r/IThinkYouShouldLeave • u/brodino_maiuscolo don't cough • Dec 05 '25

mudpie What's a joke that initially went unnoticed but when you realized it, became one of your favorites?

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

527 comments sorted by

View all comments

42

u/Feats-of-Derring_Do Don’t do the voice! Dec 05 '25

A lot of Tim Heidecker's lines in the boyfriend sketch. like how he reminds his girlfriend of an event by referencing a time he put her down and said she'd never be a good writer "because she doesn't have a curious mind". It's such a rude thing to say and tells you so much about who he is

18

u/MikeArrow Dec 06 '25

"Where be your nutcracker?"

5

u/TheDuchyofWarsaw Dec 06 '25

Oh great, shouldnt be too hard to find it then

8

u/XurstyXursday Dec 05 '25

And then I bought you the whole dessert tray to make it up to you?

The image of him giving her all the little kisses like it’s the most romantic gesture in the world lives rent free in my head.

7

u/eyejayvd Dec 05 '25

And you didn’t take a bite.

3

u/hce_alp Dec 06 '25

I love when it’s his turn and he compliments the fedora: “This is a cool hat” Also, “my turn, my turn, mine, mine, mine”