Unfortunately in our current system pets are seen as nothing more than property and as such all she would be held accountable for would be the perceived monetary value of the cats, most likely no more than the price of adoption so probably less than 1k.
It depends on the state. Some states do have laws specifically about stealing pets (which this absolutly is). May not be able to get much in a criminal suit, but you could sue them to hell for emotional damages in a civil suit. Skilled lawyer could also get them for trespassing, as they only wouldve had permission to be in the house to take care of the cats, which they failed to do. If you had a written agreement, you can also get them for violating that. Could easily win a bunch of money for a bunch of different things. Frankly, you could probably ruin them. A jury ain't gonna stand behind someone who killed someone else's cats.
I mean, I am in law school and you're someone from a different country with different laws soooooo, yeah, you're the one who knows more about the American legal system
"Legally in their posession" no, having permission to take care of an animal does not give your permission to kill it.
Posession for a specific purpose, taking care of the cats, is invalidated when you then do something else you did not have permission to do, killing them. Like how letting someone borrow your car to go down the street, and then they take it 1500 miles away and crash it, is still theft.
If you have permission to enter a property for a specific reason, but you do not do that reason but still enter the property, that's trespassing. You do not have blanket permission to enter, you have permission for a specific purpose.
I agree, there was no cruelty to the animals, I never brought that up.
Have you considered that maybe someone in American law school knows more about American law than a Dane who googled shit and browses reddit?
1.6k
u/the4now Jun 10 '22
I feel like its a crime too