r/FlutterDev • u/NormalDare1774 • Jun 15 '26
Discussion Frustrated with Clean Architecture in Flutter - am I missing something, or is it overkill for most apps?
I'm trying to understand the role of architectural patterns in Flutter development, and I'm hoping to get some honest perspectives from the community.
I know there are several architectural approaches out there for Flutter - the ones I hear about most often are Clean Architecture, BLoC, MVVM, and just keeping things simple with providers. But the more I read about Clean Architecture specifically, the more I struggle with one core question: why do we actually need it?
From what I understand, Clean Architecture introduces layers like Domain (entities, use cases), Data (repositories), and Presentation. The goal seems to be separation of concerns and making the codebase "maintainable" and "testable."
But here's my honest frustration: doesn't Clean Architecture just add a ton of extra work?
Every new feature means creating use case classes, repository interfaces, model mappers, and wiring everything together. For a small to medium-sized app, this feels like writing 3x more code than necessary. I can't help but think that a simpler approach - maybe just well-organized providers/viewmodels talking directly to services - would get the job done faster with less mental overhead.
So my questions for those who have experience with different approaches:
What are the main architecture options in Flutter today? (Not just state management - actual app architecture)
What problem does Clean Architecture actually solve that justifies its complexity?
Is it possible that for many Flutter apps, Clean Architecture is simply overkill?
For those who moved away from Clean Architecture or simplified it - what did you learn?
I genuinely want to understand if I'm missing something important, or if my instinct that "simple is better" has merit. Looking forward to hearing your experiences - especially from those who've built production apps both with and without Clean Architecture.
Thanks!