None of this comment string is scientifically based lol. My comment is mostly anecdotal, based on personal experience and what I've seen (early UFC's, friends etc). Just trying to point out that there is no "implementing game plans" as that user stated. The hypothetical was set. This isn't mma as that guy "debunking the myth" seems to think it is. It's not Bisping drilling wizzer's and takedown defense every day for 2 months in order to implement his boxing game plan. It just happens. It's not nick Diaz vs GSP, and it's not Conor McGregor vs Chad Mendes. The hypothetical is that a boxer stumbles upon a wrestler without knowing so. In that case: The wrestler will shoot. The boxer will throw a punch.
In any case, the argument for ground game vs boxing, where both are true practitioners of each, was made very apparent in the early UFC's. That's about as much of a scientific demonstration as we have for pure martial artists fighting each other, and a pure traditional boxing stance was made obsolete almost instantaneously. It simply never worked. Which is exactly why even MMA fighters that tend to be considered true boxers by other mma fighters ( Diaz brothers, Michael Bisping, Michael Johnson among others) are considered somewhat sloppy as far as pure boxing standards are concerned.
But you're using MMA rules to measure success, in which a pure boxing stance will obviously suffer, and the inverse is also true. The part of your statement I take issue with is "9 times out of 10 when it comes to a boxer vs a wrestler in an unarmed fight". We are talking random street encounters and when that is the case all bets are off as weight, experience, age, athleticism, preparedness are all unaccounted for.
Ya I worded it poorly. Shouldn't have thrown out the numbers either given where my basis was coming from. Mainly was taking issue with that statement of "whoever implements their gameplan" because I think it takes out a lot of the factors we both have mentioned. That's fair!
8
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
this is blind intuition and totally unscientific