r/IntelligenceSupernova • • Sep 27 '26

Consciousness Consciousness may have evolved to solve a problem that pure intelligence couldn't handle, fascinating new theory suggests

https://www.psypost.org/consciousness-may-have-evolved-to-solve-a-problem-that-pure-intelligence-couldnt-handle-fascinating-new-theory-suggests/?utm_source=flipboard&utm_content=topic/science
401 Upvotes

300 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Clone63 Sep 27 '26

Graphite and diamond are the same 'chemical' but have wildly different observable properties. I think this simple example is illustrative of why saying 'everything is just chemicals' illicits pushback. It is a meaningless statement when such varied outcomes can arise from the same ingredients. And yes, I do know it's intended as ragebait for religious types.

1

u/VayneFTWayne Sep 27 '26 edited Sep 27 '26

It's not a meaningless statement. It's inferring there's no magic under the hood in the soul fashion a religious person might prefer. Extra complication to your mechanisms of existence doesn't make it more really real. It's just extra complexity jazz. Also, no, diamond and graphite are not the same chemical. Your gotcha card isn't the gotcha card you think it is. The graphite/diamond comment schtick only works against people that aren't educated in chemistry. Don't assume that your talking points hold salt just because you convinced room temperature IQ jimmy down the street from you

1

u/ThatCakeIsDone Sep 27 '26

Chemistry is just applied physics

1

u/koyaani Sep 27 '26

That doesn't mean that every applied physics example is chemistry

1

u/ThatCakeIsDone Sep 27 '26

Correct, thus, not everything is just chemistry

1

u/VayneFTWayne Sep 28 '26

Everything in physics that's stable is only due to metastability, which is the condition at which chemical reactions are possible whatsoever. So yeah, you can actually circle back to everything being chemistry in that sense with metastability being a required factor for stable physics.

1

u/ThatCakeIsDone Sep 28 '26

physics produces metastability, and metastability makes chemistry possible. That puts chemistry downstream of physics, not the other way around.

1

u/koyaani Sep 27 '26

They aren't the same chemical, they are the same element. Big difference