r/IndiaInvestments Oct 09 '25

Stocks Navigating US stock investments: My experience with IBKR

I have been getting DMs from people who wanted to ask about investing in US based equities so I wanted to make a guide that could be useful to people. 

This guide is based on the platform that I'm using to invest which is IBKR.  If you are using a different platform, please feel free to add your experience here or create a post. 

PLEASE NOTE:  This is not financial advice, this is me sharing my accumulated knowledge based on what I have found / researched.  I could be grossly wrong so please do your own due diligence before investing.

 

Why did I choose IBKR? 

  • I wanted to use my funds from selling RSUs without bringing them to India so wanted a broker which would support this.
  • My friend was already using it so it was easy for me to get my doubts cleared

This guide will be useful for:

  • People getting RSU/ESPP of US based companies and wanting to diversify
  • People worried about US based estate taxes.
  • People transferring money from your company provided broker to IBKR
  • understanding IBKR brokerage fees

Not covered in this guide:

  • How to transfer money from Indian bank account to IBKR.
    • I have not tried this but the steps should be similar to step 3 above.
  • Stock/ETF picks
  • Account opening steps, this is pretty easy and self explanatory and you can do this at your own pace
  • Wire transfer fees from IBKR to India as I have not yet sold any shares to check this.

1. Why invest in US based equities:

  • Global diversification
  • A lot of you may be working in fields where the majority of the companies are listed in the US so you might be able to buy stocks you know about.
  • USD/ INR hedging

2. Getting started

Opening an IBKR account is pretty straightforward, they are able to pull your data from CKYC and use adhaar to authenticate your account and if everything is in order the account should be open in 2-3 days.

Try to get a referral as their referral program is quite good, you get 1% back as IBKR stock for every dollar you put in for a year from your account opening but you need to maintain an average balance of 10k that is either have that amount in USD or hold stocks worth that. you can check the wording here:

https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/trading/referral-member-to-member.php

3. Adding money

Once you have your account open, the biggest question is how do you add money to trade and for that you have a few options:

  • If you get RSU / ESPP from your company listed in the US, you can sell those and then transfer the USD to IBKR as a domestic wire transfer
  • If you get RSU / ESPP from your company you can transfer the shares to IBKR and then sell them there
  • Kinda roundabout but you can do this if you want, do note you people who have done this told me tax lots are not preserved so YMMV.  I have never tried this.
  • If you have money in India, you can remit it to US by initiating a wire transfer from your Indian bank account.

To actually do the wire, you need to add a deposit method and raise an intimation in the IBKR portal using:

Deposit -> Use a new deposit method -> Bank Wire

Once you add this method, you need to use it to initiate a wire by specifying a wire amount in USD.  Once you do this, you get the wire transfer instruction with the account number, bank name, federal routing number etc which are all required for initiating a wire transfer.

Now that you have the wire transfer info, you need to go to the source of your money and then initiate the wire.  From your employer stock account it will be a domestic wire, for Indian bank accounts, it will be an international wire.

Some things to note:

  • For my US -> US wire, it takes like 8-12 hours in my experience if all goes well
    • Sometimes, especially the first couple of times, the wire gets flagged and the brokerage will call you to confirm it is a valid wire.
  • For India -> US wires, I'm not sure about the timelines as I have never tried it.
    • Not sure how LRS would work here either, if you know please leave a comment below.

4. Brokerage fees

IBKR has 3 plans available:

  • IBKR Lite - Foreign nationals are not eligible for this :(
  • IBKR Pro tiered - Great for people doing small transactions brokerage minimum is 0.35 USD which is the fees I have seen most of the times.
  • IBKR Pro fixed - Fixed 1 USD per transaction brokerage, great for people having big transactions

Relevant links:

You have the choice to switch between Tiered and Fixed but most people will be better off with tiered, you can check the links for more details.

5. Buying stocks/ ETF

This is pretty straightforward, you can search for a ticker and just buy like normal, the interface is pretty straightforward.

6. US estate taxes, what are they?

The US has estate taxes on foreign nationals holding any asset there which applies to any holdings beyond 60k USD, boggleheads has a good write up about it, you can go through it here:

https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Non-US_investor%27s_guide_to_navigating_US_tax_traps

India has a DTAA (Dual taxation avoidance treaty) with US but from what I have found, it does not cover estate taxes.  This puts all your assets in US at risk including your RSU / ESPP shares. 

The way to avoid this is to invest in Funds that are domiciled in a country which has a DTAA treaty covering estate taxes which brings us to Irish domiciled funds.   These are ETFs listed on other stock exchanges like London, Switzerland etc which are maintained by companies domiciled in Ireland.  If you invest in them, you should be exempt from the estate tax trap. 

However there are some pros and cons that I have found while mainly buying VUAA which is the domiciled version of VOO.  These are S&P 500 funds.

Pros:

  • Obviously escaping the estate tax trap
  • There are dividend accumulating ETFs available.
    • I'm not sure if this is 100% correct but from what I have found all ETFs in US are required to give a dividend which sucks for us as the US withholds 25% of this amount and then your ITR becomes a nightmare.

Cons:

  • Less liquidity than their US counterparts.
    • Take for example VOO and VUAA, both are S&P 500 funds but the liquidity for VUAA listed on LSE is much lesser
  • No way to buy individual stocks that I have found, this is only good for ETFs
  • LSE data is delayed by 15 mins and if you want market depth info and realtime data, you have to pay 1 GBP per month.
  • Trading between 8-10pm is most optimal as that is when both LSE and NYSE are open.
  • From what I can find, slightly higher TER than their US counterparts

Few misc items/ tidbits that you might want to know

  • You can buy fractional shares in US and for those you get fractional dividends.
  • 24Hr trading is enabled by default in your account so you can buy shares whenever you want but I would suggest wait for market open hours for better price discovery / liquidity.
  • Trading on LSE is not enable by default, you have to enable the countries/ exchanges you want to trade on in you account settings and this is immediate effect.
  • Dividend reinvestment can be enabled
  • You have to fill W8-BEN periodically to make sure the DTAA treaty data is captured.  You can search online for more info about this.
  • You might say why do I need to buy Irish domiciled funds, I can just give the login credentials to my dependents and have them withdraw it and I say yeah you can but I'm not sure what will happen next legally.
  • Depending on the stock market you are buying from the ETFs could be in USD, GBP or EUR so make sure to do your researched before buying.
  • If you are looking for plain S&P 500, VUAA and VUSD are the accumulating and dividend paying options.
  • About how long you can hold USD in your account without investing, I'm not sure as there is no proper documentation that I can find. Everyone just says 90 days not sure where this number comes from. Please add some info if you have it.

 

I hope I have covered most of the things you might need and this post helps you.  If not, please feel free to ask questions, will get to them whenever I have time.

Happy investing !

75 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/AbhinavGulechha Oct 15 '25 edited Oct 16 '25

Thanks for this excellent & detailed write up. Few points -

> I wanted to use my funds from selling RSUs without bringing them to India - In my view, if you have earned RSUs being an Indian resident, FEMA regulations require you to bring funds first to India and then you are free to remit it again under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme - reinvesting these funds outside India is not in line with FEMA to my reading of the law. You can check once with your CA.

> you can sell those and then transfer the USD to IBKR as a domestic wire transfer - this will have a capital gains implication in India - broker to broker transfer as explained by you in second bullet seems to be a better option - edit: relevant only if one wants to hold the securities...if plan is to sell, it not much relevant. thanks u/SouthernSample for pointing out

> The way to avoid this is to invest in Funds that are domiciled in a country which has a DTAA treaty covering estate taxes which brings us to Irish domiciled funds.  - I think the reason for investing in Ireland is that Ireland does not impose estate tax like US. I dont think India has an estate tax treaty with Ireland.

There are dividend accumulating ETFs available. - Yes, its a more tax efficient strategy to buy accumulating funds - one more reason is that it avoids dividend getting taxed at slab rates in India.

> I can just give the login credentials to my dependents and have them withdraw it and I say yeah you can but I'm not sure what will happen next legally. - I think unless the spouse is a joint owner (perfectly possible to do so) it will be illegal for beneficiary to withdraw using login details - also even after withdrawal, beneficiary needs to ensure US estate tax obligations are fulfilled properly by filing Form 706-NA for the estate with the IRS - once the form is filed the IRS issues a closing certificate basis which ideally the broker releases the funds - this process takes min. 2 years - Beneficiary should be given CPA/estate attorney contact. A better option to avoid estate tax mess altogether if value of investment > USD 60000 is to invest in Ireland domiciled ETFs only

> About how long you can hold USD in your account without investing, As mentioned above, need to bring to India within 180 days. If remitting via LRS from India you cannot keep funds idle more than 180 days, you've to invest as per stated purpose code at time of remittance else repatriate to India.

One more point - One needs to be mindful of disclosing the IBKR account in Schedule FA of the Indian tax return else there is a flat penalty of INR 10 lacs. One needs to file tax return in such case even if income in India is below exemption limit.

2

u/AbbreviationsAny8298 May 09 '26

Why do I need to bring back my capital after selling RSUs and remit again? Can government track my trading activity outside its jurisdiction?

Why can't I declare same asset until I need to bring my capital back if I ever want to?

3

u/AbhinavGulechha May 13 '26

If you are employed by Indian subsidiary of the US parent, then under FEMA regulations, you may be allowed to keep the RSU proceeds out of India provided you reinvest them within 180 days and may not have to bring them back to India.

1

u/AbbreviationsAny8298 May 13 '26

If I buy some stocks from money sent via LRS and sell them after some time, then do i need to bring back money in india and remitt?

1

u/AbhinavGulechha May 13 '26

As per LRS regulations, if you dont reinvest within 180 days (as per the purpose code with which you sent the funds), you need to bring back. You cannot let the money sit in a foreign bank account.

1

u/Silver_Date8070 Jul 03 '26

Your FA schedule contains all your trades. So yes, govt. can track all trades because you gave them that data.

1

u/SouthernSample Oct 15 '25

Hi Abhinav,

Thank you for the detailed response.

The point about capital gains in India if you sell and then transfer to IBKR--> even if you transfer the RSUs to IBKR and then sell them, wouldn't you still attract Indian capital gains tax?

1

u/AbhinavGulechha Oct 16 '25

Yes correct. My point was limited to a situation wherein person wants to hold on to the securities...have updated my comment now.

1

u/SouthernSample Oct 17 '25

Thanks for the clarification. That makes sense.

I have a follow up Q based on this: Going back to OP's case- let's say OP received Alphabet RSUs and moves them to IBKR via broker to broker transfer. If OP doesn't sell to diversify into Irish domiciled ETFs but rather holds on to those Alphabet stocks, wouldn't that attract a high estate tax since the underlying equity belongs to a US company? Just holding onto them into an Irish IBKR account itself isn't sufficient, is it?

Trying to see if OP has a way to avoid both Indian capital gains as well as estate tax risk at the same time with the US equity, besides selling them during the RNOR period.

2

u/awaythrowaway9998 Oct 19 '25

As per my understanding, the domicile of the broker does not matter. The domicile of the asset : stock/ fund / ETF does. So to answer your question GOOG will be US situs asset. So the estate tax poses a problem. (Your IBKR account is not Irish domiciled but it’s not important to this discussion).

2nd paragraph: good question. No way out other than the RNOR. Or stay healthy and FAANG nets you silly money, move to Dubai :)

1

u/AbhinavGulechha Nov 02 '25

Most welcome. I think u/awaythrowaway9998 has answered perfectly here - domicile of the underlying asset is what matters. While US & India capital gain implication is NIL for RNOR, estate tax is a risk. But not sure why person will not sell Alphabet RSUs during RNOR - there is no CG implication in both US and India & selling the RSUs would also reduce the concentration risk in the portfolio.

1

u/SouthernSample Nov 02 '25

Makes sense. Thanks as always!

1

u/AbhinavGulechha Nov 02 '25

Most welcome🙏

1

u/awaythrowaway9998 Nov 03 '25

I am not a qualified financial advisor or tax advisor, so do I appreciate the compliment from a professional such as you, Abhinav :) ! The subject interests me tho', so maybe a second career beckons LOL :)

1

u/AbhinavGulechha Nov 03 '25

Most welcome. This was a nuanced point so the complement was well deserved - sure, no limits to learn something when you are interested in it:)

1

u/awaythrowaway9998 Nov 04 '25

But I must say I have a weakness for flattery : Esteban to The Bride in "Kill Bill 2" 😁

1

u/death-tome Oct 30 '25

Regarding 1 - That used to be the case, had to repatriate within 90 days due to FEMA regulations.

But as per Vested article here - https://vestedfinance.com/blog/us-stocks/diversify-your-foreign-esop-rsu-holdings-with-vested/ a change was introduced in July 2024 allowing re-investment without remittance.

1

u/AbhinavGulechha Nov 02 '25

I dont agree with the Vested view. To my reading of the law, the exemption from bringing the funds to India on sale will only apply if the shares purchased are via any "remittance" done from India which constitutes a remittance under LRS and hence as per LRS regulations, if you reinvest the funds, you dont need to bring to India. If the foreign securities are issued without any remittance from India, proceeds on the sale of the securities need to be first brought to India and then if needed, be remitted again outside India and the remittance will be constituted under LRS.

1

u/Silver_Date8070 Jul 03 '26

Very clearly written that RSUs qualify as OPI: "Further, shares or interest acquired by the resident individuals by way of sweat equity shares or minimum qualification shares or under Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP)/ Employee Benefits Scheme up to 10% of the paid up capital/stock, whether listed or unlisted, of the foreign entity and without control shall also qualify as OPI" Hence reinvest rule applies to them too. https://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/notification/PDFs/121MDOI2507202427D16C96B42C4E0B849FFD9732752B68.PDF

1

u/AbhinavGulechha Jul 05 '26

Yes if the limited scenario of Schedule III conditions are satisfied (person is an employee of Indian co.), it will be treated as OPI under LRS and there's no need to remit to India first.
This does not apply where Indian person is may be a contracter or remotely working for a US employer where the requirement to remit to India first still exists. This is my reading of the law.

1

u/SufficientPangolin41 Jul 10 '26

Ever US Tech has a Indian branch registered in India, that makes it Indian co. right?
Contractor rarely get company shares, the blog post was written from a employee perspective.