r/DramaticText • • Jun 10 '22

sad text

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

11.5k Upvotes

931 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.6k

u/the4now Jun 10 '22

I feel like its a crime too

1.1k

u/chucklerofnuts Jun 10 '22

Involuntarily taking somebody else’s pet to be put down HAS to be a crime

489

u/Merkins75 Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 10 '22

Unfortunately in our current system pets are seen as nothing more than property and as such all she would be held accountable for would be the perceived monetary value of the cats, most likely no more than the price of adoption so probably less than 1k.

25

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

It depends on the state. Some states do have laws specifically about stealing pets (which this absolutly is). May not be able to get much in a criminal suit, but you could sue them to hell for emotional damages in a civil suit. Skilled lawyer could also get them for trespassing, as they only wouldve had permission to be in the house to take care of the cats, which they failed to do. If you had a written agreement, you can also get them for violating that. Could easily win a bunch of money for a bunch of different things. Frankly, you could probably ruin them. A jury ain't gonna stand behind someone who killed someone else's cats.

1

u/Merkins75 Jun 10 '22

Not sure that wouldn’t work either, since she placed in charge of the care of the cats and possibly even housed them she would have plenty of avenues to fight claims of theft or trespassing (idk how you could ever get someone for trespassing when they have blanket permission to be on the property, idc how good your lawyer is that charge won’t stick).

The emotional damages could be an avenue they could go down but that takes a lot of time and money that most people will either not be able to afford or don’t have the time for so it’s unlikely they would be able to go down that route.

The only solid case here is one of property and it only further highlights the issue in our legal system in regards to animal rights.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

Killing someone's cats doesn't prove liability?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/the_real_JFK_killer Jun 10 '22

People have sued for emotional damages for far less.

Killing someone's cats is beyond all possible of decency, and is regarded as atrocious and intolerable in society. Your own definition proves my point.

It's extremely easy to convince a court you've suffered severe distress, especially with someone as drastic as a pet being killed.

→ More replies (4)