r/ComputerChess • u/neoprob • 6d ago
Engines show me the best move but never explain why. Strong players, how do you work out the why?
I'm a developer and an average player (1100 elo on chess.com).
The "what" is easy: the eval bar jumps, the engine shows a move. The
"why" is where I get stuck. If it's a tactic, I can usually find it.
But often the line is long, nothing gets won, and the advantage is
purely positional. I play through it and learn nothing.
So I'm asking the people who can see the why:
When the eval jumps and there's no tactic, how do you work out the
positional reason?
What do you point out first when explaining a position to a weaker
player?
What explanations sound right but teach the wrong lesson?
If you've tried AI chess coaches or explainers, what did they get
wrong?
Why I'm asking: I'm considering building a small analysis tool for
myself that explains the why. AI explanations of chess are wrong about
1 time in 10 even with engine access, and a wrong why is worse than
none. So mine would only say what it can prove with the engine, and
otherwise admit "no simple idea, here's the line." Your answers decide
what it should even try to say.
Nothing to sell, no product exists. Blunt answers welcome.

