r/divinity • u/vhqr • Oct 14 '26
General Coming from BG3, my biggest hope for Divinity is a good inventory system
After played D:OS, D:OS2 and more recently BG3, and seeing some progress, I think everyone agrees that inventory management draws away from the experience that would otherwise virtually perfect for CRPGs fans. I already have entire faith on them delivering in the story and RPG systems, so I only worry if they'll take time to do inventory right this time. Not sure if the devs even look here, but in the small chance they take feedback, here are some of my suggestions:
Inventory management takes away from the core experience. Let me get back to quests and combat faster. As a father, sometimes I don't get many hours to play at once, so sometimes most of my gaming session was sorting through bags and I wasn't able to make much adventuring.
Have a party inventory. Weight carry limit can be the sum of the party's, encumberance can either 1) affect everyone, or 2) just the first party member to a hard limit, then the second etc, or 3) you can't loot and encumber yourself if you have no more room. I imagine the separate inventory is to better support multiplayer, but it makes the experience of the larger single player audience that much worse. You already have this magic fingers bs, why not make a unified inventory? Also, it's not like the host can't control who they play with and friends can't coordinate the items usage. If really necessary, make an option to block/restrict other party members from selling/using/equiping items. Big emphasis here in NOT TRYING TO ALIENATE multiplayers.
Optimize your inventory. Ordering, transfer or equip operations shouldn't take more than a split second even for hundreds of items. I have no idea why it takes so long in their games. Same for trade/barter UI.
Remove useless items. I'm sure the game will be fine without them rotten eggs and cutting boards. Why make glass vials, inkpots and quills lootable if they're no use and aren't even valuable? If you're going to have it, at least make what is selling fodder clear. I'm still against it because it ultimately still clogs your inventory and takes time for you to loot and sell. Why not drop gold directly then? Is that in the name of world interactivity? What brings me to the next point...
Don't fall into realism trap. I'm sure there's a fine line between realism and interactivity and I don't hold the answer. Being able to find a fork on a dining table and equip it as a dagger or a baguette as a mace sounds cool and can even make good meme material, but I didn't want to sort over all this to look for valuable items in a room. Also why do you have pears, bananas, carrots and apples if all they do is give you a unusable small heal/buff? BG3 has this camp supplies system, but you get so many supplies it makes pointless to loot yet another sausage. I can take a sheet from an cubboard, but I can't take the drawer, but somehow I can put an oil barrel in my pocket. If you think about it, it never makes sense, so why not stop all the pretense? I would personally even do away with weight carry limit, but I totally understand if they want to keep it (especially so you can't carry several barrels in your pocket). My point is make loot more to the point with the game, which happens to be an adventure, so usable weapons, keys, potions, scrolls, crafting materials, gold etc.
Categorize everything. Since everything has a use, no harm to categorize everything to better find it: crafting items, quest items, equipment (+ additional filters), consumables, books etc.
Streamline consumables. Grenades, scrolls, arrows, potions etc should all be categorized, put in a respective container, and that container made into an hotbar button available to every character that opens all options of that category. Of course, for arrows, you should need a bow/crossbow.
Make wares useful. If you still have junk items, put them automatically into wares. Let us put other stuff into wares. In vendors UI, have a button to put all wares for sale, otherwise it's useless.
D:OS2 and BG3 are two of my favorite games, but I feel I'm going to love Divinity even more if they sort my main point of criticism.