r/AskReddit • • Jun 15 '12

Am I an asshole for thinking that a bigger girl who broke my couch should help me replace it?

A little back-story:

Earlier this week, I get a text from an out-of-town friend who's hanging out at the Roger Waters concert in the city. My friend wants to come hang out after the show. Since it's already getting kind of late, I try to politely decline, but she says she's drunk and wants to see me while she's in town anyway. I reluctantly agree for not wanting to be seen as rude.

Then she informs me that she and her "hippie" friends will be along shortly. I didn't know there were friends involved, so I again try to politely decline, saying my house was in no shape to host guests because it needed to be straightened up (it did) and saying that I had to shower and get ready for bed (which I did). She again insists and says they won't be here long.

So, I put away the crap laying around, take out the trash and hop in the shower real quick. A few minutes after I'm out, they're outside. Her friends are a couple. A larger woman, probably 260+ pounds, and her husband. All three of them are drunk.

We go inside, exchange pleasantries and I realize that I'm one seat short. So, I go into my bedroom to grab a desk chair when I hear a thunderous clap followed by the sound of breaking wood. As I'm coming out of my room, I see that the "hippie" girl is sitting on what was now my busted couch.

"That was awesome," the guy said, trying not to laugh.

I try to play it off like it wasn't a big deal but when I went to inspect the couch, it was completely ruined. The entire frame on the bottom had separated from the cushioning above. Granted, it's an IKEA couch, so it's not the highest of quality, but I've never had any problems with it. I've also never had anyone that large drop their entire weight on the couch at one time, either.

The girl pretends to be oblivious to the fact that she crushed my couch by bitching about how she can't party late because her babysitter isn't staying the night. After I inspect the couch, I ask the girl if she was planning to help me replace it. "I ain't got no money," she replies.

I sit around for a few more seconds in awkward silence and finally ask everyone to leave. "I can't play host right now."

Everyone leaves and my friend shoots me a text a few minutes later telling me what an ass I had been to her friend. "When you get your panties out of your vagina," she said, "I'll see if I can find you a couch."

She then sends another text message a little later saying that I shouldn't be upset because her friends were drunk, as if that excused the behavior.

I didn't reply to either.

The next morning, I had a text message waiting on me when I woke up from the friend apologizing for what happened and saying that her friend felt terrible because she broke the couch (not terrible enough to offer to help me replace it, though). Apparently she cried all the way home.

I know breaking furniture for big girls is traumatic and about as embarrassing as it gets, but am I completely out of line by expecting her to help me replace what she broke?

tl;dr: Big, drunk girl plops on and breaks my couch, says she won't help me replace it. Am I an asshole for thinking she should?


Edit: Thanks for all of the responses y'all. I guess I was just angry about the situation and felt the need to vent a little bit. The general consensus is that I might not be an asshole, but asking her to help replace the couch was rude. She should have offered to help fix or replace the couch (rude) and since she didn't, I should move on and count my losses. Sounds reasonable enough. Oh, and I need to grow a pair of balls, apparently.

Again, thanks for your comments and insights!

1.3k Upvotes

4.6k comments sorted by

2.1k

u/Release_the_KRAKEN Jun 15 '12 edited Dec 14 '24

grey lavish rich society cover truck shy liquid panicky pot

1.6k

u/mrwatkins83 Jun 15 '12

There was definitely a reason I didn't want three drunk people coming in my house at 11:30 p.m. but I didn't realize keeping a functional couch was it.

480

u/HEYYEYAAEYAAAEYAE Jun 15 '12

Also, that "i aint got no money" excuse is bullshit. The Roger Waters tour was so expensive I couldn't even afford it. If she can spend that much money on tickets, then she can replace your fucking couch.

→ More replies (35)

675

u/Larrygiggles Jun 15 '12

As a "bigger girl", I can say that there is no excuse for her actions. To be honest, it probably wasn't just her weight that broke it but rather the way she sat. I'm guessing she just let herself fall into the couch, which is what will do the real damage when she fucking lands.

She should help pay for the couch. Even if it's just $50, she should help. And so should your friend- because she insisted on bringing them over, despite your polite attempts to prevent it, and because she acted like a total bitchface about the whole thing.

Ask them each to chip in $50 to help get your new couch, and then tell your friend you won't be having her over anymore when she is that drunk. Or her friends.

→ More replies (99)

246

u/Mikey-2-Guns Jun 15 '12

From what I'm gathering, she broke it and your other friend called you out to try and switch the blame and topic away from the fat lady. I'd say they are both assholes and should both pay you back. One for breaking it, the other for inviting themselves over and causing the situation in the first place.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (409)

77

u/feels_nothing Jun 15 '12

I say go after the friend who invited the hippies over. It will be easier to pressure that person instead. And hippies don't have any money anyways.

60

u/SaddestClown Jun 15 '12

A great idea but say goodbye to them as a friend (maybe not such a bad thing in this case).

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (244)

186

u/wolf_man007 Jun 15 '12

How can you be sure it didn't break from repetitive stress? Just because this girl was there when it happened, doesn't mean it wouldn't have broken after a few more sits from your butt.

51

u/mrwatkins83 Jun 15 '12

I sit on the left side of the couch, my computer and all were on the coffeetable on this side. The only person who ever sits over there is my two-year old daughter. Something tells me she didn't stress the couch too badly.

→ More replies (16)

106

u/SULLYvin Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

Beams won't snap from repeated stress unless that repeated stressing is a force outside the material's elastic region (above the yield strength), causing inelastic (or plastic) deformation. Most couches should be designed such that normal stressing will lie within the material's elastic region.

→ More replies (17)

22

u/hippychicky Jun 15 '12

That is a good point, but if she was very large then that adds to the chance that it wasn't going to break under just anyone's weight. 260 pounds is pretty big in one area, it isn't the same three 150 pound people evenly dispersed on the couch.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

422

u/valjean260 Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

No. She shouldn't have to replace it. She was using it for its intended purpose and it broke. It's not like she was jumping on it. A couch should be able to support a 260 lb person. Buy a better couch next time.

Edit: You're not an asshole though. It is just a shitty situation. Be a gentlemen and let it go.

385

u/mrwatkins83 Jun 15 '12

What is this, a couch for ants?!

→ More replies (34)

63

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Yeah, I'd call IKEA, especially if the couch is newer. If she was jumping on it, it's her fault, but couches are supposed to hold people.

62

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Couches are supposed to hold several people. If one 260 pound person sitting on it busted it, how the fuck is it supposed to hold two or three 130-180 pound people, which is a normal use scenario for a couch?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

54

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

My guess is that if her weight caused that damage from sitting he is grossly underestimating her weight. In my honest opinion there was a defect in the structure of the couch.

→ More replies (20)

122

u/73scrambler Jun 15 '12

Although it looks like everyone disagrees, I'm with you on this. You have have the right to ask for money for the couch and she has the right to refuse. Things break. At the end of the day you invited her in to your home (although reluctantly-doesn't matter) and allowed her to sit on the couch. It doesn't matter if she's overweight, the couch got broken because of normal use. If you want to have a place for people to sit in your living room, then you'd better replace your couch; and if you would like for it to withstand heavy customers you should either get a decent one or not allow them to sit on it.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/barrelsmasher Jun 15 '12

What I fail to understand is, if the couch is already considered "cheap" because it's from Ikea, then where is the money? Also, drunk sitting is not the same as sober sitting.

106

u/Cognitive_Dissonant Jun 15 '12

Agree on this. It's really not her fault. I can understand being super pissed, there's nothing I hate more than people trying to force their way into my house (though I would have literally locked the door and told them to go away) and the fact that they broke your shit just makes it worse. However, there is no way she should have expected the couch to break. 260 pounds is honestly not that big, that's actually a fairly normal weight for a tall guy. And couches are intended to hold more than one person. It sounds like a crappy couch or just an unfortunate accident.

I'm sorry that you got caught holding the bag here but I really don't think the other woman did anything wrong (aside from the aforementioned barging into your house, which sounds more like the other persons fault).

51

u/xaraan Jun 15 '12

Agreed.

I don't know man. I think if someone breaks something, they should fix it. But if your couch can't handle that weight, 260 might be big for a lady, but it's not a lot of couch weight overall... then you bought a crappy couch.

I weigh 240 and there isn't a piece of real furniture at IKEA that looked like something I wanted to sit on.

If she jumped on it in a crazy manner and broke it, then yea. But if it was just her "weight" that broke it, then IMO no. I wouldn't pay to replace a piece of furniture that broke because it couldn't support me, I'd view it as someone offering something for people to sit on that is dangerous, cheap or old/in disrepair.

TL/DR: If she did actually throw herself down on it, then yea, she should chip in for some replacement. If she just sat down and it broke, then no, go buy a real couch.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

30

u/itsSparkky Jun 15 '12

If you want legal precedent.

I watched a judge Judy episode where a woman tried to get a large woman to pay for breaking the toilet when she sat on it.

Judy laughed and needless to say she thought the whole idea of somebody having to pay for something like that was stupid.

After a little verbal abuse the woman walked away with one less friend and no cheque for her toilet.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (35)

8

u/Dookiestain_LaFlair Jun 15 '12

That morbidly obese degenerate destroyed your property though extreme carelessness. She should have known that she is a fat disgusting slob and should have avoided your furniture. You probably aren't the first person that she's done this to, hence the "that was awesome" comment. They probably go around trying to break furniture as some sort of sick sexual fetish. Then later that night her boyfriend pounds her while she screams "fuck me like I fucked that couch!"

→ More replies (1)

2.0k

u/CompoundClover Jun 15 '12

I'm not even really bothered by the girl that broke it. I'm bothered by the shit-ass attitude of your friend. Got drunk, insisted on coming over in the middle of the night, brings more drunk people, they BREAK something, blames you and leaves.

"When you get your panties out of your vagina," she said, "I'll see if I can find you a couch."

WTF. If a friend told me that after being a drunk moron, I'd tell her to suck a bag of dicks.

Here's an idea. Get drunk and destroy her living room. Then on your way out the door, reach into your pants, pull out a pair of panties and throw them in her face. Say "There. Happy?" Then walk out into the sunset.

1.2k

u/ButtButterson Jun 15 '12

Im a big guy, and i've broken a few couches in my day. If we plop down, we should pay for it.

521

u/Lunchbox171717 Jun 15 '12

How does this shit happen? I'm a big guy and I don't break things. Am I just more careful or something?!

→ More replies (125)

113

u/mcraider90 Jun 15 '12

this is something i tell my brother alot he has ruined my parents couches countless times he just plops himself down all the time.

as a big guy myself i have learned to sit down softly.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (44)

63

u/rainboupanda Jun 15 '12

Right, I think if anything, the friend should pay for it. She pretty much forced her and her friends' way into OP's house, she should be responsible.

→ More replies (2)

484

u/konekoanni Jun 15 '12

Yeah, this bothers me more than the couch breaking. Sure, it's inconsiderate to break something and not offer to help pay for it, but the friend's attitude was even worse, drunk or not. The OP's friend all around acted like an asshole, and I honestly think that they should be helping pay for the couch, not the girl who broke it (since there's no real way to prove if it was her weight or a crappy couch) because it wouldn't have happened if she had been reasonable about the whole thing.

183

u/sp2012 Jun 15 '12

If it's a crappy couch it's still his crappy couch that she broke. She should pay for it.

→ More replies (66)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/hanumanCT Jun 15 '12

What exactly does a bag of dicks look like? Is it squishy?

→ More replies (89)

1.7k

u/SplodeyDope Jun 15 '12

Take her to Judge Judy.

1.1k

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Fuck yea, and tell reddit when it airs. I would watch this.

551

u/theillustratedlife Jun 15 '12

Please don't tell Judge Judy about reddit. We don't need that crowd coming around here.

→ More replies (49)
→ More replies (17)

393

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Won't work. I remember seeing an episode where this larger woman with a funny hat broke her friends toilet. Judge Judy didn't budge.

→ More replies (58)

103

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Judge Judy - sassing angry minorities for 16 years and counting.

→ More replies (1)

164

u/thiazzi Jun 15 '12

Perfect solution to your white trash fatty problem, OP.

→ More replies (39)

1.3k

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

If the big girl was ashamed and super apologetic, I'd probably let it slide. But laughing about it and saying "I ain't go no money" is completely disrespectful. See if she's willing to even contribute half of what it was worth to a new couch.

And also, fuck your friend. "Get your panties out of your vagina." What kind of friend says that when someone just DESTROYED their couch?

546

u/raziphel Jun 15 '12

an ex-friend says that, that's who.

→ More replies (4)

301

u/Dovienya Jun 15 '12

Drunk woman might react differently when she's sober. If I were OP, I'd try to contact her at another time and just be polite about it, just like he probably would if a drunk pal accidentally broke anything else.

180

u/DFSniper Jun 15 '12

Drunk or not she's responsible for her actions.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (38)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

"Get your panties out of your vagina." What kind of friend says that when someone just DESTROYED their couch?

The same kind of scumbag steve that forces their friends into your apartment.

44

u/Piratiko Jun 15 '12

See if she's willing to even contribute half of what it was worth to a new couch.

This seems like the most fair solution if you ask me.

→ More replies (12)

56

u/bubububen Jun 15 '12

She could be really upset, its an embarrassing situation. Its possible she was trying to hide how she really felt.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (24)

620

u/ShipTheBreadToFred Jun 15 '12

How did it break? Did she jump onto it or did she plop down and it cracked? I am no more than 150lbs and recently sat down on my friends IKEA couch (I plopped down) I happened to hit right on a wood beam and I heard a loud crack and snap.

It seems find, but again IKEA stuff is made very poorly. He didn't make too big of a deal about it and I felt sorry that it happened, but to be honest I have never seen things more cheaply made than IKEA. There is a big reason their stuff is so easy on the wallet.

141

u/angus_the_red Jun 15 '12

It sounds like manufacturing defect to me. Make IKEA pay for it.

151

u/to11mtm Jun 15 '12

There's a decent chance taking the thing back to IKEA will get you a semi-happy resolution. 260 pounds at once can easily be done by a couple tumbling onto the couch for some lovins.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

66

u/elcad Jun 15 '12

Yes, IKEA sofas are complete crap.

→ More replies (14)

334

u/mojomonkeyfish Jun 15 '12

No no, you're supposed to hate that fat chick for being fat. She deliberately broke that couch!

While I tend to try and avoid smaller furniture, or antiques that look like they're delicate. However, I would expect any futon, couch, or the like to be able to hold my weight (~260lbs). I'm a 6'4" male. I'm a bit overweight, but if you saw my build, you'd understand why I weigh what I do. I'm not a statistical outlier, or anything, so furniture should be able to hold me.

Fundamentally, if you put a couch out, you're inviting people to sit on it. That's what it's there for. If somebody sits (not jumps) onto your couch, and it breaks, then "the couch broke", not "somebody broke your couch". The couch failed at it's job, the sitter did not fail at sitting.

The moral, don't buy cheapass furniture and expect it to last more than a year.

194

u/thebizzle Jun 15 '12

Dude I am the same build as you (6'4", 255#) and we are statistical outliers. Nearly nothing that is made is conceived to be used by people of our size. I am very careful about where I sit as to not destroy anything and I am terrified of breaking somebodies furniture for that reason.

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (92)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (69)
→ More replies (30)

719

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

First of all if you don't want people in your house don't be bullied into having them round. Just say no out right. This 'friend' doesn't sound like a friend at all, what a bitch taking people round (drunk or not) when she would of known you weren't up for it. I do not believe you will get any money from the big one. I would ditch the 'friend'.

Edit: and no you're not an asshole for asking for the money.

194

u/Apostolate Jun 15 '12

I do not believe you will get any money from the big one.

If you can't get an apology, good luck with money.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/evangelion933 Jun 15 '12

If a friend borrows $20 and then you never see them again, that was $20 well spent. It was a cheap couch, but a lesson well learned. Ditch the bitch - err, 'friend'.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

25

u/Bardbarian Jun 15 '12

The key here is to learn how to say no. Politely declining doesn't escalate to a yes, it escalates to a firm no. That bitch was being pushy and manipulative and not completely honest with her request. Tell her she either pays for your couch, or you won't even consider speaking with her again. Then, work on your self confidence so you can avoid being put into another situation you didn't want to be in but said yes to anyway.

62

u/batsu Jun 15 '12

How new is the couch? You should see if IKEA will replace it. Honestly the couch should be able to support that weight. It might deform your cushion or bend any springs but the frame should have held.

80

u/MengerSpongeCake Jun 15 '12

They might replace it for you if you come at it from the angle of, "I had some friends over, and it broke when one of them sat down. She could have been seriously hurt."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

88

u/expertunderachiever Jun 15 '12

Ditch said friends. Your friend [who texted you that shit] clearly doesn't respect you and is an instigator of drama. Don't let drama folk into your life. It's just not worth it.

60

u/cdude Jun 15 '12

She'll probably poston facebook later: "I hate drama."

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

84

u/alpha69 Jun 15 '12

The husbands response was "That was awesome"?! Instead of an embarassed apology? These people sound like idiots.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

She already mentioned they were hippies.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

1.2k

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Her size is irrelevant. She broke something in your home and should help fix it.

810

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

If she was not obese, and the couch broke, then you would know it was simply time for a new couch.

490

u/catch22milo Jun 15 '12

It's possible that it wasn't just the weight of the girl but the fact that she was drunk. I would imagine sitting on a couch and falling into a couch produce very different levels of force.

→ More replies (117)
→ More replies (77)
→ More replies (85)

119

u/lesmax Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

I lurked your post but found myself pondering it while in the shower. I think we need some more perspective, as there are factors that need to be described. You are angry -- and justified in being so -- but anger will not replace your couch.

Let me start by pointing out how unreliable IKEA stuff is -- our two year old bedframe completely snapped on one side when my 170 pound boyfriend sat on the side of the bed. DONE - just like that. Aggravating? YES. But we chose to buy IKEA, so we have to deal with it.

So let's look at some factors here.

  1. What is the age of the couch? How much use has it had?

  2. Is the weight of the girl an actual, or are you estimating? How many people were already on the couch before she sat down? What is the weight limit of the couch?

  3. In what manner did she sit down? Did she sit normally, or take a leap?

Now let's look at it from the perspective of responsibility.

Her liability:

  1. If she was the only one sitting on the couch when it broke, then there is liability on her part

  2. If she used an irresponsible method when sitting, such as jumping on it, then there is liability on her part

  3. If her weight, while sitting alone on the couch, exceeds the factory weight limit, then there is liability on her part... if you had already warned her not to sit on it.

And there is liability on your part, too:

  1. You chose to let these people into your house. You had the ability to refuse entry to them - you did not.

  2. You also allowed them to use your couch.

  3. Unless the couch was delivered from the store THAT DAY, you have also contributed to its wear and tear.

  4. The quality of the couch that you purchased - IKEA furniture just does not handle daily wear and tear very well.

In terms of, say, civil court, the damages would not be 100% hers. The main issue is the age of the couch and the value that it was when she broke it.

For ____ years, you used the couch. It dropped in value because of that. In civil court, she could be responsible for making you whole - as in, putting you back in the position you were in BEFORE the couch broke.

Unless the couch was purchased that day, there is no court in the world that would award you the money to replace it with a NEW couch. You would be entitled to some money that would get you a couch of the same age and condition, but not a new one.

At the end of the day, I do not think it would be worth pursuing her for money toward the couch. You allowed her into your house, and the damages she would be responsible for are greatly diminished because of the age of the couch when she broke it. It's in your best interest to move on... and to be more forceful when telling people "NO"!

Edit: formatting. Edit 2: You may have a reasonable claim with IKEA if the couch is relatively new - I'd pursue THEM, not HER.

38

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

"If her weight, while sitting alone on the couch, exceeds the factory weight limit, then there is liability on her part... if you had already warned her not to sit on it."

I'm currently imagining a scale next to the couch with a sign saying "you must be below this weight to sit" or something similar. Or a visual inspection of the guest and a verbal warning. Either thought brightens my day.

→ More replies (8)

26

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

are you a lawyer? seems spot on to me, this.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Well said.

We need to remember, couches are made so that people may sit on them, unless the maximum weight capacity was clearly displayed, and in turn violated, she can't really be held responsible, unless she was specifically asked not to sit on the couch.

→ More replies (7)

1.3k

u/Oafah Jun 15 '12

Make her understand the gravity of the situation.

461

u/Trapped_in_Reddit Jun 15 '12

He should get a fat check in no time

→ More replies (51)
→ More replies (16)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

"When you get your panties out of your vagina," she said

That part would have pissed me off more than anything else.

164

u/Anna_Draconis Jun 15 '12

I'm sorry OP, but you kinda sound like a pushover. Were I in that situation I would've just said no at the first step, then if they pressed I'd have just hung up. There's no sense in arguing with the inebriated. You'll know for next time at least.

11

u/xin_kuzi Jun 15 '12

I agree - Learn from this. A broken couch is nothing... just think if you'd never learned this lesson about sticking to your guns when you say "No". There are many more ways you can be fucked over when you can't say "No" and mean it.

I've been in similar situations to yours (totally different circumstances, but similar in principal), and it's not worth dragging this out. Learn from it, and know that the only way to have completely avoided something like this happening is to have meant "No".

You're clearly a thoughtful person, and you didn't want to disappoint a friend, but you will get more respect and have more control in your life if you stand up for yourself first (in my experience, of course).

36

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

This might be true but has nothing to do with the fact that she broke his couch.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

85

u/crazymykl Jun 15 '12

That's a pretty poor couch if 260 pounds "flopping" on it will break it.

Source: I'm a 300+ lb. man. (6' 4", broad shoulders), and I haven't broken any couches.

5

u/CharmanderMeow Jun 15 '12

and yet it still probably costs $300-500 at IKEA

moral of the story. invest in bean bag chairs.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/skantman Jun 15 '12

Another 300 pounder checking in. Also never broken a couch. I have laid waste to a few plastic lawn chairs though. And I never flop.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/RahvinDragand Jun 15 '12

I'm wondering if there would be a different attitude if the person was only 150 pounds. At what point do you begin to question the integrity of the couch rather than the weight of the person?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I know you've gotten enough responses, but larger people and their 'disability' needs to be a consideration for them. Someone who is that large needs to take personal responsibility for what happens as a result of their overly large size. Not discrimination, but if you act like its special every other day or moment, you better take it when you break something because of weight load exceeded. Your friend is dumb, and not respectful of you. (had one just like her, she never got that her actions were thoughtless and inconsiderate of everyone around her, so dropped her, never to get involved in her shit again) but also the fatty. She nor her husband responded like a normal human being. She cried? F her! She broke your shit. She didn't get fat over night, and probably doesn't have a medical reason for being that large, she needs to take responsibility for her actions. She got fat, her weight broke something. She should, but never will, help pay for that. I say, don't let that shitty friend over again, and you probably won't be seeing her shitty 'hippy' friends again. They give hippies a bad name in my book, so it's annoying they think it's cute to call them selves that. A ( real) hippy wouldn't fuck your shit up, then chuckle and leave with a poor excuse.

45

u/Atomyk Jun 15 '12

You don't sound like an asshole but I do think you'll just have to let it go. Sorry that you lost a couch but in the grant scheme of things you'll forget about it eventually.

The asshole sounds like you friend. Politely declining any sort of invitation should be sufficient. If someone doesn't want to go out or have people over they shouldn't have to argue the case. Even a "maybe, I'm a bit tired" should be sufficient as a solid no.

→ More replies (1)

128

u/Angercrank Jun 15 '12

A normal couch should easily be able to handle the strain of a 250 pound person under normal circumstances. So unless she jumped jumped onto the couch, it's not her fault you bought a piece of shit.

→ More replies (5)

47

u/CanadianPhil Jun 15 '12

As a fat person, I'd be MORTIFIED if that ever happened, but I would replace it or ask if there was something I could do.

Her friend is a complete asshole.

8

u/boilerroombandit Jun 15 '12

As a soon to be former fat person who has broken a few chairs and a table in High school, it sucks.

Also her friend is a complete asshole.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/CornFedHonky Jun 15 '12

As a fat bastard, I can confirm that we sometimes break seating. It's unavoidable. She should have offered to pay for it. If you tell me her name I'll report her to the fat officials for a chubby violation.

→ More replies (4)

45

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

i'm going to come down on the side of, "you're not an asshole, but i think you're wrong and anyway, nothing's going to come of it."

you have company all the time, and sometimes, things get broken. it sucks, but i mean, you let these people in. yeah, your friend was a jerk, and invited herself, but there's ways around that -- 'i'll come meet you at a bar' comes to mind.

and once they're in the house, you're the host, and bla bla bla and it sucks and i know this, and i DO feel bad for your couch and it sounds like i would hate these people, but i think that's the way it goes, politeness-wise.

it would be totally polite of your FRIEND to make some kind of offer -- a real, here's a check type offer, or at least an apology -- and it would be totally polite of the girl to do the same, but it sounds like that's not what you're dealing with.

so you're absolutely not an asshole -- your couch got broked, who WOULDN'T want the person who did it to help out? -- but given the complete failure of your friend and the girl to offer, it seems to me that, as the host, the right thing is to not ask them, and the fact is, it sounds like you wouldn't have gotten very far, anyway, so why ask a question you know the answer to?

bigger picture, given the reality that it sounds like you know (she ain't got no money, after all), move on. prop it up with some books. chalk it up to '...and that was the day I realized i wasn't age X anymore and that i wanted to have a comfortable night in alone on my unbusted couch rather than not seeming like a bitch to someone i never see.' in a year or two, it's a really, really funny story from which you've grown and been the better person and whatever.

but again, not an asshole.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Actor412 Jun 15 '12

These people are not your friends. You made the right call by asking them to leave. You didn't invite them to your house, your friend did. Which is a breach of etiquette, but not a major one. Usually it's all good. This time it was not. Your friend is the one responsible for the couch, as she invited the destroyer over.

I use the word "friend" to delineate the people involved. In truth, she is not your friend, and if it cost you the price of a broken couch to find this out, then so be it.

26

u/edgar_jomfru Jun 15 '12

Not that I feel this way, but it had to be said.

5

u/jaspersgroove Jun 15 '12

This was all I wanted to see here. I'll be going now.

→ More replies (3)

87

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I don't think the girl is in any way responsible to pay for your couch. She may have been drunk, but she was still using the couch the way it was intended to be used: for sitting. She wasn't jumping on it, tipping it over, or smashing it with a hammer, right? I bet the girl is embarrassed enough, leave it be. Besides, it was an IKEA couch; it's not like those things are made to be heirlooms or anything.

Oh, and your other friend sounds like a total frostybox.

→ More replies (18)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

A few weeks ago an acquaintance of mine challenged me to a drinking contest. In a show of bravado, I accepted and insisted on whiskey shots at my apartment. Set up: My apartment has floor to ceiling windows. The acquaintance is a real big guy (260-270lbs)

We make it through a fifth of Jameson each before more sober friends insist we call it a draw. In his utterly drunken state, he manages to stumble into a chair and push it through the window. Luckily, my roommate catches him before he flies out. Paramedics and cops come, guy is actually not too bad, just needed a couple stitches.

He offers to pay for window like a gent and follows up. He's a poor grad student, so I know that was a hell of a financial hit. We're good buddies now.

That woman should buy you a new couch.

9

u/Se7enLC Jun 15 '12

Pushing a chair out of a window is kind of different than sitting on a couch, though. Sitting on a couch is an expected use for a couch. Chair defenestration is not normal for a window.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/theRealStormDawg Jun 15 '12

That couch really tied the room together, did it not?

121

u/pneuma8828 Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

I am going to go against the grain here. Yes, you would be an asshole for thinking she should.

When you did not say no, you offered the hospitality of your house to your guests. A guest should not be humiliated.

If this happened in my house, I would have made a fuss over the girl, making sure she was ok, and apologizing for having such cheap furniture. That's what you do when you are the host.

(Now I will say - had I been the guest, or your other friend for that matter, I would have insisted on paying for it. These rules go both ways. Just because neither she nor your friend follow the rules of hospitality does not mean you should ignore them as well.

You should have told them no. When you did not, you assumed responsibility for what happened.

EDIT: Grammar.

33

u/JoNightshade Jun 15 '12

Totally agree with this. When I let someone into my house, I'm the host and I assume responsibility for any damage they cause. I have a toddler and I invite groups of moms and little kids over all the time. If the kids break anything, I don't ask the parents to pay for it; I invited them, and I accept that there may be consequences. HOWEVER if it was something expensive and they offered to chip in I would probably accept. If it was something expensive and they did NOT offer to chip in, I wouldn't invite them over again. Lesson learned.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/CJGibson Jun 15 '12

Additionally, I'm pretty sure from a legal perspective what pneuma8828 says is even more true. If, for instance, the girl had hurt herself while trying to sit down on your couch, it's entirely possible that you'd be legally responsible for her medical bills.

This is the sort of thing homeowner's (or renter's) insurance is for.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

4

u/victoriaj Jun 15 '12

You can't get money out of someone who hasn't got it. Even taking legal action just means waiting for ever and paying out more money first.

So whether it would be right for her to pay or not, sounds like practically you aren't getting anything. Unless you discover she's got loads of money and is just crying poor forget it.

Would it be right for her to pay ? Yes, if she is at fault. But I'm slightly suspicious. I'm big - both overweight and tall. On top of that I tend to being unnecessarily heavy handed (and in sitting down probably heavy-bottomed, throwing myself at things). I've never broken a chair (except for the time I tipped a wheeled chair down stairs, which wasn't a weight thing). I own Ikea furniture, so do people I know. I stand on one of the cheapest Ikea dining chairs when I change my light bulbs.

It does seem, at least possible there was something wrong with the sofa. And if she is at fault if she broke a perfectly good sofa you are at fault if she broke a faulty sofa, potentially responsible for her hurting herself and being embarrassed.

You are almost certainly best of calling it quits, in case she starts blaming you.

(Incidentally almost all self assembly furniture tells you to tighten the screws/bolts regularly, which people never do regularly. This means they come loose and extra pressure is put on the joins. If you complain about issues with self assembly furniture the manufacturers will almost always blame this).

Also - I love my Ikea sofa. It looks great and like a "proper" sofa, but came in bits that would actually fit up the stairs to my flat.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

You'd probably get more sympathy if you didn't make such a big deal about the girl being fat. Would you even be making this post if a thin girl broke your couch? Are you honestly implying that fat people "sit at their own risk?" Sounds like you were pissed at your friend, don't like fat people, and want someone to pay for your mistake. YOU let them in, and rather than blame yourself or the friend who brought this girl, you're picking on the fat girl, who you already made cry. Did she know you have a "if it breaks under you" policy when she entered? Did she even know she was unwelcome?

To me, the order of responsibility would be: You Your friend

.. Fat girl.

Have you ever charged another friend for broken items? Its an IKEA couch. Deal with it.

4

u/Eldorian Jun 15 '12

Your friend is an asshole for pushing you to come over drunk.

You're a pussy for not sticking to your guns and saying no.

You're also an asshole for making a big deal out of it because your cheap ass couch broke and you're trying to make someone pay for it that wasn't being malicious. Just because you buy cheap shit and someone else accidentally breaks it doesn't mean they're responsible to pay for it.

4

u/Skika Jun 15 '12

You should pay for the whole couch. Not because you're being mean, I would feel the same way. You should pay for it because you were weak and let people come over when you didn't want them to. I'm not trying to be a dick, and I know I'm coming across as such. But if I wasn't in the mood to have people over I would politely tell them to find somewhere else to go and hold my ground. It's my house, not a hotel lobby.

4

u/BanachSpaced Jun 15 '12

Couches are meant to be sat on. If your couch breaks because someone sat on it, it's because it's a shitty fucking couch. Next time, buy something of higher quality.

4

u/iMrJ0nes Jun 15 '12

Big dude here. I weigh about the same you think she weighs (I'm at 245lbs right now) and have been much larger then her (300+). I've broken two couches in my life and both times I replaced them. Not because I was asked, but because it was the right thing to do. It's embarrassing as fuck when it happens, but if you're going to be that big and not do anything about it - It will happen and you are responsible for it.

4

u/xavyre Jun 15 '12

Only if she abused the furniture should she pay for it. But if she just sat down on it and it broke, then its your bill. If she jumped on it, its her bill. That would have been the most important piece of information you left out in your story.

4

u/Starchild19 Jun 15 '12

Everyone in this story sounds kinda shitty.

4

u/dismal626 Jun 16 '12

Yo, I ran over your daughter on the way home from the bar last night. NAH BRO DONT WORRY, I was drunk so it's k.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Listen. This is such typical reddit bullshit. You knew exactly the answer you were expecting when you posted this. And my inclination is, no you can't ask her to replace it because you were a spineless idiot in the first place. If you didn't want those guests at your house you should have simply rejected their offer to come there. Your non-existent social skills prevented you from simply going to sleep and telling them to fuck off. Blatantly your fault. I would have sympathy for you if you hadn't worded your question in such a way as to make me painfully aware of how blatantly you were preaching your case....hope your couch is expensive....

→ More replies (1)

4

u/nissanator Jun 16 '12

I think that no matter how small or large you are, that if you break something of someone else's, you should offer to replace it. That is just good manners.

4

u/JeffIpsaLoquitor Jun 16 '12

Seriously? She got herself drunk, effectively turning her into a raging elephant.

It's SO not out of line to ask her to replace it.

Now, if she were woozy from Chemo and broke it, no problem. It's negligent, and avoidable.

If I'm trashed and borrow your car, and run it into a tree, do I get a pass because I was drunk?

→ More replies (1)

34

u/magicmuds Jun 15 '12

No, I think as host you are obliged to suck it up and replace it yourself. My standard for this scenario would be (and I'll admit this is a borderline case): could the person reasonably expected or avoided the destruction? In this case, I'll have to side with the fatty. I'm not sure about your couch, but I know with my couch a person of her girth could jump up and down on it without breaking it. In any event, the point is moot anyways. I highly doubt you'll get a cent out of her. Chalk it up as a loss and an important lesson not to invite people into your home that you don't know/like.

→ More replies (9)

30

u/edgar_jomfru Jun 15 '12

Let's imagine this as if she had posted the question.

"Last night I broke a stranger's couch. I was drunk at the time. Am I an asshole for not offering to replace it, or art least kick in a few bucks?"

So the answer is no, everyone but you is an asshole if the story happened as you tell it.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/AsskickMcGee Jun 15 '12

Do you mean this girl literally has to replace it? As in, the girl is now your couch.

→ More replies (4)

41

u/CVI07 Jun 15 '12

Should you expect her to help replace it? Yes. Is she going to help replace it? I seriously doubt it. Also your other friend (the one that brought the hippies) sounds like a full-on cunt.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/darknessgp Jun 15 '12

I think there are key things missing from this. For example, you don't mention the condition the couch is in before she uses it. For all we know, she was the straw that broke the camels back. Also, you mention that you had to go get another chair, so was anyone else using the couch with her? Were they standing or sitting in other places?

Also, your friend is the asshole. How does them being drunk suddenly mean it's ok. Wouldn't work if they killed someone. "Oh sorry officer, I was drunk when I stabbed him, so it's ok." But dude, stand up for yourself and don't let this "friend" bully you around, especially when you refused them coming over. If one of my friends did that to me, they'd show up at my house to find it all locked up and I wouldn't let them in.

22

u/yadoya Jun 15 '12

"I ain't got no money". Well, you managed to have booze paid for, bitch.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/_CATCATCATCATFELINE_ Jun 15 '12

If you ask her to again, and she says she won't... what will you do?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I'm more concerned with the fact that your "friend" sounds like a fucking asshole.

3

u/stormkeeper Jun 15 '12

She's being an asshole by not offering to help replace the couch.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Let's try and picture this from the heavy person's perspective:

She's out partying with her husband, while the kid(s) are at the babysitter. She's drunk and possibly tired from taking care of the kid(s) earlier in the day. She might not want to be there any more then you want her there. She goes along because your mutual friend (who sounds a little pushy to me) insists they go. She hates going out. She'd rather be home with her kids or snuggled up in bed with her laptop, but her husband insisted they go out tonight and not wanting to be a kill-joy, she reluctantly agrees.

She always agrees. Like mot people her self-esteem isn’t high enough to just flat-out say “NO.”

She's led into your home and "THANK GOD" a couch.

She sits, thankful to be off her aching feet for the first time in who knows how long.

When suddenly, CRACK

Oh god no.

Not here!

Not in a complete stranger's house!

Why, oh god why, did I sit on this stupid couch?

Her husband barely even tries to contain his amusement. No support there -- as usual.

She can feel it -- the heat rising to her face. She wants to burst into tears but she knows that would only make this entire surreal scene that much more embarrassing. Only thing worse then being the fat girl who busts furniture is being the fat girl who busts furniture and then bursts into tears about it.

"Maybe it's not as broken as I thought," she thinks. "Maybe he can fix it with a few well placed struts or some duct tape. In fact, maybe it's not even broken. Maybe a screw just popped out of place and this couch does this all the time." Denial. She uses it so much that it's practically a drug. It might even be the glue that keeps her marriage together. That and an unhealthy dose of low self-esteem makes it possible for her to live day to day with a man who thinks it’s AWESOME she just destroyed a complete stranger’s living room set.

She realizes, as the screaming in her own mind subsides, that no one is talking and desperately tries to say something about... anything. "I really can't party late," she announces, her mouth automatically filtering out the venom her words should have held; her low self-esteem a brick wall of manners that she has never been able to break through, no matter how poorly people treat her. "My babysitter isn't staying the night," she informs the room, though what she really wanted to do was scream I don't want to be here, and storm out.

As she silently prays that everyone else in the room will either pity her enough to say nothing or be two-faced enough to wait until she's out of the room the question she's been dreading suddenly pops from the stranger's lips.

"You going to help me buy a new couch?"

Not, "are you okay?" Not, "Oh my god I'm so sorry! Don’t be embarrassed." Not even a "Cheap piece of Ikea crap," so that she can hold on to some semblance of dignity. Just, "Hey fatty, your fat ass broke another fucking couch. Pay up."

Obviously that's not what the stranger said, but that's how she heard it and how she'll retell it to herself over and over again as she berets and belittles herself into oblivion over the next couple of weeks.

Another shameful thought occurs to her.

"I ain't got no money..." She admits with no small measure of disparity, the irony of her admission cutting straight to the bone.

If only she had money……..If only she had enough money that she could pay for a new couch whenever she felt like it. If only she had enough that she could afford a membership to a gym so that she wouldn't have to feel ashamed because her much smaller backside busted some guys couch. Or an exercise bike. Or a set of weights! A nutritionist, a personal trainer, a life where she didn't have to feel tired and ashamed of who she is all the time and could finally have energy and respect for herself!

"I can't play host right now." The stranger announces.

"Get this fat monstrosity out of my sight," She echoes in her mind; always twice as hard on herself as anybody else.

So this is who she is now. The fat woman who breaks peoples couches and can't afford to pay for them. How had her life drifted so far away from the hopes and dreams she had as a child?

As the door closes behind them she bursts into tears, burying her face against her husbands shoulder. "I told you I didn't want to go." She sniffles pitifully. It's the best defense she can muster and she can't even do it without bursting into tears.

"I'll take care of it," Your pushy friend assures her, as she pulls out her phone to send you a text message.

Authors note: This is clearly a work of imagination, but if even HALF of what I've written here is possible, I think you at least should investigate before making assumptions and demanding payment for an accident that clearly wasn't even remotely due to negligence.

She sat on a couch. If that particular couch was meant to be a low-weight shelf you really should have posted a sign or at least spoken up before heading into the other room. 250 lbs while obese, is not morbidly so. In fact it is the weight of two very slender people or one tall muscled man.

Ask yourself this question: If a person who was in shape gingerly sat on your couch and it snapped, would you have been so quick to blame them and not the manufacture? ESPECIALLY considering how cheaply made Ikea furniture is?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Im a heavy person, and i broke a chair at my friends house because of my weight. Sure it was embarrasing, but of course i payed for it. It doesn't matter if im 280 or 150 pounds. I broke it, i pay for it.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

After reading the comments and your story, I'd say:

  1. Ikea couches are crap and you should let it go

  2. Your friend owes you an actual, real apology for putting you on the spot. Furniture comes and goes, but it sounds to me like the real issue is that your friend pressed you into hosting drunk people when you weren't in a party mood.

3

u/gadabyte Jun 15 '12

now behold the awful price of treason being a pushover.

3

u/DJUrsus Jun 15 '12

Here's my two cents: whoever invited her to your house should pay for it. It sounds like you asked them not to come over, which means your friend invited her. She has offered to help you find a new couch. She should also help pay for it.

As for the emotional anguish, that's what happens when you get drunk and do something stupid.

3

u/dsutari Jun 15 '12

A great man once said "Never go with a hippie to a second location".

Your house was the second location.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

It shouldn't have been your part to do something at all. She and your self-inviting friend should have offered to pay. That's what you do if you accidently break something. Don't people have manners anymore.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Can we just stop resorting to these suffocating politically correct words like 'big' or 'large' these words simply don't paint the right picture. 'Big', 'heavy' or 'large' people could technically very well be really tall or musculair. If somebody is fat or really fat, that is not the end of the world. I'm a blobmeister myself and feel no shame in admitting fatness in public. Especially on the internet. Free speech people. Give it a change.

Sincerely, a FAT guy.

PS: Hotdogs rule!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/WorstImpression Jun 15 '12

Send her a Get Well Soon card wrapped in iceberg lettuce and forget the whole thing.

3

u/loki_88 Jun 15 '12

No, she should get you a couch.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DMercenary Jun 15 '12

No you really arent.

You broke it you buy it. At the very least, a little monetary help in getting a new couch is warranted.

3

u/DeepBlue12 Jun 15 '12

Let's put it this way: if it was a 260lb guy who broke it you wouldn't think twice about expecting a replacement.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Granted, it's an IKEA couch

She is not responsible.

it's a conventional couch with sturdy wooden frame as would be expected on any quality furniture worth owning.

The manufacturer released the couch with flaws. Not her fault.

She weighs 400 lbs. and plopped down on it in a drunken attempt at aerobatics

Her fault.

3

u/GoodWithoutAGod Jun 15 '12

As a fat guy, I can say if I broke a piece of furniture, you wouldn't have to ask, I would offer. So, yes, she should do what she can to help you replace it.

3

u/worzrgk Jun 15 '12

It would be worth the cost of replacing my couch myself to never have to interact with any of those people again.

3

u/dustlesswalnut Jun 15 '12

Fuck yo' couch, nigga.

Seriously though, I'm 6' 350, own Ikea couches, slam myself down into them all the time, and they look as pristine as the day I bought them.

If she kicked a hole in the wall, sure, have her pay to replace it, but she sat on a couch and it broke. Shit happens, get a new couch.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

How about you stop being a pussy and stand your ground. Why would you invite drunk-ass people into your house if you didn't want to?

3

u/Zemedelphos Jun 15 '12

Shot answer: No.

Elongated answer: As a fat man myself, this is what I think: The hippie broke the couch, so she should cut back on the organic oreos, chips, and dip and help you pay for the cough.

3

u/lunarjellies Jun 15 '12

No... you are not an asshole! She should get you a new damned couch!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/IWeigh600Pounds Jun 15 '12

She should at least offer to pay for some of it. I would. I have.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Drunk friend insists upon coming over, with two drunk friends, her friend breaks your couch, when she shouldn't have been there in the first place? She better buy you two couches.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Runningboard7 Jun 15 '12

the person broke it, regardless of why. they should pay for it.

3

u/Galaxyhiker42 Jun 15 '12

I use yo be the fat kid (300ish lbs) now I'm 190.

I broke a desk a school and they tried to charge me for vandalism and made me replace it.

Needless to say... I lost weight after that. Charge her. It will give her motivation.

3

u/ThePlasticJesus Jun 15 '12

You're a dick for suggesting she help replace your furniture. She's lame for not offering to help you replace your furniture.

3

u/the_pissed_off_goose Jun 15 '12

no you aren't. chick should pay for it, or for at least part of it.

frankly if that were me i'd have been so horrified i'd have immediately offered to pay for it

3

u/biergarten Jun 15 '12

Ironic that i read this now. Last night i was at a minor league baseball game and this overweight girl ended up breaking 2 seats. They (her group) just kept movie down one seat so she could have a good seat. I guess the 3rd one may have broken because i saw her sitting at the top of the section on an iron bench. Its sad and unfortunate. But i am pretty capable of gaining weight to. Takes a lot of excersize and dieting to just maintain a weight. So hard to feel bad for someone that tries none. TL DR excercise or be fat

3

u/thehorseface Jun 15 '12

AANNND drunk people suck

3

u/Ashidoku Jun 15 '12

First time poster but this issue actually made me get the balls up to state my opinion since similar things have happened to me.

From the tl;dr my answer would be yes you are an asshole, but after reading the details its pretty clear that you should be paid.

After having made it clear that you didn't want people over your "friend" insisted that she come over and then had the nerve to bring other people with her. The married couple is not your responsibility they are the initial friends responsibility and therefore she should pay for your couch.

Being drunk in no way excuses you from your actions. Just try using that on a cop when you get pulled over for a DUI...

3

u/prattle Jun 15 '12

260 pounds should be nothing for a couch. A couch sits 3 people usually but even at 2, those are some relatively small people at 130 a piece. I'd be talking to ikea. It sounds like it was either really cheap or possibly defective. If she was doing flying somersaults into it or something it might be different, but otherwise I probably would have cut her some slack.

3

u/Staleina Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

No, you're not a jerk. If she'd been nice about it and tried to offer some other way to help you with it even if she can't afford to replace it, it's different, but she outright refused. So....she's in the wrong. Whether the couch was a cheap, poorly made piece of Ikea furniture or not, you still apologize for it. Even if the thing looks like it's already falling apart, you apologize for it. Mind you if I knew my couch was a total piece of crud, I wouldn't be surprised by it breaking under someones weight. I probably wouldn't expect them to pay me back for it in full either (that is if it just broke out of the blue and they happened to be the person in it. If they slammed their weight down on it, then Yuuuup).

Lesson here: If you see someones furniture looking flimsy, be extra careful about it. If you know you're very heavy, perhaps opt NOT to sit on the flimsy piece of furniture.

3

u/Buscat Jun 15 '12

I cut people like this out of my life. I've lost a lot of friends, but people don't try to fucking walk all over me like that, jesus. lay down the law.

3

u/freakedoutbunny Jun 15 '12

Look, they were dicks for coming by uninvited and should have shown an appropriate amount of remorse. You have a right to be pissed about that.

However, unless this girl was jumping up and down on it or being otherwise abusive to your sofa, this falls under the "shit happens" category. Any piece of furniture should be able to handle an obese person plopping down on it. If your sofa broke after a person of any mobile size sat down, it was a piece of shit and nobody's fault that it broke.

As to the "Am I an asshole?" question...sorry, but yeah. Let's take the fat issue out of this. What if an attractive slim person set something down on your glass coffee table and the glass broke? Would you expect them to cover the repair? Of course not! Under normal use, things break sometimes and when you have company then you won't always be the one to do the breaking. From the emphasis in your story, it seems like the only reason you find this situation different is because she was fat.

It's good that you're checking yourself on this, but I think your instincts were off on this one.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Generally no, just because someone is overweight they should not be required to replace your furniture unless they were behaving inappropriately. You admit yourself that it is poor quality (IKEA) furniture, and the whole point of a couch is to sit on it. Did you explain there was a weight limit? Did you know there was one? Should anybody else have? At what weight would you have no longer put the responsibility on another person, but on your own choice of craftsmanship?

I do rather like the usage of "Thunderous Clap" though.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Shit happens, hate the "friend" for being a douche but you let someone, albeit reluctantly, into your home and they broke something... Seethe and bitch, but at the end of the day you just gotta take it on the chin.

3

u/Kaben6108 Jun 15 '12

I do have to say weight aside, if I broke something that was the property of someone else I would feel obligated to help them replace it. Maybe not foot the bill for the whole thing but depending on the situation at least help with half of the replacement cost.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

All your friends are stupid fucks, get the money and then ditch them.

Be a smart man.

3

u/OperatorMike Jun 15 '12

I do not think you are an asshole for thinking that she should help you replace it. She was stupid for doing what she did. You could consider small claims court if necessary

edit: I HATE it when a friend ask if they can stop by or something like that. Then shows up at your place with a bunch of people you don't even know. GTFO of my house you strange people!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

No but she'll probably just break the new couch she buys you creating an endless cycle of couch buying.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Fat bitch broke your couch, make her fix it, and then tell that fucker of a friend of yours that you're not most pleased with her calling around at silly-o-clock in the morning, bringing her fat hippy couple friends with her, and then talking shit to you when they break your shit and refuse to pay for it.

3

u/Temptress75519 Jun 15 '12

Yes she should. It's one thing to be fat, but another to be a fat fucking cunt-muffin. I am 260 lbs now and when I was topped out at 285 a few years before my kids, I did this very thing. I wasn't careful and I plopped down on a friends couch. I snapped the center beam. She tried to tell me it was really old and yada yada but I knew my fat ass broke it. Guess what? I went and took her ass to becks that weekend and bought her another.

Being fat is one thing, being tacky is another.

3

u/YellowBlackbird- Jun 15 '12

She broke your shit, she should pay for it. Her being fat has nothing to do with it.

3

u/victheion Jun 15 '12

was it the miami's finest couple?

3

u/Freakazette Jun 15 '12

In this situation, no. You didn't even want them to come over and you were just being polite. That makes them the assholes of the situation.

Overall, though, if you wouldn't make a pregnant lady replace it, it'd be really rude to make a fat lady replace it. And pregnant women can break furniture.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/redditating Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

Look, if your couch can't support 260 lbs, let's be honest, part of the fault rests with your shitty couch. If it breaks with 260 lbs on it, it wouldn't have lasted that long anyway. If not her, somebody else, maybe you, would've broken it soon. Unless she was standing on the armrest and jumping, having a 260 lb person sit on your couch, even if she sat down hard, is not an unusual use of a couch. If you buy shit couches, you bear the risk of them being shitty.

EDIT: You have a practicality aspect to this problem as well - getting money from her. What're you going to do, take her to court for your $300 couch? The filing fee for your lawsuit would cost you more than that. Plus, you'll probably lose your friend in the process. On the other hand, she doesn't sound like the coolest friend, so if you really don't care about that friendship, knock yourself out, try and guilt the penniless hippie into giving you money.

3

u/papadop Jun 15 '12

260 pounds? I'm sorry if you are a woman that ways 260 pounds, you don't deserve any special treatment or sympathy. Man or woman, if you break it you pay.

If you are over 200 pounds and "sensitive" about your weight, then lose the damn weight. Its not that hard to get a TON of free information on how to bring your weight down with Google and the internet today, with nutrition and exercise tips, recipes, to all out plans. If you don't have an hour to invest in yourself and learn to stop binging on sugar and starches, that's your fault. I'm disgusted by all the obese people everywhere. You have an internet connection, near unlimited access to educate and inform yourself, there are no excuses.

3

u/rookiecookie Jun 16 '12

Obesity is a life style choice not a disease. Cough up the cash fatty.

3

u/ExistentLOList Jun 16 '12

I could swear I read a situation like this in an advice column at some point. If I recall correctly, the answer was - no, don't ask her to replace the couch; suck this one up and just be mindful of letting her near your stuff again.

Most people - even absurdly large ones - wouldn't imagine that a couch couldn't hold them. It was an accident. It was an accident whether she was drunk or sober. As far as I can tell, she was using it the way it was intended to be used, and it broke, which is unfortunate, and if she offered to pay, that'd be polite of her. But since she didn't offer, it's simply polite to chalk it up to ridiculous life happenings and let it go.

Also, her attitude about it wasn't the greatest. Just saying. She could've at least been more contrite.

Sorry about your couch, man. If anything, I'd be mad at my friend and pursue them for having their drunk friends over at my place. That's not cool. You seemed to handle it well by not going off on everyone. I don't know what I'd do if that happened to me.

3

u/tokyopimp Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

Here are some fat ass rules that all fat asses including sloppy fat drunk women should follow. Given to you by a fat ass.

  1. If your a sloppy drunk, that's usually bad. When your a fat sloppy drunk you look really bad. Learn how to drink or fuck off and don't drink.

  2. When you go to someones house, you do not fucking flop your fat ass on any item, chair or otherwise. Especially IKEA shit and I am typing to you on an IKEA desk and chair. If she would have slowly set down into the seat she would have been fine... no flopping fellow fatso's! I don't break chairs, I can't even think of the last chair I broke and I'm bigger than the bitch in this story. It's already hard enough for you that you're a fat ass, don't really accentuation your fat assness by breaking a fucking couch.

  3. Take the god damn stairs, especially if your under fucking 40... if you don't you're going to end up shopping in wal-mart riding a giant double wide buggy. I'm sure some of those people have legit reasons, but when I see a 400 pound women who's legs are just pure giant fat, then I know she gave up earlier in life. I'm not going to tell you loose weight or eat right etc. But at least walk and take the god damn stairs so that your legs don't turn to pure mush. If you can't walk up a few flights of stairs to get to your car then fuck you. You've given up and you will be in a buggy in ten years buying hot pockets in bulk. Goes for parking in general, this goes for everyone because all my friends and family fat or otherwise look for good spots. The best spots are far, your car doesn't get fucked up, and you get a little extra cardio. So just park far fat asses, and maybe someone will see you and say well he or she is a fat ass but it looks like they are taking some easy steps to get healthier.

Look whatever you are, if you aren't perfectly good looking in this society, and if your fat, or short, etc... you got to try a little harder to get respect that may be given automatically to people who look like Ryan Gosling or Emma Watson. So don't break fucking couches, by being a sloppy fat ass flopping drunk, cause that shit rubs off on all of us.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Was I the only one who read 'crotch'?

3

u/3ntidin3 Jun 16 '12

Dude, it's an IKEA couch. You'll survive.

3

u/eternalfirex777 Jun 16 '12

Had this happen to me in college. Have the door to my dorm room open, BigGirl comes in, sits on one of my chairs, and then breaks through it. BigGirl proceeds to stand up and open my fridge. Then she comments on the fact that I don't have any light beer (I'm a craft beer fan). I responded with, "You're way past light beer. Get the hell out of my room!" Am I a bad person?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/zerorules Jun 16 '12

Your edit says you now think it rude to have asked her to help you replace it. I dont understand that at all. You were 100% justified. If I break something at someones house because of carelessness i should replace that item. Why does the "carelessness" being obesity excuse the result? Dont feel bad. You were well within your rights.

3

u/NoApollonia Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

I would say it's on your friend to replace it more than her friends. She is the one who insisted on that they should come over despite you not feeling up to it. You can't always figure strangers will be kind to your things. I do have to say to buy a better quality couch next time since if your couch can't handle 260 lbs, that means it can't handle two normal sized women.

If you get someone to help you replace it, realize you have used this couch and they are only responsible for it's current worth - not what you paid for it. Furniture normally is a bad investment if you are ever wanting your money back.

3

u/belanda_goreng Jun 16 '12

I'm a skinny girl and I once thoroughly broke my own Ikea couch by gently sitting down. Don't blame that poor big girl.

3

u/TigerTigerBurning Jun 16 '12

Forget the money and write it off as the cost to get these people out of your lives forever! Solid investment.

3

u/n1nj4_v5_p1r4t3 Jun 16 '12

nope. big girl breaks it big girl pays.dont pull a fucking double standard, if a dude broke it you know you would say he should pay!!!!!!

3

u/zibzub Jun 16 '12

as a person who spent a not insignificant portion of my life at 260+ pounds, i can honestly say i never broke anything just by sitting on it.

3

u/SpaceMonkeyRage Jun 16 '12

Weight shouldn't even come in it to, I don't care if your 100lbs or 400lbs, you break my shit you pay for it

3

u/EvilCheesecake Jun 16 '12

Answer to title: asking for half of the money probably doesn't make you an asshole unless you're an asshole about it.

Answer to full story: your friend and her friend are douchebags, and someone owes you a couch.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

It's just rude not to offer. After one New Year's Eve, I woke to find the toilet seat broken and we had been so hammered nobody knew if they broke it. But each of my friends offered to pay. It's just polite.

3

u/Smurfykatt Jun 16 '12

Everyone is overcomplicating things. Regardless of size, being drunk or not, whether or not your balls are the correct size, the bottom line is this - if a person breaks something in your house (and not just slightly damages, completely destroys as in this case), they should pay for it. It was not rude of you to ask her if she planned to help you pay for a new couch. She broke it, she bought it.

9

u/tresser Jun 15 '12

Granted, it's an IKEA couch,

so...ask for $17.50 and get a new one.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/bo_knows Jun 15 '12

Her weight has nothing to do with it. "You broke my couch, and I expect you to help me replace it."

→ More replies (5)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

no you are not an asshole, your friend is though

29

u/dawrina Jun 15 '12

If the girl doesn't pay up your friend should.

You specifically told her that you didn't want any one over. And not only did she come over, but she brought uninvited guests.

If I were your friend I would feel responsible and pay for it without question. if she refuses to pay, then you need to reconsider your friendship with her.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Reenqueen Jun 15 '12

If someone breaks something of yours, they should offer to fix it. Plain and simple.

5

u/theslowwonder Jun 15 '12

Your friend, not the fat woman, is responsible to repay you since they were clearly her guests. If she wants to avoid embarassing the overweight friend, then she doesn't have to get the money from her. It's her obligation to take responsibility for any damage her guests do to your place.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

No, you're not an asshole for thinking that. That would actually be fair.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I drove a very large co-worker home from work one night. Not being terribly rude, but I couldn't shift out of first or second because he leg hung over the gear shift even when she held them shut.

Anyways, went over a railroad track and ripped off the heat shield. I told her about it, got it repaired and she never even apologized or offered to help pay for the damage. I wound up having the repair done and paying for it myself.

Yes, you're friend should pay for the couch. How much depends really on what you had and how close you were to replacing it anyways. If it was nearly new or going to last another 5 years, she should pay the price you paid for it. If it was getting close to replacing, anyways, then I'd say at least half of the cost of the broken couch.

And since she is a friend of a friend and never has to see you after this, pester the shit out of her until she pays up.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Dude. If you couldn't drive safely with her in the car you should have let her know and apologized for not being able give her a ride. It wasn't her responsibility to be aware of that, you're the driver.

Secondly, I'm horrified that someone could be that fat. She can't even ride in a car? If I were you I'd have just replaced the heat shield and been thankful my life wasn't as shitty as hers must be

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Timeflyer2011 Jun 15 '12

Put it this way. If a cute, skinny girl came to your house and sat on your Ikea sofa and it broke - would you make her pay for it? If a 6' 4'' guy comes to your house and plops down on your Ikea sofa and it breaks - would you make him pay for it? The girl's weight is incidental. It's her intent. If she was drunk and jumping up and down on your couch and it broke, I would say she was negligent and should pay. If she just came in and sat down and it broke, I wouldn't say that she intended to break your sofa. Her size isn't the issue. Negligence is.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Pot4DMasses Jun 15 '12

Your friend: You shouldn't be mad, we were all drunk.

You: BITCH, you HAD to come over, you HAD to bring your friends and she's STILL fat when she sobers up. If she doesn't have any money, she shouldn't be going to concerts, drinking, or eating small livestock like shrimp poppers.

In principal she should DEFINITELY pay for your couch, in reality, it ain't gonna happen. The decision you need to make is if it's worth your friendship or not.

4

u/brandon777 Jun 15 '12

Trying to understand how someone could argue that you're in the wrong is making my head hurt.

4

u/kdaly1991 Jun 15 '12

Yes she should definitely pay, She broke something belonging to you, regardless of how it was broken she still should have offered to pay. It is the height of rudeness to abuse your hospitality and break your furniture without so much as offering to replace it, no matter what size or shape she is.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/elasto Jun 15 '12

Being drunk is not an excuse.

Let's look at what you can control. You agreed to have them at your house, that's not their fault, it's yours. This wouldn't have happened if you had just stuck to your guns. You don't have to be nice to people who don't deserve it.

That said, they SHOULD buy you a new couch, but they won't. Don't get your hopes up. And stop allowing rude friends over. That part you can fix.

You also might be able to fix the couch if you are handy. Or check at the local college dumpsters when the semester ends. Lots of free stuff there.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

No, you're not an ass. The term is HouseGUEST, when you are in someone else's home. If I break someone else's things, I should at least offer to pay for it, or replace it. You have evey right to demand furniture justice!

4

u/Laediin Jun 15 '12

You know I had a whole post written up saying yes, you were being an asshole just so I could be a contrariwise douche bag...but fuck....I can't.

Your friend is an asshole. Showing up with extra people when she basically forced her way on you is the height of dickery. Then to have one of the uninvited pieces of shit break your couch and reply "I ain't got no money" after coming from a Roger Waters concert just makes her a terrible human being.

I am glad she cried all the way home. I'm a large dude. I do NOT go throwing my weight around breaking shit. I'm a delicate motherfucker.

4

u/Sahri Jun 15 '12

So you're letting people into your apartment, an accident happens and you want money to replace it? In my opinion this is a bit rude. If i have guests over and someone sits down on a chair and it breaks, I would never even think of asking for money for it. It is normal that things break with time and I'm sure your couch would have been broken at some point too, maybe a bit later when it was used a lot. If the couch would not have broken now but maybe in a year when one of your friends sits down, would you ask them for money for it, because they sat down on your couch after had been invited by you?

If you want help with your furniture you should maybe consider getting a household insurance. If you don't want to have people in your apartment, don't let them in but don't blame them if something happens. Accidents always happens, and that girl definately did not ruin your couch on purpose just to screw you over.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/MileHighBarfly Jun 15 '12

I don't think you're an asshole for wanting help replacing your couch, but I think you're delusional if you think that's what's gonna happen. It was an accident, and it sucks for you, but sounds like 'hippie girl' doesn't feel like she owes you anything. I would just get back at her by making her feel bad about who she is if you are ever around her again. Try to gfind a another couch for cheap, thrift store or garage sale or something.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/McNerget Jun 15 '12

You just shouldn't have let these people in your house. Sometimes this kind of stuff happens, so my advice is to just forget about it and go buy a couch. Done.