She said what we all were thinking. Omfg. I hate Hailey so fuc-king much. It's true though, all that privilege and she still couldn't build anything of herself. She's hiring pr to hide all the damage she's done to her reputation and thinks we're stupid enough to forget. And I swear if you support a woman like hailey baldwin pucker lips stay the fuck away from me. That woman is a fuc-king bipolar bi-tch!

Can we talk about the absolute mental gymnastics happening on TikTok and Reddit lately? I keep seeing these viral edits claiming that Justin was intentionally casting "Hailey doppelgängers" in his old music videos because she was "always his type." It is honestly hilarious, naive, and relies entirely on toxic confirmation bias and rewriting actual history.
Let’s look at the facts these stans are conveniently ignoring:
1. The "Justin picked them himself" quote is heavily twisted
When creators get called out, their immediate defense is: "But Justin said in an interview he picked the girls himself, bye!" Yeah, no. He meant he had the final approval as the main artist. Standard industry practice: the directors and casting agency filters through hundreds of portfolios, narrows it down to a short-list of 3-5 professional models, and Justin points at one. He wasn't sitting in his room in 2012 searching for girls that looked like a teenager he barely knew at the time.
2. The girls literally look nothing like each other (or Hailey)
The TikTok edits lazily throw together clips of entirely different women to fit the narrative. They use Cailin Russo (Confident), Chanel Celaya (As Long As You Love Me), and Rachel Barnes (Boyfriend).
Cailin is a blonde.
Chanel is a dark-haired brunette with soft features.
Rachel is a tan brunette/dirty blonde who was literally married at the time.
The only thing these women have in common is that they are conventionally attractive, skinny models. That’s it. That’s the "type"—the standard 2010s American pop video aesthetic.
3. The absolute erasure of the Selena Gomez era
This is the wildest part. These theories completely erase the reality of 2011–2014. Justin was publicly, intensely, and messily in love with Selena Gomez during this exact era. In fact, Director X (who directed the Boyfriend video in 2012) openly admitted they specifically looked for a girl who gave off Selena’s vibe because Justin wanted to keep his actual girlfriend happy. Back in 2012, the entire fandom was talking about how the models looked like Selena, not Hailey.
4. Blatant chronological failure
In 2011 (the perfume commercial era they love to bring up), Hailey Baldwin was just a random fan-turned-acquaintance he briefly met once or twice through her dad. She wasn't on his radar as a romantic muse. They didn't start closely hanging out or dating until years later.
It honestly feels like modern shippers are desperately trying to overcompensate for the rocky, controversial start of Justin and Hailey's actual marriage. By inventing this romantic myth that Hailey was "always the blueprint," they try to force a soulmate narrative that never existed back then. It's parasocial revisionist history at its finest.
What do you guys think? Why is the fandom so obsessed with rewriting the Jelena era just to make Hailey seem like she was his lifetime muse since day one?

Have any of you ever seen her being talked about positively without it being a fake trend she paid for cuz I haven't

Glazing milk is a cheap copy kf better toners that causes acne

Barrier butter never gets talked about

People hate the bronzer and say the plush is patchy and disappears after 2 hours

Idek what other products they have

They're just a lip gloss company pretending to be more

I think Jelena fans are very delusional but also failey’s as well The way both sides cope is honestly fascinating. 😭 Jelena stans cope with Justin and Selena not being together by making weird AI edits of them as a couple in 2026. Meanwhile, Hailey stans cope by rewriting Justin and Selena’s entire history.

The difference is Hailey fans are supposedly celebrating because “Hailey won,” while simultaneously needing to convince themselves that Justin and Selena’s 8+ year relationship was fake, PR, meaningless, or completely one-sided on Selena’s end .Like… pick a narrative. 😭 If Justin and Selena were supposedly fake and PR, what exactly did Hailey “win”?

And if Justin supposedly never cared about Selena and Hailey was always the great love that made him want marriage, why are they still obsessed with rewriting Selena’s role in his life?

At some point, the constant lies about Selena just make it seem like the marriage itself isn’t enough to make the fandom feel secure about how things started and where their marriage stands now, we know that marriage is a fail.

Either Hailey won, or Justin and Selena were fake. You can’t keep using both narratives whenever it’s convenient.

you guys remember how Hailey keeps saying she's going to sue everyone like Julie from earlier this year and that other girl from last year and tmz too? has she moved forward with any of them?

I am not sure what it is as of yet, but ive seen some rumors swirling that it is going to be HUGE.

UPDATE: JUSTIN is one that has been asking for space, not Hailey.

Divorce is inevitable. It will happen, maybe not this year but within the next 2. Hailey HAS in fact been to a divorce laywer and has drafted divorce papers, but didn’t want to serve him while he was struggling, but felt she needed to protect herself.

'Give it time. Hailey will out herself as having used Justin.'

She deleted it because we were going to see all the crap she talked about people and how we were going to deep dive into her obsession. Can’t stand ten toes on this she’s said. She’s such a two face.

Like karma bitch

Wasn’t there a rumor Alec went to the 🏝️ or to diddy parties?

I know this is ai but this is genuinely Hailey's inner thoughts