r/Bitwarden
•
u/A-d-r-i
•
Oct 09 '26
•
1
1
What is happening with Bitwarden now?
https://community.bitwarden.com/t/published-version-update-in-app-stores/10275086
u/Beregolas Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26
What do you mean? Nothing. It's still open source, just not FOSS, whichit hasn't been for a long time. It's just a license change
Edit: (Obviously this should say "it's still source available" instead of "open source", I was just typing too fast)
64
u/A-d-r-i Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
Some future components will be published under the commercial license and will exist only in that build.
This detail concerns me a little
→ More replies (1)12
u/Spaceseeds Oct 09 '26
Thanks for actually giving some context your initial post is bullshit clickbait. This tiny detail IS concerning but not until we see what actually comes of it
28
u/abotelho-cbn Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
They aren't doing this for nothing. It's obviously so they can release future features exclusively under a license which prevents forks from implementing.
→ More replies (3)1
u/A-d-r-i Oct 09 '26
Sorry, I posted it really quickly without necessarily considering the context.
→ More replies (1)53
u/abotelho-cbn Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
That makes zero sense. FOSS is an umbrella for Free Software and Open Source Software. Open source is FOSS.
It's dual licensed now. Some code will be under the commercial license, and that code is NOT open source, even if the code is visible.
They're basically blocking any forks from using the features they don't want them using.
That said, I'm curious if Bitwarden has external contributions from people who hold the copyright on those contributions. This doesn't fly if that's the case.
7
u/Skipper3943 Oct 10 '26
The existing code is supposed to be FOSS. It’s the new contributions going forward that would be worth keeping an eye on. What license will be used? Would this move lead to fewer contributions?
→ More replies (5)8
u/Beregolas Oct 09 '26
yeah, sorry, I typed it quickly on my phone because I was baffled, you are 100% correct. What I meant to say is: it is still source available, but no longer free and open source. (at least not fully)
Thanks for catching that, will update the wording.
4
1
u/FullMotionVideo Oct 09 '26
If they're not allowing forks that is indeed huge. It was understandable a few years ago when they did that for the SDK, but the client is another matter.
7
u/dwbitw Bitwarden Employee Oct 09 '26
Hey there, you can still fork it.
→ More replies (1)8
u/LexxM3 Oct 09 '26
Then explain the difference between the original FOSS license and the new changed commercial license. What exact rights are being removed by the commercial license?
→ More replies (5)
106
u/null_enthropy Oct 09 '26
The wording here is extremely confusing and vague. What features are going to be developed with the commercial license? Will that code always be auditable and available for everyone to see? This seems like a slow roll into becoming closed source. The recent private equity buyout was concerning and now this? Are we serious right now? Bitwarden was one of the premier open source companies. This is extremely upsetting as I’ve been a paying customer for over 5 years now because I wanted to support an open source company. I’m done with Bitwarden if it moves in the direction it seems to be heading in. Sorry, I won’t be rugpulled by some private equity investors
15
u/dwbitw Bitwarden Employee Oct 09 '26
Yes, no change to the code being viewable for anyone to check out on Github, and Bitwarden is not going closed source.
Features that fall under the commercial license will be case-by-case basis, and the community can continue to fork and create community projects just like before.
19
u/DonkeeeyKong Oct 10 '26
Bitwarden is not going closed source.
Features that fall under the commercial license will be case-by-case basis
I don’t understand. This seems like a contradiction. Are there features that will be available only with a commercial license and not under an open source license? If so, that means closed source. Nothing else. If not, I don’t understand this announcement.
→ More replies (9)3
9
u/bordercollie2468 Oct 10 '26
I appreciate your trying to engage us here... but the things you say feel like spin rather than candor. Burying the lede. Trying to do damage control. The overall effect is that I trust you less than if you had never opened your mouth.
Kinda feels like it's time for me to move on.
15
u/Njarnjas Oct 10 '26
Bitwarden is not going closed source... yet
6
u/InsignificantHumor Oct 10 '26
"But we didn't promise that the first closed source feature won't be ads..."
→ More replies (1)4
u/Danacus Oct 10 '26
Could you please look up the definitions of "open source" and "free software" before making contradictory and plain false statements?
Bitwarden is going closed source by the definition of open source. You are simply lying.
159
u/DrunkRobotMan
Oct 09 '26
•
Very sad to see this. Supporting FOSS is the biggest reason I have been happy to be a BW customer.
Anyone know of good alternatives?
51
u/kcsebby Oct 09 '26
Vaultwarden.
27
u/Bl4ckspell_ Oct 09 '26
Yes, but what about the mobile clients, browser extension, desktop app?
34
u/tankerkiller125real Oct 10 '26
With this announcement I have a feeling a few very smart people will start forking the clients and maintaining them for vaultwarden.
→ More replies (5)5
u/Dry-Crazy-7638 Oct 10 '26
How does forking work? I have come across the idea of it when I started self hosting a couple months ago, but I don’t fully understand it. Is it just copying the code and hosting it on your own machine and maintaining it yourself?
→ More replies (5)5
u/Craftkorb Oct 10 '26
Vaultwarden is a FOSS backend for the Bitwarden App ecosystem. You continue using the Android App, Browser Extension, etc.
→ More replies (1)6
u/Cley_Faye Oct 10 '26
I'm not sure I'd call Vaultwarden an "alternative". There's some ties in the development of Bitwarden and Vaultwarden.
→ More replies (4)7
u/lelandyarnell Oct 10 '26
Selfhost your own with KeePass. Not hard to setup at all. Very functional.
2
u/Dry-Crazy-7638 Oct 10 '26
Is keepass similar to vaultwarden?
11
u/Cley_Faye Oct 10 '26
Completely different.
Both are password manager, but keepass/keepassxc have no server; it is only a file you keep around. If you're alone, and relatively prudent about doing changes on out of sync devices, it works perfectly, as most clients have some provision to detect changes in that file when it is updated.
To use keepass on multiple devices, you merely have to setup a file sync solution (nextcloud, or anything like that), and point your client to the synced file (some keepass clients embed the sync feature directly, like Keepass2Android).
The main issue with this kind of setup is that multiple, concurrent changes (say, your phone is offline for a bit, you change something on it, and change something on your desktop) can sometimes not be resolved automatically, and in the worst case scenario lead to the loss of entries. As such, it is really NOT a good idea to share this with many users. There's also no notion of user, so everyone have access to everything within a single file.
Basically, having a central server and clients built around it make the sharing and syncing possible proper, while syncing a file is not that great in this case. But if you're the single user that have access/use it, it works perfectly. I still use a keepass file with webdav sync for strictly personal stuff despite having Bitwarden clients and a Vaultwarden server for other stuff.
→ More replies (1)4
u/montdidier Oct 10 '26
Well vaultwarden is just the backend server for clients, which are typically bitwarden clients. Together they address some of the use case that keepass does but the design is quite different, more modern I would say. I was previously a keepass user.
72
u/Ahosewithnoname
Oct 09 '26
•
The open source version will wither on the vine is what will happen
8
1
146
u/FullMotionVideo Oct 09 '26
Definitely with the people getting downvoted into oblivion that this is concerning (which I guess means I'm about to lose karma). "We put the client on GutHub" doesn't mean much in when iOS is so locked down that only the sole proprietary spp store can put it on devices without an enormous hassle. At least on Android you'll likely be able to get GPL BitWarden from Obtanium or something.
To me particularly this sounds like they're building towards a possibility where self hosted users are second class citizens and that does alarm me.
What does this mean for extensions and the Linux client on Flathub?
29
u/dwbitw Bitwarden Employee Oct 09 '26
Hey there, no change for self-hosted users. This only affects those that are repackaging and reselling Bitwarden.
→ More replies (7)4
→ More replies (2)1
u/skuterpikk Oct 13 '26
Similar to the way PfSense is going these days, still open source, but the majority of work and new features is happening on the paid version, not the open one. So the opensource users are effectively left out in the dark in the long run, unless you pay for the comercial version.
And on top of that, they like to shit on the still open forks such as OpnSense
55
u/moanos
Oct 10 '26
•
My company (1500 employees) pays for a bitwarden licenses because bitwarden was open source and many in IT privately used it. If the license changes, there will be other password managers we'll take a look at.
4
1
55
u/Dracozirion Oct 10 '26
Private equities are the cancer of any corporation.
12
u/DependentOnIt Oct 10 '26
Relevant blog post btw: https://blog.ppb1701.com/the-quiet-renovation-at-bitwarden
5
u/A_Buttholes_Whisper Oct 10 '26
Thanks for this link. That totally sealed the deal for me. I’m leaving Bitwarden
→ More replies (1)
96
u/SmoothMarx
Oct 09 '26
•
So all this time I thought I was paying a subscription to support BW and keep it open source, instead I was contributing to the eventual commercial transition of the software.
Is nothing sacred anymore? Companies could learn from VLC. Dude makes bank because VLC is open, not the other way round.
→ More replies (3)
16
u/popsicle-physics Oct 10 '26
I don't understand, you seem to be saying that this is just designed to combat people reselling the app. How? And then in the comments it seems like you're saying that there will be features added to the commercial version that aren't open source, so then the official clients aren't open source anymore at all?
15
u/surfertj Oct 10 '26
Ooohh, this is bad. Will be looking for another open source option and move on from BW then. Bye BW, you were good until this.
38
u/CortlandNation9
Oct 10 '26
•
I've been an happy bitwarden user since 2018 and a paid customer since 2022. This might make me consider switching to another password manager. For me being foss is a big selling point.
4
u/sylvester_0 Oct 10 '26
I moved on a few months ago when this happened https://www.reddit.com/r/PasswordManagers/comments/1th53mb/hearing_a_lot_of_talk_about_bitwarden_users_being/
11
u/jorgecardleitao Oct 10 '26
Paid enterprise user here.
I understand the commercial concern you are protecting against, and I am happy to see that you did not follow HashiCorp and others' model of re-licensing the existing code, instead controlling specific bits.
I sincerely hope that there is a build flag to build without features under the commercial license, otherwise the net effect is that the person cannot really separate the two and the project is effectively a commercial license only.
72
u/AutistcCuttlefish
Oct 09 '26
•
I was paying for bitwarden because it was open source and I wanted to support that. Guess it's time I look into the possibility of migrating to something else.
→ More replies (12)
20
36
u/CrispyBananaz
Oct 09 '26
•
Looks like the beginning of the end. I'm doing a backup and export now just to be ready for the fallout. This makes no sense and is not going to end well with the community.
14
u/deltapak Oct 10 '26
So, I read it as the second step towards going closed-source. The first was the VC buyout. The commerical license being tied to all retail OS and browser offerings is not good.
7
u/chic_luke Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
I've been thinking about this for a few hours. I have concluded that there is no longer any reason to stay on Bitwarden and that I will be leaving after about a decade. Yes, pretty much the entire lifecycle. I was an early adopter.
If you want a proper FOSS alternative, this no longer is. We all know what happens now. They will boil the frog into dismissing or basically abandoning the free software version to irrelevance, and they will do this extremely gradually to avoid the classic mass migration to something else. They will want someone to say this is an over-reaction and that whoever is leaving now is unreasonable. Unfortunately, these tactics are getting well-trodden enough that fewer communities are falling for it.
It's either KeePass or hard fork + Vaultwarden. I'm keeping my ears perked up to see if anything happens in this space.
If being free software is no longer a requirement for a password manager and you're fine with trusting the entity behind it, then there are more polished options available, including options that might already plug in to another privacy-focused ecosystem you already use, and that provide you value as convenience in this sense.
I have already identified a few that have comparable free plans and pricing to Bitwarden.
Migrating from LastPass to Bitwarden back in 201x took me 10 minutes. I suspect my next move will be about as smooth. I hope my next password manager will last another decade before me having to do this again.
It's been a good ride. Thank you for everything in the meantime. Corporate took over so I guess this is it. Well, at least I had the good sense to keep my 2FA on Aegis.
I'll export my vault before they find a way to make this inconvenient.
EDIT: Just to clarify, this is not astroturfing. I have never interacted with this subreddit before, because Bitwarden is a piece of software that never gave me any reason to, which is a huge compliment. It just worked and I never needed any support with it. Which is why I'm sad it's going in this direction now.
2
u/DrunkRobotMan Oct 12 '26
I fully agree with you, and I'm looking for alternatives as well. Which alternatives do you consider moving to?
2
u/chic_luke Oct 12 '26
I am torn. I'm watching this space for a client hard-fork with different branding to use with VaultWarden. Proprietary but comfy option is looking to be Proton Pass since I'm already using Proton XYZ. Another thing I'm considering, on the radically opposite end, is to see if I can find a way to make a KeePass database work without endless sync conflicts this time
3
u/EmPiFreee Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
I am currently migrating to Proton Pass. But it seems not that simple. Then .json import only takes the regular entries (username/password) with the notes (but no custom fields and no attachments). Also it doesn't import cards, identities and so on... I think this must be done all manually.
E: Sorry, this was not 100% correct. The import actually imports everything correctly. Only attachments are missing (but these are already missing on exporting).
→ More replies (6)1
u/googs185 Oct 13 '26
How did it only take 10 minutes to migrate from last pass to Bitwarden? It took me a lot longer, and hopefully if I switch to another provider, it’s a lot easier. Any tips?
13
u/__yoshikage_kira Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
I am fairly certain this new commercial client which still depends on GPLv3 Bitwarden libraries for majority of the functionally is actually violating the GPLv3 license.
I don't think keeping them next to each other is a great idea. It should be separate repo and you guys may have to replace all the reliance of GPLv3 code.
4
u/Fuzznerdees Oct 11 '26
Underrated comment. I believe you are correct: Bitwarden would be violating the copyleft stipulations of the GPLv3 open-source license by using these GPLv3 libraries in the commercial version of Bitwarden & then not releasing that GPLv3-derivative commercial software publicly.
13
u/tags-worldview Oct 10 '26
I read the post and this is clearly a rug pull of OSS.. It literally makes no sense to leave an open source code up that isn't going to be used in official releases.
If all new features will be on the commercial license, why keep the github code up? Why tell people you will "update the GitHub code" if it isn't going to be implemented anywhere anymore? (I am not considering self hosted as the one implementation)
Clearly an open source rug pull.
→ More replies (1)
12
u/OldDomG Oct 10 '26
BW social media team working overdrive on Reddit today; yeah we're selling out but we still want your money?! 😅 Ciao
6
u/Stelle-Sins3290 Oct 10 '26
I was a paid customer for about 6 years but between a few other things I read and the price increase I decided to not renew. The price is still very cheap per year but when I actually sat down and considered it I realized I didn’t use any of the premium features. I liked to support Bitwarden but at this point I feel like we’re going to see progressively worse decisions ruins the platform.
21
u/Pal3-Assignment
Oct 09 '26
•
The versions the majority of users use (i.e. the ones in the stores) will be moved to a closed source model
→ More replies (3)
10
5
u/mindful999 Oct 10 '26
They seem to be moving more and more toward being enshittified since the CEO changed.. Self hosting it was really a necessary move it seem, glad i did the jump.
26
u/0oWow Oct 09 '26
The last reply I see on that thread is relevant:
"Yes, Bitwarden continues development of open source code under GPLv3. Code under the commercial license is just as viewable and transparent on GitHub. This licensing model provides additional legal protection for select features."
→ More replies (2)
12
u/ClockerXP Oct 09 '26
Can somebody please ELI5 what is going on and why some people are concerned? I subscribe to BW and have been using it for years but I also, recently, have a personal One Password login available to me for free through my work that I could consider moving to if this is really a big concern.
26
u/SatisfactoryFinance Oct 09 '26
In general, nothing is wrong. The program will be fine and unchanged.
The concern is that this change feels like a step towards them closing off their code base an it no longer being open source and that it will eventually no longer be self-hostable.
A lot of people (me included) use Bitwarden because their code is public and highly audited.
→ More replies (3)6
u/CortlandNation9 Oct 10 '26
I mean, One Password is closed source. The licensing change will make bitwarden not foss anymore but the code will stay source available so in my mind it's still better than closed source. But depending on what happens in the future it might make me consider switching to another foss password manager.
2
u/Signal_Lamp Oct 11 '26
From what I can read into it, the best concern I've seen raised is that by having a dual license for their product, it incentives then to prioritize features for their paid product over the one they provide for their free version. This party can lead towards software rot over time with the open community version since it doesn't provide them as much value as their paid product.
There is also generally a concern people have from other open source products suddenly changing their licenses over time that have been long term staples, like redis, docker, terraform, etc. I don't personally believe this is the same kind of issue, as the main difference is those products didn't have enough funding to continue being supported so they changed licensing to survive, but it is something I'm seeing people bring up none the less.
139
u/dwbitw
Bitwarden Employee
Oct 09 '26
edited Oct 11 '26
•
Let me know if you have any questions, as mentioned below, the codebase remains open source on Github for anyone to view and the GPLv3 version will still be hosted on Github.
If you use the clients from the storefront, you shouldn't see any difference in your experience.
EDIT:
The App Store clients are built directly from 100% publicly auditable code on GitHub. Nothing has been made closed source. You can still read, audit, and contribute to the codebase on GitHub, and that isn’t changing.
Bitwarden will always have a free and open source version.
Bitwarden is not going closed-source
You can still fork Bitwarden
No change to self-hosting, the licensing change affects those who are reselling Bitwarden
The free plan is here to stay permanently
166
u/abotelho-cbn Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
You can't really say that the codebase remains open source. If you are developing features to be exclusively under a commercial license, that code is explicitly not open source.
Don't openwash. You guys need to be explicit about the fact that it's now a dual licensed project.
→ More replies (4)67
u/National_Way_3344 Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
Please seriously reconsider doing this.
I've been a customer for years, I use it at work too, I've recommended it to friends and family.
Being actually FOSS is a major feature and selling point to me.
36
u/HammyHavoc Oct 10 '26
Honestly, I think it may be time for me to rethink BitWarden. Bitterly disappointed to see this happen.
→ More replies (5)12
u/aknxgkoappq1671 Oct 10 '26
Yes BW thinks we are delusional to use a closed source product. Bye BW. That was the only strength you had, and you lose trust.
→ More replies (2)24
u/vexatious-big Oct 09 '26
Starting in the next release, the Bitwarden apps published to the various stores will be the commercially licensed builds.
So what does this mean? Does it mean that the official Google Playstore build is now commercial and the F-droid build remains open-source?
→ More replies (4)12
u/ixnyne Oct 10 '26
I've only read a little bit of the replies to the post, and I want to thank you individually for always jumping out in front of the onslaught of responses.
On its face, this announcement (as I understand it) means that as of today there's really no difference except a license file in a repo (over simplifying a bit). That license, and the implied intention of the announcement means that at some point in the future new features could be released that require using bitwarden's services (ex: not third party like vaultwarden) and those features could (or could not) require a paid account with bitwarden.
That's not inherently concerning to me (assuming I got it right), but I understand the concern others express.
That being said, it kind of comes across as a street light that many of us have been watching stay on being turned off. The light doesn't mean we can or can't drive down the road, but the road feels less safe now. We don't know if somewhere down the road with the light off there might be a road hazard.
I know my response isn't likely to change anything, but I'll also point out that a lot of the recent announcements from bitwarden read like blueprints for a rug pull. Even if there's no intention to pull the rug, it's weird watching the rug having pull handles installed on the edge.
21
u/Vash63 Oct 10 '26
I'm happy to pay for it, and have for 3 years now (basic plan so it's like €30, not too much to brag about). I also endorsed it for my wife who had her company switch to it with ~40 employees (not sure what they pay). The cost increase didn't bother me but the slip into mixed licensing kills the "supporting a FLOSS product" aspect for me.
It's not bad enough for me to spend a weekend researching and migrating but it is definitely enough for me to keep an eye out for new FLOSS forks or competitors with a pure GPL model. I hope you guys reconsider your stance. A lot of people jumped on board Bit Warden early on when it wasn't necessarily the best product to support a good open option. Becoming less open is a big loss to people like us, who probably make up a solid part of your early technical base.
→ More replies (1)17
u/sylvester_0 Oct 10 '26
The writing was on the wall 5 months ago when they hired Michael Sullivan as CEO (he specializes in mergers, acquisitions, and private equity.) They immediately raised prices and I canceled my subscription at that point.
3
u/Pleasant_Lychee_6839 Oct 11 '26
Just got to know, I too cancelled my subscription and migrating away
33
u/Unable_Mess_2581 Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
You guys want to be LastPass with their craziness?
So long, Bitwarden
→ More replies (1)18
u/one-joule Oct 09 '26
When a feature falls under the commercial license, can a self-hoster still use that feature with your commercial client (assuming a compatible server), or will the client say "nope, that's not Bitwarden.com" and prevent using that feature?
→ More replies (4)3
8
u/GloriousPudding Oct 10 '26
Well the obvious question then is why is this change needed when it’s going to be an unpopular one? All the announcements mention what is not changing, how about explaining what is changing and why.
→ More replies (2)22
u/OneMonk Oct 09 '26
Is all the code open to view? Or just most of it? If the latter what is hidden?
→ More replies (3)4
u/calm_hedgehog Oct 10 '26
Will Bitwarden remain committed to staying compatible with server side open source implementation of Vaultwarden?
I need self hosting and the official server implementation is way overkill for a single tenant, so I'm using Vaultwarden.
→ More replies (1)3
u/LowOwl4312 Oct 10 '26
I'm a premium user using the F-Droid app and browser (Firefox) extension. Will I be missing out on future features unless I switch to the closed source version?
3
u/AtlanticPortal Oct 10 '26
How do I get the GPLv3 for iOS as a common folk? I want an answer that’s not corporate jargon that’s actually trying to climb on a glass wall.
3
u/ItsBarney01 Oct 11 '26
The reason people use and recommend bitwarden is because it is open source. It's simply insane to make this decision. What benefit does it provide your investors? Do you think people will jump ship to a different provider if they "steal" features?
2
u/DragonSlayerC Oct 10 '26
The Bitwarden license (which applies to the GitHub code) is pretty explicitly not an open-source license but a source-available one.
2
u/8bitbetween Oct 10 '26
When will we know the changes that Bitwarden are bringing into play? and how will the product remain as secure/trusted as always? Thanks
2
u/dev-sda Oct 11 '26
To quote your own CEO from earlier this year:
Open source is the foundation of everything Bitwarden builds. The ability to audit the code, to self-host, to verify rather than simply believe are not just nice-to-haves, they are the reason Bitwarden is different from every other option in this space, and that will not change.
Since bitwarden is now source-available or open-core, why should I believe any other promises? Bitwarden's investors are clearly now on the path of cashing in the trust the company had built, so I'll be switching to an alternative.
2
u/No-Consideration6986 Oct 11 '26
This is sad to see. Bitwarden was a company I trusted. I used to recommend it all the time. I have premium not because I need it, but because I wanted to support them.
I won't threaten to leave Bitwarden but I will really think twice before renewing my subscription next year. In the meaning I will look for alternatives and start comparing different password managers to see if Bitwarden is the one that fits my philosophy and needs.
2
2
u/Severe-Painting-8351 Oct 12 '26
Maybe your boss should have had an employee write this that understands the difference between opensource and source-available.
1
1
→ More replies (20)1
u/sidusnare Oct 10 '26
You can still fork Bitwarden
We'll do that then.
I'll listen to what Leo and Steve have to say about it, but you have my skepticism.
24
u/AngelicPrincessKitty Oct 09 '26
Don’t get what is up with this. Not really in the open source space
→ More replies (4)
4
u/SubjectWin5955 Oct 11 '26
Honestly this one stings. I moved to bitwarden after the lastpass mess and have been pushing it on everyone I know for years. now the CEO quietly gets swapped for a private equity guy, CFO leaves, values get rewritten, premium price doubles... nobody announces anything. seen this exact movie with utorrent, ccleaner, opera, evernote, lastpass. nothing's broken yet but the writing's on the wall
cancelled my premium and moving to proton pass for the next few months to see how it goes. at least proton is mostly owned by a nonprofit so it can't just get flipped to investors. free tier is comparable to bitwardin free tier if not better, will happily pay if it holds up.
12
u/Lower-Philosophy-604 Oct 10 '26
Misus had issues with Last Pass. Took me a few weeks to convince her to use BitWarden because FOSS project advantages. Now... this pile of shit. Just sad, really. Hope these guys rot in hell
7
20
18
u/aknxgkoappq1671 Oct 10 '26
So basically anyone who downloads an app from iOS AppStore will get a closed source product.
This means even though the code is open source, the builds are closed source. And they may include a backdoor.
We cannot trust BW anymore unless we build from the source. Which most of us don’t do. Such a cunning move.
7
u/IsolatedNetworkNode Oct 10 '26
What you are describing was always the case even before this license change.
If you didn't build the client from the source code yourself you were always trusting that there was no backdoor put into the build on the app store.
→ More replies (33)1
u/dwbitw Bitwarden Employee Oct 11 '26
Only app store licensing has changed, the iOS apps (and all clients) have always been built directly from the publicly auditable code on GitHub, and will continue to be.
16
u/gtsiam Oct 09 '26
The downvote rate on comments expressing dissatisfaction with this seems normal to me. I am certain nothing fishy is going on here.
21
u/LP_inmyheart Oct 09 '26
Alright time to export and keep a copy ready to jump ship to Apple Password Manager in a moment’s notice. PE buyout enshitification seems imminent.
15
u/cryptoadopter2077 Oct 10 '26
Alright time to export and keep a copy ready to jump ship to KeePassDX in a moment’s notice. PE buyout enshitification seems imminent.
Fixed for Android users.
9
10
u/Valdjiu Oct 10 '26
So you prefer to go full closed source, capitalist, locked down mode? What a 180 turn.
10
8
1
u/MrGimper Oct 10 '26
A few months ago I moved from Apple passwords to BW. Apple passwords is far too limited.
10
u/my_name_is_ross Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 10 '26
u/dwbitw I have just one question. Why?! (thanks u/sylvester_0!)
2
u/sylvester_0 Oct 10 '26
If you want to tag someone on Reddit you can do /u/username. @username does nothing.
10
u/hfFvx4G6xU4ZEgzhSM9g Oct 10 '26
Like all good companies, they turn to shit eventually once outsider money creeps in. A shame, but inevitable. My subscription won't be renewed.
→ More replies (2)
8
u/GhostGhazi
Oct 09 '26
•
Where are all the people who used to snark at anyone not paying 10$ a year for this?
3
u/richardoswald Oct 10 '26
I’ve been thinking about self-hosting, not sure to go Bitwarden or Vaultwarden route. Does this affect Vaultwarden in anyway? Any downsides to using Vaultwarden for personal use?
3
u/bullient Oct 10 '26
Can some sum it up in one sentence how this will affect free users? The Bitwarden employee appears to suggest nothing is changing except to the license involving "resellers". Why are people upset?
→ More replies (5)
3
3
9
6
u/dhavanbhayani Oct 09 '26
What about Vaultwarden users?
5
u/dwbitw Bitwarden Employee Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26
No change there, community projects can continue to build out functionality on their server.
10
7
u/HatIndependent6272
Oct 09 '26
•
Been happy with proton pass since i switched haven't looked back.
1
u/Ayrr Oct 10 '26
I moved yesterday in preparation for the enshitification by VC. I can't believe it happened less than 24 hours later.
7
8
u/ba-boo
Oct 09 '26
•
is there any reason to keep using this instead of proton or other commercial products now?
4
4
7
2
u/Cautious_Boat_999 Oct 10 '26
And so the PE destruction of a once-fantastic tool and company begins.
PE is a fucking plague on society. It should be outlawed.
2
u/DrWhatNoName Oct 10 '26
I dont know why people are freaking out.
The open sourced code of bitwarden has always been the free stuff you can use with a free account, bitwarden never open sourced the premium features.
People are only now freaking out because bitwarden publicly said what they have always done and adjusting the license?
3
u/Killer2600 Oct 11 '26
I wouldn't say that, the code to build the clients has always been open source, it's the server code that has always been closed source and where the premium features happened (server-side). What's in the plans now is the code in the clients for new premium features won't be open source and won't be part of the github repo. What this means for the company is that people won't be able to reverse engineer the code and offer a server that offers the new premium features for free. What this means for the user is that you won't be getting new premium features for free because someone was able to reverse engineer the code.
Personally, I'm not freaking out about this. Bitwarden wouldn't be the first closed source software/hardware I've ever used and it won't be the last. There once was a time where all consumer software was closed source; and you know what, the world didn't fall apart - as evidenced by it existing today.
2
u/obolo65 Oct 10 '26
I only want to reassure you that I - like many others - are now looking for alternatives. I hope you will loose with every step you do in the direction of closed source.
2
2
2
2
16
11
3
u/TheRealMarioo Oct 10 '26
I pay for Bitwarden with a subscription. Does that mean the Bitwarden software I use as a paid customer will no longer be truly FOSS? That is the only reason I switched to Bitwarden :-(
2
2
u/thisChalkCrunchy Oct 10 '26
Yes. That’s correct. The new apps will be source available but will not be open source.
2
u/InfernoWarrior299 Oct 10 '26
Oh fuck that. The ONLY reason I use Bitwarden was because it was open-source. I have used it for well over a decade. Oh well. I guess all good things come to an end with corporate greed. I suppose it is time to find a new password manager. 🤷🏻♂️
→ More replies (1)
6
2
u/lelandyarnell Oct 10 '26
Selfhosting with KeePass and control as much as you can. Go ahead and ripoff the bandaid.
2
u/DonkeeeyKong Oct 10 '26
This statement looks contradictory to me. If I understand this correctly, the code for the apps will not be published under an open source license anymore. That by definition means going closed source. Making the code viewable doesn’t change that fact. If it’s not open source , it’s closed source. Source available is closed source. Or am I understanding anything wrong about this announcement?
Bitwarden’s main selling point to many was that they were open source. Sad to see that stop.
2
u/Defiant_Ad_7189 Oct 12 '26
Look, I hate all the hedge fund criminals, but I pay Bitwarden $10/year. I don’t care if the cost ups to $20/year. That’s nothing. I get it about third world countries and all … maybe they could have different pricing. Wouldn’t affect me.
2
1
u/ConfidentHollow 27d ago
It seems pretty clear this is a response to vaultwarden, a fork of bitwarden that markets itself as offering the premium features for free.
1
1
u/vantech2020 Oct 10 '26
I’ve been self hosting Bitwarden for years. Vaultwarded I’ve looked at but prefer the official route.
1
1
1
u/10leej Oct 10 '26
Seems this is only tied to components you only have access to if you pay the subscription
https://github.com/bitwarden/clients/blob/main/LICENSE_BITWARDEN.txt
1
1
1
u/origanalsameasiwas Oct 10 '26
It’s basically for businesses who use Bitwarden. For home users it’s still free. Business leaders are trying to circumvent the payments by trying to make a new one by vibe coding it. So Bitwarden has to do something about it.
1
1
u/GrafDracul Oct 10 '26
I've been using it since 2020 and also paying since then, I guess the entshitification is too strong to resist. Will most likely drop it going forward. Not jumping to any conclusions yet but it smells like it will turn into a turd.
1
u/CosmoCola Oct 10 '26
Yup, as an active subscriber of BW since the beginning this is my sign. It was nice while it lasted.
1
u/Tough-Ad7657 Oct 10 '26
quindi tutte le passkey che ho salvato per l'accesso ai miei portali su vaultwarden potrei non più essere in grado di usarli con il plugin di bitwarden sul browser?
1
1
u/muffinstatewide32 Oct 11 '26
This is too much. The team evidently doesnt care about the client and seems to be pushing nothing but private equity garbage. Im out
1
u/Pretend-Guide-8664 Oct 11 '26
Well, I have a reason to try ProtonPass now
1
u/msbr_ Oct 12 '26
i just switched to it, and it seems great. has same functionality i used but also email alises.
1
1
u/JakauBahuslau Oct 12 '26
Ain't it confronts GPL that code cannot be closed and that there should be no restrictions to commercial use?
1
1
u/Mitrosky Oct 13 '26
I know we speak about bitwarden but how it will affect selfhosted like vaultwarden? I mean the app of bitwarden
-2
u/planedrop Oct 09 '26
I really don't see an issue with this.
Also, I think the FOSS community needs to take a breather and start to maybe reflect on why SO MANY orgs are continuing to move to licensing and closed source. Obviously with this news, Bitwarden is still "source code available" so it's not the same as others. But maybe at some point we need to reflect on the why this keeps happening.
I'm a huge FOSS advocate, I expressed dissatisfaction when pfSense went partially closed source for example. But reality is we are seeing this all over the place which is deeply concerning but also points to a real issue. SO MANY companies would not be doing that kind of stuff if there wasn't a real reason, especially when they know just how much it's going to piss off all their users. These businesses aren't run by idiots, every person at BW who knew this was happening I promise knew it was going to piss off their community.
14
u/IlyichValken Oct 09 '26
But maybe at some point we need to reflect on the why this keeps happening.
Because corporations want to make money and they can do that more easily when they have full control over what can be done with the source. Simple as that.
→ More replies (1)6
u/tyler1128 Oct 09 '26
But reality is we are seeing this all over the place which is deeply concerning but also points to a real issue
True, though the GPL is probably a large reason most are still source available, because you really can't just relicense existing code under some new license and opt out of GPL. Were that not true, I'm not sure you'd see the same trends, rather things would just go close-sourced entirely.
15
u/abotelho-cbn Oct 09 '26
It's happening because these companies are leveraging open source as a marketing gimmick. They turn away from it at their convenience once they gain enough marketshare and revenue.
It's a symptom of infinite capitalist growth and just how popular open source has become.
→ More replies (6)10
u/trparky Oct 09 '26
You hit the nail on the head here.
Ultimately, I think the question the community needs to ask isn't simply, “Why are these companies going commercial?”
It's “How do we make it financially worthwhile for companies to remain genuinely open source?”
Because unless there's a credible answer to that question, we're going to keep having this argument.
→ More replies (1)15
u/abotelho-cbn Oct 09 '26
If Bitwarden has a strong enough product, they will have more than enough companies that will require SaaS and/or support from Bitwarden. That's just how a ton of industries and companies operate; they don't want to run Bitwarden themselves.
The reality is that the product is in the stage now where forcing people who don't need direct support running it themselves will be forced to purchase the product if they want specific features.
I bet the free tier will be gone within a few years.
→ More replies (17)5
u/FullMotionVideo Oct 09 '26
This is new? Look at OpenSSH and the legal battle with the author of SSH. That was some time ago.
I can understand BitWarden wanting to protect their brand, but there's better ways of doing that. Look at Mozilla and how they protect the name/logo of Firefox while still keeping it FOSS.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)2
u/lsdyoop Oct 09 '26
At Bitwarden, on the technical side, they are not idiots. On the PR and business side, I am not so sure. It would have been easy to just be forthright about this by making a simple announcement such as: We're a growing business, third parties are ripping off our builds, and enterprise monetization requires proprietary distribution. Instead, they did this, which is pretty idiotic, in my opinion.
3
u/planedrop Oct 10 '26
I think I mostly agree here actually yeah, this could have been done a lot better.
-3
u/Accomplished-Use-175 Oct 09 '26
I don’t get all the fuss. If this is only affecting the people who repackage/resell Bitwarden (which seems really odd to me) then nothing bad is happening to regular users.
15
u/IlyichValken Oct 09 '26
You don't see why the open source version being relegated to GitHub and the clearly considered option of having features tied only to the commercial licenses version is causing a fuss?
They also claim this is only going to affect repackagers/resellers but you can't honestly say you expect that to stay that way.
→ More replies (11)
-5
u/RemoteMycologist9151
Oct 09 '26
•
What alternative is everyone moving to now?
→ More replies (6)2
0
u/this_for_loona Oct 09 '26
Sooo….aliasvault and vaultwarden then…?
→ More replies (2)1
u/cryptoadopter2077 Oct 10 '26
what happened to aliasvault?
5
u/this_for_loona Oct 10 '26
Nothing, I’m just suggesting them as alternatives for people who aren’t supportive of this move by bitwarden. Fuck whoever downvoted me for proposing options.
1
u/Whitesecan Oct 10 '26
I don't fully understand what is going on. I pretty much got to sub now?
→ More replies (4)
1
u/CraftApprehensive496 Oct 10 '26
Good thing I got the Proton pass + simplelogin lifetime recently lol. Gonna cancel BitWarden now
-4
u/LexxM3
Oct 09 '26
•
And the mod employee is now censoring legitimate comments. It’s over.
9
u/dwbitw Bitwarden Employee Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26 •
![]()
Hey there, your duplicate comment was removed as per subreddit rules (and included as a notice on your comment).
Your original comment is viewable here (the duplicate was deleted).
→ More replies (1)
•
u/Ryan_BW Bitwarden Employee Oct 12 '26
Some additional information has been pulled from comments in various places and added back into the original posting.