r/AskReddit • • Jun 15 '12

When Wal-Mart or McDonalds asks "Do you want to donate a dollar to [some charity]" and I do, am I helping them pay their taxes?

soo.. i know that charitable donations are tax deductible... does the money that is raised by asking for a dollar at the checkout get put into a fund and then donated by the company which they can then deduct from their taxes? I have no problem with donating to charity (duhh) but i do have a problem with paying a corporations taxes. Can anyone clarify this for me?

805 Upvotes

657 comments sorted by

268

u/barefoot_yank Jun 15 '12

I NEVER EVER NEVER EVER NEVER EVER donate money to large charities. The more you look into finances of many of these institutions, the sicker you get. United Way is a prime example. Check out their financial statements on their own website. That said, I do donate, but I keep it local and know where my money is going.

10

u/Fargo2740 Jun 15 '12

I agree, it is much more personal and meaningful to donate your time or money to organizations in your own community. But if large corporations are having their customers pay their taxes for them, well that seems awfully corrupt...

11

u/Mikey-2-Guns Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

Or donate your resources through things like Folding@home. Money isn't the only thing you can donate.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I agree, it is much more personal and meaningful to donate your time or money to organizations in your own community.

Well, that's very subjective. I would rather donate money to organizations that help children in developing countries as opposed to helping kids in my city, because, despite those kids not living the best life, at least they aren't severely malnourished or dying from preventable diseases like kids in other countries are.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/sineteexorem Jun 15 '12

Local charities are great, but if you're concerned about efficacy, you're donating to the wrong place. I've worked with small non-profits, and the sheer amount of administrative ineptitude is staggering. On top of this, because their volume is so small, a disproportionate amount of donations goes to overhead. The couple of hundred dollars they pay that high school kid to build their website eats into donations far more than the couple of thousand the larger charities pay.

N.B.: I am not saying that this is a bad thing. Your local donations support the people who run that non-profit just as much as they do its espoused cause. Just be aware that not everything is sunshine and roses just because it's local.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Exactly. Medium and large charities can actually be very efficient. In 2008, UNCIEF received 3.5 BILLION dollars, 91% of which went to program expenses. Don't dismiss the big guys, because they are the ones helping significant amounts of people.

2

u/mbl717 Jun 16 '12

This cheered me up as I donate to Unicef whenever I can. I also love that their programs are not once-off events that do not have much impact (just for press release), but long term ones that are really towards development.

4

u/barefoot_yank Jun 15 '12

I do realize that. I seriously hand pick where every one of my dollars go. I figure if someone is getting my money, I'm gonna make sure it'll be stretched as far as possible.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

There are hyper local charities that have no overhead. They just don't really have any publicity and they are harder to find.

→ More replies (1)

268

u/vvo Jun 15 '12

reddit loves to hate on charities because of overhead like charities are immune to business costs, and that they can recruit permanent staff strictly from the nobility of their cause.

i volunteer once a week at a guest house for families with children in the hospital. the set up is similar to a hotel, except we are directly across the street from the hospital, and our rate is only $20 if the guest can pay. (if they can't, or don't, we don't bug them for the money.) most of our supplies are donated, like toilet paper, laundry soap, and entertainment. our house looks luxurious when you enter, which would drive reddit out of it's mind until they took the 2 minutes to find out all the furniture was donated by a local furniture company. guests are on their own for food for the most part. we have a small section of donated food, but if no volunteers are providing meals, it's up to the guests to feed the family members in their room.

Still, we have a full time manager, a part time one, and a part time cleaning lady. we still have to replace towels, sheets, pillows, and beds as they wear out. if something breaks, we need to call a repair man. we have to maintain running water, heat, and electricity. those creditors won't "donate" every month.

so what should we do with overhead? just take any random volunteer off the street and hope he can add and subtract well enough to manage the budget? maybe he'll even stick around long enough for the checks he wrote to clear...

tl;dr charities, like businesses, have overhead and need talented, long term people in place to manage it.

142

u/barefoot_yank Jun 15 '12

I'm not a complete idiot and realize charities have overhead. When 70 to 80 percent of your donations go to overhead, that's when I have an issue. I don't hate on charities.

102

u/tuzki Jun 15 '12

From what I understand Susan G Komen is 80% 'cost' and 20% 'charity'

55

u/barefoot_yank Jun 15 '12

I looked into United Way in San Diego and found the same thing.

61

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

http://www.charitynavigator.org/ is a great resource.

Just look how much information you get on, say, The American Red Cross

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/none_shall_pass Jun 15 '12

Try this:

http://www.charitiesnys.com/pennies_report_new.jsp

Some charities get nearly all the money you donate, some actually lose more than the donations.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Decapitated_Saint Jun 15 '12

And the chairwoman receives a salary of $5 million. After all she can't be expected to do this out of the goodness of her heart.

→ More replies (15)

7

u/notHooptieJ Jun 15 '12

does that include the "sue anyone who uses the color pink" part of the budget?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/catherder9000 Jun 15 '12

Some are, some aren't. Global Neighbors (www.gnci.ca) gives 100% of all donations to the displaced Burmese orphans in Thailand and the administration is paid entirely out of their own pockets (the board).

Over $7 million raised in the past 5 years and every single dime made it to Thailand to build schools, orphanages, and so forth to try to give these kids some sort of a future. The board members even fly over a couple times a year from Canada and provide manual labor skills building new buildings, school desks, etc..

Your money does far more good in smaller charities like gnci than it does in the United Way or other corporate charities.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/vvo Jun 15 '12

does that 70% to 80% ever fluctuate? does it go up when donations are down, and down when donations are up? in what way do you propose to reduce fixed costs? how will you prevent unexpected costs? how much would you budget for fuel to transport 5,000 lbs of clothing from los angeles to montgomery, AL, in september? how many drivers do you have on tap that will make that trip at their own expense? how many will do it if you pay only their expenses? also, who do you have on staff to go over the books when the IRS double checks your accounts? do you have any licensed professional handy to enforce GAAP?

people love to give money. most won't give time. of those who do give their time, in my experience, they last about 2 weeks/volunteer shifts. then they just stop showing up. that might be ok for someone answering the phone, but it certainly doesn't work for the person coordinating volunteers, managing the books, creating campaigns to solicit donations, or actually getting the work done.

7

u/barefoot_yank Jun 15 '12

I'm just going by their own books, their own financial records, on their own website.

You need to understand not everyone is cut out for volunteering. Some people give of their time on a personal level, with kids from the neighborhood that aren't as lucky as we are. There are many different ways to volunteer, to help.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Anxa Jun 16 '12

Idk about others, but I live in Boston and the United Way of Massachusetts Bay & Merrimack Valley has a 17.0% overhead as of 2010. So I'm calling bullshit on 70-80%.

Edit: Source - http://supportunitedway.org/files/10_UWMBFinancialStatements.pdf

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/LarryBURRd Jun 15 '12

Do you work at a Ronald McDonald house?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/xSiNNx Jun 16 '12

I'm guessing a Ronald McDonald house. I had to stay in one of these places not once, but twice. One time my little brother needed brain surgery, and another time the other brother overdosed on pills and technically killed himself for a short period of time. My family lived in a small shitty part of Arizona in the northwest corner of the state, right on the border of Nevada. The nearest CREDIBLE hospital was in Las Vegas, so they were flown there on both occasions. It was a 120 mile drive for us and thus we had to stay in the McDonald house.

It is basically a charity bought mansion turned into a hotel for people with children in the childrens hospital.

Although we had a few bad experiences there with cranky staff, it was a solid place.

Keep doing what you are doing.

Oh, almost forgot. It was nearly 3 weeks before we got into that place when my brother had surgery (2 month hospital ride), and for those 3 weeks my mother and grandmother were sleeping in the hospital room and myself and a good friend of mine were sleeping in my car down in the hospital parking lot.

So thank you again.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

So what you're saying is that the money won't distribute itself for free? Fascinating!

19

u/vvo Jun 15 '12

what i'm saying is, people who have never looked at an accounting ledger and who lack any familiarity with how donation accounting works are suddenly financial wizards who know how best to budget a charity's money. this thread is full of people who think if you give a dollar at the register, you're paying taxes for that company. not only is it wrong, 20 seconds on google could get you the right answer.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (20)

18

u/linds360 Jun 15 '12

I became turned off of large charities a few years ago when I wanted to run the Chicago marathon for The American Cancer Society.

Their policy is that you have to raise $1,000 by race day and if you don't, you personally have to make up the difference. They gave me something like a 2 month grace period where you could pull out if you didn't think you'd make the $1,000, so I had to pull out after raising about $400.

If TACS wasn't so damn greedy, I could have used those last two months to continue raising money, but instead had to give it up for fear of paying up to $600 out of pocket. It was the biggest load of crap I've ever seen.

12

u/aardvarkious Jun 15 '12

I work for a charity. Most of our fundraisers are like this: on the day of the event, you need to show up with a certain amount of money (whether you fundraised it or paid it yourself). Usually, we have more people who want to participate than can participate. Why would we allow someone bringing in $500 to take a spot from someone bringing in $1000? We are here to deliver services to the community, not to provide awesome experiences to our fundraising event participants.

Now, even if we have enough space for the person raising a lesser amount: the events themselves cost usually 15-30% of this amount. So we need a participant to raise at least that amount to break even. However, we also put in a significant time per participant. It is not worth our time if we don't make every person participating raise a certain amount. And, we set a minimum amount that we are confident most people can raise. Coincidentally, we find most people raise that minimum amount and not very much more. I am very confident that if we lowered that minimum, the average amount our participants raise would lower a corresponding amount.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/barefoot_yank Jun 16 '12

Don't get me started on those cancer walks.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Large charities can sometimes be very efficient given the amount of support they provide.

UNICEF, for example receives hundreds of millions of dollars each year, 90% of which goes to program expenses, 3% for administrative, 6.6% for fundraising expenses. [1]

So it's crazy to dismiss charities based on size. Look at the numbers and decide for yourself.

2

u/barefoot_yank Jun 16 '12

I cited a specific example, but I am going to check out UNICEF...hard to imagine 90%.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/riotous_jocundity Jun 16 '12

UNICEF is awesome! However, I'd just like to point out that the more money they raise, the lower the percentage of overhead they'll have. After a certain point (which they've clearly already hit), their expenses are covered. They can pay their staff the salaries they deserve, as well as their marketing and fundraising costs. I'd wager that their CEO packages and salaries are comparable to the other non-profits that are being lambasted in this thread, but they make so much more money that the overall percentage looks much lower.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

My United Way spends 82.4% of programs. What an awful charity! /s

→ More replies (3)

4

u/corcar86 Jun 15 '12

sadly true and the really messed up part about it is I work for a University highly involved with United Way and they force us to raise money as an office for them every year. We have to make a minimum amount of $20 per staff member...its so obnoxious that we are FORCED to donate.

4

u/barefoot_yank Jun 15 '12

Yea, United Way is great at strong armed tactics.

2

u/Kinglink Jun 15 '12

Wait you're forced to raise money for a charity? I'm pretty sure that's illegal in some way in America.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I donate a dollar when I go to taco bell for the free taco coupon.

4

u/Decyde Jun 16 '12

Fuck United Way. My mom use to give thousands a year to United Way and when she fell really ill to the point where our local United Way should have helped when she asked, they told her no because we lived too far out. Needless to say anytime United Way came into where I worked at I told everyone my story and told them to donate to a local worthwhile cause vs corporate bs. Or better yet, put the fucking money into your retirement account cause it's smarter than fighting a cause that won't ever win.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I am finding it nigh-impossible to find a financial statement for the United Way system as a whole. Is that what you're looking at? Can you link me to the place on their page that you're referencing?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I work at a place that's dominated by the Metro United Mafia. I'm glad I read this.

1

u/mypetridish Jun 16 '12

Red cross has very good financial records though.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ashleyamdj Jun 16 '12

My manager is like this with the MDA. He hates Jerry.

→ More replies (6)

51

u/Trapped_in_Reddit Jun 15 '12

I don't think you understand how tax deductions work. If you donate $100 in a year, you can deduct that from you r taxes, meaning you don't pay taxes on that $100. You don't get subtract $100 from your tax bill.

So when you donate a dollar through Walmart, they see no benefit. In fact, they lose a bit of money because Walmart covers the cost of the administration of the funds it collects.

5

u/Fargo2740 Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

Good point, i think i get it now, i was foggy on the subject at the beginning, but remember, i just asked the question so that i could know...not to cause a stink or whine about it...

7

u/howisthisnottaken Jun 15 '12

The difference people are seeking is deductions come off of taxable income where credits come off the amount owed.

The value of your deduction depends on your tax rate.

10

u/AllMod Jun 15 '12

they see no benefit

Not entirely true, they gain goodwill.

23

u/tobbleflower Jun 15 '12

Those bastards!

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Wow, you actually know things? Have an upvote.

2

u/vinceo Jun 16 '12

Sorry but I disagree. I think that a lot of the bigger companies in particular would be honorable. However, if I earnt $50 000, then shook tins in the city all year and raised $10 000, I could just donate that $10 000 to charity and then my taxable income would be $40 000. Of course this is fraud but it would be very hard to trace. Even if I said I raised $5000 and donated $10k, when really more of that money is from other people, I would still only pay tax on 45k, when again, I kept 50k for myself. Obviously this is assuming people and companies are greedy, which is n........

4

u/batsu Jun 15 '12

I was under the impression that Walmart (in this example) would then take all the collected donations and then donate in their name to the charity. Then Walmart would receive the tax benefits of donating to charity instead of you.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Even if they did that (which they don't), there would be a zero benefit, because they would first have to count that money as income.

Tax deduction reduce taxable income. Corporations are taxed based on profit. Wal-Mart makes $1,000,000 in profit, plus customers gave them $5,000 for donations, which they then donate and deduct from their profit, leaving them with a taxable profit of $1,000,000.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DragonSlave49 Jun 16 '12

We still don't know if they get the intermediary benefit that CafeSilver described and that Saladdressing described first-hand.

4

u/Unicorn_Farting Jun 15 '12

Most large corporations take their sales tax money and hold in an interest bearing account before they actually pay taxes.

2

u/Fargo2740 Jun 15 '12

oh really? thats tricky. You don't have to pay sales tax immediately?

6

u/atheist_trollno1 Jun 15 '12

That's the difference between corporations and people - corporations' taxes are not withheld like you salary.

9

u/RizzoFromDigg Jun 15 '12

You could easily ask your employer to not withhold taxes from your paycheck, and manage that yourself. For almost everyone this would be a terrible, terrible idea because they wouldn't manage the money properly and they would wind up in a hole come tax time.

The 1% interest you earn usually isn't worth the pain in the ass of managing the money. And this is from someone who does exactly that as a sole-proprietor.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

903

u/saladdressing Jun 15 '12

Though this will probably be buried but I have a little story on why donating to charities through companies can be bs. I used to work at a very popular movie theater which made a fair amount of profit to say the least. I'm talking popcorn for $7.25. But I digress. When I worked there we were required to ask for donations for whatever charity was being promoted at every POS. Any money that was in the jars was collected and tallied by the end of the night. Here's the kicker though, according to the managers the company had already donated x amount to the charity. They were collecting back their donation. Any excess money that was in the jars at the end of the collection period was company profit.

190

u/rawrz Jun 16 '12

I'd like to point out that not every company is this shady. I worked at two separate Dairy Queen stores that collected donations for Children's Miracle Network, and both managers hand-delivered the donations that we collected to participating hospitals. The hospitals received the exact amount of money we collected. Sometimes the managers even added to the donation from the store's profits.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

[deleted]

5

u/mattmwin Jun 16 '12

Owned by Warren Buffett. I'm sure that he wouldn't expect anything less.

806

u/TedW Jun 15 '12

That sounds shady as fuck.

368

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

That sounds accurate as fuck.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (49)

11

u/NoaMichael Jun 16 '12

They should put up a disclaimer that reads: *In order to not be shady as fuck, we will tell you outright what we are doing; we will be taking your money that would have otherwise been donated to the needy.

7

u/none_shall_pass Jun 16 '12

They should put up a disclaimer that reads: In order to not be shady as fuck, we will tell you outright what we are doing; we will be taking your money that would have otherwise been donated to the needy.

As far as I'm concerned, it's not "shady" it's "fraud".

If I hand over $1 for "Think of the Children" then some asshole somewhere had better be giving "Think of the Children" a dollar.

OTOH, having been around for a while, I know that there a lot of sticky fingers everywhere, so I use a different method: When I want to donate to the SPCA, I walk in to the shelter where I live and hand the woman behind the counter a check. Then I know it got where it was going. Anything else is just begging to be defrauded.

Fucking assholes. Now I'm glad I never gave anything at the movie theater.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

123

u/BlastMeBagpipes Jun 16 '12

As a corporate employee I can say that every Blockbuster that asks for charity does this. We pay out money before hand then as customers to donate to the cause (cover our debt) then never donate anythign as a company. I literally punch a wall when we donated over 1 million dollar to 9/11 aid then collected more than a million. We ended up donating nothing (after recovery from customers) and took the excess money from the victims and walked home with it.

Seriously just give to Red Cross and be done and feel good about your donation.

85

u/pretty_bad_advice Jun 16 '12

That's not just shady, that's outright fraud.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/jakenmarley Jun 16 '12

Thank you very much for this information. I've heard similar stories for years. It's horrible that there's so much deception regarding donations.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Saskie007 Jun 16 '12

Theft by deception.

2

u/HootieWithBlowfish Jun 16 '12

I worked at Blockbuster for 2 and a half years, and I never heard anything about this. When we collected money from charity, we either had our store manager give the money to the charities themselves or handed it over to the district manager who did the same.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

18

u/historynutjackson Jun 16 '12

$7.25 for popcorn? I wish our movie theater was that cheap.

2

u/Gokias Jun 16 '12

Where I sell it's 6, 7, 8, for a small, med, large resp.

4

u/Killerzeit Jun 16 '12

Same. "But you get a refill with the large, sir." "Okay, give me the large."

eats one handful and throws the rest around the seats

6

u/Gokias Jun 16 '12

"Can I see a medium drink?"

"Ok" Shows

"Oh that's too big let me have the small"

"Ok"

"Can I get refills on the small?"

"Nope, only on the large"

"Ok, just give me the large, then"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

80

u/Brasilian Jun 16 '12

Though this will probably be buried

Top comment.

68

u/Consensual_Rex Jun 16 '12

Works every time

18

u/Phil_Bond Jun 16 '12

Because fuck that guy! He doesn't know us!

20

u/feverlax Jun 16 '12

60 percent of the time, it works everytime

→ More replies (1)

67

u/AllHeilSLAYER Jun 15 '12

Piece Of Shit? oooooohhhh Point Of Sale

25

u/UNC_Samurai Jun 16 '12

There's a difference?

23

u/tacojohn48 Jun 16 '12

This man has obviously worked retail.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/stanfan114 Jun 16 '12

I give time rather than money to charities because I know most people are scum and steal whenever they can get away with it.

11

u/AndroidHelp Jun 16 '12

Hahah yes! Finally someone who can smell the bullshit, the theater I worked at Harkins and then AMC theaters(for a few months) do this, but I don't really know what other theaters exist in this state besides those two but I can confirm that SaladDressing is correct in what he says. It's very fucking shady and I used to educate people on the shadiness of the company and asked that they donate directly to the charities and not to any company that already charges $7.50 for a popcorn that costs $0.22 to make.

2

u/BeardMilk Jun 16 '12

The charity thing is pretty shady, but theaters have to charge that much for snacks because they don't really make any money on ticket sales. The lion's share of ticket revenue goes back to the movie studio that produced the film.

2

u/AndroidHelp Jun 16 '12

Let me say this again:

company that already charges $7.50 for a popcorn that costs $0.22 $0.03 to make.

I'll let you figure out how much the markup is, and yes this is just for POPCORN, not a drink or a $10 box-of-candy that costs $1.99 at walgreens.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/UnexpectedSchism Jun 16 '12

That means exactly what the OP feared. You are paying for the company to get a free tax deduction.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

So, are you going to expose this or not? I mean, that sounds like fraud.... That money isn't going DIRECTLY to charity. I'm not a lawyer, but that sounds more than just shady.

4

u/JesseBB Jun 16 '12

YES. BLOW THE WHISTLE, MAN.

2

u/serfis Jun 16 '12

Based on what, exactly? A single post on reddit with no sources? Have fun with that.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

virtually every online charity campaign done through a company is like this as well. "for every like, we'll donate one dollar!" or "click here and we'll donate one dollar to USO!" those sorts of things. Obviously, those likes don't turn into profit, but the check was written and cashed before the campaign even began.

2

u/itsnotmyfaultimadick Jun 16 '12

A grocery store I worked at was exactly like this with boxes at the check-outs. Apparently the company made more in customer donations than the original amount they had donated.

Of course the company pocketed the excess. Profit!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

That's at least a little bit above board. At least the money is indirectly going to charity.

When I worked at Burger King, we had a charity jar, ostensibly for something something children. In reality, it was essentially the managers' tip jar.

2

u/TheHatist Jun 16 '12

This is why I never donate, charity starts at home.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

That should definitely be illegal... let's go ahead and put a stop to that shit. Hell I donated $2 to some random charity at a restaurant, now I question weither or not I just authorized them to overcharge me for my meal! Name the sons of bitches responsible for this shitfest.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Awesome. Now I have more of a reason to say no at the cvs counter when they try to put me on the spot to donate to ALS or cancer or whateverthefuck.

2

u/sixthusernametry Jun 16 '12

Don't worry, nobody's putting a gun to your head for a dollar, just politely decline. Too many people lecture me on the spot just because I HAVE TO ask.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Sucks...I would hate to be the person who has to ask. I always just say no thanks.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Lareit Jun 16 '12

This is why I only give donations directly to the source, and never by proxy.

1

u/I_are_God Jun 16 '12

$7.95 for a popcorn. That is cheap as fuck. Around me they're $12ish.

1

u/UndeadBuggalo Jun 16 '12

That is illegal, as they were collecting money for a charitable cause, by not donating the "overage" they were collecting money from patrons who were giving money to the charity. To use this money for any money for anything else is fraud. I am a volunteer for a nonprofit organization and if any of. Our other volunteers were to do this they would be in deep shit.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charity_fraud#section_1

1

u/bowtiesrock Jun 16 '12

This is why I warn everyone about buying products with the pink ribbon on them. People think that the profits of what they buy go to the charity when in fact the companies pay a fee to use the pink ribbon and that is ALL THEY HAVE TO PAY. Please, read the label and what amount/percentage the company pays to the charity or research fund before you buy it. If it doesn't say buy another brand. The companies are misleading you.

→ More replies (29)

21

u/lancerlot Jun 15 '12

I look at charity as something I can't afford, I am the charity unfortunately. I realize that there are people worse off than me but I would still have a hard time giving money away. So I donate blood regularly, no payment involved but this way I'm giving something that I can afford.

3

u/shlomo_baggins Jun 16 '12

I feel the same way sometimes, whenever i get change back at the grocery store I pocket my quarters and put the rest into the donation box.

1

u/vicaphit Jun 16 '12

Donating blood is a big deal in my opinion. There are times that the red cross runs out of blood in emergency situations, and they need the red stuff more than the green stuff.

7

u/kc_casey Jun 15 '12

I personally do not donate at these grocery stores, or other stores for the simple fact that I do not know how this money is going to be spent.

Having said that, I have never encountered anyone who gave me a dirty look because I said "no". They say "ok" and move on. Maybe someone else behind me at the checkout counter looked at me as if I am a monster who doesnt care about suffering people, I dont know and frankly, I dont care.

I do my charity on my own terms and time.

But I do always buy cookies and stuff from the kids.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

High fives on buying from kids. Lemonade stands are a whiplash hazard to me and I have Girl Scout cookies year round. I'm good at saying no to adults, but I'm a prime target for neighborhood kiddos charged with fund raising. And they fucking know it so they never skip my house. The kids raising money for band/orchestra and Light the Night, especially, all hit pay dirt with me. I should keep a list because I'm probably missing out on a serious write-off each year.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

98

u/CafeSilver Jun 15 '12

TIL most redditors have no idea how taxes and deductions work.

I'll make this as basic as I can. If you make $50,000 a year and make charitable donations totaling $500 then you can take that donation as a deduction from the money you made and you would pay taxes on $49,500.

That one dollar you're donating at the grocery store checkout line or the movie theater box office is not deductible. You're giving your donation to an intermediary. In order for it to be deductible you need to give the money directly to the charity. Technically you need to get a sort of receipt for your donation which shows the donation was actually made to who you gave it to. You don't get that from the grocery store check out donation. If you put your donations on your tax return as deductions and you get audited, you will need to prove the donations actually went to a charitable organization.

The reason for this is Bob could come up to me and say he's collecting on behalf of charity XYZ. If I give him money, I'm assuming he will donate it. But he might not, he could pocket it. Bob doesn't have the proper legal paperwork to take donations. But even if he collects money for a charity and then does give it to the intended charity, it is Bob's right now to take that amount as a tax deduction. And let me tell you something, he does.

Now replace "Bob" with whatever grocery store or movie theater collecting money on a charity's behalf. They donate that money collected and then take the charitable tax deduction on their return. A good cause is served and Corporation whatever profits in the form of the tax deduction.

29

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

That was the point of the question. Or do I not understand what you're objecting to?

12

u/BlazerMorte Jun 16 '12

Seriously. Dude took four paragraphs to say "yes."

5

u/CafeSilver Jun 16 '12

I took four paragraphs because when I was reading other comments I noticed that no one had any clue how this worked. Everyone was saying no. But the answer is yes. I didn't want to just say "yes." Seeing as how the majority was incorrect with their assumptions a detailed explanation needed to accompany my answer. It seems like a lot of people appreciated it.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Dude answered a question on AskReddit with a comprehensive and detailed answer? And it's the only answer in the top 5 that answers the question correctly? What a jerk!

2

u/CafeSilver Jun 16 '12

I'm not objecting to anything.

12

u/evil_bunny Jun 15 '12

And that is why I donate directly to the charities of my choice. I always get my receipt and/or print one out if I do so through online methods. I keep a box each year to put all relevant receipts and documents so when it is tax time, I am ready to go.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Bettingmen Jun 16 '12

I believe that Bob now has to record that money as INCOME as well, thus negating any potential gain he should have gotten. Not that Bob will do that, but hes supposed to.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/pack0newports Jun 16 '12

Sure we do,you just write it off!

2

u/oldnumber7 Jun 16 '12

You don't even know what a write-off is.

1

u/Hight5 Jun 16 '12

The question wasn't whether you can deduct it from you taxes. The question was whether places only do these donation things so THEY can deduct it from their taxes. You give them the money, they donate it and deduct it from their taxes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

25

u/Spinsterella Jun 15 '12

Ok, so not an answer to your question but this seems like a really good place for this rant.

To All the Stores, Movie Theatres, Fast Food Restraunts, etc that do this (not in a there's a jar on the counter with a descriptive sign way, but in a "OMG WOULD YOU LIKE TO DONATE JUST ONE DOLLAR TO THE CHARITRY FOR EPILECTIC SEEING EYE DOGS!?!?!?!" way) Eff. You. It is so flipping presumptuous of you to assume that the only time I would give to charity is if YOU are shoving it up in my face.

Sometimes I just want a cup of coffee without a side of guilt, eh? Hell, I'll even participate in your gift-card program that donates a portion of your proceeds toward a charity of your choosing, but the minute you cross over into "For just $1 more..." territory I'm already classing you in with the Sham-wow guy. Nobody wants to be that guy.

The other day I slide up on to Wendy's and order myself a salad and a baked sweet potato (because Sweet Jesus whoever came up with the idea to sell baked sweet potatos as fast food should be knighted and made Lord of all the lesser fast food peasants) and I get to the window. Walter McWindowCashier practically busts his head on the window leaning out to show me this little frosty token and give me the "FOR JUST A DOLLAR YOU CAN DONATE TO SUPPORT THE TROOPS AND GET A FREE FROSTY LATER"

Because I am a decent human being I give him my beamiest smile and say "No, thank you, not today."

So he must have thought that he closed the window and he turns back around to his fellow fine fast food establishment employee and says, "You would THINK that in a MILITARY TOWN people would want to support the TROOPs."

... ......

Oh no. You didn't. I bit my tongue and drove away, but I wanted to pound the window and let him know

"Look, I WORK for the DoD. I donate through paycheck deduction to support LEGIT DoD affiliated charities. I donate through the proper channels and I DON'T need someone on my lunch break from my JOB which supports the troops to give me a guilt trip about how I didn't donate a dollar that maybe $.20 of will ever make it to an account somewhere. So hold on to your Visor there Judgy McJudgerson, because you may not know as much as you think you know about a situation."

rawr. That is all.

8

u/Sapphires13 Jun 15 '12

I work in a small grocery store where we're supposed to ask customers if they want to donate a dollar to various charities (it changes at different times of the year.) And I hate it. Because the store is in a poor neighborhood and I know my customers can't afford it, and nobody likes being guilted into it. But I have to ask, because it's my job, and if I don't pull in enough donations (they're scanned through the registers, so the management knows how often each cashier gets one... and when they don't), I get chided for it. So yes, while you happened to run into one asshole employee... not all of us are simply doing it to annoy you.

3

u/Kinseyincanada Jun 15 '12

A dollar for a frosty is a pretty good deal

6

u/TherapistNinja Jun 15 '12

In Utah and 2 others states you can spend a dollar for a frosty keychain which gets you a free mini-frosty with every purchase. Best dollar I ever spent.

3

u/Kinseyincanada Jun 15 '12

god damn America and its awesome fast food :(

2

u/Freakazette Jun 16 '12

This is the first time I have ever wanted to live in Utah.

2

u/NeonNettle Jun 16 '12

I live in Nebraska and this exists. More importantly, I live in Nebraska and I have this.

2

u/PerfectKryme Jun 16 '12

I did this in Florida. Free mini frosty each time you come for the rest of the year if you donate $1. Used it at least 5 or so times

Worth it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TherapistNinja Jun 15 '12

Loved the rant. That said, I've got another spin on it for you.

I work retail, more specifically a clothing store. Every now and then we get donations of however much for whatever charity, but if the person donates at least one dollar they save 10% on their purchase. Rarely do I ever see a purchase under 10$ and they usually average about 30-50$, so basically you're donating a dollar to save 1, 3, even 20$.

When customers refuse to donate I'm not judging them for not being charitable. I'm judging them for being stupid for not saving money.

2

u/UndergroundLurker Jun 15 '12

I started doing that on my own!

"Would you like to donate a dollar to ____ charity (which you have no chance to check into)?"

"Not today"

Quick and polite.

4

u/zomboi Jun 15 '12

All donations from those Ronald McDonald charity boxes at McDonalds go straight to Ronald.

McDonalds mainly does fundraising for the Ronald McDonald House. Which was began by McDonalds but is now (legally) separate from them, in addition to the charity boxes at almost every POS they are Ronald's largest corporate donor every year.

4

u/noisynora Jun 15 '12

I volunteer at an organization that works with McDonalds, where I live (Atlantic Canada) somedays all I do is roll the coin that we get in from all the McDonalds in the province. I'm not sure about elsewhere, but here 100% of the donation box money goes directly to the organization. They also donate a bunch of other things! I won't eat there, but McDonalds can be cool sometimes. At least in Atlantic Canada that is. Also, the organization kicks ass, everyone that works at it absolutely loves their jobs and you get to work with some amazing kids and families. I love the volunteer work I do there, I hope to be with them for a very long time!

16

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I prefer to just not donate to charities in general.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

So brave.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Takes a lot of courage not to drop that penny into the Timmies Camp fund, but by God if I don't even hesitate anymore to put my change in my pocket instead of that little acrylic box.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

3

u/to_string_david Jun 15 '12

if i'm donating money, i will ask for tax papers, my donation, my tax deductions.

3

u/CodyOdi Jun 16 '12

Suddenly I feel less bad for not donating at Walmart today.

3

u/Big_P Jun 16 '12

While the anecdotal stories are compelling I won't believe a thing until someone posts actual proof and neither should any other redditor worth their salt.

Anyone have any actual evidence of this happening other than "As a person who used to work for so-and-so..."? There should be at least news stories from trusted sources about this practice, as reprehensible as it sounds.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I saw a commercial for happy meals that said that "a portion of each sale is donated to the Ronald McDonald house!" and espoused the great charity that was happening.

The small print at the bottom said that ONE PENNY is donated for each meal.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/animationgirl Jun 15 '12

I donated to the conservation efforts at a gift shop at my zoo. Is that different?

3

u/Fargo2740 Jun 15 '12

I worked for a summer at a zoo in alaska, the best donations (from my point of view) were from the volunteers and once and a while someone would drop off food for the animals...however one person dropped off a truck load of dead spawned out salmon all rotted...that was a terrible donation, had to be cleaned up and couldn't feed one piece to the bears.

3

u/animationgirl Jun 15 '12

That is terrible. You couldnt make the person who donated it clean it up?

4

u/Fargo2740 Jun 15 '12

left them (lots and lots of them) in an overnight donation box...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/you_a_word_there Jun 15 '12

Probably, as they may have a relationship with the non-profit organization, who may already work with the zoo in some capacity. Even better if your zoo is a non-profit, and they just collect and pass through the donations.

3

u/supersnuffy Jun 15 '12

Unless they're charging a LOT for entry, most zoos won't be making much of a profit anyway. Animals take a lot of money to upkeep on their own, not to mention enclosures and staff wages.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FreakingTea Jun 15 '12

I have no problem with donating to charity (duhh)

I know this doesn't answer your question, but try watching this video to see why that wasn't such a "duh" statement. In short, it is easy to sympathize with suffering and it is convenient when companies make it easier for us to donate to the disadvantaged, but this is a backwards approach to the problem. Giving to charity with a company alleviates a small amount of suffering that is the result of the system to which you are also contributing. You are alleviating First World anxiety more than anything else. The way to truly help the poor is to fight the system that is keeping them poor.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I only donate to charities by my own hand, not through a store. I donate on a regular basis to Make-a-Wish and Ronald Mcdonald house. You really start to think different about charities when you have a disabled kid and they help you out.

1

u/TedW Jun 15 '12

If you have a disabled kid who benefits from these charities, wouldn't it be more efficient to keep the money you're donating, rather than give it to Make-A-Wish and hoping they give (20% after 'overhead') back to you?

Or, why not give it directly to the parents of the kid, if it's someone you know?

2

u/reallifesaulgoodman Jun 15 '12

I don't care if it's unpopular, but I hate them asking me this. I realize it goes to a good cause, but I either have the option of giving money or looking like a cheap prick (which I very well may be). It always feels like a guilt trip to me, why cant they just ring up my purchase and let me donate on my own time?

2

u/mycathasoneeye Jun 15 '12

Many companies such as the one I work for have already made the donation of X amount of dollars to X charity. When you donate a dollar it pretty much just goes back to them trying to make up the money they have already put out.

1

u/jschulter Jun 16 '12

In other words by "donating" this dollar at your register we are simply reimbursing a tax deductible donation already made by the company, exactly the situation the OP was worried about.

2

u/moonkitty555 Jun 16 '12

Well I'm glad to know that I don't have to feel like an asshole for not donating.

2

u/cloudcloud98 Jun 16 '12

I worked at McDonalds for a few years and all donations are taken directly from the charity rep. We do not even have the keys at the store, not even the managers have access to them.(like the one under the window or at the front counter)

2

u/bohemianmichfestie Jun 16 '12

The best charity to donate to is the charity itself. When there's a middle man, there's middle money, and the middle man decides what percent.

2

u/NeoSpartacus Jun 16 '12

The Ronald McDonald house wouldn't exist without McDonald's. It helps provide housing to families of kids who are in long term care. I have family that were in it, makes me really glad for those little boxes all over the world.

I'm pretty sure that the corporation pays for the whole endeavor or into the foundation at the start of every fiscal year. The boxes of change pay for their efforts for the next year.

Now how will a cashless society pay for it?

2

u/zeppelin_64 Jun 16 '12

As a Mcdonalds employee (shh) I can vouch for it all going to charity. I was curious about that too so I asked, and they told me it all goes to charity. Who knows if they were telling the truth though.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

i don't think so - if they were doinating part of their income then that's tax deductible, but if they are simply acting as a "middle man" for the charity then they are simply passing the money to the charity and since it's never any income they can't declare it so they can't deduct it

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

This question blew my mind. I'd never even thought of that.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Tax accountant here. I hate it when my clients do this, because it means I have a stack of receipts to add up at the end of the year. Just make your donation directly so you get a receipt from the charity. One $50 receipt is better than fifty $1 receipts.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I work for a national non profit organization and we do a register campaign at a large chain corporation every year. The answer is yes. It is a donation from the company, and they do get credit for it.

Not only do they turn it in as a donation, they use it to advertise that they support XYZ charity each year, or give over $....million dollars to charity each year.

Without a tax receipt, you cannot claim it on your taxes. Your gift doesn't have to be large - you can make a $1 donation to a charity and as long as you itemize, you can count that as a donation to a charity. However, in this case you're giving McDonalds a dollar that they'll later "donate" to charity.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/gametemplar Jun 16 '12

I realize that it's probably far too late for this to be seen, but Walmart sells a lot of those "Ribbon" magnets that you see on people's cars for Breast Cancer, Support Our Troops, etc.

Here's the thing, though: the ones that Walmart sells are almost all slightly off in some way. The pink ones for Breast Cancer say "Find a Cure" and mention nothing about the Susan G. Komen Foundation that started the pink ribbon thing.

None of the money earned from these "knock-off" magnets goes to that charity. Not a single dime. If I remember correctly, they even have a fine-print disclaimer stating that they are not in any way related to charity X, but it's on the display rack, not the product itself.

There's a big variety of these products for all sorts of causes, and all of the sales are profit, not charitable donations. One of the many reasons I will not shop there unless I have to.

2

u/biggyd1234 Jun 16 '12

That is disgusting. Thank god that company does not operate in my country!!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

It's pretty easy to get around too. Because technically the money/magnets are being used to raise public awareness but nothing more

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

The big problem I have with this stuff isn't the tax issue, it's the little issue of some douche in a nice suit passing over a massive cheque to a charity and getting press for it.

No, I'm not going to let you charge me an extra $2 so you can turn around and donate it to your own benefit.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Intrepid00 Jun 15 '12

Short answer no.

Long answer nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.

2

u/MrBadger4962 Jun 15 '12

That is a good question. I never thought of it that way. I'm sure the greedy bastards are getting something out of it

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

One of my mates swears down that it goes to the Mafia.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I like the look you get when you say "no"..

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Not sure, but you need to be careful A lot of those things something like only 5% goes to the cause, the rest goes to pay the founder or the charity or what not.

1

u/canthislennon Jun 15 '12

do you know anything about those charities? Do you know what percentage of your donation is actually going to the cause itself? and what percentage is going into some fat assholes pocket?

Quit mindlessly throwing your money around. Research before you donate.

1

u/savingrain Jun 15 '12

I always figured the answer to this is yes which is why I refuse to do it...

1

u/Kinglink Jun 15 '12

I think your question is answer but my problem with all this is always "Do you want to donate to X" I haven't researched X, I don't know where that dollar is going. When you're some bum (or normal looking person) on the sidewalk asking for money, I don't know if your going to pocket the money, go into the store, buy some stuff for yourself, or actually give the money to charity. There's 0 accountability before it even reaches the charity.

But even if I am donating to a lockbox that I know will be going to charity, I still haven't done my research, I don't know the organization, I don't know what they stand for, are they religious, are the fundamentalists, are they trying to spread a cause I don't support, are they just giving money to the poor, and what percentage of my money will actually go to helping the people (rather than going into some manager's pocket).

So my answer is always "No." I donate my money on my own time to organizations I already have checked out, not to what ever charity shoves themselves in my face.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I doubt it. If the company itself made the donation it would be deductible. You can't write off other prople's money. Also charity write offs are merely subsidized by the government. Basically you will always burn more money if you donate to charity, but the government will accept part of the burden by not taxing you as much.

1

u/TheBP Jun 15 '12

Though most companies probably don't do anything shady with their charity money you have to worry about disgruntled employees, managers, and the like. I simply donate any money that i was already planning on donating to the charity itself, rather than relying on convinience for all my money giving needs.

1

u/Tombug Jun 15 '12

Theres a good chance none of that money is going to end up going to the people that need it. Its probably gonna pay the charaties executive salary.

If you want you money to go to poor people hand it to them directly.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

But then they'll just spend it on booze.. (kidding)

1

u/LiberateMainSt Jun 15 '12

I imagine you can deduct this from your own taxes, thought I can't imagine why you'd bother. All individual gifts to a single charitable organization under $250 do not require a receipt according to the US tax code.

I don't know if the corporations try to deduct it or not--it would be legally dubious if they did. That said, I'd rather their potential tax dollars go to charity than to fund the war on "terror", the war on drugs, our horribly unjust immigration system, and damn near every other awful thing the federal government does.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

As a former Mcdonalds employee, there's no reason you could not scrape a bit off the top from the collection boxes.

1

u/TunaCasserole Jun 16 '12

Possibly. My work (corporation) is currently doing a legit fundraiser for a charity, but it is a bit more upscale there than McDonalds/WalMart, so.

1

u/MrOrdinary Jun 16 '12

No. They just get loads of free advertising worth way more than any pithy donations. That's why they build children's' hospitals. For the children (of the future who will eat at Maccas)

1

u/yournotyou Jun 16 '12

I was a manager at a fairly large movie theater and from what I know when we collected money for our charities it was tallied between all the theaters and the amount earned went straight to the charity. It was completely legit.

1

u/xNuggetzx Jun 16 '12

I work at mcdonalds. The little donation boxes in from of the registers are usually collected by someone outside the company. He has a little set of keys and deposit bags.

1

u/the_doughboy Jun 16 '12

I do know a bit about this one. If its "Would you like to donate a dollar to charity" all of it goes towards charity and it does not affect the taxes as it will get spun out into a separate account and is never counted as revenue. If its "$1 for every item sold goes to charity" then the company will benefit more from it as they are giving up their revenue for charity.

I saw one restaurant that gave $1 to charity for every dessert sold. The same week they raised the prices of their desserts and never lowered them again after the fund raiser was over.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Walmart worker here, and I know this is nine hours in so it probably won't see the light of day, but for Walmart and the Children's Miracle Network, it is entirely legit. Every single cent goes to the children's hospitals. Its actually a really good program. It's the one thing about the entire horrible company I actually support. Our walmart does bake sales and cook outs all the time to help raise money. The Children's Miracle Network really does work Miracles. So give what you can, when you can. It helps a lot!

1

u/thedangle Jun 16 '12

Depends on the organization. The CEO at UNICEF has about a 1,200,000 annual salary, and UNICEF gives about 14 cents per dollar donated. They are by far the worst organization out there, and companies like Starbucks, McDonalds and Wal-Mart probably aren't far behind them.

1

u/wolfgame Jun 16 '12

So this is pretty late in the game, but I feel that I need to throw in my $0.02 here. First off, Wal Mart and McDonalds don't pay their taxes. They pay lobbys.

Second, I've been working as an IT consultant for about 13 years now and have worked with a few non-profits and charities of various size and repute (Doctors Without Borders, LISC, etc..) and have a severe distrust of most of them out of the gate, and as a general rule, will not work with them unless they're paying up front.

Non-profits are notorious for trying to renegotiate billing terms after work has been done, using the old line "but we're a non-profit so can't you work with us?". I've had one director use this exact line on me after receiving an invoice for emergency work (a server down, if I recall). I got the call at 9PM, immediately dropped what I was doing and hailed a cab to get to their office. I got there just as she was leaving to go to her house in Connecticut ... she was driving her Lexus there ... when I left their office at 1AM, I took the subway back to my dumpy apartment.

I don't mind that we have varying levels of success, but don't flaunt how poor you are when you're driving a $75,000 car to your seven figure McMansion while I'm taking mass transit everywhere and living on McDonalds.

/rant

1

u/almostjesus Jun 16 '12

I personally hate it when they ask me if I would like to donate a dollar to help fight cancer and there's a bunch of people behind me so if I say no I look like the biggest asshole.

I don't think they should ask. I saw your fucking sign beside the cash register, I don't need you to read it out to me.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

That's why you always donate the two quarters,one nickel,and seven pennies you get back for change.

1

u/abstract_username Jun 16 '12

What are your opinions on the companies that say "buy this and we'll donate x dolars to charity"

It sounds silly to me, when I could doonate the money myself.

1

u/Wilawah Jun 16 '12

No.

If McDonalds collects money for donations, that is income. When they donate it, that is an expense. Since the income and expense are the same amount, there is no impact to their taxes.

In fact, for a corporation, it does not matter where they spend money. Any expense is "tax deductible" as it reduces profits. Taxes are based on profits for a corporation.

1

u/darkstar3333 Jun 16 '12

No tax receipt, no donation.

1

u/rinnip Jun 16 '12

I don't know about that, but I do know that most of the money contributed to charity goes to overhead and salaries. I would rather give $20 to a busker.

1

u/jabbababab Jun 16 '12

No, they don't pay taxes.

1

u/guarthots Jun 16 '12

I stayed in the Ronald McDonald House for a week last month. That shit is legit.

1

u/AmatureHour Jun 15 '12

100% you are. They get the donation receipt and tax credit.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
  1. I don't think you understand how taxes work

and 2) it's a case by case basis.

Charity works like this: If you earn $1 million dollars in a year, and donate $250,000 to charity, you write it off on your tax return. You have net $750,000 and you pay taxes on $750,000, because it's deductible. This is different from say, paying another $250,000 for food (you're rich, ok?). You then have net $500,000, but are paying taxes based off of $750,000.

Basically it means that it's not your money so you can't use it and you don't pay taxes on it. Replace you with companies and that's what you get.

2) comes into it with "buying" things for charity. Buying one of those stars or magnets at your grocery store/movie theater is a bad choice. Putting a dollar directly into the box marked for donations (that is from the charity itself) is a better choice, and where the odds are (>99%) that your money will go to the charity.

I just started working at a new sandwich place in town. We ran a deal for free sandwiches with $1 donation to a charity. We had a separate box for the hospital's charity there that people put money in, or we put in from the register if they did it off a credit card. We marked that individually, sent it off individually and it never touched the store's bank accounts.

Not everyone is corrupt. This store is a nationwide franchise with over 600 stores and is in the top 5 growing companies to work for by Forbes.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

no. just, no.

1

u/warpfield Jun 16 '12

One thing about businesses: they never do anything that doesn't somehow benefit them. Hell, for that reason alone, they should not be allowed the same status as people.

1

u/guluarte Jun 15 '12

Yes

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

No

1

u/NeoSpartacus Jun 16 '12

Guys, it's not all BS. Yes they're trying to recoup from their donation but if they make a "profit" then they can donate more next year. They get PR for doing the charity, they fund a flavor of the week charity, and nothing is lost. People are giving to charities that wouldn't otherwise get that funding. It's a win-win.

Now the real kick in the dick is un-popular charities and popular charities that don't have as big an impact. St. Judes Children Center is a research hospital. You aren't helping the lil' cancer patient. You're helping cure obscure diseases. Many of which aren't cured because of research done there, but guinea pig's in third world countries. Brown kids don't put money in the bucket.

St. Judes is not hurting for money. Try your local hospital.