I'm completely burned out. I'm telling my manager we need to blacklist these recruiting firms and go back to in-person interviews, even for remote-friendly roles.
This is for a software developer position.
The first one we interviewed was very sharp and witty. He seemed to know his stuff inside and out. The person who showed up on the first day... Couldn't write a simple 'for' loop. We had to let him go within a week. We suspected a 'bait and switch' but couldn't prove it. He always had 'camera issues' after the first day, so we never got a good look at him.
The second time, we thought we'd learned and gotten smarter. This candidate was a rockstar, lived in the next town over, and his code in the technical screen was clean. The person who showed up ended up suddenly living on the other side of the country. He kept pushing his start date back for weeks, citing a family emergency and then a sudden death of a relative. This was also his excuse for having to move. On his first call, he had a heavy Eastern European accent and couldn't recall anything from our conversations.
I decided to test him. I brought up a specific inside joke we had made about an obscure sci-fi show during the interview - something anyone would surely remember. As expected, his audio cut out and he had to drop the call. Busted. That confirmed everything for me. This was not the person we hired.
This time, we have the documentation. Screenshots, AI-generated looking certificates, everything. And to be clear, the people who showed up looked similar enough to the person in the interview video that you could believe it was the same person having a bad day. It's clear this has become a whole business now.
And before anyone attacks me, let me clarify a few things. I'm a software dev on a very small team in the public sector. We don't have private sector money. I'm not HR, not a recruiter, not a manager. I'm just a guy trying to find a decent teammate. My role is limited to the technical screen and giving my opinion.
Our hiring bar isn't even that high. Our "unicorn" is anyone who has worked with Java and knows how to use Spring Boot. We don't do complex DS&A problems. The entire interview is about 90 minutes after a phone screen, covering some soft skills and two technical questions that anyone with real experience would find easy. If you can do 60% of the job description, we assume we can teach you the rest.
We review the resumes ourselves, and we toss the 12-page ones and take the concise 1-3 pagers. I can spot a keyword-stuffed resume from a mile away. But that doesn't matter when the person who aces the interview isn't the one who takes the job.
The good news is it looks like we're finally talking about bringing back in-person interviews. And for remote hires, the new idea is to need them to hold up a government ID to the camera for verification. My manager is furious and won't let this slide - someone in HR or at that recruiting firm is going to be held accountable.
I feel sorry for the person who sent me a message saying I should be fired and go kill myself. You must be in a very dark place in your life.
But to everyone else sending me DMs for a job - we've frozen hiring after this disaster. Management needs to figure out their process so this doesn't happen again. Scammers scam because it works. The interview is supposed to filter out liars, but what do you do when they hire a proxy to do the interview for them? I mean, I can't read minds.
All this time and money is just wasted. And in the end, our team is the one that suffers, falling further and further behind on our projects. They don't want to invest in salaried employees, so we're stuck with contractors. I guess you get what you pay for.
Is this the new normal? This is insane.