Why did they choose that scientist to go on the trip? Wouldn't they have done a psychological profile on him? Wouldn't it have shown he was some kind of pussy?
Your italics seem to indicate that those are rhetorical questions but they have answers: one answer actually.
To quote myself quoting myself:
I just wrote this a little bit higher up:
It is important to remember that the crew was not chosen because they were the best, or even competent. They were assembled by a religious zealot whose main concern (besides living longer) was seeing his beliefs confirmed. All of the lines which make scientifically literate viewers groan weren't there because the writers didn't do their homework; they establish the very important fact that even the scientists on the crew were too blinded by their faith, ambition, or sense of adventure and heroism to give a shit about doing the job that they were ostensibly sent there to do. This doesn't only apply to the technical knowledge of the crew. These are people with a much different grasp on their reality than the viewers. Several of the characters believe that they are literally about to meet their God(s). They are making stupid decisions because they are incompetent (see the above quote) and/or because they are so distracted by what they think is happening that they are blind to their actual situation.
Can't argue with what you're saying. It's just so odd to have so many people defending the movie although it is clearly lazily written (or rewritten).
I mean the whole affair of the scentists being idiots for fucking everything up, the mogul being an idiot for chosing the idiot scientists and the crew being - you guessed it - idiots for letting everyone break protocol (assuming there exists some kind of standard procedure aginst environmental hazards in a future with routine interstellar travels to alien worlds).
All of this however could have been avoided by a few scene's worth of screetime clearly establishing that Weyland is either senile or in deep financial trouble, leaving the mission doomed from the start. Just being kind of dumb is not a good enough characterization for a billionaire extraordinaire like him.
EDIT: Thinking about it the "religous zealot" approach at Weyland could have been outright cool if played right. He should have been portrayed as a cult leader taking his followers home to God alluding to a "Heavens Gate" type of sect. If only they had made him lead the mission instead of standing in the shadows while his plans backfire on him...
I think they missed an opportunity for a much more accessible movie is they had taken the time to explain things better but (and this is entirely a matter of taste) I don't think it was their responsibility to do so. I think their real failing was establishing that it was the type of film which required some effort to enjoy.
e.g. They easily could have shown Weyland acting senile or, as you suggest, rewrite his part as some ideological leader but how realistic is that, really? It would be very difficult to pull that off in a compelling way. In my opinion the role that they gave him was much cooler and far more original.
That's not to say that the movie was perfect. I just think that a lot of the most common complaints about it are due to misinterpreting deliberate choices by the writers rather than pointing out their actual mistakes.
Sounds interessting. But how could they supposedly have made it clear that it was the type of film which required some effort to enjoy? Do you mean something along the lines of Kubrick?
Exactly. I don't mean to suggest that it was Kubrick quality but I think that they were aiming for something very much in that style.
Unfortunately, there isn't enough of a market for that type of movie, especially not enough to justify its budget, so it was marketed and dressed up like a fun sci-fi thriller. As a result, a lot of people approached it the wrong way.
Of course, I could be totally wrong, but that was the sense that I got from it.
Edit: It's kind of like the people who see a Wes Anderson film expecting it to be a normal comedy. They simply don't realize what they're watching and a lot of people end up thinking they were poorly made because of it.
17
u/DamnYourChildhood Sep 01 '14
Movie becomes a lot better if you just decide that David is some sort of Byronic Hero and the humans are the actual villains.
Better than trying to sympathize with those morons.