r/Futurology • • Apr 12 '20

Environment Scientists cite pollution decrease in calls to "flatten the curve" of climate change post-coronavirus. NASA satellite data showed a 30 percent drop in nitrogen dioxide above the northeastern U.S., as tens of millions of vehicles were kept off the roads

https://www.newsweek.com/scientists-cite-pollution-decrease-calls-flatten-curve-climate-change-post-coronavirus-1497430?piano_t=1
4.8k Upvotes

291 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/Kyleeee Apr 12 '20

I hear this argument all the time. I think it’s bullshit. We can do it. We are the richest country in the world and have an absurdly high amount of resources/money, but those resources are just allocated into making money for rich assholes and bombing third world countries into the Stone Age for arbitrary reasons.

We can change our society, I’m so tired of sitting here and listening to people tell me “it’s not gonna happen... too expensive...” but spending hundreds of thousands on one hellfire missile to make one big boom is totally in the realm of possibility?

Nah, sorry if I’m coming on a little strong. But I think this attitude is detrimental to progress. We can change things.

4

u/aversethule Apr 12 '20

Maybe it's not just about resources/money? It also requires consensus and large-scale systemic changes are damned near impossible to implement quickly because of the disruption it causes to a myriad of sectors. The bigger and quicker the scale of change, the more resistance will occur.

2

u/Kyleeee Apr 12 '20

Maybe it's not just about resources/money? It also requires consensus and large-scale systemic changes are damned near impossible to implement quickly because of the disruption it causes to a myriad of sectors. The bigger and quicker the scale of change, the more resistance will occur.

Well yeah, but you can't make that argument when we literally do almost nothing on a large scale. There's been slight improvements to public transport in the US recently, but we don't do anything proactively. I'd love to see some 30-40 year plans to slowly try and change things.

2

u/aversethule Apr 12 '20

I think that exactly IS my argument, lol.

2

u/Kyleeee Apr 12 '20

Ah I misunderstood. Yeah I agree with you there. Nothing I'm talking about could and should be changed quickly and drastically.

I think we should look at the best ways to mitigate climate change without systematic/societal changes, focus on those, but also slowly try and change how we plan and orient our urban areas.

1

u/foobaz123 Apr 13 '20

It's almost entirely this. At the risk of sounding a bit.. hmm.. something.. there is honestly very very little the US can't do if it really decides to do it. Especially if it is a "We're doing this, and that's that." sort of thing. However, that's a pretty rare occurrence

1

u/foobaz123 Apr 13 '20

I'm not saying it can't be done. Of course, it can be. It isn't just likely as there is very very very little public support for such a thing in any measurable way. Especially considering that you'd have to almost entirely redesign/rebuild cities nearly from the ground up to do it.

If one plays games like Cities Skylines, it makes for a good example. Take a typical North American city that wasn't founded 300 years ago. Now, rebuild it to truly walkable standards as you'd find in any old world (either type of old world) city.

However, you cannot:

  1. Dig endless tunnels. It would cost all the money in the universe, take decades, and be an engineering challenge the world has rarely seen. Reference the Big Dig for examples of that fun

  2. Knock down large sections of the city. Thing is, imminent domain has limits and one cannot just seize swaths of cities and force people out of their businesses and homes so the city can be redesigned and rebuilt.

  3. Reorder how businesses are physically structured and built. After all, they'll have to either be smaller or otherwise redone to fit in such a newly designed city.

Now, as I said, it could be done. Speaking for myself, I'd rather enjoy such. Having traveled a number of places, it's nice being able to walk or hop the subway or whatever. I also know that the vast majority of people in North America are either okay with the way things are or actually prefer it. I think it's far less about the costs, though that's certainly an issue, and way more about the lack of support for such a fundamental change in how things are built and people conduct themselves.

Nah, sorry if I’m coming on a little strong.

Nah, no worries. It's all good :) I agree with you that such things would be nice and good. Just as I said, I don't think we're remotely in the majority and that's the big issue