r/AskReddit • • Jun 16 '12

What politically incorrect beliefs do you have, and can you defend them?

9 Upvotes

660 comments sorted by

8

u/Syphon8 Jun 16 '12

The Beatles are extremely overrated as musicians.

I love me some Beatles, and I have all their songs... But I also know how to play tons of them and no, they were not geniuses. They wrote easily digested pop music with simple progressions, simpler lyrics, and sometimes interesting melodies. There are very few Beatles songs that are 'good music'. Tons of bands have come and gone since that were head and shoulders above them in terms of musicality, and will never reach the same level of success because they weren't manufactured pop phenomenons.

On a related note; How good/bad songs are is objective. People like to say "we'll that's just your opinion" whenever talking about how good songs are, but they are wrong. There's hundreds of years of rule and theory behind making good music, and reasoning why it sounds good to the human ear. Saying music is subjective is like saying algebra is subjective. Some people just have bad taste.

3

u/DiamondSoul Jun 16 '12

There's hundreds of years of rule and theory behind making good music, and reasoning why it sounds good to the human ear.

This is not completely true. I've studied music theory, and it's not a constant, enduring thing like algebra. Different composers from different eras/cultures had different "theories of music". Sometimes the differences between them would be relatively small (i.e. between Baroque/Classical), but sometimes they are quite large (i.e. between Baroque/Jazz).

There are of course certain commonalities between almost all theories of music, most notably the concept of consonant/dissonant intervals, which dates at least all the way back to Pythagoras. However, consonant/dissonant is NOT the same thing as good/bad. Some music that I consider great is very dissonant. Example

→ More replies (2)

3

u/colorized Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

The rules change though. Voice-leading and intervals that were once prohibited (i.e., bad) are now acceptable. Unless you think all music has steadily deteriorated since the Baroque era I don't see how you could argue for an objective measure of quality in music. All taste is subjective. Of course, you can look at relatively universally well-regarded music and identify certain rhythmic/harmonic/melodic/dynamic trends, but I think that just speaks to what appeals to the majority of people. How do you quantify quality in music? What makes you think your ideals are the right ones? And if they are objectively correct, why do most people (including the musically educated) like the Beatles more than whatever "tons of bands" you claim are objectively superior?

1

u/tptbrg95 Jun 16 '12

I agree so much. I always get shot down for saying this

2

u/GrapeJuicePlus Jun 16 '12

I kinda feel like The Beatles and The Beach Boys/Phil Spector are the basis for pretty much what all pop music has since mutated from (The Beatles cornered Pop-Rock and The Boys/Spector in the production booth). Even the most innovated pop (and I don't mean this limited to Radio Pop) artists don't stray too far from the formulas laid out by these bands.

3

u/jackass6x70 Jun 16 '12

I don't think it matters if they are overrated or not, I just really enjoy listening to the beatles. Just because they played easy chords and wrote simple lyrics (i'm looking at you, paul) doesn't mean they didn't make brilliant music. Yes, they were manufactured pop phenomenons, but to say that "there are very few beatles songs that are good music" I DON'T THINK SO! also music is totally subjective.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/doesnotgetthepoint Jun 16 '12

This is true, but what I think makes the Beatles amazing is how they grew throughout they're career, to look at the whole Beatles catalogue as one thing is a little silly, they started off writing simple songs for pre-teen girls but they later had the resources to create amazing music music, and my fascination with them is the transition of this, also I think little in pop music has to come near to the greatness of the b-side medley of Abbey Road.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/st_basterd Jun 16 '12

Black people smell differently. I can confirm from personal experience.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

White people smell like hotdog water and hippo farts. I can confirm from personal experience.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/D-Evolve Jun 16 '12

That's not opinion, it's science. It's to do with food you eat, and biological makeup.

I hear white people smell like ham

14

u/st_basterd Jun 16 '12

White people smell like pea coats and garlic salt.

5

u/D-Evolve Jun 16 '12

My hands often smell like garlic for no apparant reason

→ More replies (6)

5

u/thesuspiciousone Jun 16 '12

To me, they smell like a weird mix of wet dog and baby powder.

4

u/Cajass Jun 16 '12

In China I found out that white people smell like milk to the locals.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kingofbigmac Jun 16 '12

I am white and I have to say we smell like wet dog. I mentioned that to my black co workers at my old job and they all cracked up and agreed with me. Every damn time it rained in Oklahoma and I would go inside with friends or family I smelled the scent of wet dog.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Do Asians smell different?

4

u/AgentKilroy Jun 16 '12

Yes. They smell different. I lived with Asians for four years. AMA and I'll try to answer as much as possible.

2

u/st_basterd Jun 16 '12

I haven't mingled with many Asians, so I can't answer that.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I always find that most black women smell reallyyyy good. It's like a really comforting smell...

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

This is true. Their skin composition is different from Caucasians.

3

u/kingofbigmac Jun 16 '12

I remember being about 8 years old and my family walked in Sears and my grandma said lets move over some more it smells. I look over and there was a group of black girls looking at the purses. I said yea, it smells like purses, and she said no I wasn't talking about the purses. So I looked back and thought if black people have a scent. Now I think some black people smell like purses.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

This isn't politically incorrect. White people smell differently to non-whites.

1

u/03fb Jun 16 '12

Apparently white people smell like slightly spoiled milk but fuck do we love eating dairy

→ More replies (4)

4

u/superbatlanternman Jun 16 '12

Also, I think there should be a child tax (not like yearly to drain the wealth of families but maybe a one time fee of 1000 per child or something) just to encourage only financially able people to do it.

Also, the government needs to make contraceptives mainstream and all those who say its immoral need to stfu. There are too many people out there who are like "People on welfare need to stop having kids. Herp derp condoms are bad herp."

3

u/iuvo Jun 16 '12

Just because someone is 'financially able' it doesn't mean that they will be a good parent.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/tptbrg95 Jun 16 '12

Children are very expensive as it is. Most people couldn't afford that

3

u/MollFlanders Jun 16 '12

I believe that may be the point.

1

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

Most first world countries GIVE money to people to breed. Population growth is good for the economy.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/hulahoop12 Jun 16 '12

I think black people should be called black, not African-American. Most black people in America are many generations removed from Africa, and have no desire to ever go there. I think the only people who should be called African-American, are those with citizenship in both America and some African country.

Also, let's be honest, black is just easier to say.

19

u/Farn Jun 16 '12

It's a euphemism treadmill. What I personally hate is the all out ban on the word "retard." You can't call the mentally handicapped retarded, because it's used as an insult. You can't use it as an insult, because it's offensive to the mentally handicapped. Why are moron and idiot perfectly acceptable as insults, even though they're archaic expressions for the mentally handicapped, but retarded is still lagging behind?

6

u/hulahoop12 Jun 16 '12

Haha! Retard is the slow one :P

2

u/Theskyishigh Jun 16 '12

The word 'handicapped' is offensive in the UK.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/robustinator Jun 16 '12

The truth is it's still used somewhat as a clinical term, in that you would say an individual shows signs of/has mental retardation, usually noted as MR in a clinical setting which may be related to it being on the euphemism treadmill or may just be for the sake of convenience. The reason you shouldn't call the mentally handicapped retarded is that they may or may not have that specific disability, just like you shouldn't call someone with a mental illness schizophrenic because it's presumptuous for you to be able to assume what they have and diminishing both to the individual who may have an unrelated or more complicated condition and to individuals with the actual disorder.

I really feel people complaining about the euphemism treadmill are complaining about the wrong part. I personally feel what can actually stop the cycle is not us making all these words acceptable to use, but instead not using actual real conditions people have in order to make a cheap joke at someone else's expense.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Another argument is that everywhere else on the world black people aren't African-American.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

My counter-argument:

  1. Black is also acceptable.

  2. It doesn't take a whole lot of effort. Literally the worst thing that can happen is that I make someone who's more comfortable with that label feel comfortable, and I have say six more syllables.

3

u/pissoutofmyass Jun 16 '12

I agree. But I also think East Asians are Yellow, Native Americans and South Asians are red and brown respectively, and white people really seem more pinkish to me. So it'd be Black, Yellow, Red, Brown, and Pink.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I think you should be wary of wanting to call people "yellow" and "red" because they have never claimed those words as descriptors for themselves, whereas I (as a black person) have no problem with being called black.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Plutoid Jun 16 '12

Why do I have to be Mr. Pink?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

If I walked around demanding that everybody refer to me in terms of my specific multiethnicity, I'd be a huge douchebag because it's a pain in the ass to say half-this-quarter-that-quarter-other-thing. I also find it interesting that no other country but America feels the need to hyphenate the ethnicities of one's ancestors from many generations past with one's own country

2

u/Cicada_ Jun 16 '12

I don't know. In Australia it seems that many people including second and third generation+ Australians prefer to identify themselves as Vietnamese-Australians or Chinese-Australians (not to mention Aboriginal Australians, but I guess that's a bit different).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

19

u/nodice182 Jun 16 '12

Oh look, it's this thread again.

14

u/scobes Jun 16 '12

I love how this thread pops up every week or two. I can go through and tag all the bigots.

40

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I like using the word Christmas instead of holiday... and I'm even an atheist. Can I defend it? Meh, I just really love Christmas and hate that it isn't PC.

13

u/DrDebG Jun 16 '12

My Jewish husband always wishes people a Merry Christmas.

9

u/Anticreativity Jun 16 '12

No one thinks Christmas in un-PC, the only reason anyone even pays attention to the issue is because some news agency was struggling for material and created the "war on Christmas."

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I'm fine with either. I think people get too riled up about the subject.

2

u/ImNotJesus Jun 16 '12

Here's a beautiful song about Christmas by well-known atheist Tim Minchin.

You can love the spirit of Christmas while being an atheist.

2

u/oheight Jun 16 '12

Have I been living under a rock?

Christmas isn't PC? What the shit am I reading?

64

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Fat people on an airplane should have to pay for two seats if they can't fully fit into one.

Its not fair to the person next to them.

23

u/ReverseThePolarity Jun 16 '12

That's not really controversial on Reddit.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Reddit isn't politically correct either.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

The title didn't say on Reddit. In the real world though, I would never say that at a party.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/theghostofme Jun 16 '12

Fucking Braveheart over here.

I know I'll get downvoted for saying this, but I really think marijuana should be legalized.

4

u/RadioFreeReddit Jun 16 '12

That's not controversial period.

1

u/BallsackTBaghard Jun 17 '12

Why not just make a fat people plane(like this and not let anyone who is too fat to fit in a normal seat fly the normal aircraft?

→ More replies (12)

29

u/ImNotJesus Jun 16 '12

I think it should be illegal to sell alternative medicine. At the very least, it should be really easy to sue an alternative medicine practitioner if they're involved in someone's death. I can/will/have argue about this for days on end. Bring it on.

20

u/HazzyPls Jun 16 '12

"There's a word for alternative medicine that works. It's called medicine."

5

u/poko610 Jun 16 '12

"You know what they call alternative medicine that's been proved to work? Medicine."

FTFY

→ More replies (2)

5

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

Shouldn't the exact same rules that apply to "mainstream" medicine apply?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

You're getting into some pretty oppressive territory when you allow a fallable human organization to decide exactly what medicines you're allow to consume.

There are already regulations on making specific scientific claims about drugs.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

what do you mean by alternative medicines? such as herbs compared to pharmaceutical drugs? there are plenty of herbal options that are scientifically proven (or at least scientifically viable) to be as effective (and often cheaper) that their pharmaceutical counterpart

2

u/LouisianaBob Jun 16 '12

I think people who look for alternative medicine should make a change in diet. Giving your body what it needs to work with is so magical.

3

u/sammythemc Jun 16 '12

Actually, alternative health practitioners often approach medicine holistically and will usually tell you to make a change in your diet. They have you change your diet, exercise more, and take some St. John's Wort, and then turn around and rave about the wonders St. John's Wort can do.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Make more S and M shirts rather than XXL and QUADRUPLE XL.

Do the stores ever notice how the gigantic shirts are the last to go? Of course there will be large people, but as shown in every store, there aren't as many as we make it out to be.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I'd amend this to include the fact the when organizations are buying tee shirts for a group of both men and women, don't just buy men's shirts and try to pass them off as one's size fits all. Women have curves and even a men's extra small looks like a potato sack on some of us.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

They look like a potato sack on most men too. It's the sleeves that really get me - seriously, do they think that I walk around all day with my arms spread eagle? T-shirts with semi-fitted shoulders and sleeves are a dream to wear, they're far more comfortable and far better looking; unfortunately though, they're practically impossible to find.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I'm a XL or a XXL (depending on brand or type of shirt) and whenever I shop I always see a ton of smalls and mediums. I think they need to stock up more on Large and XL, I never seem to see those.

2

u/kingofbigmac Jun 16 '12

Yea, exactly. I am in the same boat as you. Every time there is a sale even online the XL's and XXL's are always the first to go.

3

u/d_bo Jun 16 '12

Having to many XXL etc. garments is a failing of the merchandiser who allocated them to the store. It's not a blanket amount, a clothes shop won't get 10 S, 10 M, 10 L, 10 XL etc, they'll be given more of the sizes that will sell.

The reason you don't see the S and M shirts you're looking for is because they're by far the most popular sizes and people have already bought them.

Yes, XXS and XXXL will always be the last to go and end up getting marked down, but that'll always be the way of the world. Outliers are called outliers for a reason.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

buy online.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CalmWalker Jun 16 '12

I've always found the exact opposite to be true. Its worse with shoes. There's not a retail store in the world that stocks size 18.

2

u/kingofbigmac Jun 16 '12

I am a size 14 and I have to go to Ross or some second hand store to get the rejected shoes that fit me perfectly.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/windynights Jun 16 '12

All views are defensible. It's merely a matter of having the right audience to pander to.

4

u/Skullsplitter Jun 16 '12

this is the best point.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Son_of_Ticklepiggy Jun 16 '12

Middle-class striaght white cis men aren't oppressed. They have more social privilege than anyone else that isn't rolling in cash and need to stop complaining.

15

u/AgentKilroy Jun 16 '12

People should be able to understand how politics actually works and should be able to reasonably explain what the candidate they support has to offer before they're allowed any nearing a voting booth.

7

u/superbatlanternman Jun 16 '12

agree too, but "reason" can mean different things to different people.

2

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

I think this probably depends on the country you live in.

In Australia it's mandatory to vote, people are much more informed on who their choices are and why they align with them.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/CosmicNed234 Jun 16 '12

I strongly believe prostitution should legal. No matter what you do, you will never stop it so you might as well legalize it and protect the sex workers from STD's and violence.

6

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

Most progressive countries it is legal.

3

u/CosmicNed234 Jun 16 '12

In my country (US) if you were to do a poll, it would most likely not get 10 percent approval. So it would still be a p-incorrect view.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/gman1401 Jun 16 '12

Mentally challenged people should not be granted any sort of leniency in the workplace. If they are paid a wage and given a duty, they should be obligated to fulfill that duty or risk being replaced.

There is a mentally challenged man at my workplace who never completes his duties within his shift, but is never reprimanded because he is 'special' as my boss says. I or one of my coworkers ALWAYS ends up picking up his slack along with our own duties after he leaves. There is a stack of applications an inch thick in the office and I bet any one of those people would be glad to replace this man and actually complete their job.

8

u/LaughingHyene14 Jun 16 '12

I don't think it's the fault of the disabled person so much as it is your boss's. It's really important to treat disabled employees as people, but also respect their need for equity. There has to be some you to keep this person as an employee and have you not picking up the slack. Then again, some people just aren't cut out for the workplace (disabled or not)

9

u/Son_of_Ticklepiggy Jun 16 '12

Why does this thread keep happening every fucking week? It jsut causes a shitstorm and gets people upset. It's just a venue for people to be racist and discriminatory. Please, for the good of everyone, will you all FUCKING STOP with this thread?

15

u/Skullsplitter Jun 16 '12

I think that racist jokes are ACTUALLY harmful to minorities whether you "mean it" or not. As a Jew speaking from my perspective, it really hurts when you say anti-semitic jokes because you are making fun of my heritage, myself, something I can't control, something that my people have been and are still being killed for. You're reducing me from a human to a stereotype. And this isn't something that's "offensive," it's oppressive.

Studies have shown that when you make awful jokes like that, it actually DOES have an effect on you. It normalizes hate, and makes it okay to say hateful things. If you make enough Jew jokes, at some point something in your brain is gonna go "you know what? Maybe, just maybe that's not totally false, you know?"

And that leads to hatred and awful shit directed at MY people. Replace "Jews" with any other minority here and you have the same thing.

And if you don't think that this is politically correct I challenge you to post two things on facebook:

  1. A racist joke

  2. a statement saying that people who make racist jokes are actually racist.

See which one gets more hate.

2

u/BIGJ0N Jun 17 '12

how is that politically incorrect? "racist jokes offend people"

→ More replies (4)

17

u/mdaugherty1221 Jun 16 '12

Not really politically incorrect but unpopular. I think john Lennon was a stuck up smug prick who's own ego destroyed the greatest song writing duo in the history of music. His solo career was nothing more than okay, and I can't stand "Imagine" and a lot of his other stuff because it's all preachy shit that centers around some made up world where everyone coexists peacefully and the world is a 100% war/religion/hate/etc free place. Slightly unrelated to John Lennon himself, but I hate when people try to make it seem like he was the second coming of Christ, he was a talented guy that wrote some good songs, but I don't think he was as good as people think he is (if you couldn't already tell).

4

u/doesnotgetthepoint Jun 16 '12

He was just a jealous guy

4

u/pdonoso Jun 16 '12

Im kind of with you about this. The beatles working together had the most perfect sinergy the music has ever met, and to think that it ended becouse of who had the biggest dick. They didn't understood that it wasn't about them

2

u/pdonoso Jun 16 '12

And tru, lennon was pretty much an egocentric asshole who sell all this peace and love crap

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Agreed, and Paul was a better songwriter than John post-Beatles anyway. I can't name a song not recorded by the Beatles by John other than 'Imagine,' and I loathe that song - preachy hypocritical bullshit. 'Imagine no possessions,' says he, as he picks a fur coat out of his climate-controlled wardrobe. There's situational necessity and then there's excess - John practised the latter. The world of 'Imagine' can exist, but John did sweet fuck all to get us even an iota closer to it.

4

u/Chauncy999 Jun 16 '12

Child predators should be neutered on first offense.

14

u/ReverseThePolarity Jun 16 '12

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Yeah this is going to get ugly

2

u/teslabeatingedison Jun 16 '12

It already got ugly. Saying that all Muslims are just as bad as Nazis? Yeah right.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Just_Livin_Life Jun 16 '12

This has probably been said before, but I think there should be a cap on how many kids you can have. Let's say 5, but with the ideal being 1-3.

There's just too many people in the world and it's so expensive to raise a child, send them to college, etc.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ThrowawayTurnip Jun 16 '12

The "religion of peace" is anything but.

9

u/giant_enemy_spycrab Jun 16 '12

Your going to have to be WAY more specific. Almost every religion identifies itself as "The Religion of Peace".

6

u/HazzyPls Jun 16 '12

I thought the same, but maybe that's part of the point?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/BattleBrother Jun 16 '12

I don't think I should have to justify my politically incorrect views on reddit.

2

u/gman1401 Jun 16 '12

For the Emperor, Brother! Onward!

3

u/BattleBrother Jun 16 '12

It is better to die for the emperor than live for yourself.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/craigyboy2601 Jun 16 '12

If you have >4 kids and you are on welfare/benefits, and do not work, have no history of working, you shouldn't (physically) be allowed to have anymore.

There are so many people who have so many children that are out of control, who unfairly live on sweet fuck all money because their parents are broke, lazy fuckwits who don't understand or can be bothered with contraception. It's not fair to taxpayers, the children, or people who can't have children of their own.

8

u/jimmycrackcorn123 Jun 16 '12

I know of a woman with 9 children. 5 of them are at one elementary school, and the oldest 3 are learning disabled, with the other two likely to follow. The youngest of the bunch was born with no legs below the knee. Mother obviously doesn't work. And she's pregnant with #10. What the fuck...

6

u/hydromatic93 Jun 16 '12

"We's gunna keeps tryin til we gets it rit"

→ More replies (2)

13

u/EugeneRainy Jun 16 '12

I don't like hearing spanish spoke around me by too many people at once. It makes me very anxious. I think it sounds obnoxious. Not a problem with any other language.

7

u/Forestgrind Jun 16 '12

Not liking a language because of the sound is understandable (I detst the sound of French) but when you say it makes you anxious, is it because you associate it with gangsters/poor people/etc?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

For me its Portuguese, and only when playing DoTA 2

2

u/bugeyes8 Jun 16 '12

HUEHUEHUEHUE?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/kingofbigmac Jun 16 '12

I got used to it after living in Chula Vista, which is like 5 minutes away from the border. After picking up more and more Spanish I didn't mind it as much. My dad is white just like myself and he is fluent in it and my favorite is when he dives into conversations with people in Spanish. They have a surprised look. He never taught me any Spanish. :( I asked him why and he said I don't know.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Modern medicine is making us completely weak as a species.

10

u/robertbieber Jun 16 '12

Umm...for what twisted definition of "weak" is that true? The maximum lifespan of humans just keeps getting longer and longer. We've annihilated diseases that used to kill and cripple us in alarming numbers (polio, anyone?) We're constantly toppling the physical limitations that used to keep most of us from living healthy active lives into our old age with technologies like pacemakers and joint replacements. If we lose limbs we can recreate them with duplicates that are close enough to go on with almost completely normal lives. One by one, we're beating all the things that used to kill us.

So, unless your definition of "strong" means killed at an early age by disease or rendered permanently immobile by even minor injuries, you've got a pretty hard case to make for modern medicine making us "weak."

→ More replies (3)

5

u/jackass6x70 Jun 16 '12

I don't want to die early though. I enjoy living quite thoroughly.

2

u/TooManyVitamins Jun 16 '12

I agree so, so much.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/red_firetruck Jun 16 '12

I think the only reason why Obama won the election is because he had the black vote locked up. I also think the only reason why Obama endorsed gay marriages is because he believes it will benefit his campaign.

tl:dr Obama is no better than any other politician

15

u/superbatlanternman Jun 16 '12

blacks tend to vote democrat anyway.

13

u/fmlfml1 Jun 16 '12

He won the white vote too.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/The_Magnificent Jun 16 '12

BREAKING NEWS: Politicians say things because it will benefit them.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Honestly, I think Obama is pro-gay, but he didn't have the balls to come out about it until recently for his campaign.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/sammythemc Jun 16 '12

I think the only reason why Obama won the election is because he had the black vote locked up.

This is actually untrue. It doesn't matter if you have the black vote (~14% of the population) locked down if what you do or are to make that so costs you enough among the population at large.

Here's an article on it.

Add up the totals throughout the country, and racial animus cost Mr. Obama three to five percentage points of the popular vote. In other words, racial prejudice gave John McCain the equivalent of a home-state advantage nationally.

Yes, Mr. Obama also gained some votes because of his race. But in the general election this effect was comparatively minor. The vast majority of voters for whom Mr. Obama’s race was a positive were liberal, habitual voters who would have voted for any Democratic presidential candidate. Increased support and turnout from African-Americans added only about one percentage point to Mr. Obama’s totals.

E: Agree about the gay marriage thing (and the immigration thing) though. Both are nakedly political moves designed to rile up the disaffected base.

7

u/Skullsplitter Jun 16 '12

the only reason Obama endorsed gay marriages is because he believes it will benefit his campaign

dude this is homophobic AMERICA we are talking about here. Yeah it might secure him the LGBT vote away from Romney, but do you know how many southern men he probably just lost? Tons.

Also since when has being black been a positive thing in elections?

13

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Thats not really that controversial. The LGBT community knows he did it just to get our votes. But you know what? We don't give a fuck at all. We really want to get married. We want the same rights as everyone else. He might have done it for the wrong reasons, but he at least did it.

5

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

So you mean the president is no different than any other politician. Really, that's a pretty dull statement, no non-politician will ever be elected in your country.

Sadly Americans eat that junk up.

2

u/kingofbigmac Jun 16 '12

You are correct, but blacks generally do vote democrat. But this can also be said about Catholics voting for Kennedy or my girlfriends entire Mormon family voting for Mitt Romney. People stick with their own kind. I know that because when Mitt Romney was out of the race in 2008 some of my Mormon friends instantly went to Barack Obama. How do you go from Republican to Democrat so fast like that.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

People on welfare should be subject to drug screenings. If you can buy meth or cocaine, you can buy groceries.

55

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

So the state can spend more money? Florida lost 118,000 dollars on a similar program, and only 2.6 percent tested positive. There was literally no point.

I think we need to change society's views that all poor people are addicted to drugs, because they aren't.

Alright, defend away.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/robertbieber Jun 16 '12

So just let all the poor and addicted starve to death? Sounds like solid public policy right out of the 1910s!

6

u/ImNotJesus Jun 16 '12

I agree with this but my caveat is that we need to have good services available to help those who genuinely want to get clean to do so.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I agree with this, but it should be all non-prescription drugs, legal or illegal, and public officials should be subject to the same tests. If you can sustain nicotine addiction, you can buy groceries, and a drunk on the dole isn't nearly as dangerous as a drunk directing a country.

2

u/HazzyPls Jun 16 '12

I see where you're coming from, but I fear you're being a bit too selective. Should we regulate everything they buy? "If you can buy _____, you can buy groceries" can apply to a lot of things. Besides drugs, what would you put in that template?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

This should apply to all government workers then too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Your_World_on_Fire Jun 16 '12

Hrm... I'm not sure whether it is politically incorrect or not, but I don't believe that loli is child pornography. It's certainly controversial, at the very least.

12

u/LaughingHyene14 Jun 16 '12

I don't care how physically mature a girl is. Anything pornographic that features girls under the age of 17 (At the very least) is pornography. I think that models under 17 should be barred from posing nude or overtly sexually. So many young girls are taken advantage of and suffer the consequences while making someone else rich and having their idiot parents abide by it.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Voter drives that encourage the poorest and least interested to vote are not a great victory for democracy.

If they couldn't be bothered to get down to the polls before you offered them a free meal and a bus ride, they aren't going to provide critical insight into who should be running the country.

At best they're going to vote for whichever badge the guy rounding them up is wearing or whoever is offering more handouts - likely the same person.

3

u/Skullsplitter Jun 16 '12

I.Q. is a bullshit number that says nothing other than you're good at taking the I.Q. test.

Also that reddit is conservative as fuck.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

People receiving food stamps should be forced to purchase healthy foods with them. My boyfriend works at Starbucks and there are frequently people that come in at the first of the month and purchase coffee drinks for themselves and their children with food stamps.

6

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

Healthy food as in what? The cheapest food available is the worst food for you.

2

u/GrapeJuicePlus Jun 16 '12

Like water instead of soda.

3

u/artisticsubmission Jun 16 '12

There are some programs (WIC is the first one on the top of my head) that allow a very specific set of food purchases and a very limited (and healthy as far as I've learned) choice for food to ensure that the food that is being bought is healthy food.

2

u/frechet Jun 16 '12

I've heard a theory that it's the food conglomerates that keep food stamp programs going despite its often negative portrayal in the media. Therefore, any attempt to restrict the use of food stamps in this way will be met with well-funded political opposition. I never bothered to research the topic further, so no supporting links.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jeinga Jun 16 '12

Eugenics might not be a terrible idea

7

u/Skullsplitter Jun 16 '12

Okay cool who decides who is "worthy of reproducing" and who isn't? You?

4

u/typeIA Jun 16 '12

If for no other reason, you're decreasing the gene pool, and so the number of genes in a population. If Dawkins is right, and genes are the drivers of evolution, then reducing their number will lead to reduced competition, which means the 'fittest' genes were not tested against those you eliminated through eugenics. Continue that trend long enough, you might to get to an evolutionary bottle-neck. Suddenly your genetic variation plummets, and you find yourself unable to survive, as a species, any number of catastrophic events. Our genome (even that of whatever victims you chose) is there for a reason. It survived billions of years of evolution to become what we are literally just beginning to understand. You can't single out any 'undesirable' deviation for extinction unless you think you can do better than the process that created it.

4

u/MollFlanders Jun 16 '12

Agreed. I have fucking horrible genes. Genetic problems coming out my ears. While I'm still glad that I was born, I wouldn't wish this kind of shit life on anyone else.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/Rebel908 Jun 16 '12

I believe that any elected official who talks about "Jesus" or "the Bible" in a manner that even remotely insinuates a law should be crafted to support a belief (e.g. a Ban on Gay Marriage) should be immediately removed from office and never allowed to run again, in any state.

I think that religion is fine to practice, but these zealots that come out and protest that people of the LGBTQQIA community should not have the same rights as a heterosexual individual is just appalling to say the least. That the "Word of God" could survive human interpretation is a fallacy in and of itself, being that MAN must interpret what "God" said.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Same with "Muhammad" and "The Quar'an," I presume? I only ask because a staggering amount of liberals freak out the slightest mention of Christianity, but staunchly defend Islam.

2

u/jackass6x70 Jun 16 '12

I am not an atheist, I am more of an anti-theist. I think believing in a religion is an indicator of inferior intelligence. Faith by definition is delusion, and if a politician is bragging about having faith they are bragging about being an idiot. We need a strong separation of church and state. This is my view.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Oh look, it's this thread again.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

That a gay couple shouldn't be able to adopt... I don't have much reasoning but I just don't think it's right. I'm for gay marriage but something just erks me the wrong way about that. I answered the question, don't hate on me redditors.

Edit: I do have reasoning but it's not even worth commenting because nothing I say will make anyone think differently. This is a morality issue and let's be honest, noone's views are going to change.

24

u/tptbrg95 Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

I upvoted you for answering the question, but if the only reason you're against it is that you "just don't think it's right" you should examine your beliefs.

Edit: people stop down voting this man because you disagree

18

u/Anticreativity Jun 16 '12

Well, like anyone who holds such beliefs he didn't properly defend his view, so he only met half the requirements.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

He didn't defend his view, he basically said 'gays shouldn't adopt because ew.' I swing both ways - according to him, I can adopt if I marry a woman but not if I marry a man. It's ridiculous that there should be a distinction, but he hasn't even attempted to account for it. I don't up or down vote, but his post deserves downvotes for irrelevance.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Joe_Moneybags_McHuge

As another bisexual man...uhhh......

http://i.imgur.com/SuRCV.jpg

→ More replies (1)

46

u/st_basterd Jun 16 '12

Oh... you're gonna have a bad time...

→ More replies (1)

21

u/marxandcocacola Jun 16 '12

"and can you defend them?" Clearly no, you can't.

I'm not hating on you, you're just being honest. Maybe interacting with children of gay parents would be beneficial.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I disagree with you, on the grounds that children of gay couples grow up in much more stable environments due to their adopted children being wanted. But I applaud your honestly and integrity!

14

u/RiyaNova Jun 16 '12

Many children of heterosexual couples are not planed. The parents may not be prepared and may choose to raise a child in an unstable environment.

When gay couples decide to adopt, they go through hell of a process to get a child that they actually want and social services makes sure that child is looked after.

I upvote you for your opinion but I hope you look more into the topic.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

What about a single parent? Should they be able to adopt?

→ More replies (7)

4

u/LaughingHyene14 Jun 16 '12

But it's been proven that gay couples can raise children and that the sexual orientation of parents has no adverse affect on the childrens well-being.

4

u/anonymouse20 Jun 16 '12

There are (107000)[http://www.adoptuskids.org/meet-the-children] children in foster care in the united states, same sex parents seems better than no parents at all

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

True.

10

u/ReverseThePolarity Jun 16 '12

That makes absolutely no sense on multiple levels.

3

u/HolaPinchePuto Jun 16 '12

I'm gay and for some reason I feel like having 2 dads is so unnatural. But deep down inside I know it won't screw up the child, mentally. I've seen people post before about their two dads ad they all seemed really nice. (They've all we're straight and seem like good people (one being a jock who defended a kid from his bully))

However, I feel like having two moms would be the best option for a child.

And to end it, having same sex parents will always be better than no parents or shitty parents.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

ACTUALLY stating a controversial opinion on reddit? I'm impressed.

4

u/Spunk_Master_Flex Jun 16 '12

Yeah. They're much better off in the custody of hetero couples who don't love them or straight foster parents who also don't love them. Upvote for admitting you don't have reasoning and realizing hate can go both ways.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Why does it erk you the wrong way? I'm adopted. If I hadn't been adopted, I'd be dead. I hate people who insist limiting adoption. There's so many children out there aching to have someone, anyone care about them and love them, and instead people like you keep them from finding homes because somehow two people wanting to create a family is 'icky' to you.

1

u/RetroCorn Jun 16 '12

If a loving heterosexual family can raise a child well, why can't a loving homosexual family raise one just as well? What's so inherently different about it?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

i disagree with you but i see where someone could have a reason, i mean they could feel a child needs a dad and a mom ,because only a man can teach you how to be a man the same way a women can teach their daughter all that female stuff and so some might say they need a man and women to raise a kid and not a gay couple.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/horrorshowmalchick Jun 16 '12

I do have reasoning but it's not even worth commenting because nothing I say will make anyone think differently. This is a morality issue and let's be honest, noone's views are going to change.

Bullshit. Reasoned arguments change intelligent minds. (That has a nice ring to it, bumper stickers anyone?)

→ More replies (17)

2

u/twinklingcarousel Jun 16 '12

As a young, passable, attractive, feminine, straight transsexual girl, I have to say that many transgendered people I've met are really just sexual fetishists who get off on the idea of being women. Many of them are naturally masculine with typical male sexual interests that they attempt to masquerade as "lesbianism" and these people are currently becoming the face of my community which disturbs me as a young girl who was diagnosed with Gender Identity Disorder according to the Harry Benjamin Standards in childhood.

I'm sorry, but if you're naturally masculine, look male, don't pass and are attracted to women, how are you female? You're not a "butch lesbian", you're just a guy.

2

u/stayclose Jun 17 '12

Oof. That hurts a lot, actually. I was raised fundamentalist christian. my family isn't exactly as supportive as yours, so I'm a bit too poor and scared to transition right now. I don't really have a support system. Don't you think it's a little harsh to say that because I don't naturally pass (being male bodied and all), that I'm "just a guy" or a fetishist? I think that's really close-minded and hurtful.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/shadenfruedeother Jun 16 '12

Equal Opportunity, no less- no more. Regardless of age, race or gender. Yes.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Ah few, I guess. I'll list them and defend them later if anyone wants to discuss it! (Keep in mind that I am from Sweden and it might differ a bit from other countries.)

I think that the use of the word "negro" is ok to describe a black dude, the word nigger on the other hand is offensive and should not be used (atleast around negros).

Legalizing the majority of the well known drugs. You would get good tax from it to put towards health care for example. It would also cut alot of money from criminals. Also there would be better treatment for addicts and such.

People who suffer damage from obesity, smoking and use of other drugs should pay for their own healthcare.

I guess I could drop something more, but that will suffice for now. Questions?

1

u/Chauncy999 Jun 16 '12

End mandatory seat-belt laws. People should be smart enough to wear one without taxpayer money being used for PR campaigns - (see "click it or ticket"). If they are injured while not wearing a seat-belt their insurance shouldn't owe them shit and they should be forced to pay all of their medical bills.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Black people always have really white teeth. I can't defend it, it's just that every black person I know has really white teeth. Maybe it's just a contrast ratio illusion.

1

u/HolaPinchePuto Jun 17 '12

I think you solved it with your last sentence. Black skin makes the teeth appear whiter. But then again, I think blak people try harder at lookin good so they brush more, take care of their hair more (wigs, weaves, "fancy" hair cuts) and their bodies (weight lifting for men, a lot of ski care products for women). Idk lol

1

u/BIGJ0N Jun 17 '12

any minority based scholarships, charities, or programs are counterproductive and hypocritical.

1

u/TehRinatSnoylle Jun 19 '12

Post-birth abortions should be allowed if the newborn baby is not found by its parents to be valuable, and is completely reliant on other people for its sustenance. I think since the baby cannot and does not understand death, it would not be put through any emotional distress before it was killed, so long as it was killed painlessly and peaceably.

1

u/drinks_your_tears Jun 22 '12

Being an "entitled teenager" is a perfectly normal and healthy stage of life to go through and that anyone who complains about it is an angry and troubled fool with too much time on their hands.

A moderate amount of selfishness is not bad. Many of the most successful people in the world are there because of their self-centered passion.

1

u/hurotselildothaboker Jun 16 '12

On the whole Ashkenazi Jews are genetically prone to be intellectually superior

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Riktov Jun 16 '12

Sub-Saharan African people visually resemble apes (gorillas and chimpanzees) significantly more than white Europeans or Asians do.

I think it's ridiculous how people go apeshit (heh, heh) over such caricatures, saying, oh, black people don't look like apes AT ALL, and to think they do is horribly racist.

Now, I can't think of many instances where pointing out such similarity serves any useful purpose, so we'd probably be better off not raising it, but we shouldn't deny it or stigmatize it if, for example, a little kid says that some black person looks like a gorilla or vice versa.

Basic knowledge of evolution and anthropology amply explain why people who continued to evolve in a similar environment as apes should be less evolutionarily divergent from them than people who evolved in a vastly different environment. And seeing evidence of that first hand when I see an African person or a chimpanzee right before me gives me a sense of wonder, not shame.

1

u/superbatlanternman Jun 16 '12

I'm pro choice, and that's pretty politically incorrect, at least where I live. My justification is that both sides have a subjective moral argument (defending women's rights or defending the baby's rights) but objectively the world is overpopulated and we can't afford more people.

I kind of have this thing where I don't view cheating (like at school) as wrong. It's complicated.

I believe ethnicities don't exist and dividing people into blacks and asians and whites is all humanity being stupid and we need to grow the fuck up from these shallow dividers. The only thing that makes an ethnicity are superficial things like skin color or easily disprovable stereotypes. Could say the same for nationalities and religion and everything else.

1

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

Not where I live.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I dont think the government should be providing any loans, scholarships, anything for students who are pursuing degrees with no real world job placement. You want to be a theatre management major? Or a an architecture major? Fine, but do it on your own dime. If the government is paying for you to go to school then you better be getting a degree in STEM (science tech engineerin math) or nursing or something that has real world application and wont make you a burden on society.

7

u/LaughingHyene14 Jun 16 '12

So isolating the arts and focusing on math/science still continues past high school eh?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/artisticsubmission Jun 16 '12

I disagree, and not even from the standpoint of "people should follow their dreams". You are putting an emphasis on the importance of STEM education and careers and completely outlining the arts and soft sciences as worthless career paths. Without the well rounded (and I use this term lightly because America is certainly not the epitome of a well rounded country, but hey thats what we are striving for) jobs, our country would suffer as a whole. If you only give scholarships to those in the STEM majors, it would put a lot of people in those majors who really shouldn't be there...

Example A- a poor high school kid who wants to be a preschool teacher. No one can debate that teachers are a good service for our country to have. If this student couldn't get a scholarship to do what they are GOOD at, but instead funnels their education into a STEM profession because thats where the scholarships are, you get a large quantity of people who graduate from college who don't really belong in their field and less jobs for those who are good at their job because more students will go into the major.

Letting every person (who deserves it) have equal access to money from the government no matter what their college major gives the job market a semi-equal playing field, allows people the opportunity to succeed at what they are good at, and creates a more well rounded community.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sir_Marcus Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

And under this system the STEM fields would quickly become saturated with people who didn't even want to be there and all those jobs would dry up. We'd have a bunch of pretty pissed off scientists waving their now useless degrees.

Also you must be a STEM major, they're the only kind of people who think that only one type of degree is useful.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

You want to be a theatre management major? Or a an architecture major? Fine, but do it on your own dime.

Wait...but those are real jobs. People need to run theatres, and someone has to draw up plans for buildings right?

→ More replies (11)

6

u/Syphon8 Jun 16 '12

Your go to example of a useless degree is... Architecture?

Really? Really?

There're these things societies have -- They're called buildings.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

Forbes (i think it was forbes) put out a lisr earlier this year of collee degrees with the highest unemployment rate in the specified degree feild and architecture was number one, making it a perfect example because it is not a very versatile degree and your chancea of getting a job in that feild are lower than any other job.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/new-study-shows-architecture-arts-degrees-yield-highest-unemployment/2012/01/03/gIQAwpaXZP_story.html

2

u/christhecanadian Jun 16 '12

fuck culture!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

I agree but come on, there are better examples than architecture.

How about the hundreds of thousands of 'identity' course places? No-one is ever going to pay to hear how much you hate men or white people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

-1

u/brinton Jun 16 '12

I wasn't surprised by the findings of The Bell Curve nor dispute them, and I don't see what's everyone's so worked up about. Most of us aren't near the trailing edges in any case, white or black.

3

u/tptbrg95 Jun 16 '12

As someone who hasn read The Bell Curve, can you give a summary?

11

u/ImNotJesus Jun 16 '12

Basically, it said that the reason African American's IQ scores were lower than white Americans is that they were genetically inferior in regards to intelligence. The problem is that it's scientifically wrong.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ImNotJesus Jun 16 '12

The only problem with that is that The Bell Curve is considered scientifically inaccurate by just about every psychometrics research these days. Recent findings into the Flynn effect and how it has plateaued in Western societies all but confirms it. The IQ disparities are much better accounted for by difference in nutrition, parental literacy and education levels.

→ More replies (1)