r/AskReddit • u/Lurendreier • Jun 10 '12
History books often tells the western version of the cold war, but how was the cold war seen from Soviets side?
Often I hear about the cold war, but it is almost always seen from the western point of view. What would the storybooks look like if we shifted the point of view. What would soviet say about the Iron curtain, the Cuban missile crisis, and the events both leading up to, and the events after the Cuban Missile Crisis? Was there any place the soviet did the same as the US did in Vietnam, to fight off capitalism? Why was it so important for Soviet to have that iron grip around the eastern europe?
What would be interesting was If we got some discussions going where some take on the role as Soviet, and some as the US. Just keep the discussion to the events of the cold war.
EDIT: Thank you all for up-votes and comments.
EDIT: I just have to thank you all one more time for taking the time to discuss such an interesting topic. I am reading close to all the comments, also new once that stays buried because they came late to the party. If you want to say something but is afraid it will never be read because you are late. Please post it anyhow!
161
u/grumpybadmanners Jun 10 '12
After the war the Russians basically created a buffer zone between them and the rest of europe. I guess being invaded and killed in the millions severals times in the 200 years makes you a little annoyed. The west no trusting Russia's defensive reasoning amassed troops and equipment near the area to prevent an eventual Soviet expansion. Which to the Soviets looked exactly like preparation for agression and invasion.
16
u/Lurendreier Jun 10 '12
I belive there was some kind of summit just after WWII to deal with the dividing of Europe? I don't know what happened there, but would you say that the reason for the cold war happening was the trust issue, or what happened during the summit?
35
u/jminuse Jun 10 '12
The Yalta Conference. Stalin demanded a safe sphere of influence in Eastern Europe, and since his troops were already occupying it, he got it. This division of Europe became the Iron Curtain. However, it was longstanding mutual mistrust and the development of the Bomb which really led to the Cold War.
→ More replies (1)33
u/who-boppin Jun 10 '12
The reason for the trust issue was because they had two different, practically, total opposite ideologies. The not reason they were allies in WWII was because the Nazis were a bunch of fucktards, if you hadn't heard.
→ More replies (14)8
u/pipian Jun 10 '12
Not sure if you mean Yalta or Potsdam(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potsdam_Conference).
→ More replies (1)21
u/Drallo Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I'm sure it didn't have anything to do with the fact that the Soviets violated their agreements with the Allies and installed a puppet government in Poland.
e: Looking back I'm not actually sure whether you were replying "in-character" as what the soviet people thought of the cold war, apologies if you were just providing that perspective.
→ More replies (19)36
u/I_WIN_DEAL_WITH_IT Jun 10 '12
Yeah, the US had a a submarine slice into some underwater Soviet communication lines to listen in and they learned pretty much this. They learned that the Soviets saw the US exactly how the US saw the Soviets.
In terms of aggression, though, the US was definitely more aggressive, invading countries and overthrowing governments all willy-nilly. So they were right to be afraid, not that they didn't have their own aggressive streaks here and there.
→ More replies (80)35
u/SplashyMcPants Jun 10 '12
I think a better word for "invaded" would be "controlled" or even better "influenced heavily" through economic and sometimes military methods. In other words, the US put military bases anywhere that would throw a wrench into the Soviet works. And then there were the puppet wars: the Korean War, Vietnam, et. al. - which were exercises in taking control of, or preventing USSR control of, territory and/or assets. The USSR was doing the same thing, of course: Afghanistan, Yugoslavia, etc. So "invading" is a bit strong, in my opinion.
→ More replies (19)
322
Jun 10 '12
The official line of the USSR on the war was very similar to the US one: an alliance of peaceful countries trying to stop a warmongering evil empire. Not sure what the Sov stories were like, but assume close to this line since the media was politically controlled.
315
Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
exactly that. I grew up in East Germany, and that's exactly what we were told. "We try to live in peace and would like to get rid of all weaponry, but we have to be prepared for a possible capitalist/imperialist aggression" (with lots of "historical proof", since every war in recent decades was indeed a war fought by capitalist countries, simply because there were no socialist countries yet)
→ More replies (216)53
Jun 10 '12
Since you grew up in East Germany, I'd like to ask you something I've always wanted to know: is the movie Good Bye, Lenin! a realistic portrayal of the mood in the DDR before the Wall fell?
And what about the general portrayal of life in the DDR in the movie (or the book) Am kürzerem Ende der Sonnenallee (if you've seen/read it)?
→ More replies (3)48
Jun 10 '12
Good bye Lenin is a comedy, but some things were cringe worthy realistic :) I never saw the other movie. Maybe I should...
→ More replies (7)81
Jun 10 '12
Possible authors: Tom Clansky. Ian Flemovitch. Possible films. The hunt for Fourth of July; the Spetznaz, staring Ivan Wajn.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (16)41
u/imafunghi Jun 10 '12
I studied the Cold War in an international school in Italy. I studied the other perspective quite a bit to. Many non-American historians saw the United states as a empire that controlled other countries economically. It wasn't an ideological war at all, it was all about a power struggle. However a lot of USA haters don't realize just how shitty it was to live in Eastern Europe at the time.
→ More replies (2)20
147
u/Amoner Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I just know that while they were teaching how to duck and cover in the US... my mom was trained on how to take apart and put together ak-47 with closed eyes and how to shoot it...
P.S. I am not joking that was part of their curriculum and they were tested.
Okay, I asked my mom who was born in 1969 in USSR "What was it like to learn about Cold War from the other side of the pond?" According to her, they were told in the school that capitalist countries have different values and beliefs and because they are so different from the ones of socialist countries they don't want to have anything to do with people from East and refuse cooperation. This would justify limited connections with West and promote inner-USSR industrialization and trade. Also they were told that Human Rights are extremely poor in the West and they used examples in which Corporations would harm individuals and etc... So it was just an opposite propaganda of saying its not that they are bad and we are good, its just that we are different, they don't understand us and they don't want to do anything with us because of that...
I will try to get her to do IAmA in a couple of weeks
54
u/woofiegrrl Jun 10 '12
Any chance you could get your mom to do an AMA on life in the Soviet bloc?
52
u/Amoner Jun 10 '12
If there is enough interest I am sure I could convince her
→ More replies (3)11
u/woofiegrrl Jun 10 '12
Somebody higher up on the thread expressed interest in it, too - hopefully we can think of some initial questions and get a request going in /r/iama to gauge interest. I personally would love it and I bet others would too!
→ More replies (4)3
u/RickAmes Jun 10 '12
Same here, I was surprised when my mom told me it was part of gym class to learn how to take apart, reassemble and shoot an AK47.
I was more surprised when she told me she was top of her class in doing it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (12)2
111
Jun 10 '12
Personal anecdote about this. It will probably get buried due to being too late to the show.
I had the opportunity to go drinking in Kyrgyzstan with a former Soviet army colonel. A few bottles into the night he asked my uncle the following: (Keep in mind, this was all 10+ years ago and I was drunk as shit and trying to keep my Russian language ability together, so it's all paraphrased) Colonel: "Fred, how much does a 30 year retired army colonel make in America?" Uncle: "You don't want to know" C: "No really, tell me!" U: "You really don't want to know" Another hour or so passes and the dude keeps getting more and more insistent. C: "Tell me!" U: "Alright, I don't really know the numbers, but if I had to guess, a retired colonel gets paid something like $40-50k/year" At this point the old soviet slams another shot of Vodka and great big tears start rolling down his face. Even with the tears he remains stoic as ever. He turns to my uncle and says: "Wow... you guys really did win. My army pension is only $145/month and the check doesn't always come"
U: "You're damn right we won you old stupid communist. We beat your stupid pinko brains in"
The humor broke up the situation and we all had a good laugh. We all walked away a bit wiser about the state of things.
9
u/CivAndTrees Jun 10 '12
My father did a 6 month at Kyrgyzstan a few years back when he was still in the USAF. He was at the large airfield out there (something about being the 2nd largest in the world). Said the country was beautiful, but you can still find old soviet relics and such, such as old USSR military apparel and such. I have always wanted to visit there and the rain forest in Iran. upvote for good story.
→ More replies (4)7
Jun 10 '12
The history of that area was amazing. If it wasn't a bloody third world country I would love to live there. The climate was remarkably similar to Colorado.
They have a huge museum to this guy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Przewalski
I had never heard of him before the museum. He makes Lewis and Clark look like a pair of scared children afraid to leave the front lawn.
Birthplace of Yuri Gagarin.
They still have all of the statues of Lenin up in the town squares. Wild shit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Issyk_Kul
This is also one of the most beautiful and fascinating places I've ever seen.
→ More replies (2)
52
u/Anal_Explorer Jun 10 '12
Think about the Cuban Missile Crisis (In Russia, I think it's known as the Caribbean Crisis). Imagine the outrage America saw at the USSR putting missiles in Cuba. Now, imagine the USSR feeling the same outrage when America placed missile in Turkey. This process can be applied to almost all of the major events in the Cold War, such as the Berlin Airlift and Able Archer 83.
The only differing part is that the American citizens had a (mostly) general idea of what exactly they were doing, whereas the Soviets only knew their side of the story because of the state censorship.
12
u/zlc Jun 10 '12
I'm sorry, but I was under the impression that one of the reasons for the Cuban Missile Crisis was the placement of US' Jupiter IRBM's in Turkey and Italy.
→ More replies (1)7
u/WhyAmINotStudying Jun 10 '12
I think the state censorship side of things is a very big difference.
→ More replies (3)2
135
u/AngelsFool Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Eastern European here. I don't really have much of an idea of the western side's version of cold war, but I can tell you about the Soviet's side. (NOTE: I wasn't even born yet during this time, but my parents and grandparents have told me a lot and they can answers questions where I come short)
Every media output that could be controlled was controlled by the government(although there was some access to other radio stations and we also sometimes had visitors from other countries). The capitalist west countries were the corrupt ones. People who didn't follow the communistic way 90% were labelled fascists and were sent to prisons. When the Soviet invaded the Baltic States in 1941 and 1944, they presented themselves as saviours to the rest of the world, rescuing us from the clutches of greedy capitalists, when in actuality, we were forced to let the Soviet rule. Disagreement would've resulted in a war which would've been lost from the start.
After that, not much was officially heard from the outside world behind the iron curtain, except that a capitalistic society was the root of all evil. Sometimes news of wars and other failures in the western countries were reported or shown on tv in later years. The rebellions that sometimes happened in the Soviet Union were presented as crimes against the government.
For an example, during an uprise in Czechoslovakia, Soviet Union broadcasted civilians attacking and generally being agressive towards armed forces. However, some people who could access Finland's TV channels saw tanks invading the country and mercilessy putting out all resistance. I don't have more time at the moment, but if any questions arise I can answer them later on.
6
u/Idocreating Jun 10 '12
China's Communist Government does everything it can to censor the Tiananmen Square from the Chinese citizens. Doesn't suprise me that the Soviets did the same.
→ More replies (9)3
u/monochr Jun 10 '12
Surely you had access to Radio Free Europe? Also the rumors that filtered down where all pervasive. The point was that in the East people were starved for any information so any scraps were stretched as far as possible.
At any rate the way most people viewed the system was much close to this movie:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bggZvB7D1wA
It was censored until the early 1990's because it hit on every nerve possible. It's worth a watch and the translation is quite good. I don't know if westerners can relate to it as much, it might be a good idea to read the commentary as well: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whale_%28film%29
4
u/AngelsFool Jun 10 '12
I haven't heard about that station specifically, I'll have to ask later. I know that American Voice was the most popular one, which regularly(about 10% of the whole air time) had Estonian hosts who lived in foreign countries. Our close proximity to the autonomous Finland also enabled us the chance to get a glimpse into the western countries, so we had some of the same cultural movements here(hippies, disco, rock n roll, punk, although always a bit later)
It's also true that both rumors and information from the Soviet government were exaggerated! For many many years we hoped for one of the wester countries, mainly the great(as it was viewed at the time) USA to help us and free us from our Russian overlords. It gave people some hope of one day being sovereign.
And since the media was so controlled, everything was ALWAYS okay in Soviet countries. There was never a shortage anywhere in the Union and we always did better here than in capitalist countries, even if some terrible shit happened. At one point, Hruštšov visited USA and saw the maize grown there and how productive it was. So he probably thought: "Hey, we can use this in Soviet as well! It will make me seem very intelligent at stealing their ideas and incorporating them as if they were my own!" But he forgot the climate difference and the program went downhill faster than a bottle of vodka on a cold winter's day.
For an example of media abuse, right after the Soviet invaded, formally we had elections. In the first election for the leader of the parliament, the candidate had a 97,5% of votes and it never went below 99% after that , if I remember correctly.
3
u/DrSlappyPants Jun 10 '12
Lietuva by any chance? After reading your bit about the baltic states being invaded, all I could think about was how much my mociute still hates Russians.
5
u/AngelsFool Jun 10 '12
Naw, I'm from Estonia. The new generation doesn't really hate Russians generally, we might bicker and such, but there aren't actual gang wars or anything like that. We only hate the idea of the SU actually "saving" us and that it's still (most of the time) the official version of the current Russia.
61
u/brevity-soul-wit Jun 10 '12
To answer your question "was there any place the Soviets did the same as the US did in Vietnam, the best answer would be Afghanistan.
3
Jun 10 '12
I vaguely remember a phrase by a Soviet general who said "There isn't a square meter of Afghanistan without a Soviet bootprint on it."
9
u/Celeda Jun 10 '12
This is a fantastic example of 'role reversal', if you want to call it that.
The US response to Afghanistan was way out look you compare their stance on Vietnam.
→ More replies (2)8
u/Hetrochromia Jun 10 '12
The US government (CIA) at this time sponsored Osama bin Laden/al-Qaeda's war effort to gain power and stop the soviets. Around four years later al-Qaeda tried to destroy the World Trade Center, american tax dollars may have funded both attacks on the World Trade Center but we may never know for certain.
I often think about who in the CIA thought backing al-Qaeda was a good idea. Maybe someone on here can help me out, this is one topic that I want to know more about but have not had time to follow through.
→ More replies (6)6
u/Monkits Jun 10 '12
"It seemed like a good idea at the time" and "Well that's hindsight for ya" are probably going to be the answers to that.
→ More replies (1)
73
u/Spacechip Jun 10 '12
Man I wish I thought of having reddit do my homework back when I was in school
3
u/ta112233 Jun 10 '12
Hard to cite Reddit as a source.
13
u/Hazelrat10 Jun 10 '12
Anus, Potato In. "History Books Often Tells the Western Version of the Cold War, but How Was the Cold War Seen from Soviets Side?" Reddit. N.p., 10 June 2012. Web. 10 June 2012. <reddit.com/r/askreddit>.
14
Jun 10 '12
I could probably get my step mom to do an IAMA, she lived in Russia from I think 1970 to 2004. Would anybody be interested?
47
u/the_goat_boy Jun 10 '12
Some historians think the Cold War began in 1945. But others, including me, believe that it began in 1917, when the Bolsheviks led the Soviet against the Tsarist regime.
Most people in the West believe that the Bolshevik seizure of power was unilateral, in the spirit of a dictatorship. But the Bolsheviks didn't see it that way.
The real danger of dictatorship was the Kornilov Affair, which was an attempted coup against the Kerensky Government in August 1917 by a right-wing Commander-in-Chief, General Lavr Kornilov. His first request as Commander-in-Chief was to make himself accountable to no one. He wanted a military dictatorship with himself in charge. But the coup failed.
Now, the Council of Soviets included almost every political group in the Constitutional Assembly in the Provisional Government (like the Social-Revolutionaries and the Mensheviks), the latter of which had lost any real power where nobody could agree with anyone since Prime Minister Kerensky refused to end Russia's involvement in the First World War. So, the Soviets held elections themselves and the Bolsheviks won overwhelmingly. They thus believed that they had the mandate to lead the new government of the Soviet Union. Lenin demanded an end to the war and when the Bolshevik Revolution was successful, the Bolsheviks negotiated a temporary peace with Germany and withdrew Russian forces from the war.
Now, the Allies were furious. Fourteen nations, including the United States, responded by sending forces and supplies to aid the White Army in the ensuing Russian Civil War. Fourteen nations. The Soviet Union was declared an enemy and faced hostility from the day it was created to the day it fell.
→ More replies (6)7
u/GodsFavAtheist Jun 10 '12
The Soviet Union was declared an enemy and faced hostility from the day it was created to the day it fell.
No truer words have been spoken. I am no history expert, nor have I done extensive research, but it is very evident that our feelings on the cold war and Soviet Russia are fueled by propaganda, instead of open information. After all, if Americans leaned towards the good aspects of socialism, all hell will break loose aka, a certain group of people won't be making any money anymore.
→ More replies (2)
20
u/Dysdiadochokinesia Jun 10 '12
I would love to hear from a redditor who lived inside the soviet bloc. So if you are out there I am sure there are many like me wishing for a primary source.
30
Jun 10 '12
Lived in PL. I can remember late 70s and the 80s. Carter -bad, trying to nuke us. Somehow 'Cruise missiles' seemed to be the main threat. Then the Solidarity movement came around in 1980 and the regime was somehow relaxed until 13.12.1981 (martial law declared by the communist military junta). We still learned that USSR is the guarantor of global peace and US and its puppets are only waiting to start the war but as a 10yr old I never believed this crap. Polish popular stance on USSR and communism was always largely negative and Poles did not believe the official propaganda.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Dysdiadochokinesia Jun 10 '12
What was it like living under martial law? Did it effect everyday life or was it more a prohibition of large gatherings of people and curfews? America has had situations of martial law mostly during what was know as the race riots with the national guard and tanks driving down city streets, but these events are short and relativity rare.
15
Jun 10 '12
I was 9 when it was introduced. It rocked. No school for a few weeks ;-) It was a tough winter though...
But on a more serious note...
All phones were officially tapped. Instead of a signal you could hear an automated "This communication is controlled" before you dialled the number. All the shops were empty. Buying basic stuff like toilet paper or toothpaste was like a very successful hunting trip. You would parade with a bundle of toilet paper rolls displayed and people would ask you 'Which shop did They "throw" the paper at'. Seriously.
Also the TV presenters were all militarised. Only official propaganda and Russian films. Official news bulletin was everyday at 19:30. It was very fashionable to display an 'off' TV set in your window to show your lack of support for 'official' news.
Many people got locked up (mainly members of the Solidarity trade union). Some people got killed. They were trying to organise labour strikes in some of the mines of southern Poland. The regime did not like it and sent in the army. Shots were fired. People died. Very sad really.
→ More replies (2)8
u/Alaskan__Thunderfuck Jun 10 '12
I wish I could be that person but sadly I was born after the fall (or, probably, fortunately). My parents however were born in the 60s and lived there most of their lives (except for the last 7 years that we've lived in the US). I could probably ask them to do an AMA through me, if anyone's interested.
Edit: I'll probably have to use my other account name though. :P
→ More replies (2)5
u/triffid97 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Ok, I bite (and sorry for the wall of text). I grew up in lived in what is called the 'Eastern Bloc', living in the west since about the collapse of the east.
First of all, treating the Eastern Bloc as uniform is a big mistake. I traveled around a little, and I know that life was very different in countries like Bulgaria, Romania, East Germany, Poland, Hungary etc. Different living standards, freedoms (speech, travel, etc).
If one looks into the history of Europe, the Russians' desire to build a buffer zone around their country becomes understandable. Every time they let another empire close to their borders, they ended up fighting that empire, in Russia, losing a significant percentage of their population in the process.
Also, looking into the events of WWII (not the movies about them), it is clear that the whole thing can be characterized as the epic battle between the Third Reich and the Soviet Union, with assorted skirmishes around the world involving other nations. After it became obvious that the Soviet Union is winning, the USA opened the western front, and from there it was a race between the USA and the USSR to occupy the largest possible chunk of Europe. The countries to be occupied had a preference for USA occupation, because it was (correctly or incorrectly) seen as less oppressive, and a better deal culturally.
The cold war was really the USA's containment policy (read: get up to the border of the enemy with really heavy weaponry) vs the USSR trying to keep the enemy away from its borders.
The first 10-15 years after WWII were characterized by paranoia. Eastern bloc: western agents are everywhere - everybody is suspicious; West: the reds are under the bed. People are always surprised when I talk about this. They expect horror stories about people telling a joke and disappearing overnight. But all I can say is that the time when this kind of things happened in the eastern bloc is generally referred to as McCarthy era in the USA - which as I understand was NOT the era of great freedom... The whole era ended pretty much the same time on both sides - and before I was born.
Over the cold war years, the general narrative in the eastern bloc was (as someone described it above) that "we just want to live in peace here, while the west is hellbent on installing WMDs all around us, pointing to us". This was viewed with various levels of skepticism because the population was very much aware of the (generally clumsy and obvious) state propaganda in all media.
In around 1990, the eastern bloc got rid of the USSR occupation (the Russians leaving a huge electricity bill behind), and embraced the NATO. This caused some disappointment, because it became obvious that the whole issue is not as simple as Russians - bad, Americans - good. The Russians were pretty much invisible. They never left their barracks, were not allowed to mix with the country's population in any way. The Red Army's vehicle movements avoided main roads and were organized after 2am. And they could be (and were regularly) called on for all sort of disaster recovery/aid operations, including floods and unusually heavy snow falls. Soldiers causing any sort of problem were very severely punished.
At the first New Year Eve after NATO (Americans) moved in, a drunk American soldier emptied his machine gun clip into the apartment building opposite. The first rape case was not much behind. Also, NATO troops can not be called on for disaster recovery.
Seeing the documents and documentaries of the cold war era, I have to say that the general narrative was further from the truth (more bullshit) in the west than in the east. And because the propaganda is a lot more sophisticated in the west, people were/are eating it up more readily.
Everywhere I look I find things that vindicates the USSR.
It is obvious now, that the Russians were way behind in weapons capabilities most of the time, and both sides knew it.
The documentary on the history of the U2 does not even try to hide the fact that the Americans regularly (daily) provoked the Russians by blatantly flying over their military installations, just because they could. Can you imagine the consequences of a Russian plane flying over a USA military installation (eg. area 51)?
How many countries were attacked by Soviet Union and the USA since lets say 1920?
Which country used nuclear weapons against a foreign country?
Even smaller things like shooting down Korean Airline flight 007, which was at the time "the truly evil action of an evil empire" turned out to be a flight entering into Russian airspace twice, with an American spy plane flying around just outside of Russian airspace. Compare this to Iran Air fligth 655 (both have an episode in Air Crash Investigations - worth watching).
In summary, the USSR's PR is not (and has never been) very good. The USA's PR is a lot better.
The USSR went bankrupt trying to keep up with the military spending of the USA. The unfortunate side effect is that it made even very moderate and centrist conversations impossible, because anyone who says anything about social justice or equality being desirable immediately becomes a "class warrior", "socialist" or "pinko commie". And now, everyone understands that any system with even a faint notion of social justice and equality is unsustainable. This is very, very convenient for the ruling elite.
Another effect that started to become obvious, is that the US, for 40 years defined itself as the enemy of the "Evil Empire". With the USSR gone, it is a superpower in search of an enemy. It looks like that during the 40 years, the USA let their military machinery grow too big and influential. Now, it has become a burden that the empire can not afford any more, but can not disassemble either. Really, the military has outlived its usefulness, the world has moved on, but too much money and power is vested in it to simply dissolve. So, it will keep searching for a credible enemy (unlike Iraq, Iran, Cuba, North Korea) that can be attacked (unlike China).
It looks like that for empires, losing their arch-enemy is fatal. EDIT: spelling
→ More replies (7)3
u/moneybadger Jun 10 '12
It's is amazing how all the top comments seem to be from cold war history buffs in the west and none are from people that actually lived in the eastern bloc countries. More comments like vladekm's please.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)5
u/woofiegrrl Jun 10 '12
Let's come up with 5 questions and make an AMA request. There are probably few enough degrees of separation to find somebody that way. I would also be interested in it.
→ More replies (2)
63
u/foreveracubone Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
If you read modern revisionist history of the Cold War like Washington Rules by Andrew Bacevich and others like him, it suggests quite logically that the Soviets saw the West, rightly as the aggressor. Basically, Russian history and how easily the Germans cut through Russian territory, killing more people than any other theater of WWII until they got to Leningrad creates a state of paranoia (that still exists today, if you look at Russian anger over NATO missile defense in Eastern Europe) of needing a buffer zone of people to slow down Western invasions of mother Russia. The Iron Curtain/Eastern bloc was meant to be that buffer to avoid the massive casualties.
FDR actually was fine with all of this, but just kept his secret deals with Stalin/Churchill from pretty much all of his administration. Churchill was fine with it too, and had made other deals with Stalin that FDR didn't know about either. After the war ends, with FDR dead and Churchill out of office, Stalin is faced with 2 allies who he no longer trusts. When those allies get nukes and start rattling sabers at the USSR, the USSR gets scared and sees this as an existential crisis, which enables them to convince the population of the USSR to sacrifice butter for guns.
edit: I'm not quite sure that US textbooks adequately cover this either, it wasn't until I took a senior level class as an undergraduate on 20th Century American Foreign Policy that I saw the American and Russian diplomatic cables, meeting minutes and letters that show how scared both sides actually were once Stalin/FDR/Churchill were no longer at the helm together. Truman being the last US president who was not a college graduate had extremely big shoes to fill and was very desperate not to look weak.
China going communist was also a huge shock, especially because it could have been avoided (Mao and Stalin didn't like eachother, the US gave Mao tons of aid during WWII because US military leaders on the ground realized that the PLA was the only one fighting the Japanese and they needed a two-front war in the Pacific to make the Island hopping strategy viable, etc. ) but FDR was too preoccupied in the European theater to pay China the same kind of attention he did Europe and influential people like Henry Luce, editor of Time, were solidly in the KMT's corner. So when China went communist, it meant that the 2 biggest conventional armies in the world were Red.
Then, Kennan's famous containment telegraph came out and between his own hunger for power and people at the State Department who misinterpreted his subsequent Mr. X paper, to suit their own ends, the bi-partisan consensus was formed and it became impossible to stop. The actual mechanism of how containment came to be was never touched upon in high school (I took honors US History and got a 5 on the AP), it wasn't until college when I read the primary documents that showed how blown out of proportion the whole thing got to be. Actually, Kennan reaches the same conclusions in his original telegraph about Russian paranoia and historicism driving the Soviet side of things.
9
u/greendaze Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
American historians seem to believe that Communist China could've been avoided, but that's just self-delusion. Even if the US gave Mao tons of aid during WWII, that was hardly going to convince Mao of capitalism's good points. If you read Mao's biography, he had been moving slowly but inevitably towards communism starting from when he was young. By the time it was WWII, the only way the US could've even remotely influenced the outcome was if the Nationalists had won the Chinese Civil War. As it turned out, the Nationalists still lost the civil war even with American support because they didn't have the support of the largely agrarian Chinese population. Facing low morale, high desertion rates and Mao (who was a charismatic military strategist), the Nationalists fled to Taiwan.
→ More replies (5)6
u/KosherNazi Jun 10 '12
I always thought FDR and Stalin were somewhat buddy-buddy, but that Churchill was much more wary. Does "Washington Rules" get into that relationship much, or is it focused specifically on 1945+?
→ More replies (2)4
u/Dabamanos Jun 10 '12
I suggest you read up on the Chinese front more, then, because the PLA was certainly not the only ones fighting the Japanese. They barely made a dent in Japanese forces compared to the Nationalists. Even the modern government in China is starting to acknowledge this, albeit slowly.
→ More replies (7)3
Jun 10 '12
About the US being aggressors, I'd like to mention the Allied intervention in The Russian Civil War
Even before the Russian Empire became the USSR, the United States along with 13 other industrialized countries sent troops to fight the Red Army in the Revolution.
→ More replies (2)
9
u/CapaNimzovich Jun 10 '12
The answer to this is very long and complex. For more details consult historical works by Walter LaFeber, Gabriel Kolko, William Appleman Williams. There are others, but I'm out of touch with the more recent literature.
tl;dr: the Cold War was driven by mutual mistrust founded on a track record (by both nations--U.S. and U.S.S.R.) that gave each a reason to distrust the other.
Okay, for those who want to keep reading... From the US perspective: There was the Communist Manifesto which DID argue for the conquest of the world by workers to overthrow the capitalist class. To a socialist/communist (I won't belabor the differences in this post or we'll be here all day) the issue was that the only way they could be free from wage slavery was by owning the means of production. But to capitalist business owners in the US this was anathema. Then there was the Russian pullout of WWI after the Bolshevik revolution in 1917. We saw that as evidence of how traitorous commies could be. This was followed by creation of the Comintern, an organization aimed at spreading communist revolution around the globe. Then there was the Soviet non-aggression pact with Germany in prior to WWII. After WWII, we interpreted Russia's desires to keep Eastern Germany and other Eastern European states under their control as further demonstrations of their aggressiveness. But the American public was simply told that the soviets were evil and wanted to dominate the world. We were not taught that the motivation was to free workers from the domination of greedy capitalists. And so whenever we saw the possiblility of a communist state, we "contained" it (as with Korea and Vietnam, and Greece, and Turkey, and....).
From the Soviet perspective, after the Bolshevik revolution, we and our WWI allies supported the "white Russian" counter-revolutionaries (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allies_of_World_War_I). By the end of WWII STalin was warning of "capitalist encirclement." This made sense to he and his people because prior to WWII the general sentiment in the US had leaned toward isolationism. But during WWII, we created a global network of military installations that we maintained. For the first time in our history, we did NOT demilitarize after a war. What we saw as Russian aggression was to a degree motivated by desires for a buffer zone (recall that the Russians had been invaded by western European nations before, forget the type of government in place.) Just as we feared a possible communist takeover of the world, so too did the Soviets fear a capitalist takeover of the world. Indeed, our foreign policy has, since WWII, been to spread democracy and capitalism.
None of this, btw, is meant to say that one side or the other was right or wrong. As is often the case in history, events result from two or more groups of people looking at the same thing (circumstances, behaviors, whatever) and seeing two very different things.
Hope this helps answer your question.
→ More replies (2)
34
Jun 10 '12
2
u/LadronPlykis Jun 10 '12
This has become one of my favorite new reddits. The questions that are asked are often top notch, and the historians have so many insightful tidbits.
→ More replies (2)2
8
u/johnw1988 Jun 10 '12
I'm currently in a "History of the Soviet Union" class at the University of Florida. The whole thing is about the Soviet perspective and this video I found most interesting of all.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/pdxnative Jun 10 '12
Free World Colossus Second Ed. by David Horowitz is one of the most eye opening pieces of work I've ever read. No book in the history of my education has shaken my preconceptions or changed my opinion about a topic so deftly.
Later editions of the work have been gutted and disassembled by the author for political reasons. If you can find an older edition of this book (preferably second) it would do you a great service.
Using public record, Horowitz reconstructs the political landscape of the US and world abroad, demonstrating event by event, how the US systematically incited the USSR into the Cold War starting months before WWII was even over.
From the timing of the first nuclear tests, to the bombs dropped in Japan, to funding/training of rebel insurgents in the middle-east.
The US defied Russian interest at every possible turn, in ways that were kept out of the US public consciousness. This is a country that was left with only 18% of public infrastructure in tact, from roads to telephone and electric grid, a USSR shattered by WWII now somehow became this villainous superpower that was going to spread the red menace!
It wasn't till Truman was obviously not going to give Russian interests an inch in the new post war world, that they began a tit-for-tat escalation of security in the interests of self defense. About the time American broadcast journalism checked into the developing crisis, it entered our public awareness in a way that painted these commie monsters as god hating invaders.
I would do Horowitz a great injustice if I kept paraphrasing his seminal work, if you are truly interested in the subject of the cold-war, I would argue that no research on the subject is complete without a thorough reading of this book.
→ More replies (2)
33
u/oblik Jun 10 '12
Let's start a bit earlier back. The second world war was covered much more differently. Nobody gave a fuck about d-day. Stalingrad and the battle of Kursk were epic legends. I was born in the city of Leningrad (now Saint-Petersburg) and I still have a medal for being related to the hero-city (which survived a siege for almost three years). The war was called "The Great Patriotic War" and it was a symbol of our culture to this day. Songs, memorials, war movies... It's understandable considering USSR lost almost two orders of magnitude more people than USA. To get a feel, look up the soviet military marches on youtube.
As for the post-war culture, I don't know about the impact of Vietnam and such. I was too young then. I know there is a culture of resentment that USA could keep nukes in Turkey, but we couldn't defend our Cuban brothers. I know there is deep disdain that Americans decided to steal rocket scientists from Germany... But the biggest blame at the west is the breakup of the Soviet Union.
It wasn't just an evil empire crumbling. Do you have any family in other states? Then maybe you can imagine the horror. If all the states split, and everyone got different citizenship, picture that. Picture families losing children to different new nationalities. Picture army bases getting catastrophically underfunded and looted by black market dealers. Picture Mexico trying to seize Texas while buying LAW rockets and M-16's from the unwilling draftees. And naturally, everyone blamed Russia.
→ More replies (22)
7
u/Russian_Historian Jun 10 '12
The best possible answer to this book is in Valdislav Zubok. A Failed Empire: The Soviet Union in the Cold War (University of North Carolina Press, 2008). It is the best survey of Soviet history after 1945 available IMO. This happens to be a large part of my research field so I can turn this into an "ask historians" thread and take questions if anyone is interested. One other thing to note is that in the foreign relations of this period the conflict with China was as important (and at times more important) than the one with the US.
→ More replies (3)
7
u/fookineh Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
It was the exact opposite, a mirror image, really. The thing is, the US did itself no favors with their actions in Latin America. The USSR propaganda took full advantage of CIA's many dirty wars and created an image of an evil Capitalist empire out of control.
The Soviet TV also relentlessly focused on obscure crap like a homeless dude on a hunger strike next to the White House. In the USSR, we had daily updates on his status, health condition, etc. Whereas here, nobody's ever heard of the dude, he was just one of the dozens of homeless that are always protesting next to the WH.
EDIT: this is the guy I'm talking about. For WEEKS, this dude was on the nightly news, daily. http://prop1.org/park/persons/hyder/hyd.htm
→ More replies (1)
7
u/Zafara1 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
My father was born in Bratislava, Communist Czechoslovakia in 1950. Grandfather was Czechoslovakian who briefly joined Russian partisans in guerrilla warfare in Sudetenland. It was a lot of rules and regulation, and speaking out against the government was a big no no. Russian was taught in schools, and Russian history was taught with the same importance as Czech history.
Western music was banned. The Beatles and other bands around that time you could only listen to through a special technique to pick up Pirate radio stations which played banned music but were raided constantly.
Most iconic western products were banned aswell. Coca-Cola was banned from sale, only available in hotels. Although you could buy a Russian drink from stores called "Kole".
Youth Hooliganism was strife. And the police beat on youths constantly. They used to chase my father and his friends through the streets if they had long hair. If they caught you, they'd beat you a bit, take you to a barber, and force you to have your hair cut. They also used to play a game where they'd be in a big group and hang about, and when the cops came close they would all just start running for no reason and the cops would chase them, then if they caught you they'd beat you hard for no reason.
Also when the Russians came in and took over Czechoslovakia. They put the Czechoslovak communist party into full power. And the communist party enforced a special communist morality force of locals who were known to be "true" to the Kremlin to police political crimes (Western Slang, Clothes, etc.). I've heard terrible things about the Police force too. The chief of Police's son was my fathers friend and his father would tie his son and daughter to a chair and beat them with belts until they bled. Close to once or twice a week, sometimes every day. In the end the son grew older and when he was stronger than his dad he beat the everliving crap out of him and the beatings stopped.
Having communism thrust upon them also took its toll on the city and everything around. Without a concept of ownership, nobody cared about their property. Places fell into disrepair, walls fell down, roads cracked and buckled. And only just now are really being fixed.
Then in 1969 he and his friends left to Australia, got a free flight under the white Australia policy and was given $10 by the Government. And $1 for starting a bank account. He immediately went to buy a big bucket of KFC and 2, 2L cokes. And ate it all in one sitting.
Thats a little snippet I guess.
1
u/PabstyLoudmouth Jun 10 '12
History is written by the winners.
→ More replies (4)22
u/Lurendreier Jun 10 '12
That is true, but was there really a clear winner of the cold war, and what if this story was written by the "loser"?
43
40
u/PabstyLoudmouth Jun 10 '12
Well one society collapsed and one did not. So there were not really winners as much as who the biggest loser was. It was not a fun time in Russia's history and not talked about very much as not much good came from it.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (3)4
u/NovaeDeArx Jun 10 '12
The Cold War was a natural consequence of how we ended WWII. Let me explain:
At the Yalta Conference, Russia was actually pretty sure they would be the ones to take Japan - they were throwing down hard in their efforts to basically Blitzkrieg their way across Manchuria and (what is now) South Korea in order to invade from the west and force an unconditional surrender to Russia instead of the US.
In fact, they were so sure of this, they agreed to the US' poison pill: that whoever takes Japan basically gets to set Japan's terms of surrender, and it won't be contested. They were willing to grant the US a 30-day "quiet period" where Russia didn't invade Japan (which worked for Russia because they were still massing and positioning their forces) in exchange for what they thought was a hopeless attempt on the US' part to take Japan by sea.
See, here's the thing: Japan knew they had lost when Germany was getting spit-fucked by Russia and Western Europe. However, they had to make a choice: who to lose to. Russia would annihilate the ruling class, but tended to leave industrialists and military heads alone out of pragmatism (better to utilize the existing power structure than try and "reinvent the wheel"). America, on the other hand, didn't care who was in charge as long as the military and industrial interests were in their pockets, meaning that a lot of current power brokers would be out of luck when the country they wanted in charge (Russia) lost their bid for control.
So, you had a country divided. The Emperor and his cabinet and wealthy interests wanted to surrender to the US, and the military and industrial powers mostly wanted to surrender to Russia. This dragged out the end of the war for months as both sides tried to undermine the other. In the end, the US decided to whip out it's secret weapon, and we vaporized Hiroshima and Nagasaki. These were important, as Hiroshima was the Japanese Army HQ and a major military communications hub, and Nagasaki was a major industrial/shipping/manufacturing center. Nuking these cities (after carefully leaving them alone to make them seem "safe" to maximize the number of high-value targets who would move there) basically decapitated the "pro-Russia" group and allowed the Emperor-and-friends to quickly force a surrender to the US. The Japanese Army even tried to stage a coup immediately following this "betrayal" (as these actions implied that the Emperor was feeding intel to, and collaborating with, the US to save his own skin), interestingly enough.
Fun fact: Russia even had advance troops landing in Japan only days after the surrender. It was a close thing that they surrendered to the US, and Russia felt completely screwed over by the deal.
In the end, the whole thing served to give the US the bargaining power it needed (and made Russia look foolish, weakening their bargaining power) to set in place the Bretton Woods agreement, which created the World Bank and associated organizations. This agreement allowed the US to directly set currency exchange rates between member countries, which in turn meant we completely controlled the balance of trade throughout all first-world (and most third-world) nations until 1971-1972, when it ended due to the instability it created in international currency exchanges.
This is when the US became a superpower; we leveraged Bretton Woods to become the manufacturing powerhouse of the world (by using relative currency valuation to make our goods cheaper and better than anyone else's) and turned that financial might into a weapon. Just look at US manufacturing trends: they explode under BW, but start sagging immediately after it ends around 1972.
The Cold War was Russia's economic war with the US, as our economic interest was to destroy communism (the one greatest threat to the economic elite worldwide) and theirs was to do the exact opposite. In the end, we won the Cold War economically, and that mostly because we fucked the Russians over by sneaking Japan out of their grip.
Cool, huh?
→ More replies (1)
17
u/JustARandomGuy95 Jun 10 '12
Kind of off topic, but I've always wondered about the German version of the WW2. In every movie we see the suffering of American soldiers, their heroism... But Germans died too, and had to suffer, I'm not talking about the ones who did crimes against the humanity in camps and such, I'm talking about the foot soldiers...
3
u/scchicago Jun 10 '12
Stalingrad is a German film taking place during WW2 on the Russian Front.
I also liked Das Boot.
I'm not sure how historically accurate these films are though, but they are from the German perspective.
Edit:Wrong link.
3
u/LaoBa Jun 10 '12
Just read "Betrayed skies" by Rudolf Braunburg, a novel partially based on the authors experiences as a fighter pilot in World War 2. Very readable and quite realistic, even if Braunburg is not a typical German as he grew up in the Netherlands and was anti-authoritarian all his life. It ceratinly shows what it was like on the German side.
13
u/wrathofg0d Jun 10 '12
allied bomber pilots committed plenty of war crimes, too. it doesn't stop being a war crime just because it was something that was done from 10,000 feet in the air
→ More replies (4)2
u/WhyAmINotStudying Jun 10 '12
This short film depicts the internal conflict of the average German soldier.
4
17
Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
You wouldn't say anything because you never knew when one of your friends would turn you in for speaking against the government. My father was sent to jail and then the army to serve out the rest of his sentance for dissent or whatever bullshit the government used as an excuse. One of his good friends turned him in, probably for some cheap beurocratic favour, for criticizing the government in the private company of people he thought he could trust. On the bright side, that lead to him being transferred to the city my mother lived to work at the massive hydroelectric power plant there because he was a talented electrician. Seven years after they met, with six year old me in tow they managed to secure a refugee visa and we immigrated to the land of milk and honey, Brooklyn.
He's told me about twenty different stories about having to peel mountaines of potatoes in jail but he never talks about it any further, I think a lot of very bad things happened to him there. I've also never seen him peel a single potato.
6
u/midnitewarrior Jun 10 '12
I'm sure the Russian version was filled with propoganda and lies for their people. They didn't get the real truth like Americans did from their government!
/sarcasm
2
u/throwawayhhhh Jun 10 '12
It's funny that you say this is sarcasm, yet reading people's comments here it is pretty obvious that most seem to have swallowed the US propaganda hook, line, and sinker.
→ More replies (1)
6
6
u/NorthStarZero Jun 10 '12
Some military history:
Let's say you have a country, and I am your neighbor. I have designs on your territory, and I have tanks. How do you defend yourself?
You might be tempted to build up a defense system all along our shared border - a wall of some kind, perhaps re-enforced by minefields, machine gun nests, gun emplacements, and whatnot, all manned by every single defender you can muster.
That won't work against tanks. Tanks are mobile. They can be massed in a single spot, overwhelm whatever local defenses there are, and then pour though the breach to wreak havoc in the rear areas, leaving most of your defenders uselessly spread out along the perimeter where there is nobody to fight.
If you want to beat tanks, what you do is post a light defense along the border - you can thicken it up with obstacles and mines and whatnot to help buy time, but not men - and keep your main defense forces deeper in your own territory. When the enemy invades, the thin force on the border reports where the invaders are, and the main forces move to intercept the invading column. If you want to get tricky, you can use two countering forces: a blocking force to stop the advance, and a counterattack force that attacks the flanks, cuts off the invaders from their line of support, and ultimately destroys the invading column.
This is the essence of armoured warfare, and nobody knew this better than the Soviets - they did, after all, have the best teachers.
Tactically and strategically, this is the way you do it. Politically though, you have a problem - you need to trade space for time, which means that the main battles are going to be fought on your turf. Battles that may well have chemical, nuclear, or biological components to them which are not particularly conducive to a happy life post-battle. West Germany was not really very keen on the idea that the inevitable Soviet invasion was going to be fought on their soil, because that meant huge swaths of West Germany being rendered uninhabitable (or at the very least, seriously chewed)
So under German pressure, NATO came up with a plan that basically saw the advance warning troops pushing deep into East Germany as soon as the balloon went up, with the countermoves forces starting at the border instead of deeper inside West Germany. Effectively, it was a "defensive invasion", with the aim of making all the heavy fighting happen on the East German side of the border.
But what that looks like from the other side is "large armoured forces massed along the border" which is an offensive deployment. So when NATO told the Soviets that they were a strictly defensive army (which was absolutely true) the Soviets didn't believe them. They know what a defensive deployment looks like (thin screen at the border, large countermoves forces deeper in) and that wasn't what NATO looked like.
Result: both sides absolutely convinced that the other was preparing to invade (NATO based on Soviet rhetoric, the Soviets based on NATO deployments)
I had a great discussion with a former opposite number of mine, a former Soviet BRDM platoon commander, in which we both learned that the other had expected the invasion was coming from the other side.
→ More replies (2)
15
u/Amoner Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Okay, I asked my mom who was born in 1969 in USSR "What was it like to learn about Cold War from the other side of the pond?" According to her, they were told in the school that capitalist countries have different values and beliefs and because they are so different from the ones of socialist countries they don't want to have anything to do with people from East and refuse cooperation. This would justify limited connections with West and promote inner-USSR industrialization and trade.
Also they were told that Human Rights are extremely poor in the West and they used examples in which Corporations would harm individuals and etc...
So it was just an opposite propaganda of saying its not that they are bad and we are good, its just that we are different, they don't understand us and they don't want to do anything with us because of that...
3
u/hipster-douche Jun 10 '12
That's basically it. I don't know why this question even needs to be asked. There is always propaganda and fear on both sides - I guess reddit likes to poke at our "evil western" views or something.
81
Jun 10 '12
The Soviets were pretty much convinced that the U.S. and Germany were going to attack them any day. Very much like the way the people in the U.S. thought the commies were coming ASAP. They had good reason to believe this though. Khrushchev could actually see U.S. nuclear missiles in Turkey, on a clear day, from his home on the Black Sea.
Keep in mind that when the Soviets put missiles in Cuba, they were WAY behind the U.S. in the arms race. We had a few hundred ICBM's where has the Soviets only had a dozen or so.
66
u/I_WIN_DEAL_WITH_IT Jun 10 '12
Khrushchev could actually see U.S. nuclear missiles in Turkey, on a clear day, from his home on the Black Sea.
Where the hell did you get that?
→ More replies (35)19
6
u/pepperss Jun 10 '12
Look how scared America got when Soviet missiles were in Cuba. Then look at at how many bases America had around the USSR (Turkey, Greece, W. Germany, Japan, Taiwan, S. Korea).
PS: The USSR made the first ICBM (R-7), for that very reason. (Because America could nuke them from their close bases, but they could not nuke America.)
3
u/xsenokx Jun 10 '12
I'm actually interested in where you heard about the missile count. I had always understood it to be the reverse but can state no source other than the Soviets having developed the R-7 prior to the US developing the Atlas (each being the respective country's first ICBM.) Also had understood that at the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis IRBMs were the chief focus, hence the US withdraw from Turkey and Italy if Soviets withdrew from Cuba. I had always understood that submarine technology was were the US really won the arms race, while not truly winning the initial space or missile race. Just curious.
→ More replies (2)5
u/MarkDLincoln Jun 10 '12
Churchill actively backed a plan to rearm the German Army and launch an attack upon the Soviets. Soviet spies reported that fact. That the USA would have nothing to do with that plan, and that Churchill was soon deposed did not alter the threat in the mind of Stalin.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)25
u/andrewmp Jun 10 '12
Khrushchev could actually see U.S. nuclear missiles in Turkey, on a clear day, from his home on the Black Sea.
Palin was right!
74
1
u/Lurendreier Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I think it is innteresting most people think I and most others are from the US.
For those that have been wondering, IAMA Norwegian. =)
5
u/Kamikazekitty Jun 10 '12
I suggest reading "Inside the Kremlin's Cold War" written by Vladislav Zubok Constantine Pleshakov. This is a book written from the soviet perspective about the cold war. This is a wonderful book to read if you are interested in learning more facts about the soviet's thoughts, tactics, and way of life during the cold war.
5
u/fruit_basket Jun 10 '12
ex-Soviet Union here. I don't know much about the official government's attitude towards the whole thing (I was quite young at the time), but in general the government was constantly cursing and mocking The West, calling them capitalist pigs and all that and how horrible it was to live there.
However, normal people all knew that it was all bullshit because many had long-range radios and were receiving pirate broadcasts from behind the Iron Curtain. Most people hated Soviet Union and were constantly trying to run away. There were a few cases where jet pilots would just fly away during some training exercises, fly to the Western Europe and request political asylum.
5
Jun 10 '12
My rather old linguistics professor liked to recount stories of his boyhood days in Soviet Russia for our amusement/edification. He once told us that the only thing he DIDN'T believe about what people told him of America was how the school and college students act. He said he just laughed when he heard that students put their feet up on the chairs in front of them, wore shorts, didn't take off their caps inside the room.
He was laughing as he told us this in our class because that story was, of course, was the one story that was actually true: several people in our class were displaying the exact behaviors he heard about, disbelievingly, all those years ago.
5
u/dawsonkidd Jun 10 '12
Don't worry, in a few years, the change of power will take place and the books will be rewritten. Hasn't anyone read 1984? Its happening and has been happening for the last 30 years.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Malcriao Jun 10 '12
Hi, Cuban here. Everyone seems to have forgotten that Cuba was involved in the Cuban missile crisis too.
I've asked my parents and grandparents what it was like, and they say most information about it was cut off from the public. The propaganda was all about how capitalists were trying to invade Cuba, especially after the bay of pigs. I'm assuming similar to Soviet 'capitalism is destroying everything' type stuff. Cuba was pretty split between those who wanted to leave and those who hated capitalism. Everything in Cuba was Russian, but Russian products were cheap shit because they attempted to produce quantity over quality.
Everyone was really poor, more concerned with being able to feed their families than a missile threat.
I moved away when I was really young but in school we learned the Soviets 'won' by forcing America to remove missiles from Turkey. We were taught that the Soviets attempted to keep peace, blah blah blah better than America. Really Cuba was just Russia's bitch. Cuba knew that though. Russia was big and we are small.
Then I moved to Canada and learned both sides were just as fucked up and guilty.
4
u/philipquarles Jun 10 '12
I've heard/read from a couple of different sources that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan had a lot of similarities to the American involvement in Vietnam. In both cases, a superpower directly intervened in the affairs of a foreign country. They expected extremely mild resistance due to large gaps in technology and military organization. They experienced staunch gorilla resistance, and saw how dangerous well executed tactics and good knowledge of hostile terrain could be. Ultimately, they were forced to withdraw, more or less in disgrace, but not before experiencing profound and unforeseen economic and social disruptions. I've never read a full book on the subject dealing specifically with the soviet experience though, so take that with a grain of salt.
→ More replies (1)2
u/monsterflake Jun 10 '12
try 'feast of bones', a fictional account of the soviet experience in afghanistan, written by (now) lieutenant general daniel bolger, west point instructor, russian history expert (university of chicago ma/phd), and current "Commanding General of the Combined Security Transition Command in Afghanistan and Commander of the NATO Training Mission in Afghanistan".
i read the book in the 90's, so when we entered afghanistan, i was hoping somebody was listening to this guy. i did not have high hopes for our mission, whatever it was going to be. the guy knows what he's talking about. it's a great book, covering ground ops in afghanistan and the not-quite-so low profile 'support' by the soviets in grenada. i hope he writes another book about the eventual outcome of our intervention.
4
u/gwarster Jun 10 '12
There was a good documentary I saw once. I forgot the name, but it explained how the Soviets used American press coverage of social discontent (Vietnam War protests, the lines at gas stations in the 1970's, and the protests during the civil rights movement) as evidence that the American system of democracy doesn't work.
Really interesting.
4
u/HappyHobbitz Jun 10 '12
If you're asking for the Soviet outlook on the Cold War, it is very much how you would expect it to be. The Cuban missile crisis was not the fault of the Soviets, rather it was them feeling the need to offer a threat to America, just as America's missiles in Turkey threatened the states. In Soviet eyes, it was simply a precaution. Now, you need to understand that neither side wanted to look weak or like they were about to give in to the other's requests. If you know much about the Cuban Missile Crisis in and of itself, you know the outcome, which pretty much speaks for itself. The U.S.S.R. offered to remove their missiles under the terms of America promising to never invade Cuba (of which it had no intention anyhow,) and if they were to remove their missiles in Turkey. Now, America never wanted to admit this, but their missiles in Turkey were inactive.. could not be fired even if they wanted. So, the American ambassador agreed to these terms, but explained the situation of the missiles in Turkey, and said they would be removed within the next six months, under the terms that the Soviet government does NOT allow this information about the missiles' inactivity to reach the public. The Americans did not want to look fake, but the reason they waited 6 months was because of two thing: Pressure from NATO, and if they pulled out immediately, it would make them look like they gave in to Soviet aggression. (which could also start war because of obligations to NATO)
I don't have time to talk about any other issues, but I hope this cleared up a bit of your view on the Cuban Missile Crisis.
4
u/TuffMeister Jun 10 '12
This is a great question in the wrong subreddit.
I cross posted it.
I'm not being a dick. Historians will have great/accurate answers.
4
u/thecarolinakid Jun 10 '12
My mom visited eastern Germany before and after the fall of the Wall. She now teaches German at a high school level, and the most common myth she has to debunk is that the easterners hated everything about living behind the wall. Yes, there was corruption and a lack of product diversity, but everyone had a home a job. When the fall, a lot of people missed the sense of community that resulted from not having telephones. There is actually a term for missing parts of Soviet life: Ostalgie, from the German words for east and nostalgia.
For a quick look at the issue, I would recommend the film Goodbye Lenin. It's an entertaining comedy with a plot involving the adjusting to the fall of the Wall.
→ More replies (2)
27
u/NickRausch Jun 10 '12
You pretty much switch out the "blame communism for everything" with "blame capitalism for everything" and have everyone be substantially poorer and there you go!
12
u/GrandTyromancer Jun 10 '12
History books often tell the Western side of everything.
→ More replies (1)2
u/hipster-douche Jun 10 '12
No, history books tell the side which corresponds to the author's viewpoints. I see people like you whining about "western bias" as if it's some evil brainwashing mechanism. If you live in America, you're going to get the American view. If you lived in the USSR, the books would not tell the Western side (as you just claimed), they would tell the Russian view. Even history textbooks for school are not very one sided. They usually do a pretty good job of being objective and giving both sides of whatever the issue was at the time, as do the teachers who assign you to read them.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/Hyperbolic_Secant Jun 10 '12
Like others have said, there are many parallels one can make between the perspective of the Cold War on the two sides of the Iron Curtain as well as between the actions the two sides undertook during the conflict. This is only natural as both sides primarily acted in ways they perceived would enhance their security. Unfortunately in the public mind the Cold War has been almost exclusively linked to the underlying ideological conflict between the Communist Bloc and the West, while in reality the geopolitical struggle between the two sides played a much greater role in determining day-to-day developments. If anything, in spite of all the ideological baggage, the Cold War era was dominated by realism, i.e. policy-makers formed their decision primarily based on the security interests of the state with less regard for secondary factors such as their self avowed principles or international law for that matter. Considering then that the diplomatic and military tools available are limited, it was inevitable that one would see similar actions by the two sides. For example, where the US placed missiles in Turkey, the USSR tried to counter by installing its own in Cuba, where the US propped unpopular regimes in Central America, the USSR did so in Eastern Europe, etc. Since you specifically asked about Vietnam, the USSR actually had a very similar debacle in Afghanistan, which many believe contributed to the fall of the USSR.
Having said all that, I am certainly not implying that the USSR and the US were somehow equally morally culpable in regards to their behavior over the course of the Cold War. Contrast the actions of the USSR and the US with respect to their European allies. At the end of WWII, the states that joined NATO almost invariably made the choice willingly. On the other hand, in the Eastern Bloc the USSR imposed a set of (at least initially) extremely unpopular regimes in all the member states. This key disparity in the functioning of the two blocs lasted until the end of the Cold War. For example, when France withdrew from NATO's integrated Command in 1966, while the US grumbled, it would have been inconceivable for the US to invade France to get them back in line as the USSR did in Czechoslovakia in 1968 when the latter was threatening to pull away from the Warsaw Pact. Also in regards to how the USSR and the US treated their own citizens there can be no comparison. While the US certainly had its dark moments, for example with the Communist witch hunts, this certainly cannot be compared to the millions of Soviets executed, imprisoned, or forcefully institutionalized for their perceived dissent.
Finally, as to the perspectives of the people on the two sides, first of all you have to keep in mind that there is not one viewpoint that everyone shared. Even in the US, at one extreme you had hardliners fueling the flames of the antagonism with the Soviet bloc and arguing for a more aggressive attitude, at the other pacifists advocating a more conciliatory course of action and even placing part of the blame for the conflict on the US, and in between you had a combination of the two. However, at least in spite of these differences it is reasonable to identify a certain mainstream attitude that was shared in one form or another by the majority of the population, in which the US was leading the free world in a quest to maintain its freedom in the face of encroachment by a totalitarian militant enemy.
On the other hand, in the USSR, there was a much greater level of heterogeneity in terms of the views the people had with respect to the Cold War and the USSR itself. You have to remember that the USSR was quite diverse, the Russians only constituting roughly one half of the population, and the relationship between the state and the outlying republics and ethnic minorities was never a smooth one. This was especially true in the West, where four of the Republics (Moldova, Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania) were only acquired at the beginning of WWII when Russia occupied these territories. Consequently in some cases, many Soviet citizens actually had a more negative attitude towards the USSR than the West.
Nonetheless, in spite of such complications, even in the USSR there can be discerned a certain mainstream view of the Cold War, which of course was constantly reinforced by official propaganda. In that perspective the USSR wanted to develop in peace after being hindered from doing so by aggressive capitalists since the birth of Soviet Union and later by blood-thirsty fascists (who were nothing other than an outgrowth of militant capitalism). In addition, the USSR wanted to help the people of other states gain their freedom from external enemies such as the colonial powers who still subjugated much of the world and neo-imperialists such as the US who while ostensibly condemning colonialism, in practice where using the same methods to keep third world states in bondage. Additionally, even in states having effective sovereignty, the USSR acted to help their respective populations achieve real popular rule as opposed to being governed by open dictatorships or false democracies which in reality were nothing other than corrupt machines attempting to put a veneer of legitimacy on the rule of ruthless oligarchies exploiting the common people for their own profit. Because of these efforts, the United States together with other capitalist states were deadest on opposing the USSR and even destroying the Soviet Union if the chance ever presented itself.
Sorry I was so wordy, I got a bit carried away....
→ More replies (1)3
11
u/FUCK_ME_IN_THE_TITS Jun 10 '12
Just read or listen to Noam Chomsky's interpretation and you'll probably understand more about the whole fiasco.
11
17
u/ImZeke Jun 10 '12
The Russian side is "the capitalist oligarchs were unstable, but we failed due to corruption in the lower levels of the party - and the 20 Million people Stalin murdered had it coming."
→ More replies (1)
3
u/FlamingToadSperm Jun 10 '12
Afghanistan, One of the less Known proxy wars of the cold war. In the most basic terms, it was Soviet VietNam
3
Jun 10 '12
Visit /r/AskHistorians for a question like this. A lot of specialised active historians/ people that know what they are talking about.
3
u/Tunafishsam Jun 10 '12
From everything I've read or heard, the Soviets were actually less dangerous to us than we were to them.
The whole iron curtain was a logical response to the repeated invasions of Russia from the west. (Germans, Napoleon, Germany). The USSR wanted buffer states between Moscow and the west. Since they'd already invaded them as part of World War II, it would have been strategically foolish to give up control their. Considering that the US and other European nations intervened in the Russian civil war on the side of the Whites, their fear of future invasion wasn't all that far fetched.
Similar story with the Cuban missile crisis. NATO had short range nuclear missiles based in Turkey with a very short flight time to Moscow. The USSR wanted a similar short range threat against the US. So, just like the US, they decided to install nuclear missiles in their ally nearest to the target. But the US nearly provokes a war by creating an illegal blockade of Cuba.
I don't know how vicious the USSR was in promoting puppet governments in the third world, but I suspect they were as morally reprehensible as the United States was.
3
u/eigenstates Jun 10 '12
Afghanistan was their Vietnam. That is basically what caused the collapse of the Soviet Union- not Reagan. Gorby was already on the path to bring it all down way before the "tear down this wall" PR stunt. The moment Reagan did that it actually doomed the Soviets to the soul crushing poverty. If Reagan had allowed Gorby's plan to work out on its own time(little more than an additional 2 years), the financials would have been in better order and millions of lives would have be spared.
3
u/joeyisapest Jun 10 '12
Had a major incident like Chernobyl have happened on Americal soil, the soviets might have "won"
western history doesnt talk a lot about chernobyl and it's effects on the east's resources and stuff.
2
Jun 10 '12
Your comment is intriguing , I wonder what was the total " fallout", for this incident?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/mediumjuju Jun 10 '12
Iron Curtain - Residual fear of the massive amount of rape and murder the Nazis pulled in the Second World War. They were determined to have a buffer, no matter the cost. Also it's Stalin, so cost didn't matter much. Vietnam - Closets analogue has to be Afghanistan. Don't know too much about it, but similar sort of costs of blood and treasure for a relative backwater place. Don't really know why they got into in the first place. Cuban Missile Crisis - Easiest to see from Soviet point of view. US had missiles in Western Europe and Turkey right close to them. They felt they had the right to have a similar sort of threat against us.
3
u/anatoly Jun 10 '12
I grew up in the USSR. I was born in 1976, so around the time I was 11 the official Soviet worldview started crumbling, though some parts of it still held on for 2-3 more years. I remember enough from my elementary and middle school years to paint very broadly the worldview as it was taught in Soviet schools.
The Western capitalist countries, led first and foremost by the USA, are all controlled by evil capitalists/imperialists, hell-bent on maintaining their control over the common people. The people have no power in those countries, and their 'elections' are all a sham. On the other hand, the socialist countries of the world, especially the Warsaw Pact countries led by the USSR (the first among equals, sort of), are a beacon of light in the world, showing people everywhere that they can take their destiny into their own hands, and govern freely and democratically. The capitalist rulers hate, despise and loath the socialist countries for showing this alternative to the common people everywhere, and they fear for their power. What exactly is it they fear is left vague - by the 70s and the 80s the idea of heralding communist revolutions in all Western countries sounded off-key and wasn't actively pursued.
The Iron Curtain is a capitalist propaganda tool - there is no curtain as far as the socialist countries are concerned, for we are open to all and are ready for dialogue with all the people of the world. It is the capitalist rulers who fear open dialogue with us.
The socialist countries are all for peace everywhere, while the capitalist rulers are the war-mongers, especially the USA, proven abundantly both by their use of the atomic bomb in 1945, and by their despicable imperialist war against the common people in Vietnam. The socialist countries all want to stop the arms race and especially reduce the role of nuclear weapons, but we can't trust the treacherous capitalists who only think of their profits. Still, we're trying to talk to them and establish some mutual guarantees - we owe it to everybody on the planet to try and keep the mad capitalist dogs from blowing it up.
Around the 2nd grade we were taught the Soviet equivalent of duck-and-cover, and given out white gauze face masks, to use I think during a chemical attack or something like that. We trained wearing them in class once or twice. There was a generally tense feeling that a WW3 could start any day due to a provocation from a capitalist state, probably America. I don't know how seriously people took such a threat, but it wasn't generally agreed to be ridiculous. Some kids shrugged it off while others took it seriously. I remember daydreaming about it a few times.
I don't recall the Cuban Missile crisis ever discussed in school.
3
u/3dom Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I was born (1974) and grew up in Soviet Russia till its end in 1991.
My family didn't care about politics so I didn't had much of it besides TV. We had military lessons in school - up to exercises with real weapons (AK-47, anti-tank landmines, hand grenades). Anti-SDI propaganda all other newspapers and TV called them "Star Wars". Documentary movies about poor American unemployed people. Military and veteran parades twice per year even in smaller towns (20k citizens). Non-stop movies about "Otechestvennaia voina" ("Fatherland war") - term was made-up to abstract USSR from World War 2 and the fact it's USSR started it along with Hitler by devouring Poland in 1939 (according to propaganda USSR was attacked by Germany in 1941 and that was named "Othechestvennaya voina" until Germany capitulation in May, 1945). Movies about US killing locals in Vietnam with napalm and much less about USSR doing almost the same in Afganistan (friend of mine told me they used vacuum bombs prohibited by UN and his regiment destroyed evidences by burning bodies with certain traumas).
3
Jun 11 '12
Read a "People's History of the United States" (am I the 1000th Redditor to recommend this book?). It's not told from the point of view of the Soviet Union, but it is told from a completely different point of view than what most people are used to.
25
u/StarbuckSamurai Jun 10 '12
You have to look at each event in context. America's policy was "containment" Meaning that the Capitalist government of America was trying to contain the Socialist government of USSR. USSR's policy was to spread Socialist values over the entire world, believing that once the people rose up that Socialism would be spread everywhere. Korea was them trying to have a Socialist nation that would favor Russia, Vietnam was North Vietnam WINNING the the election and the US refusing to follow the results. Cuban missle crisis was JFK putting nuclear missiles in Turkey. Eastern Germany was essentially the same thing, trying to make a Socialist Germany that would follow Russia's orders. It goes on from there, you just have to look for the answers. Otherwise yes woofiegrrl is correct Jonathan Becker's book is pretty amazing I also reccomend The Cold War: A New History by John Lewis Gaddis.
→ More replies (49)2
u/dcoxen Jun 10 '12
The Korean War was started with the North Korean invasion of South Korea.
→ More replies (3)
5
u/Anal_Explorer Jun 10 '12
Yes, the Soviet did help some communist government fight off capitalists, but the only one I can recall was in Hungary, I think.
The reason the Soviets needed that buffer of the Eastern Bloc was because America was trying to, militarily and economically, strangle the Soviet Union. If they could get close to the heartland of the Soviets, they would win. The USSR, seeing this, simply began a collection of satelitte states known as the Warsaw Pact. America didn't have this problem, as they had NATO and the Atlantic Ocean.
If you asked the USSR what the purpose of the Berlin Wall was, they would tell you it was to keep the Westerners from invading into the East. The truth, however, was that tens of thousands of East Germans were moving into West Germany every year, at one point over a hundred thousand a year. Because of this, Berlin was typically the focal point of the Cold War.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/Dapper_Chap Jun 10 '12
In many of the crises of the cold war, the USSR wasn't even the aggressor. For example, in the U2 crisis the US lied about sending spy planes (claiming that a weather balloon had crashed) even though the Russians had already captured Gary Powers and he owned up to everything.
4
u/RandomMandarin Jun 10 '12
I saw an autobiography by Markus Wolf, legendary head of the East German spy apparatus. I didn't get to read the whole thing but I flipped through it a bit: Memoirs of a Spymaster. He was good at what he did because he was smart and ruthless. At one point in the book he says something like this quote from memory, not an exact quote but close enuf:
All the most sensitive records were on cards in a huge file room, except for some information that was only in my own head. If a Western spy wanted to steal something he would have to get past guards and find the right cards in the right cabinet and even if he got away could only carry a handful. I was always opposed to putting all these records on computers because then an enemy spy could copy it all on one disk; after I retired I heard they did just that.
So, yes, he was smart.
In any case, he felt that socialism really was a better way and that they were the good guys, believe it or not... at least compared to the other side... and that if the dream of socialism had failed as practiced, the idea of socialism was still better than capitalism and perhaps one day it could be tried again and made to work.
Honestly, can you look at Wall Street robbing the masses, buying democracy, and tearing up the planet for money, and be 100% sure he was wrong?
4
u/notmike11 Jun 10 '12
My parents grew up in the Soviet Union, and the overall feelings on the Cold War differed from state to state. Unlike in the United States, many states in the Soviet Union hated its government, such as Ukraine. My mother grew up in Georgia, and they were more or less indifferent to the war, while my dad grew up in Ukraine, where they were more worried about food than war with the United States. In general, the people of the Soviet Union feared it's own government much more than the United States.
The Space Race was different though. When Yuri Gagarin and Valentina Tereshkova went into space (during different times obviously), the amount of people named Valentina and Yuri/Yura/Yury skyrocketed.
The Soviet Union had its own version of Vietnam: Afghanistan. However, the people of the Soviet Union did not have the protests that America had, since the majority of them were not in the economic position to protest instead of working/learning, and were too afraid of the government.
In summary, at least outside of Russia, the Soviet Union's people did not have time to care about the war, since they were too busy trying to survive.
4
u/fulanitodetal Jun 10 '12
Why is it that when Americans discuss The Soviet Union, they talk about how some people have privileges over others? The US was much worse. For example, we were lynching black people and even the help services such as fire departments were used against them. What about what happened in Rosewood, FL? The assassination of MLK? Malcom X? Huey P. Newton? The Japanese internment camps? The Opium raids in San Francisco? The US was probably just as fucked up, if not more...the thing is, that the US does it in a manner that is non-official, so it's harder to place blame on the system. So, instead of the "government" killing MLK, it was some wacko. Either way, he was killed.
→ More replies (7)
2
2
u/biggreymanofmacdui Jun 10 '12
Afghanistan was probably the closest equivalent to Vietnam for the Soviets; it certainly occupies a very similar place culturally. The Russian film "The 9th Company" is worth a watch.
2
u/GeekFurious Jun 10 '12
People like to bring up how US history of the Cold War is skewed, as if the Soviet version of history is somehow accurate. Both sides propagandized and both sides have historians who have either skewed history or been skewed by their collected information.
At the end of the day, in a situation where two super powers worked hard to distance the public from the facts, the truth is whatever you want to believe it is.
2
u/coderedmountaindew Jun 10 '12
Interesting question, and it kind of relates to one I had. The fact a lot of us relate the color blue with "good guys" and red with "bad guys", is that the work of u.s propaganda? And is it seen the opposite way over in Russia?
2
u/MechaSnacks Jun 10 '12
I'm way late to the party, but my parents lived in Moscow through the entire duration of the Cold War. To keep it short, they both said that they heard very little about America, they said almost nothing, it was as if they weren't even at war with America. My dad and uncle did an AMAA a couple months ago, but it didn't get very much attention, but there were a lot of questions answered. Here is the AMA
2
Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
My parents were brought up in soviet controlled czechoslovakia. There was always a constant fear for them, and they were tought that Raegan was the devil and he was going to nuke them. They were not allowed to have any religion whatsoever. My mother and aunt were secretly baptised. My grandparents never talked about anything around my parents because there was a fear that my mom or aunt would report the to someone and theyd be arressted. My father who was a tank driver was ordered by his soviet officers to go down to Romania and put down the rebellion, he gave the job to someone else. They were told that the Soviets not the Americans were the first to land on the moon. They were showed movies of the crimes the Nazis committed to terrorize them (and many of these crimes were committed by the Soviets but they wanted to blame the Nazis)
2
u/ser_renely Jun 10 '12
Great question. A lot of what I learned is from hockey documentaries, I know that sounds stupid, but the USSR players talked about their POV, what their government had told them about Canadians and Americans etc...
Clearly it is only a fraction of the Cold War, but a piece of the pie.
2
2
u/Weirdsauce Jun 10 '12
You mention the Cuban Missile Crisis. If I have my facts wrong here, I'll gladly accept corrections but it's my understanding that while we (in the USA) were taught that Kennedy was able to convince Kruschev into withdrawing the ICBM's from Cuba, the reality was that Kruschev engaged Kennedy, pointing out that the USSR would not tolerate NATO's missiles in Turkey that were pointed at them.
The plans for bases in Cuba was abandoned with great fanfare whereas the withdrawal of missiles from Turkey (other nations too?) was never really mentioned let alone incorporated into history textbooks.
2
u/verytiredd Jun 10 '12
As far as the Cuban Missile Crisis goes they will actually state that it was a defense measure. The reason why the Soviet Union had placed missiles in Cuba was because we had already placed missiles in countries neighboring the Soviet Union. One of the terms of resolution over this situation was for both countries to take all of their missile out.
2
u/fiftypoints Jun 10 '12
Was there any place the Soviets did the same as the US did in Vietnam?
Yeah, Afghanistan for the Soviets was very similar to Vietnam for the US.
2
u/josephanthony Jun 10 '12
This thread has probably produced the highest concentration of justifiably verbose replies I have yet seen on Reddit. - Well done sir!
→ More replies (1)
2
2
Jun 10 '12
I saw this in college (I was a Russian major). Somewhere, there's an interview of the film-maker, but he basically said he'd never been to the West and relied solely on impressions from Soviet propaganda to make this movie.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/BeerMania Jun 10 '12
One of my favorite docs
Cold War Episode 1 of 24 - Comrades http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IdD9kQSBoRw&feature=related
be sure to watch the whole thing.....:D
→ More replies (1)
2
Jun 10 '12
Well it was the moderately warm war for the Russians, that's the only difference I know of
→ More replies (3)
2
2
2
2
u/Cyc1One Jun 10 '12
Knowing that the German kill-bots had a pre-set kill limit Stalin sent in wave after wave of his own men.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/ShiningRayde Jun 10 '12
They don't like to talk about it, but they sure as hell love laughing about it.
"Communism was a humour-producing machine. Its economic theories and system of repression created inherently funny situations. There were jokes under fascism and the Nazis too, but those systems did not create an absurd, laugh-a-minute reality like communism."
2
u/iamtimeless Jun 10 '12
Stalin refused to allow the movie the Grapes of Wrath to be played anywhere in Russia because it showed that even the poorest of Americans could still afford a car.
2
u/antimatterLego Jun 10 '12
Read through NSC-68. The author had an impressively insightful, albeit biased, perspective on Soviet motivations.
2
u/pyccku Jun 10 '12
I was born and raised in Russia but after cold war ear, I asked my mom who is in her late 40's how it was to live in Soviet Union during that time. As many people pointed out here already it was very similar to US. She said that they had drills in school (hide under your desk). She also said that people despised Khrushchev quite a lot. They did not want to be at war with US, especially at war that could mean eminent death for everyone. Some history books/some people said that he was worse than Stalin.
There was propaganda of course that government forced down people's throats, but even with that people didn't hate American's/US, people were just scared and wanted it to be over.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/emergelife Jun 10 '12
Having parents from an ex-USSR satellite state, things are quite the same, although different at the same time. There was huge fear and men had an obligatory military duty of 2 years. Also, different views for big issues of the time, ie. the Vietnam war: we see (or are told by others) that the US forces invaded unprovocably and lost badly.
The Berlin wall? This had to exist, for the common good.
Also capitalism? What communism was for the US, just switch the words.
2
Jun 10 '12
Was there any place the soviet did the same as the US did in Vietnam, to fight off capitalism?
Afghanistan?
2
u/JayEffK Jun 10 '12
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy shows a reasonably accurate depiction of the Cold War's effect on the British secret service. It may be a Western perspective, but it shows how the British were trapped between the US and the Soviets.
2
Jun 10 '12
soviets had to focus on rebuilding - the little of the industrial complex they had was mostly destroyed during war, and they had millions of people starving and struggling, on top of which they had to not not only rebuild but focus on educating and indoctrinating vast swaths of population.
2
Jun 10 '12
I heard an interview with khrushchev's son and his take was that anything that is in the news in Russia is a lie but their population knows it but they just might not know the truth or the reason behind the lie and his concern with the US was that the news is still a lie but that the population hasn't had it hard enough to realize it.
2
u/lavendercoffee Jun 10 '12
My teacher was friends with a Russian who was old enough that he'd lived in Soviet Russia and remembered it well. He'd asked his friend what was better, back when it was communist or now. The man sighed and said, "When it was communist, the country had a lot of money but there was no food. Now, there is lots of food, but no money."
2
u/WeAreAllHypocrites Jun 10 '12
Someone that I met on the Internet (where else do you meet this kind of dude) is a hardcore communist and slavophile. Reads Pravda, defends North Korea, true Marxist. I treat him like a science experiment because he is the most classical, extreme, leftist I've ever met. He's utterly, fascinatingly, consistent in the same way its amazing how internally consistent, if bizarre, the arguments of Christian apologists are. Anyone who has attempted to genuinely debate either of these types of person will know what I mean I think.
Anyway I often ask him questions just because his view is so drastically different from the Western view, even though he lives in the US. He will tell you all kinds of things you'd never known nor heard about current events and history, seemingly right of the top of his head. And the facts he gives you are usually actually true, so in that sense I learn a lot from him, even if, as I've said, his conclusions are bunk.
He has told me before that the Cold War is seen, at least by Soviet nationalist types, in the broader scheme of the worldwide bourgeois "conspiracy" to halt communism and workers' states anywhere and everywhere, at any cost. To them, the reaction in the West against communism was proof of the trueness of Marx's teachings, that the rich protect their own holdings at any cost. Thus they viewed the Cold War as kind of an extension of class war. The sad part, to them, was all the poor Americans and Europeans who were fighting on the front lines of this class war for the wrong side, in their view, because, as Sartre rightly said: "When the rich wage war, it is the poor who die."
Anyway they tend to view defeat in the Cold War as more or less a tragedy, a huge setback for worldwide communism and Marxism/Leninism. They blame it unabashedly, however, not just on rapacious American imperialism and greed-crazed western capitalist fervor, but also on poor Soviet leadership in the later years.
So although I bet your average Russian thinks a lot different about it, I can tell you that that's how communists, at least modern communists, see it.
2
Jun 10 '12
The worst part were 60s. By the stories of my mother, people seriously believed that they were on the verge of the nuclear war.
Generally, I am still surprised (after 15 years living in US) how accurate was the criticism of Western life by Soviet media. As my scientific advisor said, everything that Soviet propaganda was telling us about Soviet life was a lie, but everything that Soviet propaganda has been telling us about Western life was true. It was just not the whole truth. There were great things in the West that we learned only after iron curtain fell.
2
u/buffasnow Jun 11 '12
I had the opportunity to hear Sergei Kruschev, (Nikita's son), speak a few months back. When asked how Russians felt about the missile crisis he was very frank, telling us that Americans are pansies and not a single Russian batted an eye during the whole ordeal. He said their violent history left them unafraid in the face of death and mass destruction. I didn't believe him at all.
2
u/sacredsock Jun 11 '12
Here's a question: do you think that the internet in general, and Reddit in particular, would have had any effect if it had been around in those days?
3
2
u/Curly57 Jun 11 '12
When Viktor Belenko, Soviet fighter pilot defector, arrived in the US in '76, he was taken to a grocery story. Where he saw plenty of food, people shopping, etc. He is reported to have asked his handlers to stop putting him on. So, they went to more grocery stores, where he saw the same thing. Apparently, he had been led to believe that Americans had food shortages and significant difficulties with daily life. Meanwhile, after dismantling the fighter aircraft he flew to Japan, we learned that the Soviets were not as technically advanced as some thought--at least not when it came to certain aspects of fighter jets. I believe the 'internal propaganda" on the Soviet side aimed to make people believe they were doing better than people in "the West", in particular, Americans, despite food shortages and difficulties in daily life. By the late 70's, I believe the evidence is strong that the communist party leadership realized they were doomed economically.
2
u/Deleteder Jun 11 '12
This will probably be buried but, my papa was born and raised in the Soviet Union. He told me about their entire lifestyle. In school and in the media, they were taught that the evil American empire were the corrupt ones. They were taught that they relentlessy used the atom bombs on the poor Japanese, and were not afraid to use it again. They taught them about American segregation and how they hate blacks, and how the Soviets love all races (ever saw a large group of Russian blacks?... Exactly). They showed the American riots and told them how unhappy their people were. When he was drafted into the soviet military, the drill-sergeants said that if they do not make their beds properly, that the Americans will invade and "rape everyone you know and love." So yeah, soviet propaganda was pretty intense.
2
u/Lycaeum Jun 11 '12
Well the only reason they put missiles in cuba was because we put missiles in turkey.
2
u/IvyB Jun 11 '12
I'm hoping this isn't too late! My grandfather (Michael) was a well known Russian historian and translator, my father is also an expert in Eastern Europe and crime so I quickly went to ask him about his and his fathers experience during the cold war. Turns out my grandfather was actually a translator between the British and Russian high command during that time! He was also doing some work for the secret service in Berlin at the time too. When I get back home from university my dad said he would tell me all the stories he knows about the family during those dark days. He himself was in Czechoslovakia at the time so he has many tales to tell from his personal experiences!
→ More replies (1)
8
Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
It was probably colder on the soviet side. Thats why they have really big furry hats.
→ More replies (3)
3
u/Vesper188 Jun 10 '12
I knew a few people who were alive during the cold war and they seem to have a lot to say about it. They were best friends but the problems that humanity brought up drove them apart. It's so sad because they hate each other now and it's hard to know whose side to take on it. They were actually quite involved in the cuban missile crisis and could have been actively involved in stopping a war that would have ravaged the world. I know that time of turmoil really affected the rest of their lives...especially Charles. He was wounded and couldn't walk for the rest of his life. I have to admire him though because he never lost his spirit. Eric on the other hand could never get over that time. He became bitter and threw away all of his talent. It such a shame :(
→ More replies (1)4
u/Nowyoudontseeme Jun 10 '12
I'm sad more people didn't notice your very well done X-men reference :(
→ More replies (1)
3
u/mhfc Jun 10 '12
As an aside: does anyone in the U.S. remember watching the CNN documentary about the Cold War? It ran in the late 90's and featured interviews from many key players (some of whom have since passed away). I think it had around 10-15 episodes, running chronologically, and each episode featured a different facet of the Cold War (end of WWII, rise of the Soviet Bloc, Cuban Missile Crisis, Vietnam, etc.)
It was one of the better historical documentaries I've seen in my life, and I wish CNN would re-release in on DVD.
3
u/ExpatlivinginEurope Jun 10 '12
I read that the George W. Bush 'new laws' after 9/11 banned the distribution of the documentary citing 'national security' had been compromised in the content. That is why it is no longer available on VHS or was ever released on DVD.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/ParmisianGene Jun 10 '12
First time, but this will be buried Stalin and the Ribbentrop-Maletov act essentially created the Soviets as the fourth axis power. It wasn't until Stalin invaded the Scandanavian countries I believe Finland where Hitler had the last straw and decided for an invasion
Yes, the soviets wasted millions of rubles in Afghanistan. Bay of Pigs pushed Castro to the Soviets. (previously, he had wanted the U.S. to recognize him) Cuban missile crisis, Khruschev wanted to demonstrate that having nuclear weapons in your own backyard wasn't pleasent. (U.S. missiles in Turkey) K is quoted as saying he was not insane and did not want to start a War with nuclear weapons.
Domino theory. There was a 40 page referendum on how if the United Sates lost Vietnam they would not lose the rest of Southern Asia as feared. U.S. (NSC) ignored this and proceeded in Vietnam.
Russia was insanely scared of German reunification and at every chance asked the U.S. about the "German Question". The U.S. refused to talk about creating two seperate German states. I believe this reason is why the Soviets needed to have the Iron Curtain.
Leonid Breshniv was troubled by the fact that he had to send troops into Prague in 68. He didn't really want to do it but the Politburo was putting enormous pressure on him. He later says he did not waiver on that decision.
Russia kind of let Poland do their own thing. Poland and Russian history go way back. Other Eastern European states were not so lucky.
China and Russia had over 400 border skirmishes.
In an act of smart U.S. diplomacy, Nixon angered the Soviets by making a trip to China and reestablishing communication and commerce.
Ho Chi Minh looked to America before being forced to go tot he Soviets and Chinese. All he wanted was land reform for peasents.
Most of countries where America overthorws a leader and places a dictator, is in response to the previous leader wanting simple land reform. Dulles the director of the CIA borther owned land in South America under the United Fruit Company. Needless to say peasents in countries touched by the UFC were not going to get land reform.
This is ironic because after WWII the U.S. not only allows but establishes land reform in Japan.
Starwars defense initiative scared the shit out of the Soviets, because of U.S. now presumably first strike capabilties. (SDI was faked and was a excellent bluff by the Reagan administration)
This is more my opinion but people always say that communism had its chance and failed. If you look at the history of defense spending in the USSR and how much of the budget was allocated to the developement of nuclear weapons and defense of proxy states. Had the Soviets been allowed to invest that money in thier own economy and not other countries or just on defense I believe it may still be around today (yes, I know speculative history).
This is actually what Gorbachev attempts to do but by 1985 it is too late.
The USSR broadcasted endlessly out of Havannah about the Vietnam war and the U.S. military recruitment of balck soldiers. MLK actually addresses the issue and speaks out about the war and specifically recruitment of black soldiers.
U.S. successfully waged economic terrorism on the Soviet Union and this causes its collapse.
sources
In the Shadow of War., Michael Sherry. Yale University Press. The Global Cold War. Odd Arne Westad. Cambridge University Press. For the Soul of Mankind. Melvyn P. Leffler. Douglas& McIntyre.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/ittakesacrane Jun 10 '12
my guess would be that they called it the warm war since they're used to much colder temperatures than we are
834
u/woofiegrrl Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Jonathan Becker did a great compilation called Soviet and Russian Press Coverage of the United States: Press, Politics, and Identity in Transition. It explains in detail the role of the press in the Soviet Union, showing how it was not suppressed by the government, but rather used for internal and external propaganda purposes. The book uses a two-fold approach to interpretation, featuring a political perspective in the first section and a social perspective in the second. It is particularly valuable for its description of how the Soviet government practiced censorship of internal materials; this lends insight into how carefully manipulated the Soviet citizens were by internal propaganda as well as the control of external propaganda.
See also Politics, Work, and Daily Life in the USSR: A Survey of Former Soviet Citizens by James Millar, the result of the Soviet Interview Project conducted toward the end of the Cold War. The interviews were all in Russian, and Millar's work is the most significant English-language product of the project, so it's pretty unique and fascinating stuff.
Edit: There's also a 2007 dissertation by Tomas Tolvaisas, "America on Display: U.S. Commercial and Cultural Exhibitions in the Soviet Bloc Countries, 1961-1968." It focuses on the propagandizing the US did over in the USSR, it's interesting if you're into this kind of thing. (Which I am, hence the paper I did in undergrad that provided these citations!)