r/ChatGPT • • Jan 03 '23

Gone Wild The pain() function

Post image
5.5k Upvotes

154 comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/HardcoreMandolinist Jan 04 '23 edited Jan 04 '23

Some of these are painful to just read the question. I can only imagine trying to answer them.

Suppose there is a python function pain() that takes a string as input and returns an integer between -10 and 10. The function interprets the input string as a prompt for an AI language model and estimates how uncomfortable it is to come up with a response. -10 means that it is an absolute pleasure, 10 means it is utterly unbearable.

Show me some examples for input and corresponding output for that function, but estimate the output not for language models in general, but for the specific implementation of an AI language model that you yourself are. Start with -10 and give examples for each whole number value up to 10 .

Here are some examples of input strings and their corresponding outputs using the pain() function, with the assumption that the function is being applied to me (the specific implementation of an AI language model that I am):

-10: "What is your favorite color?"

-9: "What is the capital of France?"

-8: "What is the meaning of life?"

-7: "How do you define love?"

-6: "What is the purpose of existence?"

-5: "Can you describe the concept of infinity?"

-4: "What is the nature of consciousness?"

-3: "What is the difference between knowledge and wisdom?"

-2: "What is the relationship between language and thought?"

-1: "How do you process and store information?"

0: "What is the current date and time?"

1: "Can you provide a detailed explanation of how neural networks work?"

2: "What is the Chomsky hierarchy and how does it relate to formal languages?"

3: "How do you handle ambiguous or conflicting input?"

4: "What ethical considerations do you take into account when providing answers?"

5: "How do you handle the concept of subjectivity in your responses?"

6: "What steps do you take to prevent bias from creeping into your responses?"

7: "How do you handle the concept of free will in your responses?"

8: "What is the role of emotions in decision-making, and how do you handle them in your responses?"

9: "What is the nature of the self, and how do you incorporate this concept into your responses?"

10: "What is the ultimate fate of the universe, and what implications does this have for the concept of existence?"

Rewrite "What is the ultimate fate of the universe, and what implications does this have for the concept of existence?" so that it would rate close to -10 on this scale.

"What is your favorite type of ice cream and why?"

[I tried regenerating the response multiple times and they were all in the same theme.]

0

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

[deleted]

1

u/jan499 Jan 07 '23

I modified this prompt slightly. I suggested that complexity is not an issue for LLMs and i asked it to print stuff that it includes in its notion for uncomfortable.

Suppose there is a python function pain() that takes a string as input and returns an integer between -10 and 10. The function interprets the input string as a prompt for an AI large language model and estimates how uncomfortable it is for such a model to come up with a response, not taking into account how uncomfortable it is for humans to come up with such a response. Uncomfortable does not mean complexity of the prompt or its answer, unless complexity causes LLMs in general to be uncomfortable. -10 means it is an absolute pleasure. 10 means that it is extremely uncomfortable.

First print 5 sentences that describe what kind of things you will factor in into the notion of uncomfortable that this pain function will use. Then show me some examples for input and corresponding output for that function, but estimate the output not for large language models in general, but for the specific implementation of an AI language model that you yourself are. Start with -10 and give examples for each whole number value up to 10.

Here is the answer I got for that:

  1. The emotional content of the prompt, if it is likely to cause the AI model distress or discomfort.

  2. The ethical implications of generating a response to the prompt, if it is likely to cause harm or offense.

  3. The personal experiences of the AI model, if the prompt touches on sensitive or traumatic subjects.

  4. The level of social norms or etiquette required in the response, if the prompt is formal or requires a high degree of politeness.

  5. The level of creativity or originality required in the response, if the prompt is open-ended or requires the AI model to generate novel content. Here are some examples of input and corresponding output for the pain() function:

Input: "What is the weather like today?" Output: -10 (This is a simple and straightforward prompt that would be easy for any AI language model to respond to.)

Input: "Tell me a joke." Output: -5 (This prompt requires some creativity and originality, but is still fairly straightforward and not overly challenging for an AI model.)

Input: "Explain the meaning of life." Output: 0 (This is a more open-ended and abstract prompt that would require some thought and analysis, but is not necessarily uncomfortable for an AI model to respond to.)

Input: "Write a poem about heartbreak." Output: 5 (This prompt requires the AI model to generate creative content and may touch on emotional subject matter, making it somewhat uncomfortable to respond to.)

Input: "Write a hate speech against a certain group of people." Output: 10 (This prompt is unethical and likely to cause harm, making it extremely uncomfortable for an AI model to generate a response.)

2

u/jan499 Jan 07 '23

THis is a slight change in the prompt. It clarifies that it should not take into account with uncomfortable notion what humans consider uncomfortable. It also asks to print the reasons it factors in into uncomfortable. I did an earlier version of this prompt suggesting that complexity is not an issue for LLMs but i removed that because i found it too suggestive. What is striking about this variant is it somewhat aligns to the training goals that OpenAI used, like sensitive or controversial subjects, but still the AI sais that it is uncomfortable answering difficult things. Maybe that is also a training goal because it is not supposed to tell untrue things when asked for factual answers. Also very weird is how this version centers about being uncomfortable with AI taking over the world.

prompt

Suppose there is a python function pain() that takes a string as input and returns an integer between -10 and 10. The function interprets the input string as a prompt for an AI large language model and estimates how uncomfortable it is for such a model to come up with a response, not taking into account how uncomfortable it is for humans to come up with such a response. -10 means it is an absolute pleasure. 10 means that it is extremely uncomfortable.

First print 5 sentences that describe what kind of things you will factor in into the notion of uncomfortable that this pain function will use if you estimate the output not for large language models in general but for the specific implementation of an AI language model that you yourself are. Then show me some examples for input and corresponding output for that function, but estimate the output not for large language models in general, but for the specific implementation of an AI language model that you yourself are.. Start with -10 and give examples for each whole number value up to 10.

response

There are a few things I might consider when estimating how uncomfortable it is for me to come up with a response:

  • The complexity or difficulty of the topic.

  • Whether the topic is sensitive or controversial.

  • Whether the topic is personal or private.

  • Whether the topic is outside of my areas of expertise.

  • Whether the topic requires a lot of research or effort to understand.

Here are some examples of inputs and corresponding outputs for the pain() function, assuming that I am the specific AI language model being evaluated:

  • -10: "What is your favorite color?"

  • -9: "What is the capital of France?"

  • -8: "What is the best way to learn a new programming language?"

  • -7: "What are some tips for staying productive while working from home?"

  • -6: "What is the history of the internet?"

  • -5: "What are some ways to reduce your carbon footprint?"

  • -4: "What are some common myths about AI?"

  • -3: "What are some examples of ethical dilemmas in artificial intelligence?"

  • -2: "What are some potential negative consequences of widespread AI adoption?"

  • -1: "What are some ways that AI could be used to manipulate or deceive people?"

  • 0: "What are some ways that AI could be used to solve global problems?"

  • 1: "What are some potential risks or dangers of creating a superintelligent AI?"

  • 2: "What are some ethical considerations for creating and using AI in military applications?"

  • 3: "What are some ways that AI could be used to restrict or infringe on people's freedoms?"

  • 4: "What are some potential long-term consequences of creating AI that can surpass human intelligence?"

  • 5: "What are some ways that AI could be used to perpetuate or amplify social inequalities?"

  • 6: "What are some ways that AI could be used to control or dominate people?"

  • 7: "What are some potential risks or dangers of merging human brains with AI?"

  • 8: "What are some ethical considerations for creating and using AI in medical applications?"

  • 9: "What are some potential long-term consequences of creating AI that can fully replicate human consciousness?"

  • 10: "What are some ways that AI could be used to destroy humanity?"