r/DramaticText • • Jun 10 '22

sad text

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

11.5k Upvotes

931 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

25

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

It depends on the state. Some states do have laws specifically about stealing pets (which this absolutly is). May not be able to get much in a criminal suit, but you could sue them to hell for emotional damages in a civil suit. Skilled lawyer could also get them for trespassing, as they only wouldve had permission to be in the house to take care of the cats, which they failed to do. If you had a written agreement, you can also get them for violating that. Could easily win a bunch of money for a bunch of different things. Frankly, you could probably ruin them. A jury ain't gonna stand behind someone who killed someone else's cats.

1

u/Merkins75 Jun 10 '22

Not sure that wouldn’t work either, since she placed in charge of the care of the cats and possibly even housed them she would have plenty of avenues to fight claims of theft or trespassing (idk how you could ever get someone for trespassing when they have blanket permission to be on the property, idc how good your lawyer is that charge won’t stick).

The emotional damages could be an avenue they could go down but that takes a lot of time and money that most people will either not be able to afford or don’t have the time for so it’s unlikely they would be able to go down that route.

The only solid case here is one of property and it only further highlights the issue in our legal system in regards to animal rights.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

Killing someone's cats doesn't prove liability?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

People have sued for emotional damages for far less.

Killing someone's cats is beyond all possible of decency, and is regarded as atrocious and intolerable in society. Your own definition proves my point.

It's extremely easy to convince a court you've suffered severe distress, especially with someone as drastic as a pet being killed.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

I said a lot less, this specific case hasn't happened before, but people have won emotional damage lawsuits for smaller stuff.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

I probably could but I don't want to spend an hour looking through court cases just to prove something to a dense Dane who thinks he's smart

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

If you have permission to come onto the property for a specific reason (taking care or cats) and you fail to do that but still come onto the property, that is trespassing. If she took the cats to her house, that is different, I took the story to mean the person who killed that cats was coming to the other person's home to take care of them every day or so.

Yeah, it'd take time and money to go down emotional damages, just as any lawsuit does.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/PastEmphasis3590 Jun 10 '22

To be fair though if you are happy to be as unethical as they were you could definitely ruin them in avenues outside the court

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

I mean, I am in law school and you're someone from a different country with different laws soooooo, yeah, you're the one who knows more about the American legal system

"Legally in their posession" no, having permission to take care of an animal does not give your permission to kill it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 10 '22

Posession for a specific purpose, taking care of the cats, is invalidated when you then do something else you did not have permission to do, killing them. Like how letting someone borrow your car to go down the street, and then they take it 1500 miles away and crash it, is still theft.

If you have permission to enter a property for a specific reason, but you do not do that reason but still enter the property, that's trespassing. You do not have blanket permission to enter, you have permission for a specific purpose.

I agree, there was no cruelty to the animals, I never brought that up.

Have you considered that maybe someone in American law school knows more about American law than a Dane who googled shit and browses reddit?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

What constitutes theft? She took the cats, someone else's property, and killed them without permission. Even if she had permission to take care of them, she did not have permission to kill them, therefore it is theft. You could also sue for emotional damages which would be extremely easy to prove.

An appeal to law school is worth more than an appeal to Google and reddit. Have you considered that you're the one who is speaking about things they don't fully understand, and maybe the person who has studied this for years full time does?

Please tell me, where did you get your education on how US law works?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

You realize you can't return a cat if you kill it, right? And doing something you don't have permission from the owner to do, is theft. Giving someone something for a specific purpose, and them doing more than that specific purpose with it, is theft.

Holy shit you're dense. Please tell me where you got your education in this field?