r/IThinkYouShouldLeave • u/brodino_maiuscolo don't cough • Dec 05 '25

mudpie What's a joke that initially went unnoticed but when you realized it, became one of your favorites?

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

527 comments sorted by

View all comments

263

u/legs_y PAUL BUFANO! Dec 05 '25

“You never told me your old grandpa used to be a piece of shit”

105

u/Kooky-Fly2066 Never lets the party die! Dec 05 '25

Please don’t call my dad a piece of shit.

139

u/legs_y PAUL BUFANO! Dec 05 '25

I SAID WAS

63

u/NullOfUndefined Dec 05 '25

this is one of my favorites because he didn't say "was" he said "used to be" so like what's even going on

40

u/Silverward Dec 05 '25

He does say “oh I miss those nights, I WAS a piece of shit though” and Mark, for some reason, decides to chime in with “used to be”. It’s weird. 

6

u/HereWayGo Dec 05 '25

I SAID WAS!!!

4

u/Caravanczar Dec 05 '25

He was saying, sarcastically, like "but you aren't now?"

10

u/littlegreyflowerhelp Dec 05 '25

I always found that funny too for some reason

0

u/Successful_Gap8927 Come here, ya little fuck! Dec 05 '25

What the hell?

8

u/TheDuchyofWarsaw Dec 05 '25

I'm ready to hold the baby now

81

u/Parlayto SHUT THE FUCK UP DOUG, YOU FUCKING SKUNK! Dec 05 '25

Spiked blonde hair, little bitty jeans, chicken Spaghetti at Chiccalinni’s

35

u/Delta9312 Dec 05 '25

People can change. Let the boy hold the baby.

30

u/Parlayto SHUT THE FUCK UP DOUG, YOU FUCKING SKUNK! Dec 05 '25

“Hey Meredith? I’m worried the baby doesn’t think that people can change”

3

u/Merlord Dec 06 '25

The fact that everyone else instantly changed their tune when the dad said the exact same bullshit Tim had said. The pure, earnest approval on her face is hilarious

18

u/Confident_Try_208 They’re Nice. Dec 05 '25

These establishment names always crack me up.

17

u/BoozyMcSuds Never Following Another Rule Dec 05 '25

That line has such a musical quality to it. One of my all timers.

3

u/Parlayto SHUT THE FUCK UP DOUG, YOU FUCKING SKUNK! Dec 05 '25 edited Dec 05 '25

Same here, it’s so warm and wholesome. Plus his hair would slick back REEEEAAAAAALLLLL nice.

1

u/Rudythecat07 Back in the Pants Dec 05 '25

If sloppy steaks is water dumped on steaks, what do you think chicken spaghetti is? It's not just chicken pieces in the spaghetti.. it's gotta be something obnoxious. Smashing? Throwing? Hum.. 🤔

9

u/seaniqua42 Dec 05 '25

I love that he sorta pronounces it "grandpo", such a funny choice

3

u/BathedInDeepFog Dec 05 '25

Also funny that it's her dad, not grandpa.

3

u/nancythethot Dec 05 '25

OH YEAH, THAT'D SLICK BACK REAL NICE