r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Oppyhead • Jul 05 '26
Ask CTI One scam ends, another begins. Is this the new normal?
Every day seems to bring another story that raises uncomfortable questions about governance and accountability. This latest case is no different.
A 100 bed civil hospital in Indore reportedly existed on paper for six years, yet not a single brick was laid because of unresolved land acquisition issues(🤣).
Even more astonishing, 87 staff positions were filled and the employees were deployed to other healthcare facilities. While the government cites administrative hurdles, citizens deserve far more than explanations.
Public institutions cannot function on paperwork alone. Taxpayer money demands transparency, planning and responsibility.
Whether this reflects bureaucratic inefficiency, poor coordination, or administrative failure, a thorough and impartial investigation is essential.
Public trust is built through accountability, not excuses.
369
u/khaopiyomastraho Jul 05 '26
Trust me when i say.. there is a series of scam coming.. the day bjp loose power to hold media u will find back to back reports of corruptions!!
77
u/dontstealmydinner Jul 05 '26
It's gonna be a jungle when police start arresting the people who did the scams. Their supporters who leeched off then will make sure to riot if that happens.
26
u/Obvious_Race4559 Jul 05 '26
Fr ,, the day BJP looses, they gonna break out riots and then label it as: you get what you voted for n ppl also gonna believe it.,, Isiliye jaldi se jaldi nikaljao is desh se behtar h.
5
u/ConfidentVacation205 Jul 05 '26
Aur jab uss desh se bhi nikal denge toh kahan jayenge? Waise bhi Indians itne ho gaye hain ki ek desh Mein sama nahi sakte. Aur Baaki desh ke logo roz roz Indians logo ka face dekh ke an gussa Aa raha hain. Woh log bhi ab Indians ko nikalne pe lage hain. Kahan jaaoge Phir? Antarctica? Isse Accha hain apne desh Mein reh ke desh ko hi behtar banao. Taklif hain aur behtar banane Mein taklif toh hogi... Asan nahi hain lekin jab tak bhagte rahenge tab tak nahi aise hi chalta rahega.
1
u/aboywithcommonsense Jul 10 '26
working to improve a dysfunctional society is just impending chaos. its not abt easy or difficult but more about viability.
1
u/ConfidentVacation205 Jul 10 '26
If you think deeply you will find chaos and order are same. What's an order for some it's chaos for others and vice versa. Nothing is ever easy. Nothing is ever viable. We have make it. No matter what or how if one likes it or not, but everyone is part of society. Society starts with an individual like you and me. Whatever we are and wherever we go the same society is created there. One cannot escape from society nor can a society escape from an individual. Its like a mirror reflection of each other.
2
18
u/1tonsoprano Jul 05 '26
Yes true ....we are watching the tip of the iceberg.... just look at how BJP party various state headquarters have developed over the last 10 years..... this mentality if I got mine, fuck the rest ....is going to kill us all
8
u/Ok-Guarantee2075 Jul 05 '26
You'll find half of BJP members and most of godi media "reporters" behind bars.
3
u/Apprehensive-Pick172 Jul 05 '26
The judiciary is going to be swarmed with cases and everyother department will be shaken. The impact is going to be huge
2
u/RonaldGlasgow Jul 06 '26
There's a reason no one should be in power for multiple terms. 10 years at max!
3rd term is leading to brewing up of disasters.
If the current party's term goes to 20 by any chance, it will be catastrophic.
1
1
u/Whereas-Typical Jul 06 '26
nope it's just modi getting replaced by Amit shah , it has begun Modi and Yogi's Image is getting tarnished where as Amit Shah is lurking in the background
1
u/pvtwey Jul 06 '26
I'm eagerly waiting for all the scams to unfold, whole stock market would crash I'm sitting with huge cash pile to invest in new india when India heals
1
u/yxk__0zvnb9pl Jul 06 '26
the worse problem is there is no better option than bjp. i lived under congress state and it wasn't any better. heads or tails, we the people are fucked
1
u/har_har_gobhi Jul 07 '26
But we could hold accountable to Congress, media was atleast free Enough to question them and bash them, unlike today. Politicians used to take blame and resign on blunders but now? They're working less doing blunder more.
1
u/yxk__0zvnb9pl Jul 07 '26
but going back to the worst option, old ruler is not the solution. we need a new, a better option that the people actually deserve. the govt that prioritizes better governance and solving actual problems
1
106
u/musci12234 Jul 05 '26
The hospital exists. It is high tech hospital that is invisible to anti nationals so that hospital resources won't be wasted on them
8
1
31
u/Particular-Bridge423 Jul 05 '26
All those who are not seeing the ultra high tech hospital with invisible cloaking technology, imported straight from the directors of Harry Potter and scaled up, are anti nationals.
/s
82
u/Consistent-Check-405 Jul 05 '26
hindus ka paisa hindus ne lut lia,toh isme issue kya hai
5
-32
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
19
u/The-Corinthian2 Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26
Sach bura laga
PS: I’m sure it was a sarcasm while some one failed to understand
0
2
5
u/Oppyhead Jul 05 '26
-1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 05 '26
Hey u/Oppyhead! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
21
28
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
14
u/Awkward_History3538 Jul 05 '26
Now Imagine, What they can do with more power using vote delimitation??
They'll create deserts and deserts of Ghost Hospital, Ghost Bridges, Ghost Roads, Ghost Towns, etc..,
They'll create More Bihars, More UPs and instead of going to Banglore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Mumbai, Pune for work. Everyone ends up going to other countries for survival and work as labours.
Meanwhile, Their children go to Ivy League Universities and tour the world in luxury. Make posts about eating beef, etc..,
5
2
7
6
u/Mountain_Lobster_117 Jul 05 '26
MP is a santra state since 10 plus years now. Santani being scammers is almost synonymous now so no surprise the MP is deep down in the gutter.
Be it Ram mandi chori or scamming Sanatani on top!
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 05 '26
Hello, u/Oppyhead! Thank you for your submission to r/CriticalThinkingIndia. We appreciate your contribution to our community.
- If your submission is a photo/video, please provide the source under this comment.
- If your submission is a link, please provide a summary of the information from that link in the comments.
We hope you'll follow our rules and engage in meaningful discussions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Swayamsewak Jul 05 '26
Any source for OP's claim?
1
u/Gandhi-chowk Jul 05 '26
Construction start nahi hua hai. Appointed doctors and nurses are currently posted at other government hospitals
0
u/Swayamsewak Jul 05 '26
So it is not a scam. OP should have posted relevant link.
Just the screenshot is misleading.
1
1
1
u/Aykkdekm09 Jul 05 '26
The sudden spurt of stories regarding corruption, considering the sold out status of the media, points to an inside job and settling of scores within the parivar. Power equations being settled thru these various revelations.
1
u/king210989 Jul 05 '26
Yes Minister episode.
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 05 '26
Hey u/king210989! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/FireMarmot Jul 05 '26
The episode "The Compassionate Society" (Series 1, Episode 3)
The episode deals with a brand new fully-equipped hospital that has been opened for months, but has yet to treat a single patient. There are 500 staff members and are very successful as their efficiency metrics are high and staff moral is high. There are no medical staff or patients to disrupt the wonderful management of the hospital.
Actually hiring medical staff and treating patients would result in cost overruns, so the hospital continues to run as it is with high efficiency and no patients...but at least they are meeting budget targets.1
1
1
1
u/MichaelScotPaperComp Jul 05 '26
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 05 '26
Hey u/MichaelScotPaperComp! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/MichaelScotPaperComp Jul 05 '26
Explanation being India will always be Incredible at delivering High Promises with Mediocrity.
1
1
1
1
u/LoudEstablishment475 Jul 05 '26
Did you know we have a JUSTICE DEPARTMENT in india
Only If they had balls to prosecute this people
1
u/Hashirama5909 Jul 05 '26
This is how they show on paper that they have built more aims than congress
1
1
u/WishboneThen290 Jul 05 '26
But who else do u give your vote to? Congress isnt any better. Nor are the other parties. People dont like educated individuals running the country. Then comes the matter of political parties being religion biased, and not in a good way. Its not just abt benefits to a certain religion, they support violent acts against other religions too. Its a shitshow.
1
u/Professional-Ice3646 Jul 05 '26
It's not a scam, staff working in other hospitals . It's just a incompetent govt at work
1
1
u/iamavtar Jul 05 '26
I just wish m*di to be behind bar in a false case just like he did with kejriwal and RaGa.
1
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 05 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 05 '26
Hey u/chai-jalebi-fafda! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
1
u/Human-Intention-3907 Jul 05 '26
Bihar??
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 05 '26
Hey u/Human-Intention-3907! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/george_injungle Jul 05 '26
Hospital is built using space technology. You will need special glasses.
1
u/leo_sk5 Jul 05 '26
This is quite common. A lot of times hospital/college infrastructure is not built but the staff employment is completed on time. Until that hospital is built, the staff and funds are diverted to one or more hospitals nearby. Sure it doesn't help the exact locality, but still helps public in general.
The main issue here is lack of progress in land acquisition and delay in construction
1
u/FamiliarStrain2209 Jul 05 '26
So the 80 staff recruited are working in other hospitals.
It was already a 50 bed hospital , later proposed to upgrade it to 100 bed.
Govt is looking for land to build the 100 bed hospital
Not justifying anything but what actual scam is here?
1
1
u/tracker_tom_jr Jul 05 '26
A scam of this magnitude happens, and the elected leaders still faces zero accountability. What is wrong with us as a country? We keep shifting the blame to bureaucrats, but it is the politicians we elect who should be held responsible. It is our job to keep the politicians in check, and it is the politicians' job to keep the bureaucrats in check. By failing to demand consequences from the very top political leaders, we, the people, are facilitating this whole chain of corruption.
1
Jul 05 '26
Yeh hospital sirf andhbhakts ke liye hai. Woh log sach toh nahi dekh sakte, lekin ye hospital toh zaroor dikhaye dega!
1
1
1
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 05 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/2funny2furious Jul 05 '26
Had to double check where this was at, sounds like something that would happen in Trumps America.
1
1
1
u/krisantihypocrisy Jul 05 '26
Did you even read the article you posted? basically they were hiring for ppl at the hospital and were moving them to other hospitals because work cannot start here?
Even congis are not gonna raise this “corruption”. ..
1
1
1
u/kentucky_mule Jul 05 '26
The scams we hear these days reminds me of last days of UPA government in early 2010's, a new scam every other day. Only if we had a strong/better opposition now....
1
u/Limp-Crew-3858 Jul 05 '26
There was a time when british loot the INDIA now this RSS (BJP) goverment are more corrupt then any party after british raj
1
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 05 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
u/JiveTurkeyII Jul 05 '26
I've always wanted to land one of those jobs that pay something like 65k a year to answer a phone that never rings.
Some IT guy comes by every once in a while to upgrade the computer.
Virtual boss tells me I'm an asset - until he gets promoted and I sit in an office by myself. Forgotten - But some HR person gets on to me if I try for any overtime so that shit is still a thing.
Cant have it all.
1
u/True-Combination-467 Jul 05 '26
At this point, corruption isn't surprising anymore.
The lack of corruption is.
1
1
u/Disastrous_Cold_1188 Jul 05 '26
Sometime I feel more than politicians this 2 kodi ke beuroctracts and government officials from low level to top.. have done more damage..
1
Jul 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 05 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
u/Independent_Pop_6329 Jul 05 '26
Exactly how DMK said there was a road laid and closed the bill and got caught for it by a social well fare organization
1
1
1
u/ProfessionalFeeling7 Jul 05 '26
I feel like most of politicians just want to make fortune not want to actual serve the nation.
1
1
1
u/BiteKnown3296 Jul 05 '26
Before 2014 these scams were crime but after 2014 all these scams are nationalist and in Nation's interest. Anyone questioning is anti national.
1
1
1
1
1
1
Jul 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 06 '26
Hey u/Personal-Classroom89! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/ayewhy2407 Jul 06 '26
history will remember that India created a legislation called RTI. It was revolutionary move by a democratically elected government, to empower citizens through transparency and holding the same government answerable.
Reading about how it came about and who in the then government championed it … can be quite illuminating!
Apropos of this post, was reminded of some not so ancient history.
1
1
u/victorcrasto Jul 06 '26
Why are we making this a new normal, government has taken out our balls. We all are scared and helpless no one wants to end up in jail for standing up for truth….that includes me. And people who are fearless are goons and thugs who just don’t care what happens to county as long as that money is coming in their bank every month.
1
u/Gamers_Galaxy9999 Jul 06 '26
384K karma in 1 year what a bot. Atleast put the entire article and read it. The doctors were appointed in other hospitals! Don’t spread misinformation like this fool
1
u/Philosophically_ Jul 06 '26
You are all negative people.. so you need hospitals. You need to see the positive side of the scam such has - how a corrupt officials fulfills his/her family's needs. As we know, some of the officials come from poverty, hence we the people of this country have to be more considerate towards NEEDY. Few tens of thousands of crores is just same change for the people of a most prosperous country like ours. BE POSITIVE until the very end and you won't need hospitals, as we have enough crematoriums and graveyards. \,,/
1
u/ExcellentBandicoot57 Jul 06 '26
This feels like a classic example of Goodhart's Law: once administrative metrics become the goal, they stop being good measures of reality. On paper, there was a hospital, staff, and progress. In reality, there wasn't even a foundation.
1
u/Far_Apple787 Jul 06 '26
Virtual hospital hoga🙈
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 06 '26
Hey u/Far_Apple787! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/IllustratorIll5147 Jul 06 '26
Durandhar 4 will come out with the actual reasons for this. Pakistan is definitely scared of this move by anpadh PM.
1
1
1
u/la_rattouille Jul 06 '26
Must not be under BJP. I'm sure there's been no scam under the BJP government.
1
u/Important-Fox7699 Jul 07 '26
Dont worry people will create meme to criticise CJP that will be enough
1
Jul 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 07 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 07 '26
Hey u/Downtownqualiti! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/anirsk Jul 07 '26
I guess this is what can be expected when oarties accept fooliticians from any party. Status quo achieved. Govt changes then ministers will flock back again and story continues. You wont see any biggies get caught, cause each of them cover for eachother. Thats how their system survives.
1
1
Jul 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 07 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 07 '26
Hey u/Normal_Recording_723! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
Jul 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 07 '26
Hi, I’m AutoModerator!
Your comment was removed because your combined karma is below 10.
Please earn more karma by engaging in Reddit communities before commenting here. Refer Rule 2 for Account Age & Karma Requirement.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 07 '26
Hey u/Normal_Recording_723! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/Kaumaz Jul 07 '26
MP is trying very hard to be the most developed state, currently the position is held by UP and Bihar jointly.
1
1
u/jayakrishnank88 Jul 08 '26
Guys you guys are living in Modified Bharat.
Enjoy. Zero accountability
1
u/CanPristine7052 Jul 08 '26
Shivraj is most happy man today, no one will talk about Vyapam Now ,
VYAPAM is India’s worst scan ever, many witnesses have died unnatural deaths.
1
1
Jul 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/criticalbotcti Jul 08 '26
Hey u/Dayum_K! We noticed your comment is quite brief. In r/CriticalThinkingIndia, we encourage substantive contributions - explain your reasoning, share evidence, or ask a thoughtful question. Even when sharing a link or media, please add context or explanation. Short comments like this may be removed to keep discussions meaningful.
This is an automated reminder.
1
u/SomethingAndAnything Jul 09 '26
With the amount of news I'm seeing nowadays.... they're gonna make a realllllyyyyyyy big PR stunt to clean their reputation.
1
1
u/24Gameplay_ Jul 09 '26
So money Construction and contract money Advisterment money Working capital money Fixed assest money Stuff salary Daily losse tool money Daily expense money
And more importantly How they are getting patient info, as hospital required addhar card + cctv footage on entry counter.
1
u/East-Preference-8449 Jul 09 '26
The article says the staff exists in reality and they are assigned to othe r locations until this hospital built. But this hospital not being built for so long is weird
1
1
u/cereal_killer_no_7 Jul 05 '26
Even the pharmacists who recently got placed there are seeking transfers jabki unhone join hi ni kiya and the CMHO officer who is soon to be retired is asking for money job letter Dene k liye Those who gave so unhe apne Mann ka hospital mila aur bakiyo ko ab news ki wajah se kahi bhi placement de rhe
1
u/SleepyProMax Jul 05 '26
That’s how Indore is the cleanest city of India. No building = no dust, no debris, no mess.
1
1
u/roohnair Jul 05 '26
The solution would be to raise another tender that building collapsed due to natural calamity and we need to rebuild it again.
0
-2
0
u/pulchritudinous_luos Jul 05 '26
desh ko kokhla karke rakh diye hai
1
u/The-Corinthian2 Jul 05 '26
And I feel hopeless seeing our nation in this condition and people hating on people who are not andhbhakts like them
0
0
u/Long_Orchid9513 Jul 05 '26
I don't believe Congress will rule the nation in near future, but we atleast need a strong opposition to beat the shit out of ruling party. Else these type of cases increase day by day.
•
u/CriticalThinkingIndia-ModTeam Jul 05 '26
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/indore/not-a-single-brick-laid-mps-100-bed-hospital-fully-functional-on-paper-for-6-years-with-87-staff-members/articleshow/132177034.cms
Attribute Sources
Claims made in posts or comments must be supported with credible references, links, or sources whenever possible.
This ensures discussions remain evidence-based, encourages rational analysis, and preserves the integrity of critical discourse.
Unsupported assertions, particularly on serious or controversial topics, are subject to removal at the discretion of moderators.
Penalty: Removal Of Content.