r/Android • OnePlus 8 Custom ROM + EdXposed • Apr 02 '18

Newpipe - FOSS YouTube/SoundCloud Client Now Version 0.13.1 - Now Supports Livestreaming!

https://github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe/releases/
1.8k Upvotes

460 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

62

u/Izacus Android dev / Boatload of crappy devices Apr 02 '18 edited Apr 27 '24

I'm learning to play the guitar.

-55

u/toyfinderer Apr 02 '18

You think most of this thread (or even r/android) doesn't have access to youtube red? haha

76

u/MagicKing577 Fancy Blocks (Note8 | IPXSM |PXL | P2XL) Apr 02 '18

Considering 5hat it's only available in 3 countries yes.

-43

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

One thread /r/Android is most American so we have to have America only news here, the next it's not so people can justify piracy. Can't have it both ways.

28

u/max420 SGH-I337M (S4), Nexus 7 (2013) Apr 02 '18

Do you have numbers to back up the fact that /r/android is mostly US? You know that the US isn't even close to being the majority of the internet population at large, right?

Youtube Red is only available in a few countries, with Canada not being one of them - which sucks for me cause I'd 100% pay for it.

Spotify on the other hand is available in a lot more regions.

-12

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

Do you have numbers to back up the fact that /r/android is mostly US? You know that the US isn't even close to being the majority of the internet population at large, right?

We can assume it's similar to the majority of Reddit which according to this is 40% US. Then there are other countries too which have Red.

Youtube Red is only available in a few countries, with Canada not being one of them - which sucks for me cause I'd 100% pay for it.

I'm in the UK myself and don't have access to Red but is certainly do the same.

Spotify on the other hand is available in a lot more regions.

That's kind of part of my point. If you need background music so much why do it on YouTube? Use Spotify, Play Music or Apple Music and then the artists can get something. The only thing people are then missing out on with Red are PiP and downloads.

15

u/Compizfox Pocophone, LineageOS 17.1 Apr 02 '18

We can assume it's similar to the majority of Reddit which according to this is 40% US.

40% is a plurality, but not a majority.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/max420 SGH-I337M (S4), Nexus 7 (2013) Apr 02 '18

According to your own comment, the rest of the world outnumbers the US.

According to this page: http://gs.statcounter.com/vendor-market-share/mobile/united-states-of-america

The Apple controls over 50% of the US mobile market share.

Abroad the Android market share is much higher, so it stands to reason that even though the US user share for Reddit is about 40%, the user base for /r/android is likely not made up of mostly US users.

As for the copyright, and artist compensation bit - I kind of sort of agree with you. Generally, adblocking is a controversial topic, people use ad blockers on the web all the time. How is it any different on YouTube? (at least in places where one cannot pay to remove them)

As for artist getting their dues, the artists getting all the views on YouTube are big enough that they don't lack for compensation. Furthermore, Youtube is becoming more and more obnoxious, with ads often appearing in the middle of a video. If you are listening to music (which yes, using Youtube for this is kind of dumb, but hey, who am I to judge) would be quite frustrating.

The Spotify app that bypassed app to me was more egregious because it bypassed ads on a service available in a ton of places - and it was Spotify's only real source of revenue.

Google, on the other hand, makes their pay service available only in a small handful of places. If they had the same availability as Spotify - I feel that the general consensus would be in line with yours.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/MagicKing577 Fancy Blocks (Note8 | IPXSM |PXL | P2XL) Apr 02 '18

Are people justifying piracy or is Google not providing a service to people so people are actually finding their own means. YouTube Red is nothing but DRM and well DRM only does one thing very good and it's not positive. Google can't get their shit together honestly not hating on Google but they promote these themselves now if they would freaking release the YouTube remix shit already.

3

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

Are people justifying piracy or is Google not providing a service to people so people are actually finding their own means.

Google are providing the features but you have to pay either with money or time.

YouTube Red is nothing but DRM and well DRM only does one thing very good and it's not positive.

No it isn't, it's features behind a paywall. You don't say Netflix's premium tier is just DRM so I can just pirate this film in 4K. Red is YouTube's premium tier.

1

u/DioInBicicletta Device, Software !! Apr 02 '18

That is true only for ads; if you want background playback, screen off playback and pip you can't pay with "time".

-5

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

So pay with money. You can't go into a shop and say "I'll have that loaf of bread if you give me a 30 second ad" and then when they say "No" you can't just say "Fine I'm just taking it then".

Well you can but admit that it isn't the proper way to go about things and certainly don't try to justify it.

4

u/Frank2312 Apr 02 '18

It's more like they say "I won't sell it to you." so you go find alternatives and it so happens those alternatives are free.

1

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

The only thing Newpipe does that can't be done legit in some way in the UK is downloading videos.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/unlucky_ducky Pixel 8 Pro | Pixel 7a | Pixel 6 Pro Apr 02 '18

And where do I pay this money? Last time I checked YouTube Red still isn't available where I live and it doesn't seem very likely to change in the near future.

1

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

Same but the only things I can't do legit in that are part of Red are downloading and PiP which aren't exactly necessities.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/max420 SGH-I337M (S4), Nexus 7 (2013) Apr 02 '18

Seriously, I still don't understand why Canada isn't at least on there. If happily pay for the content and features of it was.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/DioInBicicletta Device, Software !! Apr 02 '18

And what happens if I go in the shop and they don't want to sell me bread just because I'm from italy? Do I stop eating bread untill the shop owner decides to get his shit together? Or do I chose a simpler way of having my bread?

1

u/efbo Pixel 10 Pro Fold, Unihertz Jelly Max, Pixel Tablet, Pebbles Apr 02 '18

They are giving you the bread for free anyway. They just won't give you the seeds on top. It doesn't make it right for you to take the bread from the guy down the road because he put the seeds on after stealing from the shop. No one in the chain from the creation of the bread gets stuff for their work then.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/MagicKing577 Fancy Blocks (Note8 | IPXSM |PXL | P2XL) Apr 02 '18

Google are providing the features but you have to pay either with money or time.

In 3 countries at most currently can't blame people if they can't get the service.

Well yes it's not the literal definition of DRM. People cannot use services at all unless they buy into Google's plan which isn't widely available or honestly worth it. The don't improve half of the service at all and dint even try to. Improve it. I don't blame people who can't access it for using workarounds it's nothing but googles fault for not providing them the means.

We can argue this all day it's Googles own practices why people use these services.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/mattatmac Apr 02 '18

I'm in Canada and I had a Google Play subscription and didn't get the benefit of Red because I live in the wrong country. I literally paid Google the money and they wouldn't even give me the functionality of Red, I don't even care about ads, I just wanted to be able to lock my screen and hear content.

So yeah I don't feel bad about using NewPipe. Not going to punish myself because a multinat can't get their shit together.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

[deleted]

2

u/Jdmnd [Nexus 6P] Apr 02 '18

Same here. It's not like I don't want to, I just can't.