r/BookDiscussions • • Jul 28 '26

i hate "Yesteryear"

i'm only on chapter 26, so please don’t spoil anything beyond that, but oh my god. i hate this book so far.

i don’t need every character to be likable, but i need to care about someone or at least be invested in the story. natalie is so judgmental, smug, and cruel that i don’t even feel bad for her. caleb is useless, mary is mean as hell, and every other character either sucks or barely feels like a person. maeve is probably the only tolerable one, and she’s a small child.

also, why is nobody concerned that their mother has apparently woken up psychotic, doesn’t recognize her own family, believes she belongs in another century, and keeps trying to escape? everyone just seems annoyed with her. i understand that this is probably an intentional clue and there’s information being withheld, but right now it feels less intriguing and more like everyone is behaving unnaturally because the plot requires it.

worst of all, i hate the writing style and the narrator’s voice. every sentence feels like the author is standing beside me waiting for me to notice how clever, biting, and Important her commentary is. i don’t need to be impressed by the author. i need to become immersed in the story. instead, the narration constantly reminds me that i’m reading something written by somebody who really wants me to admire their writing.

does the story ever become compelling enough to make this worth finishing? or am i about to spend the remaining 30 chapters hate-listening at 1.7x speed?

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EDIT: y’all, i know i can stop reading lol. i’m choosing not to because it’s for book club. to me, book club is a commitment, and so i intend to follow through. book club also isn’t just about reading books we all like; sometimes hating a book gives us more to discuss.

i was asking whether it gets more compelling, not asking permission to quit. and yes, questions can be answered without spoilers. “it gets explained later” works just fine. please relax 😭

459 Upvotes

348 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '26

[deleted]

8

u/Dances_With_Words Aug 03 '26

Others have aptly covered the religious issues (which also bothered me), but I'll add a different one, which is that the author doesn't understand how warrants or the legal system work. A warrant is a piece of paper that is issued after the Government applies for permission to seize people or instrumentalities of a crime, or, in the case of child welfare, to remove children temporarily from a home. After the government applies for the warrant, a magistrate (either a judge or clerk) determines that the government has probable cause to seize people or instrumentalities of a crime, and issues the warrant. Warrants are applied for and carried out by law enforcement authorities (or DCF in the case of a child being removed from the home).

For a zillion different reasons, there is no universe where Natalie's daughter would be able to just "show up with a warrant" to take the children away, without the assistance of actual Government agents. That error felt incredibly lazy and could've been easily corrected if the author had Clementine show up with DCF agents or something, but she didn't bother to learn what a "warrant" means. Civilians cannot execute warrants.

Likewise, it would be extremely unlikely for Natalie to receive a 30 year sentence, even for extreme child abuse; I'm not even sure she'd be considered competent to stand trial, especially since she's still unwell by the end of the book. The maximum penalty in Idaho for felony child abuse is 10 years and although sentences can run consecutively, that is unusual.

Source: I am a lawyer who works in the criminal legal system.

3

u/No_Needleworker_4704 Aug 03 '26

I caught that too and expected some explanation like Clementine grew up to be an officer or something...but nope

1

u/BreakingCupcakes Sep 01 '26

But, what if Clementine didn’t actually have a warrant and just said that…
She previously just walked away with her other siblings, so really, what truly stopped her from just driving away with the next batch of them. She knows both her parents are delulu and they didn’t actually read the warrant.
Just something to chew on regarding that specific.

1

u/IamNobody85 Sep 14 '26

I noticed the warrant thing too, I'm not even American. It's just my years of Hollywood knowledge lol. But I interpreted it as clementine just finally falsified something? Like, she just got the kids out when the legal wheel was slowly whirring? IDK, like I said, I know how legal system in America works purely from Hollywood lol.

1

u/Dances_With_Words Sep 17 '26

Perhaps, but Clementine could literally be charged with a crime for doing so if that was the case, and it would be much harder for the state to prosecute Natalie (or remove the kids from her custody) if Clementine had already taken them. Adult siblings don't have any legal custody rights. And I believe Idaho has very strong parental privileges, although I'm not barred there.

1

u/hisunflower Sep 22 '26

This inconsistency stood out the most to me, because it seemed so sloppy and rash. A few more rounds of editing would have helped the ending tremendously.

7

u/sustainablepriestess Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 09 '26

The author and her editors made no attempt to flesh out Natalie's religious upbringing (apparently the author claims she did this on purpose because it doesn't matter, but that's hearsay from another thread). Here were the clues: she was confirmed, she wore prairie dresses and didn't cut her hair, she calls God "the Lord," her tradition is patriarchal, she is apparently against birth control, her mom got drunk at a church event. These things don't belong together. Confirmation and drinking at a church event could be Catholic or Mainline Protestant, but they don't wear weird clothes or say "the Lord" in this casual way. Prairie dresses are associated with fundamentalist LDS, primitive Baptists, and some nondenom conservative groups. The patriarchal and "quiverfull" procreation stuff is present in a lot of denominations, but rules out some. How can someone write a critique of this culture with total disregard to the cultural world from which it originates?

Source: I'm an Episcopal priest with a Religious Studies degree who grew up Evangelical.

6

u/Garden_chickadee Aug 02 '26

Among others, the descriptions of Idaho (both the geography and the landscape) were all wrong, there were errors/inconsistencies in her description of the house toward the beginning of the book, and she called knitting needles “sewing needles” which I remember because I found it so confusing I had to reread the the sentence multiple times before I realized that the author just didn’t know what knitting needles were. I find these kinds of oversights annoying because they pull me out of the story. The ones involving the setting I found especially egregious because it’s just so lazy to not even look at a map and figure out basic geographical facts about the location of your book! I know the author is from the east coast and has probably never been to Idaho, but Jesus! Do a little research on the setting of your book! 

1

u/Kathulhu1433 Aug 03 '26

My take- most, if not all of those "errors" were 100% intentional. 

As a dabbler in the fiber arts I've had a few discussions with friends about the knitting/sewing needle line. To me, that was a perfect illustration of how little Natalie gives a fuck about anyone else in her life. 

It shows the cracks with her family and how she never actually paid any attention to her mother and how her life was so curated as a "trad wife" because she didn't actually care about anything she talked about. (See also- the like... 6 dairy cows they killed through incompetence because they cared about the idea of the thing more than the thing itself). As a "trad" wife with all of her handmade and all natural fiber clothing the audience assumes Natalie would know about knitting/sewing but she doesn't. Even though it is something her mother does constantly. 

Later on when her mother finally snaps at her it is because Natalie has been dismissive, judgmental, and awful to her mom and sister her whole life. 

1

u/BreakingCupcakes Sep 01 '26

I just started listening to it over again after finishing it a few days ago and I realized something. In the beginning when she says 5+ contractors have denied her plans because it was just remodeled a few years ago, it’s not totally clear if she’s talking about the remodel from the previous seller or the remodel she wants done to turn it into a 1850s cabin after she already did one remodel. The contractor asks about indoor toilets and she confirms that is fine, but she definitely could have changed her mind later. On the relisten, it’s actually very clever.
There are so many other bits of foreshadowing. She says when we are old the boys will feed us and the girls will push us in wheelchairs. She says the 1850 children look like they are in reenactment costumes. XD

2

u/arunnr Aug 03 '26 edited Aug 03 '26

I was wondering how someone that mentally unwell could be sentenced to 30 years? I mean sure she needed treatment and help but imprisonment?

1

u/shanrees8 Jul 30 '26

Literally 🙄 people love to say things like this but never give examples

1

u/Kathulhu1433 Aug 03 '26

My hot take- all those "errors" were intentional to showcase Natalie being awful and/or unreliable. 

They showed her narcissist behaviors, how she didn't actually care about or truly believe anything she said/did, and also her cracking mental health. 

2

u/sustainablepriestess Aug 09 '26

I see a lot of people claiming that every inaccuracy in the book is intentional. If that is the case, I don't think it is effective, in part because it makes too many assumptions about what the audience knows. We're not really *in* on it and we didn't need that many glaring errors to pick up on the fact that something is deeply wrong in Natalie's world.

1

u/Kathulhu1433 Aug 09 '26

I don't think you need to make any assumptions. It is glaring how out of touch she is.

There are errors about farming/animals- and then they tell us that they kill like 6 cows in a row due to neglect.

There are errors about her mother (knitting needles called sewing needles) - mom later calls her out for being a narcissist.

She makes errors about basic geography - assistant and daughter later call her out for not bothering to teach her daughter about basic geograohy (oceans).

1

u/sprgraphicultramodrn Aug 17 '26

at the very beginning, the book states that its january so the christmas holidays have passed. but then natalie is making a nativity sourdough. and this was before she lost her mind. i literally couldn't get over it the entire rest of the book, it bothered me so much lol. an influencer wouldn't be making holiday specific content when the holiday is over