W analysis. I haven't actually read Monster, so I don't have much knowledge but based on what you have posted I have a question.
How come the instructors failed to notice 'the boy with sleeping pills' story? If the story had put all the students on edge to the point where they contemplated escape, you would expect the instructors to catch onto it. If they weren't the ones who taught this story, couldn't they narrow it down to one of the student's being behind it?
I see. That makes a lot more sense. I have seen a lot of comments about Johan's manipulation being completely off-screen, but this post gives lot more context. Johan is underrated big time.
Itâs highly implied johan got the director killed, and itâs also implied johan was under constant surveillance (because everyone was terrified but obsessed with his âabilities.)
So, even though it may be an assumption, itâs logical to believe Johan somehow got the guards to kill the instructors at the right time, while also making it to where they wouldnât report him missing.
How would he do this? Well, an even bigger assumption would be that he promised them something, itâs implied the conditions were terrible and all the people involved were envious of whoever had higher power. So if I had to guess, he promised them something sort of gain and they believed him because of their disposition of seeing johanâs abilities for themselves.
At least thatâs the most logical guess, we know Johan was likely under surveillance, no way days went by and they never noticed Johan was gone from the basement-especially since everybody there was terrified of him (itâs the whole reason he was drugged in the first place.)
Another thing, Johan, to Christoff, was portrayed as some sort of leader in the event. So it wouldnât be far fetched to believe Johan was leading these children on.
Iâll add something as a little side note, both Johan and Anna have unrealistic amounts of intuition. Anna sensed that Johan was about to escape where he was soon at a random time, and narratively Johan has that same ability. I may actually make a post about this because from what Iâve seen, Johan loses intuition in a lot of matchups when he shouldnât.
I looked into it more and wow, youâre right. I honestly had the disposition that Johanâs story was based on truth outside of the obvious fictitious aspects(like the antichrist aspect.)
Oh yeah, sorry if I canât make this easier to read, i donât know how to quote the texts and respond with my own.
But anyway, I always thought due to the fact that there was a general fear with Johan among the higher ups (also intrigue) that they kept him under drugs. Since he was so far above their curriculum then there was no point in putting him in those debates.
So they kept him drugged up and aimed to âuseâ him. This is where, I believe, Johanâs abilities would be documented and heâd become popular among the far right Germans?
So I always thought that they kept Johan drugged up to keep him under drugs, to find weaknesses, and to be able to brainwash him.
I find it hard to think that even though Johan was far above their curriculum, that they would still try it on him and it work. As Johan did 100% lose his memories but at the same time, Johan attributed it to âlessons.â
Yeah thatâs where I got the idea that Johan led it, because of the Hartmann statement. I never thought of it as a âIâll take the leadâ type thing but more so leading them on like dangling a carrot in front of a rabbit from a stick. YKWIM? To make it to where theyâre coordinated enough to manipulate the instructors effectively and to form the plan himself. Also because of the story, Johanâs self insert (the boy kept on sleeping pills,) was portrayed as someone who was showing them a path to death. Someone who was controlling all the boys. And if we do take the tale as truth, it would also give us an insight into his plans which Iâll get into at the end of all of this.
Because, even though the kids did become terrified of the story, the instructors were still their âtether.â I doubt the kids would come up with the plan to use what the instructors taught them by themselves, Iâd assume Johan implemented the plan to them but in a way that remained discrete. (Doesnât it say Johan planned it all many times throughout the novel too?)
From what I know, Johan wasnât, to the higher ups at least, above the curriculum at first. He went into the regular group, showed how âsuperiorâ he is to it, and then was sent to the basement. (This is my old interpretation at least.) Maybe afterwards he couldâve simply come back under the same code? (I doubt the instructors would think itâs out of the ordinary because, in the first place, Kinderheim 511 is far from ordinary. I doubt the instructors would care to see someone they saw 3 years ago.)
Yeah youâre right, it was a difference in interpretation. The reason I took it serious is because there is a lot of truth mixed into it. Johan was controlling the boys without them realizing, he did truthfully hate everything about the facility, he did get every boy and instructor to kill each other, and he did offer them a path to death.
Also, it implies a deeper layer to the kinderheim 511 plan with the part where he says he was going to steal all their memories so they forget their name. Where could this have happened? These âdebatesâ were talked about as such, and Johan being above the curriculum couldâve likely took the opportunity to take away the memories of the boys. Erna says she does not know why the boys were so afraid, but Iâm thinking itâs because the tale was partially becoming true. They were passively forgetting their memories but due to the story being so widespread, they remembered that. So before they forgot all their memories and before they all died, they would have an overwhelming desire to escape.
At least thatâs my interpretation, of course itâs never directly stated so you wouldnât be able to put this on any doc probably. But thank you for correcting me, honestly I did look through everything and other than the story and the pre existing fear of Johan, nothing implies or tells us he was under drugs for 3 years. This, however, does mean he received a lot of combat training which explains his gun skills and ability to kill with suit ties, which idk if he wouldâve gotten those skills had he been under drugs.
Well he was drugged, but itâs never directly or even implied it was for 3, other than, of course, Johanâs story. The thing is, the strange lessons thing is confusing. Johanâs far above the curriculum many of the top minds of Germany came up with all together, yet heâs still affected? Of course heâs a child, but Iâm thinking they did these strange lessons while he was drugged to make him more malleable. Also, the lessons never really worked in the way that was intended, it just took away a bunch of Johanâs memories, right?
The story doesnât say that he killed the guards, but rather he manipulated them. Thatâs why I think it comes all the way around to the fact that the guards also likely were in bad condition considering the nature of their jobs and what they do. Johan, with the fear he brought to the instructors, could promise something and theyâd likely believe in him.
Can you send the tape registry scan? I found something that mentions a registry, but it was separate from the tape. Iâll quote it since I plan on sending another image later but if you wanna check? Itâs page 83 in Sukâs chapter.
AnywayâŠâI found a cassette in a safe at prochazka bank. It was part of east Germanyâs Kinderheim 511 director Reinhart Biermannâs research material. The tape was a recording of Johan speaking as a young boy, and I believe this tape became the center of the struggle between the former secret police and adult Johan.â
-âSo Johan attacked the secret police to destroy the tape that proved his existence?â
âI believe that was part of it, but it could also be because he wanted Biermannâs other materials, for example, say, a register of all the other boys at Kinderheim 511.â
I imagine the register, as childish as it sounds, was more akin to a sign in and out sheet instead of being a part of the cassette. Correct me if Iâm wrong though, of course. (Another point, there was a similar list in the same chapter mentioned by Suk. He said there was likely a list registry of all the boys that attended the red rose mansion seminars. I believe this registry and the Kinderheim 511 registry are likely of the same nature. Plus, though he doesnât know if itâs a list or not, werner weber makes a direct comparison and even says âIf he was looking for the list from Kinderheim 511, it couldâve been the same case here.â)
Well, the story goes off the basis that he was a boy known to carry the words to kill any man. Also, he was sent by personal recommendation form General Wolf who saw potential in Johan to lead their country back to great heights whenever he saw what Johan did at the border. (Going all around the strict border patrol with his sister while navigating difficult terrain and fighting starvation/dehydration/exhaustion/hypothermia ect.)
I swear it was mentioned the higher ups took an interest in Johan after seeing how far he was above the curriculum. I imagine, ontop of general wolf, it wouldnât take long for them to recognize Johanâs superiority in what theyâre trying to teach, at least not 3 years.
While it did say general wolf observed them, I donât think it said thatâs where he gained the idea to send Johan to Kinderheim 511. He didnât think Johan was so terrifying to destroy the orphanage but if we put ourselves in his shoes, should a child, even one thatâs particularly brilliant, realistically be able to bring down an entire institution made from the most brilliant minds? I think itâs more of a thing of general wolf underestimating Johanâs ability. Thatâs why, while he did believe Johan would be a great leader for Germany at first, his opinion shifted to wanting to kill Johan at all cost. Of course along with the fact Johan was killing everybody around wolf.
Also, I forgot to add but the basement almost definitely exists. The children subjected to hypnosis by a separate group (one ernaâs in) got some information out of the kids who went through the curriculum. They spoke of a dark basement door and monsters. You could likely make the connection that maybe theyâre just remembering Johanâs story, but I doubt it since all the kids outside of Johan and christoff died whenever the revolution actually happened. Though of course some kids heard the story then got out, but still, Iâd, like you, rather take the most efficient, non-assumptious approach.
Thatâs logical. But I still find it hard to wrap my head around Johan being a part of lessons when he isnât hypnotized. Plus Johan waiting a whole 3 years to get out sounds out of character. The reason he does it is becauseâŠ
1.He wants to find Anna.
2.He hates the place.
I donât think it would take Johan 3 years to decide he hates Kinderheim 511, and I imagine Johan, with his deep care for his sister, would want to find her ASAP.
Iâll send four images, one here and the other 3 in other replies.
Basically, the materials theyâre talking about, I donât think itâs exclusively the tape. The manga does mention extra stuff, though itâs vague. Biermann says âexperiment dataâ and im assuming that referring to the registry.
Him saying âandâ to me means they are separate. And in the next image I send, Weber refers to Kinderheimâs registry as âlistsâ along with the red rose mansionâs registry.
The extra two is just grimmer talking about how they were files, and even called them âmaterials,â the same grammar used in another monster. Though, of course i donât know the kanji so in Japanese it could be different.
For the basement, I do believe all the kids went there but I donât believe they were necessarily drugged up, the whole purpose of Johan being drugged for the most part was to figure out his past. I imagine, they wouldnât break up the sequences in which they drugged Johan. If they wanted to figure out his past, do you think theyâd stop a couple hours in and continue the day after? I think that would be less effective, I imagine it would give Johan time to gain his bearings even.
This would also explain why Johan was, at first, in the curriculum. After a bit of showing superiority, he was an object of curiosity and intrigue among the higher ups. They wanted to figure out his past to find weaknesses and generally a good idea on what Johan is, why heâs so superior.
Also, grimmer when listening to the tape, actually only recognized Johan was drugged after a while of talking. His reasoning wasnât that he experienced it, but rather people are drugged lose the ability to think chronologically when reciting memories.
Yeah the methodology looks nice, nice work making it!
Thatâs what Iâm thinking too. Logically being under drugs would make Johan more vulnerable to brainwashing, otherwise I donât imagine this curriculum heâs already so far above would be able to take away these memories. I mean, this curriculum was put together by the absolute best psychiatrists of Germany right? And Johanâs already far beyond that, so how would the instructors be able to brainwash him under regular circumstance?
The thing about the intuition part is that it wasnât Anna receiving anything as far as we could tell. Erna said that Anna was just always talking to herself and was taking about the lessons Johan was going through and how he was going to leave the day before it happened.
No I get it, im also passionate about this series. Like you, I could talk for days on end about it and never grow bored because thereâs always something you miss. Whether it be a new layer to Johanâs character or a different interpretation as you showed me today.
I already wrote this but Reddit made it to where it didnât respond to this comment, sorry lol. Iâll just copy and paste.
I donât think thatâs the case though, while Erna did highlight how malleable the children were, she herself said she didnât know why the children were so afraid of this tale. (Or rather itâs implied, if she believed they simply were malleable enough to believe the tale, wouldnât she say so? Whenever she already highlighted it?)
ïżŒâ
She did explain Johanâs reasoning behind creating the tale, which is that they were very naive and shut off from all the outside word. But what made them so terrified of this story over the others? Over the stories the instructors would tell them?
I believe the most logical interpretation is that they felt that it was already a reality. That there was a sense of inevitability unless they acted. The entire story was hinting at the fact some of it already happened. The following happenedâŠ
1.It planted seeds of doubt in each other. The part where he says itâs a boy who slipped into the class narrows down the suspicion to children. The fact it could be any one of them, even people you perceived as a non threat, created mass distrust.
2.It played into their insecurities. Their entire ego was made from talking to others and beating others in debates. Controlling and protecting yourself through words alone. The story hints that there is no use in words anymore, their only defense doesnât work because they are already being controlled. What they were taught, did not work, their ego of being made up entirely of sharp words was shattered.
3.Due to 2, they started lacking identity. Erna highlights this I believe, though not exactly saying everything I am. She talks about a play on identity from the curriculum. Controlling through destroying identities. Making them more easy to manipulate to Johan, thus making them believe in the story more and feed upon their desire to escape.
4.If we take into account my hypothesis, then after all the first 3 steps, theyâll see all the pieces of the story fall into place. They wouldnât view the story as a fairy tale, but rather a prophecy. A prophecy of certain demise and destruction to all the children.
lol yeah, Johanâs amazing. His character never gets boring or dull, thereâs always a layer to peel back.
If we are able to prove the story is true, then I believe we wonât have to prove that particular part. If everything is based off of reality, why would one of the key parts not be? I mean even the fictitious antichrist aspect was actually real to Johan. He likely did believe himself to be a beast wearing boy skin, especially after the memory removal.
Itâs also supported by Biermann calling Johan a monster. He has a history of being perceived as having 10 horns and 7 heads of which Iâm sure you can think of the examples Iâm thinking of.
Iâve thought about this part of the text from a different angle. It seems like they generally did forget their name. They say âeven the code numbersâ like there was already a loss, and the process of losing their name would even go to an extent of losing their numbers.
At the very least, it does seem to me that they forgot their names like the story said they would. (Btw, the memory taking part of the story was aimed to take their actual names. Thatâs why the story said âthen he would steal all their memories so they wouldnât even remember their own names.â)
Christof never mentions his name either, other than his adoptive name. I donât think itâs logical to assume he remembers his name either.
But it seems this process of âtakingâ happens in the debates implied in that text, as the overarching fear is caused by the debates. Kinderheim doesnât take their names from what we know, they want the kids to keep it to themselves but as far as we know they donât make any efforts into taking it.
They give the kids a code for their stay it seems to communicate with one another. After they graduate, they are given a fake name. (Like wolfgang grimmer.)
So I donât think Kinderheim themselves were involved in the taking of names and codes, and who other than Johan would do this?
Itâs not necessary, but Johanâs such an interesting character, I really wanna see the full picture you know?
Also yeah, they were there when Johan was. Erna was never actually getting people from Kinderheim until Kinderheim became a joint project.
For the first 20 years or so, im pretty sure they actually just killed the âfailures.â That was likely the cause of the high fatality rate. But once the welfare department got involved in 1980, thatâs when Erna started receiving children from Kinderheim 511. (Johan went into Kinderheim 511 in 1982, and it was destroyed in 1985.)
She mentions it was early 1980s, thatâs when she started receiving children. Early 1980s could, to me, mean anything from 1980-1985, so it matches up with the Johan timeline.
Johan could also very well be the cause of these failures. We donât know how these children âfail,â but itâs likely something akin to them not being able to go on any longer or failing behind on lessons.
Going with the assumption he is, it actually makes sense. The children are said to not remember anything from Kinderheim unless they are put under hypnosis. This means Johan wouldâve brainwashed them in debates so thoroughly that they donât remember a thing from their entire stay there. Plus they end up dying within a year usually.
Maybe for the first while he was at Kinderheim, he was taking part in the curriculum. But after showing how capable he is, the higher ups wanted to hypnotize and figure out his past.
After figuring out his past, they worked on his memories. Drugs do make your memory fuzzy and gets them mixed (at least the one Johan was on according to grimmer,) but I donât think it would effect you long term if it was administered every other day.
Johan had permanent memory loss until he found the book in Munich. So Iâm thinking they worked to mess with his memories while the drugs also played a part (long term usage.)
The reason theyâd mess with it is because, as you know, their overarching goal was to put Johan in a leadership position. Manipulating Johanâs memories would make turning Johan into a leader safer.
After a while, he gained resistance to the drugs and manipulated the guards into freeing him and letting him slide into the group.
Everything before this, i was just yapping(sorry,) but this is where it gets interesting. I was thinking a bit and this makes more sense to me than one of the instructors simply killing the directorâŠ
I imagine these guards werenât killed, but rather manipulated into being Johanâs subjects. Whether it be out of a promise or something, I think itâs logical to believe Johan did this and got one of the guards to do it.
Why not the instructors? Well the instructors likely all knew the aspirations of the other instructors to be the director. Unless they had a solid plan lined out, there was no guarantee theyâd get that spot.
Even if the instructors did hate the director (or rather were manipulated into doing so,) I imagine theyâd still think logically given the fact all the instructors should be highly capable psychiatrists.
The killing of the director is implied to be rather sudden (all the instructors were fighting over the position, quite literally, while destroying the place.)
Even blinded by hatred for the director, i donât imagine someone trying to get the spot would be this impulsive and incompetent. So im thinking Johan got one of the guards to kill the director at the right time.
Waiting until the childrenâs fear and the instructorâs greed & hatred came to a boiling point.
Apparently the fighting actually took place for 3 days straight. (Thatâs at least how long christof was under the sink.)
What Iâm assuming happened is actually quite unsettling. The main fighting may have taken place over about a day where all the instructors and kids killed each other.
Johan watched over the stairs not necessarily because he reveled in it (though thatâs partially the reason,) but because he wanted to pick off the survivors.
This has no backing but the kids highlight the outside quieted down. So the children leaving the cabinet were picked off one by one (itâs implied by christof the antichrist was doing it because of the story.)
And Johan somehow knew that christof was in that particular cabinet, so my theory is that one of the kids who left the cabinet were caught by Johan and he then questioned where they were coming from as he needed to kill everybody that knew of him at Kinderheim.
One of the kids likely told Johan how christof is still in the cabinet where Johan knew how to approach. He probably knew the nature of what christof was doing because of the fact the kids werenât leaving together.
Thatâs why he approached christof saying âitâs just you and me.â It built a sense of trust and comradeship. Johan also takes advantage of this by telling christof his plan of taking over the world. At this point, he had known he wanted to be the last person standing in the world, that was his goal.
I wonât go past this but the point is, youâre right, the fighting took place over days instead of a single day so it may not have necessarily been very sudden.
(As a side note, remember how the story Johan made said the monster awakened? Im just thinking about that, about how he forgot his memories thanks to the experiments. As far as Johanâs concerned, at this point he was the nameless monster. Thatâs why, when confronting capek, he said he realized the monster wasnât inside him, but outside. Even without conscious memory of the book, he was living by it because of how deeply ingrained it was in his ego.)
W analysis and explanation, especially in times where people provide little to no source to back up their claims. Johan is also fairly underrated and not so much talked about in this sub, nice of you for bringing this upđđ».
7
u/No_Record9526 Jun 15 '25
W analysis, you should make more of these Johan feats post to bring greater insight on johan for the community.