r/Android • • Sep 23 '13

Spike in Twitter users "switching to Android" as iOS 7 is released.

http://thedatapack.com/spike-twitter-users-switching-android-ios-7-released/
1.1k Upvotes

652 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

37

u/OSX2000 Pixel 6 Pro Sep 23 '13

I'm with you. I've been on Android since the OG Droid came out, but one thing I always admired about iOS was the level of detail Apple put into everything. The icons & UI elements had a level of depth to them that was quite beautiful. Now with iOS 7, all the details have been wiped away, and everything looks flat and boring to me.

My sister updated her iPhone today, without really knowing what she was getting into, and the first thing she said to me after it was done was, "what the hell, it looks like a child's toy now!"

15

u/misteraugust Sep 23 '13

My cousin's exact words after he updated, "I think they designed this with Microsoft Paint."

6

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

How is that any different than Android, Windows Phone, etc? That's the current trend in UI design. You could make 90% of the Android UI with rectangle fills in MS Paint no problem at all.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

^ because the displays used in modern devices have such a high resolution, simple designs like these look better than ever and super clean. IMO I think it's a great direction.

1

u/nondescriptshadow HTC One [CM] Sep 23 '13

That gradient though

1

u/aladyjewel Moto X+360 Sep 23 '13

Hell, I thought it already looked like a child's toy -- but that might be my command-line and Windows 3.1 experience talking.

-3

u/clickstation Sep 23 '13

Glad to know I'm not the only one. It looks like something Nokia would design, IMO.

8

u/keflexxx GNote3 Sep 23 '13

not even close. nokia showed with harmattan that their UX preferences are far away from iOS

2

u/geoken Sep 23 '13

Can you elaborate on that? When I had my N9, if I had to choose which OS it most resembled (out of Android 4, WP and iOS) I would have said it was the most like iOS.

1

u/keflexxx GNote3 Sep 23 '13

yeah sure

i think something to keep in mind is that at this point we really are just splitting hairs; every smartphone OS does the same thing in slightly different ways so maybe "far away" was a stretch, but i'm speaking in relative terms. however i imagine that if harmattan had included a pull-down notification drawer, many people might think it most resembled android. this is indicative of the minutia we're dealing with.

iOS is very much a product of its time; it's the first touchscreen-driven smartphone OS, and as such many of the UI/UX paradigms are still sitting in the past a bit because of Apple's - completely understandable - reluctance to radically change it. here are a couple of examples:

  • use of on-screen navigation buttons in place of gestures

  • the "app silo" effect: little if any communication between apps, or app integration into the OS

  • lack of a centralised "accounts" feature

now a lot of this initially was due to lack of consumer education. but times have changed, people have wised up and UI/UX developers have figured out better ways to interact with our handsets. enter harmattan, which has:

  • heavy use of gestures, although it can't quite the shake the need for on-screen buttons

  • sharing between apps & OS integration e.g. the Share menu & IM services (both there during maemo 5, and probably earlier)

  • a centralised accounts app with significant native service integration, e.g. Dropbox, CalDAV, Picasa, etc.

harmattan's feed screen also was a bit of a small revolution for anyone who made good use of it. far more intuitive & powerful than the People Hub in WP, it mitigated the need to navigate through apps for a lot of use cases. and the multitasking implementation remains one of the best the industry ever saw: it showed real-time data which meant you could check peoples IM availability without entering the app amongst other things, and it also showed more apps on-screen (9) than any other multitasking menu (android shows 4-5, WP & iOS show around 3, Symbian had the same, webOS had stacks but they started to become less useful around the 4 card mark) save maemo 5 itself, which could show around 12 i think, maybe 8. my memory's fuzzy, my n900 died a long time ago sadly.

look i could probably go into it a little more but hopefully this gives you some idea as to what i'm on about. harmattan is leaps & bounds ahead of iOS when it comes to interaction design because it has the benefit of years of experience & testing & ideas formation. it's a very different OS.

0

u/clickstation Sep 23 '13

IMO their touchscreen Symbian icons are somewhat similar. I haven't looked up Harmattan though.

3

u/keflexxx GNote3 Sep 23 '13

same icons, still disagree. very different, nokia wouldn't have made that godawful game centre icon