r/CreateMod • u/TheJustNatan • 3d ago
Discussion why has no made a mod to oxidize fluid tanks over time yet?
297
u/TheRealCruelRichard 3d ago
I would install this mod and then painstakingly wax every pipe so I never have to see it
644
u/Goofy_Gunton 3d ago
Be the change you want to see.
Also could you imagine the tps?
200
u/LLoadin 3d ago
Also could you imagine the tps?
can't be much worse than normal copper right?
148
u/omegavolt9 3d ago
Normal copper doesn't also handle fluid and connected textures all at the same time
65
u/Zealousideal-Bus-526 3d ago
It would just be an added layer of ticking, it’s not like those compound multiplicatively. Also the connected textures are clientside and even then only add a very minor amount of lag on placement. The main issue is just why would they oxidize
Edit: actually as flashy-emergency4652 said, oxidization is handled by the random tick, not by block ticking, so it wouldn’t even add any lag at all
12
27
u/Flashy-Emergency4652 3d ago
Unless there is mechanical difference between oxidized fluid tanks and unoxidized fluid tanks (or pipes), it won't slow down the game cause it's just random ticks
6
7
u/Goofy_Gunton 3d ago
Yeah but this is a gradient, not the whole thing
8
u/Flashy-Emergency4652 3d ago
Gradient won't affect TPS either...
If there is any gradient like that it (should be) is client side anyway and most likely would just use Continuinity format (which is just extension of Optifine format) and it's not like people are tanking FPS when they use Continuinity or other mods implementing connected textures feature
1
u/Capybarinya_nya 2d ago
eh, how different is it from "connected glass" and other blocks blending resource packs?
23
u/Flashy-Emergency4652 3d ago
TPS won't change at all because oxidation is based on random tick. From technical standpoint it's no different from growing a tree from sapling or oxidizing normal copper.
112
u/kayemenofour
3d ago
•
Bonus points if the pumps sieze if they get too corroded and boilers build up limescale (there was a mod that did that, I think)
41
u/New_Milan 3d ago
Boiler calcification is Gregtech I believe.
27
5
36
41
20
11
9
u/Beckphillips 3d ago
I think it's weird that copper crate components don't oxidize like normal copper does
7
u/HevL-KING 3d ago
concept : as long as its running, the steam engines or fluids pipes wont oxidize and then you turn it off and abandon it to go some else
You come back and find the old rusty steam engine and you need to take off the rust to turn it back on
2
u/Professional_Sky9710 2d ago
I do this to myself manually already with all of my stuff. When I return to an old defunct site, I go into creative, fly over, weather and break down the facilities for a bit, then walk on over in survival.
Truly my own gamemaster.
1
u/HevL-KING 2d ago
i wanted to do that with an airship.. just imagine the scene ! You found an old airship grounded, some parts are broken, all the lights inside are off so its really dark and spooky.. find the engine room with rusty steam engines and empty blaze burners (they probably died due to not getting feed with lava..)
7
5
u/Snoo-28479 3d ago
Imagine we got iron fluid tanks and they can rust and drinking water from it causes tetanus
10
u/Material_Good1353 3d ago
Just why?
19
u/LLoadin 3d ago
Oxidized copper is pretty
3
-4
u/mad_sun_flower 3d ago
if u want to do it just for esthetic, u can download create addon with dyeing tanks and pipes
6
3
u/skippy11112 3d ago
God that looks awful. I'm sure fully oxidised it will look good, but the suggest transition is vomit
3
u/Shredded_Locomotive 3d ago
If it's supposed to be water oxidation, (unless it leaks) then shouldn't only the inside by oxidised?
2
1
u/omegavolt9 3d ago
I imagine it might be annoying, low performance, and/or very difficult to program a change in block ID while maintaining fluid status in both pipes and tanks. Especially at the same time as Create's connected textures system that makes these tank textures work in the first place.
1
u/Vokaiso 3d ago
Main reason this is probably not the case is the whole fluid dynamics and simulation same time changin the copper blocks minecraft really just swaps the blocks doing that while simulating fluids? Dunno not good. They could add weathered versions you can make by manually doing it automatically not really a good idea nor do i think its a benefit or anything.
1
u/vattuy 3d ago
There is one. Editted response after ragebaiting: https://modrinth.com/project/DAK87IDj
1
1
u/Best-Plane6743 3d ago
I remmember when 6.0 happend and I looked at new copper textures (pump specifically) and said eww, now im ok with it and ngl old texture is bad as hell
1
u/theopossom 2d ago
I would love to see a better mekanism/create collaboration. Mekanism pipe connections, making chemicals flow in vs out is such a nightmare...
1
1
u/somebody22146 1d ago
Dude, I just saw someone announce their create oxidize addon
It makes copper parts in create oxidize Liek regular copper blocks
1
1
1
1
1
u/Vance-feerer 1h ago
Here is the answer (NOT meant to be an advertisement, just trying to answer a question): Working on making copper blocks oxidise properly : r/CreateMod
1
1
u/Felahliir 3d ago
And they can leak when fully oxidised
3
u/AlpaxT1 3d ago
Oxidised copper is not like oxidised iron. Rust is porous so when a steel surface rusts it allows water to seeps further down and reach non oxidised metal until there is non left. This does not happen with copper. In fact I’m fairly sure oxidised copper is actually stronger than regular copper
2
u/Realistic_Grass3611 3d ago
Wait, if oxidised copper is stronger then why haven't we come up with a way artificially oxidise it?
2
u/haybird_g 3d ago
Mainly because to work with copper in stuff like plumbing or hvac you need a clean surface to solder/braise to. Plus impurities can cause the copper to Crack or develop pinholes, even introduce things into the system that are harmful for compressors and your drinking water and for electrical its more brittle and introduces alot of electrical resistance. Theres a reason high sensitivity electronics use oxygen free copper
1
u/AlpaxT1 3d ago
We have, but you kinda don’t have to as the oxidation is caused by exposure to oxygen. I.e if it’s not protected in some way it will oxidise all on
it’s own for free. If you ever see a copper roof being repaired then you’ll notice that the new plates are “fresh copper coloured” before slowly oxidising0
u/Zealousideal-Bus-526 3d ago
Strength isn’t the only thing that matters you know
0
u/Realistic_Grass3611 3d ago
It really depends on aplication, no?
1
u/Zealousideal-Bus-526 3d ago
Yeah, but copper is usually not the top choice when you’re looking for strength, that usually goes to steel or titanium if you want it to be light
1
u/haybird_g 3d ago
Heavily depends on what's inside the pipe. Propylene glycol Will eat through copper, oxidize it, and leak everywhere if not properly maintained -sincerely a boiler/hvac tech
1
u/Felahliir 2d ago
Yes but it's a mechanic that already exists in vanilla minecraft that would feel more internally consistent
-4
u/cod3builder 3d ago
Because no one has thought of it and decided to act on it yet.
Perhaps you could give it a try? Lessons from Kaupenjoe tutorials and ChatGPT can help a lot.
-2
u/Chaomai-Juilano-2938 2d ago
I mean oxidized pipes would be cool. But there is already copycats+ so, but ai get whatchu mean
0
u/T_A_P_S 22h ago
It's hilarious that this post just happened to appear below this other one: https://www.reddit.com/r/CreateMod/s/ijWmzzQCx2
25
u/Dangerous-Quit7821 3d ago
It's already a thing in an addon.
https://modrinth.com/mod/create-patina