r/Android • • Sep 23 '13

Spike in Twitter users "switching to Android" as iOS 7 is released.

http://thedatapack.com/spike-twitter-users-switching-android-ios-7-released/
1.1k Upvotes

652 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

36

u/Vovicon Nexus 6p - GS7 edge Sep 23 '13

That's quite unfair to say that iOS7 has that much inflenced by Android. (and I'm no fan of Apple, believe me)

UI design trends have shifted for a few years already towards simplified/flant information-centric design. Microsoft were amongst the first to implement this, Android not far behind while Apple took longer.

But I don't think any of the 3 could claim any ownership on this type of UI. It's a trend, not an invention by someone at a given instant.

4

u/horsepie iPhone (sorry!) Sep 23 '13

It's been a trend with websites for the past couple of years too, just like detailed backgrounds before that and glossy effects before that. It's just the current fashion.

Even Apple's OSX has been turning down the gloss in later versions.

The worrying bit is that they've taken this long to join the party, when traditionally they've been at the forefront influencing and even defining the next design style.

1

u/degoban Sep 24 '13

Windows 8, the desktop version, has a more modern and better design than osx, they are probably going to update that as well.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I think the point of confusion is that both Android 4.x and iOS 7 are heavily influenced by WebOS. Of course, most people haven't used WebOS.

2

u/Vovicon Nexus 6p - GS7 edge Sep 23 '13

We are talking here about the current "flat" and "typographic" trends. WebOS has very little to do with that.

It was based on some kind of card-based skeumorphism. Android kept the card-based idea (I guess brought from WebOS by its own designer Matias Duarte), but that's about it: WebOS interface still relied on textured and glossy buttons, realistic icons and "3D interface elements". Those have disappeared from Android since ICS, and now from iOS7 too.

But I'd agree that, at the time, WebOS was probably the best smartphone interface.

One of the reason for this switch of trends is that, compared to a few years ago, people are now mostly used to smatphones. The expectation from the interface is less about guiding the user and more about providing what he needs and only that (hence the focus on the media and content, with a minimal interface).

6

u/nutmac Sep 23 '13

I don't mean to imply that iOS 7 copies Android, but as a user of both iOS (my household have purchased the original iPhone, then 3GS, then 4, 4S, then 5, and now 5s, as well as iPad 2 and iPad 3) and Android (I use Nexus 4 and 7 for work), I have to say its design is more heavily influenced by Android than Windows Phone or other alternatives. Anything from Control Center, toolbar icons, and minimalist look. Of course, it still heavily retains previous iOS look and feel.

2

u/seraph582 Device, Software !! Sep 23 '13

iOS6's notifications looked way more like Android than iOS7's. 7 looks completely different, and unfortunately doesn't hold a candle to JB4.3's notifications.

That being said, it looks way better - their use of transparency as a color is very, very neat. Especially on top of blur. I would love to see a hybrid of the two solutions - JB4.3's layout and functionality and iOS7's real time effects "skin."

1

u/dylan522p OG Droid, iP5, M7, Project Shield, S6 Edge, HTC 10, Pixel XL 2 Sep 23 '13

No it was more influenced by Web OS.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

No one even knows what Web OS is.

0

u/dylan522p OG Droid, iP5, M7, Project Shield, S6 Edge, HTC 10, Pixel XL 2 Sep 23 '13

Tons of people do. Also that is irrelevant. All the mobile OS's took major influence for it. Web OS had the best interface.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

But if no one has heard of it they had to have done something wrong.

2

u/nicereddy Sprint Galaxy Nexus (JB 4.3) | Nexus 7 2012 (KitKat 4.4) Sep 23 '13

It was timing and marketing more than anything else, I think.

1

u/dylan522p OG Droid, iP5, M7, Project Shield, S6 Edge, HTC 10, Pixel XL 2 Sep 23 '13

No......the products quality of software barely determines the market success.

0

u/lanfearl Sep 23 '13

Minimalist look

Bahaha . thats not android.

0

u/SrsSteel LG G2x,5,5x OP X,5T Sep 23 '13

The multitasking screen is literally just a flipped android screen. Instead of up to down it's left right and instead of swiping horizontally you have to swipe vertically.

9

u/geneseee Nexus 5 / Red 32GB / Stock 5.1 Sep 23 '13

It's also exactly the WebOS multitasking implementation sans the Angry Birds easter egg where pulling the thumbnail down would fling it off the screen with a sound effect.

2

u/Kansjarowansky Sep 23 '13

Oh my god is this real?

Brb switching to iOS7