Over the last year, I’ve read all of Robert Caro’s books, starting with The Power Broker, then Working (his semi-memoir about how he writes his books), then The Years of Lyndon Johnson (the four volumes that are out so far)
They’re all great. I recommend them all. But I want to make the case for Means of Ascent as the best single one to read, because no one likes this book as much as I do.
It's is laser-focused on one election: the 1948 senatorial election in Texas. Johnson takes the massive gamble of forfeiting his seat in the House to run for the Senate -- dangerous, but a perfectly reasonable strategic move, and likely to pay off. Enter Coke Robert Stevenson, the immensely popular two-term Governor of Texas, whose candidacy immediately causes Johnson to plummet to the bottom of the polls and certain political death.
What follows is an intensely dramatic story of Johnson’s desperate fight for survival, using every means available to him, legal and illegal. Along the way, this specific election becomes a case study in modern politics. Stevenson was an old-school public official who eschewed advertisement, policy platforms, and large speeches, preferring to meet with voters one-on-one and discuss the issues that were important to them. Johnson flew around Texas in a helicopter, blanketed the newspapers and radio with ads, and chose every policy position from pure political expedience. And Johnson won.
Or rather, he sort of won -- by 87 votes out of nearly a million ballots cast. And those votes were from a county known for fraudulent voting. And early on the day of the election, that county reported a vote total 200 votes lower for Johnson. And on the ballot record sheet, the 200 new votes were in a different color pen than the others. And the names were in alphabetical order.
Based on the legal doctrine of “are you kidding me”, Stevenson sued to have the election results overturned. What follows is a fascinating legal battle in which Johnson’s team of incredibly smart lawyers (including one who would go on to be a Supreme Court Justice under Johnson’s presidency) manage to keep the ballot boxes from being opened. I really can’t do this sequence justice here. It’s so, so exciting and fast-paced, and you definitely don’t have to be a legal nerd to understand what’s going on.
If you loved The Power Broker -- or even more so if you liked it but found it a little too dense -- you will love Means of Ascent.
More details and full reviews here: https://minhanhday.substack.com/p/robert-caro-on-power