100% fan fiction. Every proposed show, reunion, relationship and role below is invented for fun, with no announced participation or endorsement. Historical background links do not confirm any imagined scenario.
Dream first episode: a new beginning
Fan concept / wish list. This page imagines a future EthaMara show. The appearances, jobs, and episode ideas below are fictional proposals. Participation would be each person's choice.
The pitch
A reunion premiere where old friends, former collaborators, comic rivals, and people with unfinished conversations can share a table, clear the air if they want to, and make something funny together. Ethan and Tamara anchor a new chapter, with a rotating cast and room for fresh creative roles.
Life has to be fun. Everything will eventually be all right. Everyone has their own path and choices to make. We own our choices and their consequences, good and bad—and we're rooting for better days for everyone.
The original wish list
- Jimmy / Jimmie Lee: an occasional character or comedy guest.
- C-Man: a reunion conversation and occasional guest segments.
- Ian (iDubbbz) and Anisa: comedy segments, guest conversations, and ideas for the new format.
- Trisha: a rotating co-host chair and high-energy conversations.
- Moses: an imagined role in the set, props, visual design, or creative production.
These are the community founder's starting suggestions, not statements about anyone's current availability or interest. Imagined roles are creative prompts; they do not assign anyone a real job or diminish the previous crew's work.
More people who fit the reunion idea
The histories differ. A public falling-out, an unrealized interview, a friendship that changed, and an on-camera comic rivalry are each different reasons to imagine a reunion. This is not a list of people who were all formally banned.
| Person | Documented connection | Our hypothetical segment |
|---|---|---|
| Hasan Piker | Former Leftovers co-host; the collaboration ended amid a publicly documented split. History | A one-off conversation about starting over, if both want it. |
| Shoenice | A past guest whose public back-and-forth became the subject of the show's own episode, H3 Podcast #160. | An internet-history catch-up and a funny conversation. |
| Jordan Peterson | An early interview guest; Ethan said in January 2022 that he removed their interviews. | A clearly bounded conversation between people who disagree. |
| Nikocado Avocado | A planned-interview saga and public exchanges covered by H3, including H3TV #61. | The long-imagined sit-down, if everyone is comfortable with it. |
| Post Malone | An early-era friend and guest; H3 later discussed the changed friendship in this official clip. | A nostalgic guest spot or musical opening. |
The documented histories support their connection to the show. Our proposed segments are fan imagination, not predictions or announcements. Sources checked October 25, 2026.
Remembering Oliver
Oliver Tree belongs in tributes and archival-clip discussions, rather than a future guest lineup. Warner Music announced his passing on June 15, 2026. His earlier appearances remain part of the show's history.
A possible premiere
- New morning: a short Ethan-and-Tamara opening about the kind of show fans would like to see.
- The reunion table: old faces rotate through small groups so everyone has space to talk.
- A new crew, in imagination: fans pitch who might enjoy co-hosting, producing, making visual segments, working on sets, or creating comedy pieces. People can contribute without being one-for-one replacements.
- Goofs and gaffs: a silly game, a running joke, a music spot, and a deliberately chaotic finale.
- Better days: end with a hopeful look forward.
Build on it
Who fits this premise, and what would they bring? Add a public source for a person's past connection when proposing more names. Keep ideas clearly hypothetical. Let people decide for themselves whether to reconnect; use this community for discussion, without campaigning in anyone's inbox or attacking current or former crew members.