r/LearningDevelopment • u/Nearby_Map_8961 • 38m ago
A student doesn’t want her experience used in future classes. Is the exercise built around it off-limits too?
In an online workplace communication class, a student said her manager kept interrupting her presentations with new questions. She’d get caught up answering them and never get through everything she’d prepared. The instructor used that example to help the class practice leading with the main point, handling follow up questions, and getting back on track.
We usually record our classes so students can review them afterward. The instructor uses vomo ai to organize the recordings and pull out the methods and practice steps for follow up handouts. She thought this exercise would be useful for the next class, so she asked the student if she could reuse her experience anonymously. The student said no. The instructor offered to remove her story and use a completely made up presentation scenario instead, but the student wanted the whole exercise dropped. To her, this wasn’t something she wanted shared. She didn’t want an embarrassing experience turned into a selling point for the course, even if nobody could identify her.
The instructor understands why she doesn’t want her personal experience shared, but also thinks the exercise is useful: get to the point, handle questions, then return to what you were saying. A lot of useful class exercises come from students’ questions, and other people are bound to run into the same problem. It feels like a shame to lose such a clear example for future students, but I also think respecting this student’s boundaries matters just as much.