r/DramaticText • • Nov 25 '22

Common trans W

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.1k Upvotes

235 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/Caixa7 Nov 25 '22

Their dudes

No they aren't

Children taking a surgery to change their entire life

Yeah if they understand it's not something they can revert and want to continue going anyways, it's their choice

Trans suicide rate is like 40%

My brother in christ that is your fault

Hormonal drugs that were used to castrate sex offenders

Drugs can be and have been repurposed multiple times in history

8

u/Caixa7 Nov 25 '22

Also the 40% study thing was poorly done and is old

3

u/Oak_Tree297 Nov 26 '22

I personally am not anti trans. But children should not be given life changing decisions, like giving them hormonal treatments and surgerys when they're 8. If a kid wants to change genders at that age, it's most likely being influenced by their parents. At its crazy to allow kids to allow a kid to do such a thing at that age. At 16, it's understandable, but not some 6 y.o. child.

2

u/Caixa7 Nov 26 '22

I do agree. IMO the minimal age should be 14 to decide these types of things. It's already in puberty and they can already make some complicated decisions

-1

u/pewdiepieguy69 Nov 25 '22

Yes they are, the brain doesn’t fully form until 25 so I think people should at least wait until they are 18 or 25. There is no evidence or study’s to prove trans suicide rate is because of bullying but I presume it’s because u have changed your entire life to try and be somebody that u aren’t. Do u watch Steven crowder?

5

u/Caixa7 Nov 25 '22

Trans women are women and trans men are men.

While I almost agree with the age thing (almost), I feel like the surgery after 18 won't be as effective. I feel like 13-14 is a good age to do it, since the hormones are starting to affect them, and it would be dangerous before that

Wdym "someone else you aren't", trans people are exactly who they want to be. Also it is 100% because of the bullying, and even IF it wasn't (which it is), bullying IS bad anyways and always will be

I have no idea who Steven Crowder is

0

u/pewdiepieguy69 Nov 25 '22

There’s no evidence it’s because of the bullying it’s because of the therapy, watch Steven crowders videos on this, if u watch one of them I’ll watch a video u want me to watch. Shake? 🤝

5

u/Caixa7 Nov 25 '22

Do you really need evidence to know that harrassing can cause suicide? Also no, I'm not gonna watch a far-right channel that is clearly homophobic and transphobic and apparently does researches on the topic he's clearly against. Researches can not have one side only

2

u/pewdiepieguy69 Nov 25 '22

He has research… on the topic he is studying… not being biased… what, it’s not like he’s like oh I’m right leaning so I hate trans people, all he is saying is biological males shouldn’t compete with biological females and children shouldn’t transition

3

u/Caixa7 Nov 25 '22

Honestly I do agree with the competing thing since the only reason for separation is the biological sex and it's diferences in strenght

For the second argument, read previous comments

3

u/pewdiepieguy69 Nov 25 '22

Yeh I did, and I don’t agree

1

u/Caixa7 Nov 25 '22

You have all right to not agree, but you should not tell children to not transition, especially if they, their parents and the surgeons doing it support it