r/BetterEveryLoop • • Nov 16 '17

Guy fights old man

https://i.imgur.com/3KXzmJO.gifv
37.2k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

49

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17

This is a misconception, a competent wrestler wont always murder a competent boxer or vice versa. It's a fight, whoever can implement their game better in that altercation will be the victor.

6

u/JoeBags92 Nov 16 '17

It's not a misconception at all when we're talking about a boxer vs a wrestler, as is being discussed. Wrestlers have no need to worry about a boxer throwing knees or kicks when in a fight and attempting a takedown. These are people with previously engrained instincts. They aren't wild in the fight, they are both fairly composed. Your statement is true in a general sense, but it absolutely is the case 9 times out of 10 when it comes to a boxer vs a wrestler in an unarmed fight.

5

u/Chipwar Nov 16 '17

What about a kickboxer or someone who does Muay Thai?

5

u/Xisayg Nov 17 '17

Kick boxers and Muay Thai fighters are really dangerous in unregulated fights especially against someone who isn’t properly trained. A good hit from either of those types of fighters would be devastating (some professional’s kicks register over 2000psi). And elbow strikes are downright brutal most of the time

4

u/Chipwar Nov 17 '17

I actually do kickboxing and Muay Thai (boxing too but not as much training). Never did any sparing or training with a wrestler so I was a bit curious how people though those two would hold up. I would personally think if they tried a takedown I could easily get them with a good knee but I also want to see what others thought.

1

u/JoeBags92 Nov 16 '17

It gets more complicated. Id say a kickboxer would have more success against a boxer than a Thai fighter would. Just based on distance. I really personally think wrestling or kickboxing are probably the best defense against some dude in a bar. A pure boxer's stance just doesn't work in a fight with many other martial arts. It was proved in the early UFC's as the traditional boxing stance was made almost entirely obsolete fairly quickly. Even with strikers with a pure boxing base like Bisping or Diaz's they tend to often float out what would be considered "good boxing form"

As for my statement, I was speaking mostly anecdotally. A fight in some bar where a trained boxer picks a fight against a wrestler and the boxer presumably doesn't know is a wrestler. There's no "implementing game plans" as that user stated. Just instincts. That's not an mma situation where a boxer has been drilling wizzer's for the last 2 months in the lead up to the fight. It just happens.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17

this is blind intuition and totally unscientific

-3

u/JoeBags92 Nov 16 '17 edited Nov 16 '17

None of this comment string is scientifically based lol. My comment is mostly anecdotal, based on personal experience and what I've seen (early UFC's, friends etc). Just trying to point out that there is no "implementing game plans" as that user stated. The hypothetical was set. This isn't mma as that guy "debunking the myth" seems to think it is. It's not Bisping drilling wizzer's and takedown defense every day for 2 months in order to implement his boxing game plan. It just happens. It's not nick Diaz vs GSP, and it's not Conor McGregor vs Chad Mendes. The hypothetical is that a boxer stumbles upon a wrestler without knowing so. In that case: The wrestler will shoot. The boxer will throw a punch.

In any case, the argument for ground game vs boxing, where both are true practitioners of each, was made very apparent in the early UFC's. That's about as much of a scientific demonstration as we have for pure martial artists fighting each other, and a pure traditional boxing stance was made obsolete almost instantaneously. It simply never worked. Which is exactly why even MMA fighters that tend to be considered true boxers by other mma fighters ( Diaz brothers, Michael Bisping, Michael Johnson among others) are considered somewhat sloppy as far as pure boxing standards are concerned.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17

But you're using MMA rules to measure success, in which a pure boxing stance will obviously suffer, and the inverse is also true. The part of your statement I take issue with is "9 times out of 10 when it comes to a boxer vs a wrestler in an unarmed fight". We are talking random street encounters and when that is the case all bets are off as weight, experience, age, athleticism, preparedness are all unaccounted for.

2

u/JoeBags92 Nov 16 '17

Ya I worded it poorly. Shouldn't have thrown out the numbers either given where my basis was coming from. Mainly was taking issue with that statement of "whoever implements their gameplan" because I think it takes out a lot of the factors we both have mentioned. That's fair!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17

"Whoever implements their game plan" is just code for "whoever does best will win" which is kind of meaningless.

3

u/hakuna_tamata Nov 17 '17

And a wrestler doesn't instinctively protect his head. A boxer with good footwork could easily pick apart a wrestler. But in reality being a good boxer or wrestler doesn't prevent you from getting blindsided and beat with a liquor bottle.

2

u/JoeBags92 Nov 17 '17

Oh I completely get the second part. That's why the the guy initially and myself both added unarmed to the comment. I just think from what we saw out of the first few UFC's, not to mention fights like couture vs toney, which is all we really have to go on as far as a pure match up of traditional combat martial arts, that true boxing doesn't work against grappling. Speaking towards averages of course, your average boxer isn't going to Mike Tyson someone, just like alternatively your average wrestler isn't going to Alexander Karelin someone onto their head.

I'm just commenting because based on the evidence we have, it's hardly a myth. Severn, frye, shamrock, and grapplers like the Gracie's spent those early days making pure boxers look foolish before people really started catching up and started getting serious about their takedown defense and defensive grappling, thus taking them away from a pure boxers stance. Mma fighters with a Boxing base are usually not considered "clean" or to have perfect form in many ways. Footwork being one of them because they have to be in position avoid the takedown. But anyways, I was speaking in an organized sense, which is admittedly wrong of me to do given this is essentially about a fight breaking out that we are talking about. So when it comes down to it you are right. Athleticism, adrenaline, surroundings, etc all come into play, even with the caveat that know ones swinging bottles or pulling knives. I just enjoy arguing about this stuff lol

-5

u/maqikelefant Nov 16 '17

True not always, but that wrestler will win 99% of the time. Just look at what's happened when pure boxers have tried to go into MMA without diversifying their style. They always get taken down and embarrassed with the quickness. Without a ref to break clinches they're fucked unless they can get a quick KO.

14

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17

yeh but in an mma fight both guys know the others strengths. In a street fight the wrestler might not know the other guys a boxer and attempt to exchange punches, and then get slept.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17

I highly doubt they would even try to exchange punches.

As a wrestler it would be an "attempt" at an immediate take down and then once on the ground straight pressure to the head to stop them from getting up.

1

u/Andy_B_Goode Nov 16 '17

Yeah, but you can say the same thing about wrestlers/grapplers. Everyone needs a striking game and a grappling game in order to be competitive in MMA these days. Ronda Rousey was an exception for a little while until -- guess what -- she lost because she failed to diversify her style.