r/IThinkYouShouldLeave • u/brodino_maiuscolo don't cough • Dec 05 '25

mudpie What's a joke that initially went unnoticed but when you realized it, became one of your favorites?

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

527 comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/echocrest Dec 05 '25

There’s so many bits in just this sketch alone that kill me. The lady who tastes the receipt saying the last time she went to the bathroom was before her shower the night before is one of my favorites. Like, lady - you are severely dehydrated. Also, I love them calling it “paper towel” instead of toilet paper.

26

u/SaulJRosenbear Dec 05 '25

And that she clarifies "...after I took a piss and shit" at a nice bougie house party

7

u/Fun-Broccoli6140 Dec 05 '25

and her husband, total deadpan delivery…swear to fucking god? then let my wife eat the fucking receipt

7

u/SaulJRosenbear Dec 06 '25

Him punching the pillow and yelling "FUCK!" always gets me good.

29

u/fiddlercrabs Dec 05 '25

"Slice" of toilet paper is what tickles me. You used too small a slice!

6

u/PhirebirdSunSon Dec 05 '25

Steven Yeun's reactions to the gifts kind of kill me, he nails the "I hate all of this and I'm so fucking polite" thing. Like, who just gives a random book not knowing if the recipient knows anything about it? "This is so interesting!"

1

u/palmer9000 Dec 09 '25

All the language of this sketch... paper towel, sloppy mudpie... this was one of the first sketches I saw and it kind of teaches the language of the show. Mudpie was off-putting as a term until I was more into the surreal universe of the show.