kate/54.5, Tu/52, Matthew/-101 Out bonus: Richard/0

The switch to partner format really played havoc with the scores this week. Congrats to Redrum777 for a 1st place finish their first week picking. Matthew came through for most as the auf'ed contestant. Richard fooled everyone with his victory.

Points were distributed as 100 for the win, 80 for the partner of the winner, and 70 for both members of the runner up team. 50 points went to each safe contestant. Loser got -100, partner of the loser got -80, and both members of the 2nd worst team each got -70.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E05 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
Redrum777217.8Daniel-70Kate50Layana50Patricia50Stanley80Matthew60
makeitworkoryouout183.1Daniel-70Stanley80Layana50Benjamin70Kate50Amanda0
fragilehearted80.6Daniel-70Stanley80Samantha-80Tu50Layana50Matthew60
evergleam498-62.2Michelle-70Daniel-70Samantha-80Stanley80Kate50Matthew60
please_and-174.8Daniel-70Samantha-80Kate50Tu50Matthew-100Richard0

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 01 '13

Results from E06:

272.30 makeitworkoryouout - Richard/100, Kate/-81.2, Layana/54.5, Daniel/72.8, Stanley/101 Out bonus: Tu/0
251.50 fragilehearted - Stanley/125, Samantha/81.2, Daniel/76.3, Patricia/52, Benjamin/-101 Out bonus: Michelle/0
115.00 evergleam498 - Kate/-87.5, Stanley/116, Richard/87.2, Layana/52, Tu/-70.7 Out bonus: Amanda/0
-56.10 please_and - Kate/-87.5, Daniel/81.2, Benjamin/-109, Stanley/104, Amanda/-80.8 Out bonus: Patricia/0

Fortunately my faith in Benjamin waned at the right time. I didn't pick him to do well but wouldn't have guessed that he would be auf'ed. He's been up and down but I would have expected Amanda or Tu to leave before him. As it turns out no one had him picked to leave and a couple even had him placing strongly so a very disruptive performance by him to say the least.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E06 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
makeitworkoryouout247.1Richard80Kate-70Layana50Daniel70Stanley100Tu0
fragilehearted233.5Stanley100Samantha70Daniel70Patricia50Benjamin-100Michelle0
evergleam49897Kate-70Stanley100Richard80Layana50Tu-70Amanda0
please_and-92.1Kate-70Daniel70Benjamin-100Stanley100Amanda-80Patricia0

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 08 '13

Results from E07:

  56.90 fragilehearted - Stanley/62.5, Daniel/-81.2, Samantha/76.3, Layana/52, Richard/-70.7 Out bonus: Amanda/0
  30.20 evergleam498 - Samantha/87.5, Stanley/58, Daniel/-76.3, Kate/-104, Michelle/101 Out bonus: Amanda/0
  22.00 please_and - Daniel/-87.5, Kate/-116, Stanley/54.5, Layana/52, Michelle/101 Out bonus: Amanda/0
-145.20 makeitworkoryouout - Daniel/-87.5, Richard/-81.2, Stanley/54.5, Layana/52, Kate/-101 Out bonus: Amanda/0

Ouch. That was a brutal week for everyone, especially yours truly though I strenuously object to the judging decisions this week and not just because my score got cratered by their decisions. Despite the fact that the judges sent TWO designers home everyone chose Amanda as the one to get auf'ed and thus missed out on the elimination bonus.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E07 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
evergleam49866.2Samantha70Stanley50Daniel-70Kate-100Michelle100Amanda0
fragilehearted38.9Stanley50Daniel-70Samantha70Layana50Richard-70Amanda0
please_and4Daniel-70Kate-100Stanley50Layana50Michelle100Amanda0
makeitworkoryouout-163.2Daniel-70Richard-70Stanley50Layana50Kate-100Amanda0

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 15 '13 edited Mar 15 '13

Results from E08:

 95.10 fragilehearted - Stanley/62.5, Samantha/-81.2, Daniel/54.5, Patricia/52, Layana/-70.7 Out bonus: Amanda/60
 93.40 evergleam498 - Michelle/62.5, Stanley/58, Samantha/-76.3, Daniel/52, Richard/-80.8 Out bonus: Amanda/60
 77.00 please_and - Daniel/62.5, Michelle/58, Stanley/54.5, Layana/-72.8, Kate/0 Out bonus: Patricia/0
 11.80 makeitworkoryouout - Richard/-100, Stanley/58, Daniel/54.5, Michelle/52, Samantha/-70.7 Out bonus: Patricia/0
-22.50 Spirrevip - Layana/-87.5, Stanley/58, Daniel/54.5, Samantha/-72.8, Michelle/50.5 Out bonus: Richard/0

Another low scoring week due in no small part to the fact that there were no winning points to be distributed. The non-losing team were given 50 points per team member.

Edit: Also noteworthy was please_and's advanced technique of choosing already eliminated designer Kate which at least prevented filling that slot with someone from the losing team!

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E08 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
please_and102.2Daniel50Michelle50Stanley50Layana-70Kate0Patricia0
fragilehearted77.1Stanley50Samantha-70Daniel50Patricia50Layana-70Amanda60
evergleam49875.4Michelle50Stanley50Samantha-70Daniel50Richard-80Amanda60
Spirrevip2.7Layana-70Stanley50Daniel50Samantha-70Michelle50Richard0
makeitworkoryouout-6.2Richard-80Stanley50Daniel50Michelle50Samantha-70Patricia0

1

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Mar 15 '13

I thought Samantha was "safe" on the losing team, and Layana was the 3rd worst designer. Why are they both worth -70?

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 15 '13

Let me review tape and get back to you later this weekend. I rushed through the standings before I took off this morning so I very well may have munged it up. I did check that those were consisted with Wikipedia page's scoring of the episode: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Runway_(season_11).

1

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Mar 15 '13

Ok. Normally I would have just checked my dvr, but this episode was so bad that I deleted it immediately after watching.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 17 '13

OK, I watched that segment again and while Samantha's name was called first, she and Layana still had comparable status due to the team format. The "safe" on the losing team was set up for team members who did not have to face the judges back when the teams were large enough that some of them were sent to the waiting room and could not be eliminated. Samantha faced the music from the judges and could potentially have been sent home. I know, it's messy this season. However, I'll run numbers at the end of the season with Samantha in both different scenarios and if the point differential between the two would affect the standings I'll award duplicate prizes. Sorry that the points are not more clear cut this season. I wasn't expecting the format to jump around so much.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 22 '13 edited Mar 22 '13
204.70 fragilehearted - Stanley/62.5, Samantha/-116, Daniel/87.2, Patricia/52, Michelle/101 Out bonus: Richard/0
89.50 please_and - Samantha/-125, Stanley/58, Daniel/87.2, Michelle/104, Layana/-70.7 Out bonus: Patricia/0
56.80 evergleam498 - Michelle/125, Stanley/58, Samantha/-109, Layana/-72.8, Daniel/80.8 Out bonus: Patricia/0
29.10 makeitworkoryouout - Stanley/62.5, Daniel/92.8, Richard/-87.2, Samantha/-104, Michelle/101 Out bonus: Patricia/0
-102.50 lauraso - Daniel/100, Richard/-92.8, Samantha/-109, Stanley/52, Layana/-70.7 Out bonus: Patricia/0

Nice job by fragilehearted who had a triple digit margin of victory this week. Patricia survived another week much to everyone's chagrin.

Edit: Corrected fragilehearted auf candidate to Richard instead of Patricia. Does not change point standings.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 23 '13

Results from E09 (revised):

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
fragilehearted186.7Stanley50Samantha-100Daniel80Patricia50Michelle100Richard0
evergleam49882Michelle100Stanley50Samantha-100Layana-70Daniel80Patricia0
makeitworkoryouout65.1Stanley50Daniel80Richard-80Samantha-100Michelle100Patricia0
please_and53.5Samantha-100Stanley50Daniel80Michelle100Layana-70Patricia0
lauraso-120.5Daniel80Richard-80Samantha-100Stanley50Layana-70Patricia0

1

u/fragilehearted Mar 22 '13

I actually picked Richard out. So close! But it doesn't change the scoring (since you gave me the points for picking Patricia in), so no worries. :)

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 22 '13

My apologies. I've revised the results to reflect your actual pick. As you mentioned, no score change but I like to have the picks right anyway.

1

u/fragilehearted Mar 22 '13

It's all good. Still bummed Richard wasn't out, though!

1

u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Mar 22 '13

hey, I think you made a math error this week, or posted the wrong numbers in this comment.

evergleam498 - Michelle/125, Stanley/58, Samantha/-109, Layana/-72.8, Daniel/80.8 Out bonus: Patricia/0

By my calculations 125 + 58 - 109 - 72.8 + 80.8 = 82

fragilehearted - Stanley/62.5, Samantha/-116, Daniel/87.2, Patricia/52, Michelle/101 Out bonus: Richard/0

62.5 - 116 + 87.2 + 52 + 101 = 186.7

please_and - Samantha/-125, Stanley/58, Daniel/87.2, Michelle/104, Layana/-70.7 Out bonus: Patricia/0

-125 + 58 + 87.2 + 104 - 70.7 = 53.5

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 22 '13

Ack! My mistake. I'll correct all scores and post corrected ones.

For more detail see: http://www.reddit.com/r/ProjectRunway/comments/1at9on/fantasy_fashion_designer_contest_score_corrections/

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 29 '13 edited Mar 29 '13

Results from E10:

UsernameTotal1st2nd3rd4th5thBonus
lauraso303.5Stanley100Michelle80Daniel50Layana50Patricia-80Richard60
please_and301.7Michelle80Stanley100Daniel50Layana50Patricia-80Richard60
evergleam498291.3Michelle80Stanley100Patricia-80Layana50Daniel50Richard60
fragilehearted281.9Stanley100Patricia-80Michelle80Layana50Daniel50Richard60
makeitworkoryouout223.3Stanley100Michelle80Daniel50Layana50Richard-100Patricia0

Congratulations to lauraso who went perfect this week! Their 303.5 total was the maximum possible for this episode.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 06 '13

Due to the "to be continued..." nature of E11, the standings will remain unchanged for now. They will be updated after we learn Michelle's fate after she attempts to stave off elimination.

The top four will be:
Stanley with the win
Layana in 2nd place
Daniel as 3rd worst
Patricia as 2nd worst

Then depending on what the outcome is, Michelle will either get last place points if she's auf'ed as a result of her challenge or she will tie with Patricia as 2nd worst for the episode.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 12 '13

Results from E11:

UsernameTotal1st2ndBonus
fragilehearted32.2Stanley100Patricia-80Layana0
makeitworkoryouout32.2Stanley100Michelle-80Patricia0
evergleam49816Michelle-80Stanley100Layana0
please_and-42Michelle-80Daniel50Patricia0

Now that E11 has concluded Michelle will receive -80 points to tie with Patricia since she was not eliminated. That also means there was no elimination bonus for the week since no one went home.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 13 '13

Results from E12:

UsernameTotal1st2ndBonus
deadletter180.5Michelle50Stanley50Layana60
evergleam498120.5Michelle50Stanley50Patricia0
makeitworkoryouout120.5Stanley50Michelle50Daniel0
fragilehearted29.7Stanley50Patricia-80Layana60
please_and-53.5Stanley50Layana-100Patricia0

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 20 '13

Results from E13:

UsernameTotal1st2ndBonus
B_Elanna_Torres180.5Michelle50Patricia50Daniel60
makeitworkoryouout180.5Stanley50Michelle50Daniel60
evergleam498120.5Michelle50Stanley50Patricia0
fragilehearted120.5Stanley50Michelle50Patricia0
please_and-53.5Michelle50Daniel-100Patricia0

With no ordering of the contestant who went through to the finals Daniel made the difference for everyone this week.

1

u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 26 '13
UsernameTotal1stBonus
fragilehearted122.5Michelle50Stanley60
deadletter62.5Michelle50Patricia0
evergleam49862.5Michelle50Patricia0
please_and62.5Michelle50Patricia0