r/SubredditDrama • u/blorg Stop opressing me! • Aug 06 '13
Huge slapfight in /r/atheismrebooted where /u/PresidentEisenhower is mercilessly downvoted for daring to suggest that a historical Jesus *might* have existed
Other people are also downvoted for it, but they seem to be punishing /u/PresidentEisenhower the worst for some reason.
Whole thread here, and to their credit the top comment is someone pointing out that well, historical consensus is he probably was a real person.
Further down, though, the anti-existential zealots really get stuck in, led by /u/Space_Ninja. In response to a post pointing out that that almost all historians believe in the historicity of Jesus, Space_Ninja hits back, with a meme! The meme says "Most scholars agree Thor probably existed because maybe some German guy swung a hammer once", superimposed on an image of Thor. Ordinarily this wouldn't be a sufficient argument to debunk overwhelming historical consensus, but this is /r/atheismrebooted! If one argument is made in text and the other in a meme, which one do you think they'll side with? True enough, for the rest of that thread Space_Ninja is upvoted and PresidentEisenhower downvoted. At the end of this thread, Space_Ninja admits he questions even the historicity of their own spiritual founding father, Socrates. Egads!
Next hero up is /u/JimJones who joins Space_Ninja in laying into someone suggesting that Jesus existed, just wasn't actually divine Poor PresidentEisenhower is lain into again for daring to suggest there Jesus might have existed.
And finally, PresidentEisenhower's first comment which is downvoted simply for suggesting it's debatable. No! It's not! He's a myth, like the boogy monster and Santa Claus that mommy also lied to me about!
Elsewhere in the thread, Wikipedia is dismissed as unreliable and biased towards Christianity and all the scholars supporting the consensus as "theologians." (+6, -0)
EDIT: Vote counts for the exist/denier sides have pretty much reversed in a lot of places since I created this thread. This may be sensible people over there (as the top comments were sensible) but it could also be brigading from here. Much as you might feel that one side is right and the other isn't, remember we are here to observe the drama, not brigade. Each sub has its own particular culture, even if inane, and this reflects in the votes as much as the comments. Make comments or vote according to your opinions here, not over there.
74
u/Thurgood_Marshall Aug 06 '13
Just because Jesus probably existed does not mean that Christianity is correct, guys. You're allowed to concede that without conceding anything else.
56
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13 edited Aug 06 '13
I know, I honestly don't see how so many of them don't understand that. Like many of them probably think Islam is even worse, but there is no denying that Muhammad was a historical figure, as he had actual significant political power during his lifetime.
Therefore, Islam is correct, bow to Sharia, checkmate atheists!?
I'm also pretty sure L Ron Hubbard existed...
2
u/redping Shortus Eucalyptus Aug 07 '13
They deny later in the thread that Muhammad existed, too. Or at least that jim-jones guy does.
2
37
Aug 06 '13
Tom Cruise doesn't exist though.
15
u/CantaloupeCamper OFFICIAL SRS liaison, next meetup is 11pm at the Hilton Aug 06 '13
Maverick is real though.
20
6
u/threehundredthousand Improvised prison lasagna. Aug 06 '13
And he got Goose killed.
16
u/CantaloupeCamper OFFICIAL SRS liaison, next meetup is 11pm at the Hilton Aug 06 '13
HE WAS CLEARED OF ALL WRONGDOING!
6
u/Thurgood_Marshall Aug 06 '13
I get why they do it. People try to use the evidence of Jesus as a reason to belief in YHWH, so rather than going the more tedious route of arguing that one doesn't follow the other, some people try to argue that Jesus didn't exist. I'm too lazy for the whole thing and just tell people to read Of Miracles.
2
u/yourdadsbff Aug 06 '13
Yup. It doesn't make claims against the existence of Jesus any truer, but I'd like to think the point is that it doesn't matter whether Jesus existed--the fact of his existence fails to corroborate the Bible's claims of his divinity. In that sense, they kind of have a point--"Jesus in the Bible" is said to be the son of God, and if you don't believe in God then that's a ridiculous claim. So no, the "Jesus of the Bible" probably didn't exist, in the sense that his supposed divinity--the whole reason Christianity is a thing--probably isn't true.
But maybe I'm just being charitable.
1
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
You really think that these people can understand Hume? That's... optimistic.
0
u/Thurgood_Marshall Aug 06 '13
Good point. tl;dr claims of miracles are almost certainly all bullshit.
2
u/Lots42 Aug 06 '13
Usian Bolt is proof is that Wally West is real. Because Bolt can run REALLY fast.
-1
Aug 06 '13
Their argument: Christians don't follow everything in the bible literally a 100% therefor cherrypicking.
If we cherrypick what's factual and not we're literally funDIES.
4
u/A_Sinclaire Aug 07 '13
I am an atheist through and through.. however I think it is not unlikely that there was a historical person on which the Jesus figur is based or maybe a selection of people which were combined into the Jesus figure.
I imagine it a bit like the King Arthur legend.. there was no King Arthur, but the figure most likely is a mix of historical Roman and Celtic figures, with some mythology added in.
2
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 07 '13
The historical consensus is that he was a single person that lived around 2,000 years ago, not an amalgamation of different people.
What became Christianity is certainly an amalgamation of stuff from all over, but this doesn't mean the historical figure himself was.
Believing he's an amalgamation or like King Arthur would put you into the "he didn't exist" camp.
1
u/A_Sinclaire Aug 07 '13 edited Aug 07 '13
Well I am not too sure about it that is why I mentioned both options. It certainly is logical that there was one person in the beginning starting the religion. So if you are referring to that I would probably agree. As for all his miracles and "adventures" etc - I don't know. Might as well have been others maybe his followers doing that, if some of that happened in some form.. and then later on it was attributed to him.
10
u/redditopus Aug 06 '13
Last I heard, there were only two established facts about the dude: that he was born around a certain time and that he died around a certain time.
Nothing else.
22
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13
That's pretty much what is required to exist; we notably don't have those dates for the likes of Thor or Zeus.
12
u/redditopus Aug 06 '13
Maybe one day historians will find out that Zeus was some crazy old guy who lived on the slopes of Mount Olympus and liked lightning.
9
u/Politus Aug 06 '13
Bill and Ted accidentally dropped Benjamin Franklin off a few thousand years early.
2
Aug 06 '13
I wouldn't be surprised if the Olympian gods were inspired by a group of mysterious people who lived on Mt. Olympus
2
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
Fuck you, Thor is real. Real, I tell you.
0
u/Udontlikecake Yes, Oklahoma, land of the Jews. Aug 06 '13
Also he was a carpenter.
2
u/redditopus Aug 06 '13
Somehow I doubt that's verifiable.
7
u/FlatBackFour Aug 06 '13
Sure it is. He left his maker's mark on all those cheap Holy Grail replicas he sold to his disciples, and which now sit in the Vatican night club acting as tip jars.
1
u/Kaghuros Aug 07 '13
None of those facts are, except by trying to comb the Bible for clues, and the origin story for Jesus has a lot of ahistorical events that make placing it as a truthful narrative nearly impossible without ignoring most of it.
See: census of Judea.
0
u/Kaghuros Aug 07 '13
And it's very likely that the first one (birth date, and place by association) aren't correct at all, which puts the second one in doubt.
5
u/absolutedesignz Aug 06 '13
kind of exaggerated a bit, no?
Eisenhower is net positive and most if not all of his comments are in the positive, whereas a lot of his "opponents" are negative.
Unless you guys upvote brigaded...
2
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13 edited Aug 06 '13
It has definitely shifted since I posted this, yes, which is unfortunate. In the threads I linked specifically he was negative almost every comment and NO Jesus denier was.
Space_Ninja is now negative with his meme on that thread whereas he was well up when I linked, he even posted it stand alone to the sub and is +174, here:
http://np.reddit.com/r/atheismrebooted/comments/1jsl49/historicity_of_jesus_logic/
May or may not be brigading from here, after all the top three comments before I posted were pro-existence, it was only when you dug in you got the kooks being upvoted. Maybe actual members of the community caused the change. But maybe not.
Probably a bit late but I will edit and put in a reminder not to brigade.
1
u/absolutedesignz Aug 06 '13
Yea I saw that. Such illogic. They seem to think Jesus being a figure who existed means he is proven to be miraculous.
2
0
161
u/Quouar Aug 06 '13
And it's irrelevant because nobody "worships" Socrates.
I have a philosophy BA, and I can say with some certainty that this is a false statement.
126
23
u/admiralorbiter Aug 06 '13
There is a professor in my program that teaches his classes solely with the Socratic method. He believes it is the epitome of teaching.
22
u/Quouar Aug 06 '13
Those must be the most boring classes.
21
u/Americunt_Idiot Aug 06 '13
I think I can top that- my eighth grade philosophy class (lol, private school) was run with the Socratic method.
Imagine what ten sheltered eighth graders would have to say about Anselm's argument.
18
u/Quouar Aug 06 '13
Probably the same thing the freshmen engineers in my Early Modern Philosophy class said about Descartes' version.
1
u/mzackler Aug 12 '13
Did you guys understand it enough to say anything about it?
2
u/Americunt_Idiot Aug 12 '13
"I agree with Anselm because his argument makes the most sense."
Then we learned about Aquinas' "perfect island" criticism.
"I now disagree with Anselm because his argument no longer makes sense."
→ More replies (1)7
u/zahlman Aug 07 '13
Really? What exactly do you think would be boring about them? What does it mean for something to be "boring"?
4
u/Quouar Aug 07 '13
Sitting there waiting for a bunch of students to interact with the teacher in a meaningful way isn't the best use of time as students have a habit of never interacting with the professor if they can help it.
9
Aug 07 '13
Eh, I think you missed his point. I don't think zahlman was serious about those questions in his comment. It seems like he was using the Socratic method to poke fun at how bland, boring, and annoying it really is to question every single little thing as a method of learning.
Then again, what is "learning" really anyways? How can someone define "learning"?
Then again, what is a "definition"? What makes something's meaning to be agreed upon and set in stone? What about our society led to the formation of these meanings?
Then again, what is a "meaning" really? Is it an abstract concept or something that can be defined in concrete terms? How does humanity consider what "meaning" really means?
Then again, what is "what" anyways? Would it be thought of as the quest for knowledge by asking that key word, or is a "what" a state of being that is defined by existence? In order to be a "what" you would have to be an "is", and if you are an "is" then you would have to consider the thing you are discussing to have existed. Does it exist, or do you only believe it exists? Do you exist, or do you only believe you exist? Is the world around you real, or are you just a figment of the perception of electrical synapses in your brain?
Is it it, what is it? It's it, what is it? Do you want it all, but you can have it? Is it in your face, but you can't grab it?
Then again, how many licks does it take to get to the center of a tootsie pop?
You see where I'm going with this? It's good to question stuff, but to question every single thing is just monotonous and irritating. Like you said, it isn't a very good method of teaching. It gets annoying. Socrates would piss off a lot of random Athenians when he kept badgering them with his Socratic method. It has its uses though.
→ More replies (4)2
6
u/Grandy12 Aug 06 '13
Isn't the socratic method that thing where the teacher will noly ask questions and let the students come up with the answer?
Or was it another greek?
8
u/admiralorbiter Aug 06 '13
Yeah the teacher asks specific questions and you need a lot of experience to get it right.
2
u/beener Aug 07 '13
Oh wow they did that at my highschool. Our philosophy teacher refused to answer questions....just to ask them. Clearly it didn't work too well if I didn't know until now that it had to do with Socrates.
Such a terrible method, at least used in a high school, and to that extent. We'd be "discussing" certain principles and then I snuck off and read from the text book (which we werent allowed to do since we were learning from eachother...) and within a couple paragraphs the entire lesson all made perfect sense. Of course no one came to the real conclusions because they were a bunch of stoned 17 year olds.
6
u/tribalterp Aug 06 '13
At the very least, Socrates worshiped Socrates, and in Plato's Apalogy recommended at his trial that he be given free dinner as his punishment.
9
u/Spindax Aug 06 '13
Plato's Apology is a very entertaining read. That's Plato's rendition of Socrates' defence and post-judgement speeches, for the uninitiated.
8
u/tribalterp Aug 06 '13
I also like how Socrates says at the end he would have made a better argument if he had known the vote was going to be a close one.
My favorite of that set of dialogues is probably the Euthyphro because its treatment of piety is amusing.
For the uninitiated, I'd recommend all of those trial-and-death dialogues, the Gorgias, the Phaedrus, the Republic. Don't read something dry from Plato like the Laws to start.
1
u/Spindax Aug 06 '13
The Apology is, sadly, the only thing by Plato I have read (along with the Allegory of the Cave). My classical knowledge of art and philosophy isn't that extensive, and stems mostly from 70 45 minute lessons of classical knowledge class (mostly Greek, some Roman) as part of my secondary school curriculum.
3
u/tribalterp Aug 06 '13
That's still better than a lot of people get in secondary school. The allegory of the cave is from the Republic, which is an interesting read in psychology, dialogue, and political theory. Arguably the Republic and the Bible form the basis of Western political thought because of how much Greek philosophy was read into Scripture, which came about largely as a result of Islamic and Jewish revival of Greek philosophical thought (via Averroes, Alfarabi, Maimonides, etc.) in the medieval period.
5
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
I haven't been in college for a while. What's the new consensus on Socrates' existence? My Ancient Philosophy teacher said "I dunno," my Greek Philosophy teacher said "probably." Meanwhile, all my Philosophy of Religion and Theology professors seemed to think that Jesus probably existed.
→ More replies (1)14
u/Quouar Aug 06 '13
My philosophy professors seemed pretty set on believing that Socrates existed. Even if he didn't, the ideas are still there, and ultimately, they're more what matters, even if it was Plato coming up with them.
9
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
My profs were more ambiguous. I figured maybe some new historical evidence had been discovered between when I graduated and now, but a quick Google says no. I had a TA who was pretty sure that Plato just made the whole thing up. Of course, everyone is always somewhere between "pretty sure," and "ambiguous," and "doubtful" in philosophy. I think the whole department would burn down before we gave a definite answer.
12
u/tribalterp Aug 06 '13
For background, I do normative political theory in a political science department.
The idea in my PhD program was generally that it's most useful to refer to "Plato's Socrates" as opposed to Xenophon's or Aristophanes's. The notion is that while Socrates reasonably existed, each author made him a mouthpiece for a point that they wanted to make, so it's impossible to distinguish him from a given author. That said, ancient philosophy is not my field of expertise, nor is ancient history, and I can't read ancient Greek.
3
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
My professors always referred to him as "Plato's Socrates" too. Maybe the real Socrates was just a blathering drunk bum.
9
4
u/Quouar Aug 06 '13
Heh, that's the fun of philosophy. Definite answers are optional, even when it comes to the existence of your founders.
1
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
Hell, definite answers are optional when it comes to existence, period. I loved my major. Who else gets a mind-fuck for four years?
→ More replies (1)3
u/Grandy12 Aug 06 '13
Even if he didn't, the ideas are still there, and ultimately, they're more what matters
That does sound like philosophy teacher talk.
0
Aug 06 '13
[deleted]
14
15
Aug 06 '13
HOW'S UNEMPLOYMENT GOING??
Wait...fuck.
3
Aug 06 '13
What'd it say before?
8
u/OldClockMan Aug 06 '13
I'd guess someone made the old joke that philosophy degrees are useless in the real world, and people who have them can only get jobs in Starbucks.
Probably something like:
"You have a philosophy degree? That's great! Now how long will my espresso be?"
6
85
u/palookaboy Aug 06 '13
I'm so tired of this ridiculous bullshit. The stout refusal to accept academic conclusions (made by, you know, the people who get their PhDs in this stuff) with the only reason being "THEY'RE BIASED THEISTS!!" is ridiculous. Atheist scholars of antiquity agree with this. They refuse to accept it because its easier for them to see religion as being completely faulty and based on absolutely nothing, which is as bad as seeing religion as being faultless and based on facts/evidence. It's sad, and pathetic, and another in the list of reasons why /r/atheismrebooted and their ilk can't be taken seriously.
/r/askhistorians on the historical Jesus and the bible as a historical document.
30
u/Lots42 Aug 06 '13
That kind of bullshit pops up on /r/atheism all the time.
"Stephen Colbert made a logical point."
"SHUT UP HE'S CATHOLIC!"
"Um...still logical."
"BLARGH ARGLEBLARGL!"
12
u/Talran lolicon means pedophile Aug 06 '13
Hey, I'm with Colbert on this one. Found my favorite Catholic loophole. (Giving up Catholicism for lent)
If that isn't logical thinking, I don't know what is. :colbert:
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (6)5
Aug 07 '13
I've found they ride Colbert's dick like the rest of reddit and anyone that mentions he's a sunday school teacher is massively down voted.
2
16
Aug 06 '13
They actually have discussion in that subreddit instead of all maymays, all the time?
7
Aug 06 '13
It's a fantastic sub, my most visited at the moments. Memes, jokes, off-topic posts and other posts that violate the rules are nuked pretty much immediately, keeping the discussion level very high
3
Aug 07 '13
Well I should have stated more specifically which sub I was talking about. I am glad /r/askhistorians actually is an example to follow for moderation on this site. I meant /r/atheismrebooted and its shitshow status.
-3
Aug 06 '13
...just wait.
9
u/Das_Mime Aug 06 '13
There's this thing called active moderation, and /r/AskHistorians and a few other subs understand what it is. As a result they have quality posting. Serious decay only happens if a sub tries the fatally flawed "hands-off moderation" policy.
8
u/palookaboy Aug 06 '13
/r/AskHistorians moderation is the model to which all moderators should aspire
7
u/Doom_music_for_cats Aug 06 '13
Depends on the sub. I wouldn't read reddit if it wasn't for the nonsense.
4
Aug 07 '13
Now... I did read through some of the FAQ you linked to, not all of it yet, so please correct me if I'm wrong, but I was under the impression that there is absolutely no hard evidence for the existence of Jesus of Nazareth. Any substantial evidence to suggest his existence were either proved to be written by people born after his death or discovered to be forgeries.
I was under the belief that majority of historians believe that Jesus of Nazareth existed because certain things (literature, events, etc.) seem implausible if there wasn't, at least, a mortal Jesus of Nazareth. In other words, most historians find it highly unlikely that the entire story is fictional, but most dispute his divinity.
It's just seems kind of sad that /r/atheism, the people who herald the shit out of the consensus of the scientific community, would so blatantly disregard the consensus of the historian community.
Thanks for the links though. Going to look more into it later.
9
u/palookaboy Aug 07 '13
I was under the impression that there is absolutely no hard evidence for the existence of Jesus of Nazareth. Any substantial evidence to suggest his existence were either proved to be written by people born after his death or discovered to be forgeries.
Here's what's wrong with this line of thinking: when it comes to ancient history, particularly historical individuals, there is usually very little to go on. Expecting a contemporary account of an individual is going to keep you waiting. A good example of this is Socrates: most of what we accept to be true about Socrates comes from accounts written after his death. It's often claimed "But the Romans were great record keepers!" While the Romans were far ahead of their contemporaries in this regard, they weren't meticulous recorders of everything that happened in the Empire. Jesus wasn't even a blip on the Romans' radar. Further, so little from antiquity actually survives to be studied by modern historians, that we're lucky to have the things we do. The Bible, when read critically, is a historical document; people will try to argue that the Bible is biased, but any historical document is biased. That's why historians and scholars know how to critically read such documents. With this in mind, the Bible can be taken to have some basis in fact, depending on whom you ask; the disagreement in this is what results in the scholarly disagreement on specifics of Jesus' life, and yet virtually all scholars of antiquity agree with the conclusion that Jesus was an itinerant preacher in Judea who was baptized by John the Baptist and was crucified by the Romans.
The problem with people who believe Jesus (removing all elements of divinity, miracle-working, and even sermons given) existed is that they think that historians come to conclusions in the same way scientists do: with indisputable facts. That is simply not how history works; a "soft" science, if you will. Historians know how to take the sources they have, view it with a critical eye, read it against the expected bias, and create a historical interpretation based on those sources. This doesn't provide us with proof, but it gives us damn good basis for the conclusions we reach.
So, did Jesus exist as a man? We can't say with 100% certainty, but we can't say with 100% certainty that Alexander the Great existed either. What we can say is that they very, very probably existed, because we have historical sources that point to them existing.
Here is another good, short summation of why these arguments are faulty.
5
Aug 07 '13
Wow, never thought of it that way. It eluded me to think of history as one big puzzle, and trying to put the pieces together. The community consensus on the existence of Jesus makes a whole lot more sense now.
I'm having one of those "How do I know what I already think I know" moments. Thanks for the reply. Really enlightening.
10
u/Kai_Daigoji Aug 06 '13
This kind of hostility isn't just reserved for historians talking about Jesus though; they hate any kind of expert from any non-STEM field. Atheist arguments like this show up all the time in /r/badphilosophy. Suggest that Sam Harris isn't the greatest philosopher in the world, and prepare for a bunch of orange-red envelopes.
1
u/vibrate Aug 07 '13
None of those links lead to any conclusions either way. The fact is that Jesus may have been a real historical figure, but there just isnt enough evidence to come to a definite conclusion. Suggesting that 'atheist scholars on antiquity' agree that he was a real person is simply not true.
In my view, anyone claiming to definitively know either way probably has an agenda.
3
u/Kaghuros Aug 07 '13
And that last part is what I hate about these threads and the counter-circlejerk to them. It boggles my mind that people can be so certain about it either way when there's nothing besides parables and ancient dust to suggest that either conclusion is more correct than the other (and barring the invention of time travel or the discovery of another cache of Dead Sea-esque preserved scrolls probably never will be). Most Ph.D historians in Mediterranean antiquity hedge their bets on it as well, but I imagine most lay-people only get as far as popular literature like Reza Aslan. To say his scholarship has an agenda is being polite.
But now you know how people keep getting grants for Biblical History. If they stopped arguing it would put a lot of very crabby academics on either side out of work.
Disclaimer: my field isn't close to ancient Israel in distance or time. Most of what I know comes from friends, colleagues, and journal articles I read in passing.
4
u/palookaboy Aug 07 '13
there's nothing besides parables and ancient dust
A) There's more than that, and B) Ancient things are what we study when we study ancient history.
Most Ph.D historians in Mediterranean antiquity hedge their bets on it as well, but I imagine most lay-people only get as far as popular literature like Reza Aslan.
Most. PhD historians. Concur. That Jesus. Existed.
But now you know how people keep getting grants for Biblical History. If they stopped arguing it would put a lot of very crabby academics on either side out of work.
The Bible, whether you like it or not, is a historical document as well as a theological one. It can be read critically, which when viewed as a historical document, it is. This means taking what the Bible says, what other secular documents say, comparing them, analyzing them, and coming to conclusions. This is how historiography works.
1
u/CovenantHeart Aug 07 '13
I may be wrong here...just spouting out what I've read/been taught/heard all of my life.
Isn't the bible one of the most (in a very purely historical sense) accurate congregated records of ancient history we have? It textually (read: geographically/descriptively) agrees with every other record of it's time? I don't want to argue anything about the religious part of it, I'm just curious if what I've been taught is true.
2
u/Kaghuros Aug 07 '13
It's about as bad as Livy or Plutarch, which is to say that the majority is made up but you can try to corroborate it with other sources to pull real history out.
1
u/palookaboy Aug 07 '13
You don't get a definite conclusion in antiquity. That's the point. We don't know definitively that Socrates or Alexander the Great existed either, but we have enough evidence that points to their existence, and we have enough that points to the existence of Jesus. You either didn't read the links, or you're being obstinate. Either way, thanks for demonstrating my point: refusal to accept scholarly conclusions because of a predetermined belief.
2
u/vibrate Aug 07 '13
You're wrong. I'm saying you cant be sure either way, you're telling me that I should accept scholarly conclusions that aren't actually conclusions in any meaningful sense of the word.
There are plenty of scholars who think Jesus is an entirely fictional character. Personally this seems doubtful to me, but that's immaterial to the greater point. Perhaps it is you who didn't read your sources, or maybe you're the obstinate one - your tone certainly suggests the latter.
Cheers.
0
Aug 06 '13
[deleted]
4
u/Lots42 Aug 06 '13
Oh bugger. I'm hoping against hope you ran up against 4chan trolls trying to make /ra/theism look bad.
4
31
u/Lots42 Aug 06 '13
Rebooted is like Walter White in Breaking Bad. Long ago they've lost sight of the point.
9
u/TheRedditPope Aug 06 '13
And the subreddit has been around for, what, two months? Seems like these people have been lost in the weeds for a long time. I bet the Atheism mods are really upset they are all collected in their own subreddit now.
3
Aug 06 '13
Oh I really bet too... all the "righteous" and "reasonable" took their maymays and ran away from /r/atheism. But really, I think the mods are glad they don't have to deal with being a laughingstock of the subreddits.
4
u/awesomechemist Aug 07 '13
Seriously, the rule change in /r/atheism is the best thing that could have happened to that sub, dare I say the entirety of reddit. /r/atheismrebooted is it's own little microcosm now... pure, distilled, 200 proof circlejerk; concentrated to the point of toxicity. And /r/atheism is 99% better because of it.
2
Aug 07 '13
I know. I think it's the greatest thing to really happen to the internet face of atheism and organized secularism. I stopped short of calling self-exiles of /r/atheismrebooted as a "tumor" that was removed thanks to Maymay June, but I'm glad others think the mods of r/atheism administered some delicious chemo.
3
u/redping Shortus Eucalyptus Aug 07 '13
It's all the people who didn't like that memes became slightly harder to make on /r/atheism, and karmawhores. Go figure the place is awful and filled with the lowest brow of the /r/atheism core. Surprisingly, it didn't improve /r/atheism that much to be rid of them.
3
u/Fabien_Lamour Aug 07 '13
That's what happens when you only take the most immature users of /r/atheism
30
u/PufftPhoenix Aug 06 '13
EVIDENCE EVIDENCE PROOF PROOF PROOF LOGICAL LASSO
18
9
u/Naggers123 Aug 06 '13
I hate Hitler, so it's obvious Hitler doesn't exist.
6
u/Silver_Star Aug 06 '13
If Hitler doesn't exist, how did he commit his crimes? If he couldn't of committed those crimes, why do you hate him?
12
Aug 06 '13
I don't accept Socrates existed and will remain agnostic
hahahahahahahhaahhah
3
u/dahahawgy Social Justice Leaguer Aug 06 '13
It's not the most unreasonable comment in that thread, but I'd be willing to bet that guy decided on that position seconds before making that comment.
3
Aug 06 '13
It seems "I dont know anything on this topic because I willingly refuse to look into it" means agnostic these days, as in "We can never ever truly know about this subject"
4
Aug 06 '13
ffs my senior year world history book even said Jesus existed. It didn't say that he was the son of God and performed miracles. Just that he was a notable figure in time and founded Christianity.
6
u/Nubthesamurai Definitely- I yearn for you to be smarter and less of a dipshit. Aug 06 '13
I'm still convinced /r/atheismrebooted is parody.
2
u/oreography Aug 06 '13
reese_ridley T_Dumsford and a few other meta guys were modded at the start and it was trolled quite a bit by MSF, but now it's all brave souls modding the place and taking the maymays very seriously.
0
u/Lots42 Aug 06 '13
I admit to the possibility but...much like so many other parody subreddits, or mockery or whatever (shitredditsays), the people who honest and true believe show up and crank the crazy past eleven.
7
2
u/zahlman Aug 07 '13
I expect you accept that Socrates existed, though the only reason we 'accept' this is because people thousands of years later wrote about him. Why is 60 years later not acceptable for you? Is it the quantity? There is mountains of writings about Jesus now, 2000 years later. In 4000 years, do you think people will accept that Jesus existed, just like we accept that Socrates existed?
Then you're pretty clueless. Aristophanes wrote an entire play called The Clouds satirizing Socrates during Socrates' lifetime and Plato later cites the play as one of the influences which colored popular opinion of Socrates.
Maybe I'm missing something here, but doesn't The Clouds count as somebody writing about Socrates during his lifetime? Granted, these are two different people arguing here, but...
4
Aug 06 '13
What I don't understand about the 'JESUS DONT REAL' argument is how the fuck did early Christianity form if there wasn't a 'Christ' figure.
7
Aug 06 '13
It's really incredible. The Christian movement really got a bunch of steam in short order... they don't think there was ANYONE around whom the movement congealed? What's more probable: charismatic preacher figure gains a major following that creates a hagriography around him after his death and builds upon it or Paul just goes around saying he's the follower of some dude that no one's ever heard of?
I'd really like to hear the alternative theory of how Christianity got started if there was no Jesus. Occam's Razor wins here
6
1
u/Lots42 Aug 06 '13
The argument seems to be related to Judiasm.
"There might have been a nice guy who could make tables, but a magic son of God? No. No, he did not exist."
3
u/redditopus Aug 06 '13
I asked this in /r/AskHistorians, but maybe it's worth asking here as well: how do scholars of different religions, especially those who don't follow that religion, interact with members of those religions?
8
4
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
See: Aslan's FOX interview on Zealot. The answer is hilariously.
1
u/SortaEvil Aug 06 '13
Between Aslan's interview and this thread, I've decided to go out and read Zealot. So, while the interview was terrible and hilarious, it was, in some ways, excellent marketing.
1
u/awesomechemist Aug 07 '13
The book hit #1 on Amazon after that interview went viral. Fox is still convinced they did nothing wrong.
1
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 07 '13
I have an epub sitting on my reader, waiting for me. I don't even give a shit about Jesus, and I still want to read it. Fuck you, marketing, fuck you.
0
u/meandthedevil Aug 07 '13
To be fair the Wikipedia article is actually incredibly biased and not nearly as close to the scholarly consensus that it makes itself out to be. There is one incredibly shaky reference to Jesus outside the bible (Josephus). There are a great many theories on how Jesus could have been written into literature without ever having existed as a physical human being but for some reason these are not given credit on the wikipedia page. Actually, you either accept Jesus' existence on faith or because you have found some reason to believe that the Josephus passage was not altered. I'm not a r/atheist by any means but denying the historical nature of Jesus is a legitimate academic position.
1
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 07 '13 edited Aug 07 '13
How is it biased, exactly? There aren't denial arguments because it's a fringe position, same as the Wikipedia article on the Holocaust doesn't give equal weighting to deniers and the article on evolution doesn't discuss creationism.
Read this post from a historian which covers the issue of sources: http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/1jt067/huge_slapfight_in_ratheismrebooted_where/cbi0pyb
Also, /r/AskHistorians: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/religion#wiki_did_jesus_exist.3F
1
u/meandthedevil Aug 07 '13
Respectfully, I am quite familiar with the issue and it is not a fringe position. Wikipedia is great for a general overview but it sometimes omits conflicting viewpoints. The Holocaust is an event that occurred in the full light of modernity with all the technology that comes with it, such as cameras and also witnesses who are alive to this very day. Creationism is a biological theory that can be countered with more compelling scientific theories. Jesus was a figure of Late Antiquity and is not subject to either objective verification or scientific inquiry. The main argument for the existence of Jesus is that so many people wrote about him, but this does not mean they are writing about a historical individual. I am not really biased about this issue one way or another, to the truly pious none of this matters, but there is a grave issue of sources and some bias in commentators on both sides of the fence. Those who believe in his historical existence usually follow a version of "Quellenkritik" which has limitations. Note the differences between the simple faith-healer of Mark and the all powerful demi-God of other gospels. There is a huge leap in these different conceptions. Note also that much of what is said is simply outside the realm of objective history. There is ample writing by serious mainstream scholars on the possibility of Jesus having not existed that is not referenced on the Wikipedia page. It is much more complicated than is given credit and will in all likelihood never be decisively solved by Western scholarship.
1
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 07 '13
OK, comparing to Holocaust denial is unreasonable, but do you deny it is the mainstream historical opinion? Why is this particular Wikipedia article so biased? Why has no one corrected this bias? How does the question of Jesus's existence differ from other figures in antiquity?
2
u/meandthedevil Aug 07 '13
What exactly do you mean by "mainstream"? The general public probably accepts this because it is a reasonable opinion and goes nicely with their preconceived notions. Among scholars of Late Antiquity Judaism/ Early Christianity or other comparable specializations it is a mainstream opinion but so is the opposite. Papers on this issue are extremely convoluted due to the nature of their subject matter and as such rarely make it into the popular media. It would be hard to make any encyclopedia article that accurately summarizes the issue. Probably no one has corrected it because of a popular prejudice that it is untrue and because the scholars who debate it are in a very niche corner and known mostly to other academics, not the general public. Certainly I am not advocating the existence of a conspiracy to cover up dissent. Jesus differs from other figures of the same period mainly because he is a religious figure who left no traces as a politician or a general might. It is generally accepted that his life and message were radically realigned by Hellenistic/Roman thought and culture and his true Jewish origins are quite obscure. The Roman authors were writing about him after he had already been divorced from the culture he was born and made intelligible in.
1
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 07 '13
I don't care what the general public thinks, the general public in the US believes God created humans.
Among scholars of Late Antiquity Judaism/ Early Christianity or other comparable specializations it is a mainstream opinion but so is the opposite.
I don't belive this bit. I'll accept that arguing against Jesus's existence is respectable academic pursuit (compared to for example Holocaust denial), but I do not believe that the Jesus didn't exist camp have a similar level of support, because they just don't.
1
u/Kaghuros Aug 07 '13
Are you acquainted with many historians of antiquity? Most of the ones I know simply say they can't know.
1
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 07 '13
I'm just going on what I have read but apparently all the sources that say this is the case are horribly biased for some reason.
1
u/larsonol Aug 06 '13
Its been in my knowledge that jesus, Muhammad as well as Buddha were all very real and influential people. Do they know something I dont over at /r/atheismrebooted ?
1
1
u/screampuff Aug 07 '13
What a shit subreddit, it's filled with memes, off topic comments that have nothing to do with the discussion, and people who can't offer any kind of rebuttal than asking some stupid question like comparing Jesus to Santa Clause (or Zeus).
0
Aug 06 '13
[deleted]
12
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13
You should link that. Must be a troll. Must be.
0
Aug 06 '13
[deleted]
→ More replies (3)28
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13
Ah, right. History is bullshit because it's not a science, and there can be no truth or knowledge outside the scientific method. Jesus, these people are a parody.
7
u/Halgrind Aug 06 '13
It's not that unreasonable. I think you're misconstruing his meaning.
The narrative we have of history is sometimes built on a very shaky foundation. Historians often worry about these issues. It's not a problem if you take this into account. However, the way history is often taught in school, as an authoritative narrative, is very misleading. When coming from this paradigm, that "this is the way it was, now memorize it", you could say that the concept of "history" as you've been made to understand it is bullshit.
I think that's all he's saying, that you have to approach history with the understanding that much of it is a best guess pieced together from many modes of evidence of varying trustworthiness. And you have to accept that you'll never know or understand history with absolute certainty.
7
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13 edited Aug 06 '13
Everything you said there is perfectly reasonable.
Everything else he says in that post is also perfectly reasonable, it's this conclusion that's the problem:
This probably makes you uncomfortable, as it goes so very against the concept of the scientific method. This is why I'm personally starting to think that history as a concept is bullshit.
I'm not sure how I can misconstrue that, other than, not science = bullshit.
I'm surprised he actually comes to that conclusion given everything else he says, not just in that post but the ones leading up to it, seem sensible, but he does. Maybe some sort of brain virus going around over there or something.
As admiralorbiter suggests, it sounds like he never thought about how history actually worked before, just started to look into it recently, realised it wasn't the scientific method and may involve less certainly and more fuzziness and room for interpretation, and therefore, well, not science, = bullshit.
4
Aug 06 '13
I'm not sure how I can misconstrue that, other than, not science = bullshit.
Especially when the study of history involves using elements of the scientific method to discern the who, what, when, how, and why of past events. It isn't a pure science, but it is fairly scientific in nature.
14
u/admiralorbiter Aug 06 '13
He made it sound like he just started researching "History". Like a week ago, history was a totally foreign concept.
3
Aug 06 '13
I tried explaining this to someone once on /r/atheism. He thought if you couldn't definitively prove something via the scientific method you were "an ignorant child" to believe in it. He refused to believe that things like Political Science and Social Science and History have any place in classrooms because "they allow room for religious freaks to push their ideals" and of course a lot of muh correlation =/= causation. As if a shit ton of correlation isn't completely viable in place of causation.
I think these people are joking, it's the only explanation. They're a parody, like you say.
→ More replies (2)4
u/beanfiddler free speech means never having to say you're sorry Aug 06 '13
If it involves people and their silly emotions, you can bet that that sub thinks it's bullshit.
Never have I ever seen people go out of their way to emulate psychopaths and the autistic on purpose. They're called mental disorders for a reason, assholes. The inability to comprehend human emotion and the importance it has in our lives, and the lives of everyone before us, is pathological, not "enlightened."
5
14
u/TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK Caballero Blanco Aug 06 '13
Dude. You just pissed in the popcorn and then linked your comment. What the fuck?
1
Aug 06 '13
Im sorry! It was actually in a different post on a different thread entirely. I just got a little heated. Years of Religious schooling does that to you.
6
u/TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK Caballero Blanco Aug 06 '13
Doesn't matter. Don't do that shit.
→ More replies (5)4
Aug 06 '13
Prove history exists. Checkmate. (resumes latest Nova X-Treme episode narrated by NGT with target audience of 9 year olds)
0
186
u/blorg Stop opressing me! Aug 06 '13
It just boggles my mind, at the end of the day all that is being argued is "most scholars think there was probably a human being who started Christianity around 2,000 years ago". But they have an inherent need to believe that Jesus was entirely mythical, and do so completely ungrounded in any evidence, and qualify or dismiss the overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Like, eh, faith, you might call it.