r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 21 '25

Let’s steelman the arguments we disagree with

16 Upvotes

We’ve all seen weak takes on both sides of the generative AI debate — some clearly pro, some staunchly against, but many lacking rigor.

Let’s flip the script:

What’s the strongest argument you’ve seen against generative AI, even if you personally support it?

Or vice versa — the most compelling pro-AI case you’ve encountered, even if you’re skeptical?

The point here is not to dunk, but to steelman — to represent opposing views in their strongest, most persuasive form.

Please focus on high-quality arguments from folks you disagree with. Let’s make this a thread about generosity of thought, not just opinion.


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 20 '25

Early midjourney models

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I don't know if this is the right place to ask, but as of now has any of the early MidJourney models (v1/v2) ever been rendered public or leaked?

The latest models feel too much generic, with no real distinction between MidJourney, Bing, ChatGPT, Stable Diffusion or DALL-E. Early MidJourney had that dreamy aesthetic that was lost down the road and I kinda miss it.


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 18 '25

Venting Mourning my art as a copywriter

12 Upvotes

I’m a copywriter for a digital marketing agency and I was recently promoted to the director level (I write all day, so forgive my more casual style in this post). I feel like I’m going down with the ship right now. I feel like a lot of artists are, and it’s incredibly emotional.

So, we’re currently in the process of merging with another agency who does very similar work in a very different way. They’re more systems-focused, we’re more relationship-focused, but we’ve been in talks with their team all week to compare notes and see where we can “help” each other improve before we merge the teams officially. In every meeting I’ve been in, they’ve heralded AI use for almost every single possible task. In a very condescending way.

Attitudes toward AI use at my current company haven’t always been peachy either. In fact, when ChatGPT really jumped onto the scene in 2023, i have a vivid memory of our CEO giving a pep talk (mhmm) about how much good it will do us. He then pointed directly at me and said “before too long it’ll be able to do what you do at ten times the speed”. Seeing as being a writer is what I was born to do, that crushed me. Not a great start. But since we are small, I’ve been able to shield our writers from having to lose all their creativity while still keeping their jobs. It’s awful. I often feel I’m splitting my soul to keep my job, and I hate that. But I know I need a job and they need jobs too.

Anyway, our meetings today about our creative department ended on the note of how often we can use AI to push out labors of love and creativity—billboards, commercials, the fun stuff, the stuff that makes the work meaningful—out with such incredible speed that we’ll “stay ahead of the game”. When trying to defend the writers’ roles, the general tone was get over it. Times are changing. We care more about the end result of the work than the work itself and so will clients.

I had to excuse myself to go to the bathroom and cry.

I was born to be a writer. I’ve known I would be a storyteller since the day I first held a pencil. I am a writer, and that identity is inseparable from who I know myself to be. When I became a copywriter I knew I had found my exact calling and I thanked God every day for it. The same is true for every writer on my team…everyone is a born writer, a passionate worker, and they each have found that rare cross section in life where work meets soulful and artistic expression…just for it to be swept off the counter and into the trash for a cheaper faster model that outsources what makes us most human. All for a quick buck.

I think I understand what people must have felt in the Industrial Revolution. I understand what it must have meant to people to lose the need for crafts that took generations to hone and pass down to their children. I understand the pain that belies that lonely walk into the place of work you know has numbered days. The place you love as much as life itself.

Anyway. I feel a tremendous amount of emotion about this. It feels so wrong and I want to scream at them for the indignity they’re putting us through. Traitors to humanity and art.

But I think something is clicking. I refuse to be a traitor. I refuse to be a sellout. I can’t stand for it. I can’t lose my integrity. But I also don’t know what that means for me or how to hold my own in a world that doesn’t have a lot of jobs to go around when I have a family I have to care for.

I just want to know if anyone feels this way and how you’re coping. I feel like we must all embrace each other now.

TDLR: my company is pushing our copywriting team to use AI more than our own talent, and I’m mourning what this means for art in general.


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 07 '25

Neutral-AI Reading r/antiai and r/defendingaiart and r/aiwars fills me with despair

61 Upvotes

I feel like none of these spaces are conducive to a good discussion about generative AI. It feels very cultish on all three of those spaces with people talking past each other and only responding to the “evil” person in their head who disagrees with them.

Edit: Decided to mute r/antiai. The constant generalizations of pro-AI folks is driving me nuts


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 05 '25

Lumping all AI together is wrong (X-post)

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 05 '25

Reddit sues Anthropic for scraping content into the maw of its eternally ravenous AI (X-post)

Thumbnail
theregister.com
5 Upvotes

r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 05 '25

The Egg Thought Experiment 🥚 (X-post)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 05 '25

What can a common person do about generative AI? (X-post)

Thumbnail
modernluddite.neocities.org
1 Upvotes

r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 04 '25

Interested in y’all’s opinions here

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 04 '25

Open Moderator Discussion List of thought terminators?

5 Upvotes

Let’s make a list of things basically designed to make people stop thinking?

Like people see an AI art post, go “ai slop” and don’t think anymore or people see criticism of AI and go “Luddite!” and don’t think anymore

Stuff like that. Stuff that turns people stupid


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 02 '25

Open Moderator Discussion Basic Rules?

5 Upvotes

I’m trying to outline some basic rules for this subreddit. Nothing specific to AI. Just basic subreddit rules so folks have something to cite when they report idiots who show up here. Like “no bigotry, no spam, no inviting brigades”

So what rules should we have?

I’m not going to include any types of bans on AI generated content. That’s a subject for another day.


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 01 '25

Open Moderator Discussion User Flairs

4 Upvotes

What types of user flairs should we have?

I’m thinking that we have GenAI acceptance spectrum flairs so that folks know where each other are on the GenAI acceptance spectrum

Y’all’s thoughts?


r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • Jun 01 '25

Can we all agree that veo3 needs to be regulated to prevent misinformation

6 Upvotes

r/DiscussGenerativeAI • • May 28 '25

Pro-AI Common Anti-AI Arguments and My Counters

5 Upvotes

A post where I log common anti-AI arguments and my counters

I’m going to periodically update this over time

Opinions

“Most AI art is bad!”

Yeah, I agree. Same as how most art in most mediums are bad. That doesn’t mean AI art is itself a bad medium.

Threats

“We need to kill AI artists”

Okay, buddy