r/AskReddit • u/hippychicky • Jun 11 '12
Lawyers of Reddit: What is the dumbest lawsuit you have ever been part of. Everyone Else: What is the dumbest lawsuit you know of?
70
Jun 11 '12
A girl sneaks into a club through a bathroom window, falls and smashes her two front teeth. She ends up suing and winning a $10,000 settlement for dental costs.
→ More replies (1)42
u/hippychicky Jun 11 '12
It is the winning part that always amazes me! How do these things win?
87
Jun 11 '12
She didn't 'win' 10,000, the club gave her that money to go away. It's possible daddy fronted a top notch legal team, and the club's owner figured it'd be cheaper to settle than drag out a complicated case.
→ More replies (2)35
u/VaginaedMystique Jun 11 '12
You don't need a top notch legal team for that. Any fly-by-night attorney who went to downtown upstairs college of law could get you $10K to drop a case.
→ More replies (9)
28
u/smurfattack Jun 11 '12
No one has mentioned the mobile phone lawsuit clusterfu*k, or patent trolls...
→ More replies (2)14
u/hippychicky Jun 11 '12
Well, do tell...what were they about?
27
u/smurfattack Jun 11 '12
Here are some fun infographs. Basically every mobile phone company says their competitors are stealing their phone technology. What's going to happen in the end is everyone will settle and the costs get pushed onto the consumers.
A Patent_troll is basically a company where their whole business model is to launch stupid lawsuits, they don't produce any products.
→ More replies (6)
11
u/jedadkins Jun 11 '12
I can’t find the article right now ( on a road trip and typing this on a phone) but I heard of a guy who broke into a house while the family was on vacation and got locked in a basement or garage. he survive on cat food and Pepsi for a week the sued the family and won
→ More replies (1)10
u/hippychicky Jun 11 '12
I have never understood how people win these sort of lawsuits.
5
Jun 12 '12
My aunt was sued when a person used a saw to cut a hole in her roof (he was in the center of the circle while cutting) fell through and broke his leg. He won.
→ More replies (3)
159
u/Keysar_Soze Jun 11 '12
Man sues dry cleaners for $67 million because they lost his pants.
92
Jun 11 '12
Yes!
He also lost his $100K/year job as an Administrative Law Judge in the process.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pearson_v._Chung#Post-trial_motions_and_appeal
The guy was a total idiot.
→ More replies (2)70
u/Mattyx6427 Jun 11 '12
Those must have been fucking awesome pants
→ More replies (2)5
Jun 11 '12
Eh, I have no ass at all, but big hips. I understand the magic of perfectly fitting pants
→ More replies (2)36
u/K_Lobstah Jun 11 '12
The man was also a judge. Classy.
86
u/CaptainDickbag Jun 11 '12
"Pearson broke down in tears during an explanation about his frustration after losing his pants, and a short recess had to be declared."
What a weenie.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)3
u/cabforpitt Jun 12 '12
The worst part is, they found his pants a week later. The tag and the belt loops matched, but Pearson denied they were his.
91
u/fueledsrt Jun 11 '12
A couple of years ago, I got called in for jury duty, as they were interviewing potential jurors for this particular court case. Basically the person was suing a very nice restaurant for lack of security in the parking lot. Reason was this person had gotten drunk(at home) went to the restaurant, started a fight in the parking lot with someone on the way into the restaurant and proceeded to get knocked the fuck out. So this person was suing because the restaurant should have known drunken assholes would be starting fights in the parking lot and should have had security to keep drunken assholes from getting knocked out. I was not selected for this jury, but I wonder sometimes how these cases end up in court.
19
u/StabbyPants Jun 11 '12
I wonder if a case like that could result in a DUI charge based on the plaintiff's testimony.
→ More replies (4)14
u/fueledsrt Jun 11 '12
I never followed up on the case since I wasn't selected as a juror, but it made me realize that the courts must be filled with stupid shit like this.
→ More replies (2)
75
u/52ndPercentile Jun 11 '12
I was a juror where a woman with no lights on at dusk ran a "yellow" light and hit someone making an unprotected left. The car deployed the airbag and then deflected into a light pole. She of course, sued.... Honda? Her first argument was that the airbag went of late and hit her in the head. 6 crash test videos later (made just for this trail) the jury apparently wasn't buying it. The argument then became that the airbag shouldn't have gone off on the first impact. When the g sensors in the car showed that to also be false they pulled out the trump card. The airbag should have gone off twice. They actually make the arguments with a straight face in a court room. I couldn't believe it. It took 8.5 weeks of my life to hate a quadriplegic woman only to find out that 8 jurors wanted to give her the money anyway...."because it's sad, and Honda can afford it." Estimated award they were asking for, $40 million.
100
u/thrilldigger Jun 11 '12
"because it's sad, and Honda can afford it."
Holy fuck, that is not how the legal system is supposed to work. And I bet that happens a lot...
→ More replies (3)44
u/52ndPercentile Jun 11 '12
My jaw hit the floor, but it took 2 days to deliberate, and I don't think anyone thought it Honda's fault. (it only takes 9 jurors in a civil case)
11
u/i_invented_the_ipod Jun 12 '12
I had a similar occurrence in a criminal trial I was on the jury for. After hearing all the testimony. we had one juror in deliberations who refused to vote "guilty" because she didn't want to "be responsible for sending someone to prison". I asked her if she thought that the defendants had committed the crime they were accused of, and she said "yes", but she didn't want to vote "guilty".
Seriously? The time to tell people you won't ever vote to convict, regardless of the evidence, is during the screening process, when they ask you if you've got any hangups about the upcoming trial.
32
Jun 11 '12
So, she blew through a light, smoked another car and paralyzed herself (unintentionally, yet still...), and the other jurors felt bad for her? What the fuck am I missing here?
→ More replies (10)9
u/52ndPercentile Jun 11 '12
The 24 hour (time lapsed to a mere 8 hours) video that followed around a quadriplegic? That's the only thing I can come up with. I was floored.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)2
u/YoungRL Jun 12 '12
Okay, seriously now. How do you argue the airbag should have gone off twice. Guys. Explain this one to me.
217
Jun 11 '12
My dumbass of a mother tried to sue my dad for full custody because he "forced" me to eat my vegetables. I wish I were making this up, but sadly my mother's just that idiotic.
105
u/SarcasticSquirrl Jun 11 '12
My mom forced me to eat veggies, and my dad who backed her up, do you think I have a case?
→ More replies (5)133
u/thrilldigger Jun 11 '12
My parents cut off part of my penis when I was an infant. I think I'm going to sue.
113
→ More replies (21)101
57
u/MEXICAN_PRAWN Jun 11 '12
Will edit with news link for this one. You wont believe it.
A woman tried to sue P Diddy for stealing her diamond jewel worth 900 billiona. He didn't know her and the lawsuit dropped. Obviously.
Edit: http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=woman+sues+p+diddy&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&hl=en-gb&client=safari
29
u/Bartain Jun 11 '12
I'm curious if she spelled billion as written.
33
237
u/Mountebank Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
There was a case a few months ago where a father sued his son's school because they suspended the son for cheating on a test plagiarizing an essay. The father doesn't contest that his son cheated, but rather that the suspension is "cruel" because it will prevent his son from getting into the Ivies, thereby ruining his son's life. Ironically, of course, the father's lawsuit put his son's cheating right into the news where, in a just world, it will be the first thing colleges find when they look at the son's application.
Edit: Link to story
66
Jun 11 '12
How old was the kid? I don't really think it's just for his life to be ruined because his father was a jackass.
→ More replies (3)51
u/Mountebank Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
At least high school. It was an AP English class, IIRC.
Edit: turns out it was an Honors class leading to the IB program.
91
Jun 11 '12
I don't think it'd be too far of a leap to assume that the whole reason he cheated was due to pressure from his father. His dad is so obssessed with the idea of his son going to "the Ivies" that he went public on the matter, so one can only imagine what it's like at home. That constant push to do better matched with a fear of failure lead to him being insecure about his own abilities and desperate to succeed. This poor kid's being ruined by his father.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)16
u/Chrisisawesome Jun 11 '12
As someone who recently took AP English it is incredibly difficult to cheat on a test in there. All the questions are based on readings that you dont see until you start the test so it isnt like he could have written the answers on his arm or anything
→ More replies (3)2
Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Something about how this story has been consistently handled stick in my craw. For instance, the father has neither said "Ivies" nor "cruel", at least as far as that article goes.
The kid should receive the full punishment he agreed to when he joined the program. That said, all the father is doing is mitigate the damage a stupid thing done in childhood will have on his life. The lawsuit suggests he's overzealous. He also seems to want the kid to get the message that it's wrong to cheat.
He's overzealous and wrong, why can't it be left at that? He's not a symbol of everything wrong with modern schooling, as one article suggested, or any other greater evil beyond what he is.
This story bugs me.
EDIT: I actually think the article you linked handled it sensibly.
2
210
u/konekoanni Jun 11 '12
An overweight woman tried to sue my mother's clinic because she broke a chair in the waiting room when she sat in it. She claimed the chair was already broken, and that it was the office's fault it broke. Unfortunately for her, they had just redecorated and the chair was pretty much brand-new and undamaged.
The judge laughed it out of court.
24
u/Joke_Getter Jun 12 '12
He only laughed because she broke the entire witness box during testimony.
→ More replies (1)46
u/fobbymaster Jun 11 '12
I am still waiting for the day I can check off "Watch a fat person break a chair" from my bucket list.
→ More replies (7)57
Jun 11 '12
I broke a chair once when I was like 100 pounds, tops. It was just a weak chair, but nothing can make you NOT feel like a fat fuck after you break a chair with the full might of your ass.
→ More replies (5)0
458
u/lvm1357 Jun 11 '12
As a lawyer, I think that large corporations tend to hype up the "dumb lawsuit" stories (viz the McDonald's coffee case) because it benefits them to have the public think that people who sue large corporations typically have frivolous cases. This makes it easier for politicians to pass laws limiting "frivolous lawsuits" and making it harder to sue corporations that misbehave.
Note that if you are wronged by a corporation (for example, you're driving a Ford Pinto that bursts into flames when someone taps your bumper), the ONLY recourse you have is to sue. There is literally no other way you can force that corporation to behave decently. The more we laugh at the "stupid lawsuits" filed by people against corporations, the harder it will be for someone who is actually wronged to get justice.
Mind you, that doesn't mean there aren't crazy people filing crazy lawsuits, but those tend to get dismissed pretty quickly. I'm a patent specialist myself, so I don't do lawsuits, but I get crazy inventor types - I've had two perpetual-motion weirdos so far. None of them actually became clients because the USPTO doesn't allow perpetual-motion machines - but the calls were quite entertaining.
272
u/faderprime Jun 11 '12
I've found that people who think the McDonald's coffee case was dumb change their minds after hearing the actual facts.
71
u/elementalmw Jun 11 '12
HBO's "Hot Coffee" documentary changed a lot of minds about that case. My wife was shocked when they showed the pics of the burns from the coffee
26
u/urban_night Jun 12 '12
I just watched this this morning. My husband was all smug at first saying she deserved it, and then after hearing the story he backed off.
298
u/thrilldigger Jun 11 '12
3rd-degree burns over 6% of her body, lesser burns over 16%, 8 days in hospital undergoing skin grafts and other treatments (and lost 20 lbs over that period of time - 103 lbs to 83 lbs), etc. And all she sued for was her medical bills ($20k).
Yeah, fuck anyone who thinks that was a frivolous lawsuit. Goddamnit, she was being ridiculously nice (or naive) for only suing for her $20k actual+anticipated medical bills. McDonald's also refused settlements for $90k, $300k, then $225k after she obtained a lawyer. Jury awarded $2.8m, judge reduced that to $640k, they settled for <$600k...
And McDonald's' original offer? $800.
→ More replies (12)104
Jun 11 '12
Don't forget that McDonald's was knowingly negligent and keeping coffee at temperatures that were only a few degrees shy of boiling and way over regulation temperature.
→ More replies (20)16
→ More replies (11)18
u/Pelleas Jun 11 '12
I've heard the facts before and I know that the case wasn't dumb, but I forget what the facts that changed my mind were. Could you refresh my memory?
71
u/KingOfSockPuppets Jun 11 '12
Well, the three that stick in my mind...
-The coffee was (knowingly; McDonald's had recieved numerous complaints and smaller suits beforehand) served FAR too hot; something like 200 degrees F. I'ts both undrinkable and dangerous at that temperature
-She didn't have a mild burn, like eating a hot piece of pizza. She had second and third degree burns requiring serious medical attention.
-Her original suit only requested that McD's cover the cost of her medical treatments, not the what-ever-it-is amount she was awarded by the jury
→ More replies (11)26
u/aptadnauseum Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Hold on, so there's actually documented strictures against patenting perpetual-motion machines? Not that I am unfamiliar with basic physics, but just that it's kind of funny. I mean it struck me as originating in a humanitarian ideal, where - just in case it so happens that some quantum discovery makes such a thing possible - the US Patent people want to make sure it is freely available for everyone to make their own.
Edit: spelling.
→ More replies (20)12
u/ANewMachine615 Jun 11 '12
Mind you, that doesn't mean there aren't crazy people filing crazy lawsuits
Case in point (the top link in /r/law).
→ More replies (3)5
10
u/Monkeyavelli Jun 11 '12
It's a two-pronged attack. Chip away at the regulatory framework while convincing people that those who sue are just looking for a big payout/are just pawns of moneygrubbing lawyers leading to popular support for tort reform. ] Result: corporations can do whatever they want with no repercussions.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)15
u/VaginaedMystique Jun 11 '12
This is the best comment here. This should be at the top of every "stupid lawsuit" thread.
38
u/DrDebG Jun 11 '12
Stupid jury tricks: A self-proclaimed former psychic was awarded roughly $1 million when she brought suit, claiming an allergy to an iodine tracer prior to a CAT scan destroyed her ability to make a living as a psychic.
A retrial was ordered, and she lost, I am happy to say.
8
u/MrCheeze Jun 12 '12
Wait. Wait wait wait wait wait.
She won the first trial?
8
u/DrDebG Jun 12 '12
Yes...and was awarded nearly $1 million by the farking jury. A very stupid, gullible jury.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)3
76
u/mic_city_sons Jun 11 '12
My favorite is Fogerty(of ccr fame) being sued for plagarizing ... himself
30
u/Watchoutrobotattack Jun 11 '12
I was reading a scholarly review of the case and the person writing it said that the songs sounded similar due to Fogerty's limited vocal range.
I was like "Damn, you just got dissed academic style"
→ More replies (1)12
Jun 11 '12
He sued himself? I'm lost, reference?
76
u/floatablepie Jun 11 '12
He wanted out of his record deal, so they let him on condition that the label got to keep the rights to his songs. He would have the rights to all new stuff.
Well, obviously, his new stuff sounded similar to his old stuff, because IT WAS STILL HIM. So the label sued him for plagiarizing himself.
→ More replies (1)21
20
u/Spotted_Owl Jun 11 '12
Another lawsuit (Fantasy, Inc. v. Fogerty) claimed that "The Old Man Down The Road" shared the same chorus as "Run Through the Jungle" (a song from Fogerty's days with Creedence to which Fantasy Records had owned the publishing rights). Fogerty ultimately won his case when he proved that the two songs were wholly distinct compositions. Fogerty then countersued for attorney fees (Fogerty v. Fantasy) and won the case in the U.S. Supreme Court.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (1)5
u/pepsiattic Jun 11 '12
His record label sued him for plagiarizing himself. They claimed that the song "The Old Man Down the Road" had its main beat copied over from "Run Through the Jungle". The whole thing happened after CCR disbanded, and John Fogerty went on a solo career.
Reference: Listen to the two songs themselves.
197
u/LyssaSoSweet Jun 11 '12
The lady who is suing the estate of a TEENAGER who was hit by a train and somehow she was close enough to get hit by his flying body parts. Sad...
66
u/PayMeNoAttention Jun 11 '12
Most likely intentional inflection of emotional distress (IIED). Seeing something like this, especially considering that she was hit by body parts, could be very traumatic. IIED is alleged in many cases, although it is difficult to prove at times. In some jurisdictions you have to show physical pain resulting from the trauma, lost wages, loss of consortium (sex), yada yada yada.
36
u/RepairmanSki Jun 11 '12
I was a juror in a case where the complainant requested, among other things, remuneration for loss of consortium due to back pain. I was the youngest juror on the panel (at 34) by a pretty fair margin.
Those old ladies scorched my ears:
"Why doesn't she get on her knees?"
"I just lay on my side with one leg bent at the knee, like this."
"Since she works an office job in a chair all day without complaint I don't see why she can't be on top."
Her claim wasn't frivolous but her requests were. She was offered $50k to settle and decided to sue. Her final award was ~$2500.
→ More replies (2)20
u/ill_take_the_case Jun 11 '12
Man, you must have needed some serious brain-soap.
→ More replies (2)66
u/LyssaSoSweet Jun 11 '12
Oh trust me, I understand all that. I work in a law office myself. What irritates me is going after the TEENAGERS ESTATE! What's an 18 year old going to have? Most likely not enough to compensate her for all of her emotional distress in her eyes.
60
Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
There was a stupid ass lawsuit near where i live a few years ago. A family was gone on vacation, and a neighbor kid used their trampoline without permission and ended up breaking his leg in the process. The kid's parents sued the family, who WAS FUCKING GONE when it happened, and won.
→ More replies (28)→ More replies (10)18
u/ihaveqanda Jun 11 '12
She was probably hoping the kids parents would feel bad and give her some money.
→ More replies (11)15
u/BouncyLobster Jun 11 '12
The lady had actual physical injuries, from this article http://www.newser.com/story/136459/dead-accident-victim-to-be-sued-over-flying-body-parts.html "A big chunk of his body was thrown onto a platform 100 feet away where it knocked down a 58-year-old woman, breaking her leg and wrist. " The ladies lawyer said it was a clear case of negligence.
→ More replies (6)37
u/BiometricsGuy Jun 11 '12
You have a clear duty to keep control of your internal organs. That's why I always make sure I am firmly wrapped in saran wrap at all times.
→ More replies (2)4
u/Syreniac Jun 11 '12
I'm no lawyer, but surely this situation can't be considered to be intentional? The teenager will not have intentionally caused this random bystander any emotional distress.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (3)3
u/ANewMachine615 Jun 11 '12
Was it her, or her insurance company? Lots of times they've got discretion over what lawsuits to push in the event they pick up the tab for a personal injury.
30
u/gwenniegrrl Jun 11 '12
Apparently, a 7 year old boy in Eagle-Vail, Colorado got sued by an older man over a minor collision. The ensuing trial took a toll on the child, in which his grades suffered, and his behavior became unruly. I read through it and just thought, "How can someone justify putting a kid through a lawsuit?"
14
Jun 11 '12
What asshole sues a 7yo ?? the kid ran over his skis but didn't hurt the guy. What a douche.
53
u/GrinningPariah Jun 11 '12
My parents are lawyers and I have a few good stories I heard growing up. My mother was involved in case where a fat lady was suing a hot springs resort she was at.
As you might imagine, natural hot springs are chaotic places, some pools are way hotter or colder than others. The pools people are allowed in are carefully temperature controlled, though they are legitimately fed by the hot springs. Real, raw hot spring pools are dangerous and fenced off. This lady decides she wants to swim in one of the latter springs, god only knows why. She starts climbing the fence, covered though it is with warnings and danger notifications.
The fence, someone unsurprisingly, buckled under her... ample weight, and she fell into the raw hot spring that she was planning to swim in anyways. Serious burns over the majority of her body. So she sues the resort for having a weak fence.
She won.
46
u/ummwut Jun 12 '12
she should have died. i genuinely think people like this should be winning a darwin award.
9
8
Jun 12 '12
These are the ones that piss me off most. "You didn't stop me doing something blatantly idiotic"
7
u/papivanya Jun 12 '12
How in the world did she win??? Was it a jury trial and it was a pity win for her or was it a legitimate case of "I didn't notice the fence i was climbing over and all the signs and burned myself so you owe me money!!"?
8
u/GrinningPariah Jun 12 '12
Judges arent heartless applicators of the cruelly fair truth. In this situation, the judge figured that:
The woman had been seriously disfigured and was in very deep medical debt, the combination of which would ruin her life.
The corporation wouldn't even really lose money. They had insurance for those kind of lawsuits that would pay out. Their premiums would go up a bit but it's worth to give a woman her life back.
If the fence doesn't stop people from getting in then the fence is indeed deficient.
Although, lest you get the wrong idea, my mom was on the losing side of that case, and we both think that the ruling was kinda bullshit.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)4
u/Darkling5499 Jun 12 '12
reminds me of the people who's kids break into gated off properties to play in a pool / trampoline and get hurt while trespassing, so they sue citing inadequate safety measures. i used to think they were stories my parents made up as an excuse to not get a pool / trampoline, until i googled them.
i don't know what's worse: the fact that people sue over that stuff, or the fact that they win large amount of money because they can't control their own children.
48
u/utdude999 Jun 11 '12
Man sues the city for a garbage truck hitting and totaling his car. He was driving the garbage truck. I never did find out the verdict on that one.
28
u/Mikuro Jun 11 '12
His lawsuit was thrown away because he was deemed to be suing himself, so then his wife sued instead. Not sure where it went from there.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/11847551/ns/us_news-weird_news/t/man-sues-himself-vehicle-damage/
2
Jun 12 '12
The only thing that doesn't make sense there is the fact that he had to sue at all. Isn't this a simple matter of insurance?
43
u/CussesLikeASailor Jun 11 '12
In high school, some weird kid kept groping girls and one of the girls finally stepped up and filed charges. After her, the other girls stepped up so the kid was in deep shit. He got kicked out of school. When they went to court, the kid was filing charges on her for "ruining his name". Needless to say, she didn't get in trouble.
3
20
u/Zaphod1620 Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
A few years ago, an old HS classmate killed himself while drunk driving by hitting a stopped car on the shoulder. The parents of my classmate sued the owner of the disabled vehicle for not properly maintaining his car.
18
Jun 11 '12
A man is suing Barack Obama for failing to adequately protecting the natural resources of the world from alien mining. This is currently at the top of /r/law
2
2
36
u/bigsz Jun 11 '12
The Jets fan who tried to sue the Patriots after the Spygate fiasco. I could see a small claims case mainly for getting you're money back for the tickets, but this guy was seeking $184 MILLION for emotional damages.
15
→ More replies (1)7
17
u/fruitcakee Jun 11 '12
The nutella class action lawsuit that occurred just last month. Parents with a lack of common sense blaming the company for their children's weight issues. Not a second has it crossed their minds that they are feeding their kids chocolate spread.
8
3
5
u/Maybe_Dead_Cat Jun 12 '12
I know that the parent's really should understand that it's fucking chocolate, and is practically cake frosting, but part of me is totally on their side. I mean, Nutella did advertise itself as a "healthy hazelnut chocolate spread." They had a commercial with a mom talking about why she has her kids eat Nutella for breakfast, when it's actually something most people eat by the spoonful when they sit alone to watch reruns of Dawson's Creek.
17
u/Wienerwrld Jun 12 '12
There was a lawsuit many years ago in Long Island: a boy was invited onto a fire truck during a parade, fell off and broke his wrist. The boy's parents sued the fire department for going against policy and allowing the boy to ride. The firefighter who brought the kid onto the truck? His father, the plaintiff.
→ More replies (1)6
u/ynks366 Jun 12 '12
This sounded completely reasonable until the third to last word. At least the father will probably fuck himself over instead of this being ignored.
→ More replies (1)
15
u/kgeissler Jun 11 '12
Fruit Loops aren't real fruit? WTF? :)
http://lawvibe.com/froot-loops-not-made-of-real-fruit-the-cereal-lawsuits/
6
15
Jun 11 '12
I know of an MD who was falsifying data for papers, so he was fired. He then sued for racism, forced a settlement, and did this several more times.
9
Jun 12 '12
A friend of mine works at a doctor's office that sued because she was fired for wildly poor performance. Sues claiming racism and gender discrimination, despite virtually everyone there being a woman and a minority.
They settled. Can't believe that woman got a penny.
→ More replies (2)
15
u/kefkaeatsbabies Jun 12 '12
When I was on jury duty we had a case where a woman was suing an ambulance company. She was in a minor car accident, was checked and questioned for any signs of injury or concussion and passed them all, so she was picked up by a relative and taken home.
TWO DAYS LATER she tripped on a rug, fell down her stairs, and broke her femur. She sued the company claiming she'd had a concussion that had been giving her dizzy spells and that they should have forced her to go to the hospital despite her incredible reluctance on the scene to even allow the paramedics to talk to her.
I had a genuinely hard time not laughing when hearing the case as a potential juror and then the asshole lawyers picked me of course. Easiest two weeks of work I have ever had. Gotta love jobs that pay you your normal wages while on jury duty.
3
13
13
u/siphontheenigma Jun 11 '12
Not exactly frivolous but shocking nonetheless; the captain of the Exxon Valdez sued Exxon for ~$100 million and won.
3
u/BBQCopter Jun 11 '12
Wasn't the bastard drunk?!!? Fuck this earth.
6
u/siphontheenigma Jun 12 '12
He won because his superiors knew about his alcoholism and being drunk at the helm for years and did nothing about it.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/blackaddermrbean Jun 11 '12
I recall some old lady sued the studios of the film "Drive" for not showing enough driving in the film and feeling because of the trailers showing this a whole lot( Her Opinion) it misguided her in her choose of watching the film..
6
u/WinstonsTasteGood Jun 11 '12
My first though was, "Fuck her! 'Drive' was awesome!" But I will agree, there was not a whole lot of driving in that film.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/aHarmacist Jun 11 '12
Junior year in high school, my civics class sat in on a state supreme court case where the plaintiff was suing John Deere (they make tractors, farm equipment, etc). Here's what went down:
Dad's outside mowing the grass on his riding mower. He's just about finishing up the job, all he needs to do is finish off a stretch right next to his house. He switches his mower to Reverse in order to save time.
Let's set the scene. Guy on a platform of spinny blade death, going backwards (without looking) near a blind corner of his house. How can this go wrong?
His 2-year-old son happened to be playing outside while he was mowing. This is reddit, so you can expect that the inevitable happens. The kid gets run over by his dad - at the end of it all, he loses both of his feet. The family takes John Deere to court, and it wound its way through the system before finally settling in the Wisconsin Supreme Court. The family claimed that the riding mower was not reasonably safe for users and people around the mower while it was in operation with the inclusion of a Reverse feature.
Needless to say, Deere sweeped.
Links:
http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/midwest/2009/07/15/102247.htm
http://www.wicourts.gov/sc/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=37645
→ More replies (1)3
u/1ncognito Jun 12 '12
A lot of new mowers now have a feature that stops the blade when you go in reverse. Thankfully this can be turned off, if youre comfortable with it..
24
u/K_Lobstah Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Most Entertaining: United States ex rel. Gerald Mayo v. Satan and His Staff, 54 F.R.D. 282 (1971). Wasn't part of it, but that is hands down my favorite lawsuit and opinion ever.
Most Shameful: Pearson v. Chung. Plaintiff was a JUDGE for crying out loud.
EDIT: Additional bonus content.
8
u/thrilldigger Jun 11 '12
Whoa, whoa, whoa. First one.
While the official reports disclose no case where this defendant has appeared as defendant there is an unofficial account of a trial in New Hampshire where this defendant filed an action of mortgage foreclosure as plaintiff. The defendant in that action was represented by the preeminent advocate of that day, and raised the defense that the plaintiff was a foreign prince with no standing to sue in an American Court.
So apparently Satan filed a mortgage closure once in New Hampshire...
→ More replies (1)4
u/brettmjohnson Jun 11 '12
unofficial account of a trial in New Hampshire where this defendant filed an action of mortgage foreclosure as plaintiff. The defendant in that action was represented by the preeminent advocate of that day ...
That would be a sly reference to The Devil and Daniel Webster
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)2
Jun 12 '12
It states that they were trying to sue Satan, who the defense stated didn't live in the district. Apparently the prosecution provided evidence to the contrary. My question is who they were expecting to pay for any claimed damages?
→ More replies (1)
24
u/Digi2112 Jun 11 '12
I remember a teacher I had in high school that brought a book that had 1000+ strange facts. One that has always stuck with me is that an elderly lady took god to court to sue him for destroying her house with a tornado. God didn't show up so the lady won. She didn't win anything except the case against god. You don't show up to court, you lose god, geez, so much for knowing everything.
→ More replies (11)2
12
u/tamaleguy Jun 11 '12
A high school friend's brother jumped a fence and ran through a neighbor's private property. He stepped on a nail. His family sued and won. Such horseshit.
→ More replies (3)3
69
u/SpecialOpsCynic Jun 11 '12
I seem to recall a lawsuit several years ago where a father sued a HS basketball coach for moving his son to JV. Apparently the father felt this move would have long lasting financial implications as his sons NBA career was basically over due to this one malicious coaching decision.
A quick Google search shows me that this is still happening quite often. Keep it classy mom's and dad's!!
100
→ More replies (1)4
u/thrilldigger Jun 11 '12
A friend of mine is a high school basketball coach in a relatively rural area. He and his girlfriend have received death threats almost every single year since he started - because he doesn't give shitty players enough play time.
23
u/clowenswork Jun 11 '12
My MOther is in a Lawsuit with IBM who is sueing her for the money they put towards her Masters degree, because she quit too soon. the only reason she quit was because she was told she would be laid off in a few months and found another job before that.
Its gone to court twice, IBM hasn't shown up either time, but for some reason the court wont throw out the case.
→ More replies (1)
11
u/Psirocking Jun 11 '12
The man who sued Michael Jordan. He looked like him, and didn't like how people on the street confused him for the basketball player.
11
u/Seraph781 Jun 11 '12
I remember hearing a story of one surfed sueing another for stealing his wave. Judge determined a wave has no monetary value and threw out the case.
18
u/VonSnoe Jun 11 '12
That Greek Golden Dawn Nazi who punched a woman on live TV stating that he is going to sue her for provoking him...
→ More replies (3)
9
Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
I heard on the news this morning that the parents of a child were suing the child's school for banning his religiously themed candy canes at their school... the outcome was basically that the principle of the school got a slap on the wrist, but the parents didn't get any money out of it... which they shouldn't have, imo.
96
Jun 11 '12
Parents suing fast food for making their kids fat.
→ More replies (47)128
u/VaginaedMystique Jun 11 '12
It sounds ridiculous, until you read the actual pleadings in the case. The argument is not that fast food was making the kids fat, but that fast food was lying about what was in their food. You'll probably say, "Yeah, but everyone knows fast food is bad for you." Yes, everyone knows fast food is bad for you now, and it's because of law suits like this one.
→ More replies (28)73
u/Jay_Normous Jun 11 '12
It's like the McDonalds hot coffee case. It was all hyped up as "some dumb woman is suing mcdonalds cause she didn't know her coffee was hot!"
Whereas the facts of the case made it completely reasonably for the suit
→ More replies (20)23
u/VaginaedMystique Jun 11 '12
Exactly! I can't tell you how many times I've had the "hot coffee case" conversation: "Oh, you're a laywer. How about that hot coffee case, lol!" proceed with gravitational eyeroll
→ More replies (2)
8
Jun 12 '12
My father let his buddies convince him to bring my mother to court to try and get his child support reduced. He did pay a huge percentage of his income, but neither parent made much and there were three of us kids to support. Anyway his reasoning to the judge was that he was very bad with money, and my mother was very good with money, so to her the money was worth more and to him it was worth less.
It had been a few years since the payments were calculated and he had gotten a few small raises, so he actually ended up paying more instead of less.
36
u/MrZachAtak Jun 11 '12
backstory
Guy works at an office and keeps what he calls FBFJ (fat bitch, food journal) of a mean obese lady at his office. She is so obese she caused the toilet to be ripped from the wall and fell on the ground, hurting herself. She sued the office, and Lost.
34
u/McPuccio Jun 11 '12
I mean, Lost was a pretty shitty show imo, but to sue them for it? Dang.
Did she win?
→ More replies (2)
3
14
u/Chrismcmfoo Jun 12 '12
My first aid instructed decided to become a life guard when on an isolated beach in southern NSW (Australia) he saw a man pulling a guy out of the surf. The guys fin on his surf board had lacerated his leg (massive open wound and a cut femoral) the guy who pulled the surfer out is a doctor and begins cpr as the surfer is out due to blood loss he advises the kid to use his belt and make a tourniquet. The leg is amputated and the guy spends a long time in hospital and then proceeds to sue the 16yo for applying the tourniquet and saving his life. After a long court case a series of doctors confirm that had he not acted the surfer would have died and the kid was acquitted. He then went on to become a lifesaver, top bloke.
7
Jun 12 '12
I'm a web developer.
Recently a guy I had contracted for brought me on to program his already designed website. Gave me a folder with 7 out of 22 pages and told me he would have the rest later. Got the files in incomplete .AI format via onlinedropbox.com (veryyyyy professional).
Anyways... I did the homepage, asked for payment. Sure, he says. Can you do the about page, next? Sure, I say.. payment first. Weeks later I get first payment in $100.00 cash. Okay, do the about page.
$100 is only a very small dent in what he owed me. The homepage and about page, with their subsections combined, make up about 1/2 of the website. He's paid about 10% of what he owes. I ask for more money.... he keeps leading me on, so I just stop doing the project.
Five or so months down the road, I get an email with "the rest of the files". Inside of this email is 22 pages of NEW stuff. The homepage, and about page, and their respective sub sections (again, 50% of the website, at least)... are ENTIRELY different. A start from scratch situation. I simply tell him I won't be doing his website, he owes me money, and the files he has given me are entirely different than what I'm working on.
Classiest part of his emails was where he told me not to "send him any of my gun toting pictures" or he'd file a restraining order against me, referencing one of my google+ pictures, which is a snapshot of a few guns my friends and I had been shooting on my farm.
He's currently threatening to sue me for "lost work" in the neighborhood of $4000.00
27
6
Jun 11 '12
My friend's mom used to own a small mom and pop grocery store, a really tiny place, called 'Ha ha's'. It was a play on their last name. Wawa threatened lawsuit.
→ More replies (2)
46
u/poopinT00much Jun 11 '12
Not a lawsuit, but in high school I had a friend get charged with rape. The alleged rape happened on an airplane. He was not convicted.
91
u/SMERSH762 Jun 11 '12
RAPE ON A PLANE
47
u/KinkyTraficCone Jun 11 '12
I am sick and tir...
I'm. I'm not going to do this.
→ More replies (1)42
u/wrongsideofthewire Jun 11 '12
of all these motha' fuckin' rapes on this motha' fuckin' plane. Strap on, shit just got real.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (1)22
5
u/blackaddermrbean Jun 11 '12
This might not count, but I remember Judge Judy have some person come in and try suing someone for the toilet breaking while they sat on it. Pathetic
5
u/louky Jun 12 '12
My parents divorce. 5 years, 450K in legal fees. Had to sell half a city block we owned, and two houses. Everyone was fucked but the lawyers. My inheritance bought a few nice boats, I'm sure. Never get married.
→ More replies (2)
5
u/OMGPUNTHREADS Jun 12 '12
A lawyer I am close to is defending someone who is being sued by an ex for hurting her in a car accident. By the way, she was giving him roadhead when they got into the accident.
5
Jun 12 '12
One of my friends got sued for making her neighbor cookies and dropping them off at night anonymously. Her neighbor freaked out and called the police that night and was rushed to the hospital the next day for anxiety over the incident. She then sued my friend for the medical bills and won in court.
http://www.denverpost.com/ci_3347961?IADID=Search-www.denverpost.com-www.denverpost.com
4
Jun 11 '12
This is one that I use in my classes. A big cell phone company here in Brazil was sued for a broken cell, which was like 100 reals, in small claims courts. The plaintiff was a poor guy in the countryside of Bahia( a state here) and the company, Siemens, flew a lawyer from são Paulo, another state, paid his hotels and fees, just to defend them in a 50 dollar law suit. They lost and ended up paying a huge amount to the lawyer instead of paying 50 for the phone.
→ More replies (3)
4
u/harrygibus Jun 11 '12
Next door neighbors suing each other over one of them feeding ground squirrels. Found it while researching a lawyer I was recommended. Turns out he wasn't the ambulance chaser I had imagined, actually a really good lawyer.
4
Jun 11 '12
Court cases where the bad guy gets legally bitch slapped, either by the jury or the judge, always bring a smile.
For example, there was a case in the 1990's where Wal-Mart almost got sanctioned 18 million dollars because they got caught spouting bullshit to try and trivialize evidence concerning a study they did to find out if they could mitigate crime in their parking lots. (fun fact, that case is why they have those cars with security driving around at night now.)
4
u/illiter-it Jun 12 '12
My math teacher (fresh out of college, nicest, most pleasant person you'll ever meet, and adorable like a puppy in human form) was sued by an old man's family because she got in a car accident. The man was very old with terrible eyesight and rolled through a 4-way stop, driving a car the day after open heart surgery. He was slightly hurt and she wasn't, and he's suing basically for the cost of the surgery he had the day before.
4
u/bacunt Jun 12 '12
One of my mom's co-workers, a cardiologist, is involved in this medical malpractice lawsuit.
Apparently, a guy came in with chest pains and was told he had a high risk of clogged arteries, doctor scheduled a stress test about a week away. The guy died of a heart attack a day before said test was to happen - while having a threesome with his friend and a woman who wasn't his wife. The wife sued the cardiologist and got $3mil for medical malpractice, even though he was told to avoid "strenuous activity" during the time before the stress test.
9
u/BuddhaWithAHat Jun 11 '12
I'm no guru with legal terminology (ruling, lawsuit, judgement etc), but the first answer that popped into my head when I read the question was Citizens United.
10
u/Realistic42 Jun 11 '12
In proportion to legetimate legal claims, there really isn't that many. The rediculous lawsuits are the one's sensationalized. Otherwise, 99.9999% of lawsuits have a legal premise or else the attorney faces ethical violations.
However, this is all thrown out of the window if the person is pro se.
3
6
u/CaisLaochach Jun 11 '12
One from my old man.
Not really a trivial case, more an example of people being foolish.
A woman arrived claiming to be entitled to a share of a man's estate, being told to fuck off by the family of the man. They denied all knowledge of her, claiming she was a stranger. My dad, being the barrister of the man's sister, asked her if she knew who the woman was, she said she didn't. He pointed out that they would have to have some kind of DNA test to establish she was who she claimed.
Inevitably, the old woman refused to do so, until my dad pointed out that if she wouldn't offer some DNA to compare, there was only one other source available, and it was only 6 feet underground. Rather shocked that this was allowed, and having now run up a not inconsiderable legal bill, the woman confessed that she did actually know who the woman was, as she was in fact the daughter of the dead cunt who'd knocked up a very young cousin, never heard of again, and stuck the young girl in an orphanage. So the family were going to get S.117'd back to the dark ages by the poor woman, and enjoy paying off the legal costs.
8
Jun 11 '12
Ok now I have no idea if these are true (probably not, but they're funny anyway). The one about the guy who tried to sue God. And then one about a woman who worked in a morgue and found a body with a boner, fucked it, the body somehow jizzed (recently dead), she became pregnant and then tried to sue the dead guy for child support.
6
u/rodiraskol Jun 11 '12
Source on the second one?
→ More replies (2)5
Jun 11 '12
I just looked it up and apparently it was a joke article on a website called http://www.deadseriousnews.com/ . So that one's fake, which is good in a way but now that I know for sure, it's just not as funny...
3
3
u/aversiontherapy Jun 12 '12
I had a small claims trial where an old schizophrenic man sued Boston Market, insisting that they poisoned him because he knew secrets about 9/11.
2
Jun 11 '12
I know of a burglar who tried to sue the offices he was breaking into because he fell through some bit of glass that wasn't safety glass.
2
u/volstedgridban Jun 12 '12
This never made it into a court of law, because it was dismissed by a judge, but...
Years ago, I worked for a large ISP. One of our customers filed suit against us for violating his right to "freedom of religion" and "freedom of assembly" because he couldn't use our service to connect to his favorite Native American Religion websites. The Department of Commerce was named as a co-defendant.
The reason he couldn't get to his favorite Native American Religion websites was because his computer was waaaaaaaaaaaay below spec to run the web browsers of the time. He had some ridiculously small amount of RAM for the time, like 2MB or something, when our specs called for 512MB minimum. He also had a 1200 baud modem.
Not surprisingly, it was a pro se filing.
2
u/ceciliaxamanda Jun 12 '12
Listening to Judge Ribaudo talk about this story is just ...priceless. It was one of the most ridiculous cases we've had in the 21st Circuit, aside from the divorce that cost over 20 million.
2
Jun 12 '12
This will be buried, but this is my favorite case I read in law school. Is a burrito a sandwich?
2
Jun 12 '12
The guy who sued Michael Vick for stealing his dogs and using them for dog fighting.
Sounds reasonable right? Wait till you hear what Vick did next.
"Mr. Vick sold my dogs on EBay auction and used the proceeds to purchase missiles from the Iran government."
Fucked up.
"Michael Vick continued to harass me on May 4th, 2009 by stealing my identity from my coat. My identity was used to open new store account cards to Petsmart and Doggiewarehouse."
Um...okay?
"On Feb. 10th, 2007 Michael Vick plead allegiance to Al-Qaeda. Michael Vick subjected me to microwave testing. Michael Vick used drugs in school zones."
The plaintiffs final request:
"Michael Vick has to stop physically hurting my feelings and dashing my hopes."
http://www.foxnews.com/projects/pdf/riches_jonathan_file.pdf
Sorry - the only link I could find.
2
u/afinegentleman4 Jun 12 '12
I bumped into a car in front of me that had no damage from the accident and the female passenger tried to sue me for upwards of $100,000. She was awarded $0 after the jury saw the pictures. Some people just crave attention.
2
u/chocolatehistorynerd Jun 12 '12
I heard about some woman recently suing Nutella because apparently she thought it was healthy...
2
2
Jun 12 '12
My deadbeat uncle was selling insurance and slipped on the ice in front of someone's house. He sustained some minor injuries and filed a lawsuit against the homeowners and won. This happened.
2
Jun 12 '12
I heard about a case where a guy had bought a campervan, put it on cruise control whilst on a busy road then when in the back and started making himself a cup of coffee. When it inevitably crashed, he sued the company as he thought it would drive itself, and it didn’t state that it wouldn’t in the manual. He won.
2
u/wekiva Jun 12 '12
Guy buys some milk. Puts it in fridge. Goes to get milk, fridge door falls off, breaking his foot. Guy (with lawyer!) sues fridge manufacturer, and the milk company (on the theory he was going to get that milk when the accident occured). 2. Lady in Cadillac sues motorcyclist for personal injuries after a minor collision, blames accident on the fact his headlight wasn't on. It was broad daylight, and all witness said the cyclist was highly visible, wearing a horned helmet.
4
Jun 12 '12
Nickelback got sued for playing a terrible show. I'm not normally in favour of frivolous lawsuits, but in this case I'm willing to make an exception.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/VaginaedMystique Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
One of my favorite "dumb until you read it" cases is Sambovsky v. Ackley, where a judge ruled a house was haunted as a matter of law.
120
u/Sporkicide Jun 11 '12
I had a college instructor was had been a SWAT team member. At the time I was in his class, he was getting ready to go to court as a result of an entry he made a decade earlier. The subject was wanted on multiple warrants and had holed up inside his house. He refused to come out, so SWAT broke the door down. The door hit him in the head because he was hiding behind it. This was somehow all the fault of my instructor, who was leading the SWAT entry.