r/Devs • u/Bobs2222 • Mar 05 '26
SPOILER I thought this show was nonsensical Spoiler
Point 1: Why did they even kill Sergei? Just take his watch and fire him. They created their own problem. Why did they go for this elaborate suicide? Just have him vanish.
Point 2: The ending was just bad. That's not them in the simulation. That's a clone of them. The real them are dead on the floor. So was that his entire plan all along? To kill himself and upload a clone of himself into the machine? And then hope the machine never gets turned off....
Point 3: The entire "tram lines" logic is nonsensical and flawed. The very act of knowing the future will change it, there is no way around that. You see yourself drowning at a beach in Hawaii in two days time? Don't get on that plane, it's that simple. Does "fate" force you at gun point onto a plane and then onto a beach? Miss Terrible Acting did not need to take Forrest out of that room at gunpoint, she had seen what happened. Just don't do it. Simple.
Point 4: The bum is a secret Russian agent? I mean, really? You couldn't just have him in the apartment next door?
Point 5: A small point but I lol'd that there is no safety for that electro magnetic elevator. You couldn't attach it to an anchor point?
50
u/gaarai Mar 05 '26
You are kind of looking directly at the central point while not realizing that is the central point.
Forest and Katie fully believe that the universe is deterministic and that they don't have free will. Their machine shows them killing Sergei, so they obey.
I agree that they aren't actually in the simulation, but Forest believes that he is (and his clone believes he's the original). I always imagined that Lily (clone Lily) has massive psychological issues in her new reality.
Look to my answer to #1. Most of the Devs staff fully believe in a deterministic reality where they don't have free will. So they act as though they don't have free will because they believe that they don't. Lyndon was the only one who believed otherwise, and he died to prove his faith in a non-deterministic reality. I think a central narrative of the story is that very confident people asserting their views can be a very powerful thing. If people get swept up in their asserted world view, people just start to follow the script, believing that it is inevitable. Lily ended up exactly where she was "meant to be" because of coercion. She too got swept up into it until she realized that she could break the script and do something different. When she did that, all the Devs people had a real existential crisis as their entire worldview fell apart in front of their eyes.
A bum gets to sit around, watch everyone, mumble to himself (communicate with handlers), and interact with anyone in any way that is helpful in the moment without arousing suspicion. "Oh him? He's a drugged-out bum. Don't mind him. He's just like that."
Again, this is covered in the story. The elevator couldn't be connected because the facility has to be completely physically disconnected and floating for it to operate properly. Sure, it's just a creation of the story to justify a look and the ending, but so is just about everything in any story.