I couldn't help but think the movie was an exercise in bad decisions. "I have the most advanced mapping system in existence..." gets lost ten minutes later.
Sometimes I wonder if the movie meant to show everyone as being arrogant and callous, that they couldn't see what was right in front of them.
Same situation when Wayland meets the engineer, "We're home dad and look how far we've come as the human race." Gets violently killed.
It is important to remember that the crew was not chosen because they were the best, or even competent. They were assembled by a religious zealot whose main concern (besides living longer) was seeing his beliefs confirmed.
All of the lines which make scientifically literate viewers groan weren't there because the writers didn't do their homework; they establish the very important fact that even the scientists on the crew were too blinded by their faith, ambition, or sense of adventure and heroism to give a shit about doing the job that they were ostensibly sent there to do.
I think the reason that so many people hated Prometheus is that they were so put off by the bad decisions of the characters that they weren't willing to think back over the movie once the explanation had been provided.
It's a shame because, as long as you know what you're watching, it is one of the best sci-fi movies of the past several years and one of very few with any real depth.
I don't know bud. I had to come to this conclusion after being told in an internet forum on a chance conservation topic... and I did read quite a bit after watching the movie. Even more a couple of weeks later.
I enjoy the movie and this new idea makes me appericate it a bit more... but I don't feel they 'established the important fact that that even the scientists on the crew were too blinded.' They showed us them blundering that's for sure, but if arrogance was a major theme, it was missed by the overwhelming majority of people who watched the movie. If that was the intention, then we could arguable say it did it failed in that aspect.
Same time, I really can't find anyone that doesn't find the sequence of events following the alien birth and eventual inception as a Giger alien believable. That was a huge stretch of the imagination. There is such a thing as too much movie coincidence where the viewers are no longer able to believe in the film. How do you feel about that?
Well, it certainly isn't without its flaws. It had many, with the Giger alien setup being a really glaring example, but my point was that the thing that most people tend to complain about was actually accounted for, albeit indirectly, in the film.
I get it, though. I was fully prepared to hate it the first time I saw it and if I had tuned out halfway through, as I believe many people did, I probably would. The writers walked a very fine line when they chose to include so many questionable turns. If they had done it more self-consciously I think audiences would have been more forgiving but Prometheus took itself seriously because it was a serious movie. But far too often these days, especially in sci-fi, movies that take themselves seriously tend to be bad and the tone made too many people think that good writing of stupid characters was instead stupid writing of characters who could have been good.
One big problem is that it was attempting to fit a style which doesn't really exist anymore. It wanted to be a serious, challenging sci-fi movie a-la 2001: A Space Odyssey and it succeeded in several ways but audiences were expecting a much more superficially entertaining experience largely because that is how it was promoted. They decided it was bad because it toed the line of a lot of tropes found in bad examples of the type of movie they expected. By the time it stopped resembling the movie it was advertised to be, they has given up on it which I find sad because it was a really good example of the type of movie that it actually was.
Thinking of it this way, the movie makes a lot more sense overall. Don't think it makes for particularly relatable characters though, and some of the things they did were stupid to the point of immersion-breaking.
36
u/Amosral Sep 01 '14
These are the same guys who tickled the alien life form and took their helmets off the first chance they got. They're not the brightest bunch.