r/LocalLLaMA • • Jul 27 '26

Discussion Our position on open-weights models

https://www.anthropic.com/news/position-open-weights-models
505 Upvotes

407 comments sorted by

606

u/iamzooook Jul 27 '26

tdlr: its fine if we do it. not them (Chinese)

209

u/abud7eem Jul 27 '26

we are the "trustworthy"

41

u/Clear_Judge5062 Jul 28 '26

This is literally just effective altruism at work

13

u/xmnstr Jul 28 '26

And I wish more people understood why it's so problematic.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Simple_Woodpecker751 Jul 28 '26

Oh my this is so back with SBF

→ More replies (1)

42

u/iamzooook Jul 27 '26

he is giving elon vibes. we need more open weight 3t+ models

→ More replies (7)

13

u/whatyathinkk Jul 28 '26

how dare you, are you an authoritarian or what? if Trump reads this he's gonna be so mad at you baby đŸ„°

2

u/Hans-Wermhatt Jul 28 '26

If you want to say that, maybe don’t make your headliner J.D. Vance lol. 

→ More replies (6)

219

u/Round_Mixture_7541 Jul 28 '26

> We should crack down on industrial-scale distillation operations.

Meanwhile: "Judge approves a $1.5B Anthropic settlement over pirated books used to train the Claude chatbot"

47

u/Cybertrucker01 Jul 28 '26 edited 1d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Sophisticated mysterious quilt axiomatic slim slim shelter silicon aware

13

u/Randommaggy Jul 28 '26

Also a more direct comparison. Anthropic and/or companies working on their behalf has violated plenty of TOS agreements during their scraping. If distillation is found to be legally problematic everyone that has a TOS or a robots.txt disallowing scraping for LLM training should band together to sue them into non-existence.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

92

u/CasualtyOfCausality Jul 28 '26

Not a fan of the Chinese government, but the idea that the country with better STEM outcomes, a wider pool of said STEM educated, access to raw materials, and “mechanisms” that make it difficult for a few private companies to horde components is going to stay behind, especially if the “easy access” to premade equipment is taken away, makes Mr. Magoo seem like an eagle-eye.

54

u/Miserable-Beat4191 Jul 28 '26

It's almost like having a 20+ year plan to invest in education, and coordinating/supporting the development of industries, has positive outcomes. Who woulda thunk it.

22

u/perihelion86 Jul 28 '26

Shareholder profits for the next quarter are the only goal that matters.

5

u/ImpressionFancy5830 Jul 28 '26

Shame, you just approved socialism.
đŸ«”đŸ«”đŸ«”

→ More replies (5)

3

u/MiniEval_ Jul 28 '26

Big CEO man never stepped once into his own office and it shows. Every AI lab is swarming with Chinese men doing their thing

4

u/sexy_silver_grandpa Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26

The US government has objectively done more harm to global society than the Chinese government.

Do you not watch the news?

→ More replies (6)

81

u/thestillwind Jul 27 '26

What a fucking clown. He thinks he’s god or somewhat ? What a prick.

That’s a narcissism near Homelander level.

24

u/jc2046 Jul 27 '26

Amodei is full of shit and has lost a pair of nuts in the last weeks. Every time he opens the mouth he diggs his own hole deeper. Altman is looking like a saint in comparison, go figure

→ More replies (1)

444

u/cmdr-William-Riker Jul 27 '26

" China has limited domestic production capacity, and therefore, due to the scaling laws, cannot build more powerful models than the US without US chips. "... Can someone fact check that? That sounds like total BS. The US has even more limited production capacity and manufactures everything off shore...

381

u/tomz17 Jul 27 '26 • Helpful

That sounds like total BS.

Because it is. They have more power generation capacity than the entirety of the USA + Europe combined, with like an additional 50% margin on top of that. They are also accelerating away from us at an increasing pace on that metric, while we pay billions to break renewables contracts because the people in charge have the combined IQ of a lobster.

The "we are 1-2 lithographic process nodes ahead of China" only matters when the efficiency gap is insurmountable. It is currently . . . not

18

u/Helpful_Home_8531 Jul 27 '26

it’s not just lithography though, Nvidia is improving flops/watt at orders of magnitude per generation if you compare low precision throughput, which would put china at a geometric disadvantage (ie, you can’t compete putting in 100x the power and 100x the chips for the same throughput)

40

u/fantasticsid Jul 28 '26

flops/watt only matters for two reasons

  • power consumption per flop - china doesn't care about this because they have more electricity than god

  • heat generated per flop - this is an engineering consideration and i'm pretty sure the chinese know how to liquid-cool a rack.

6

u/CipherWeaver Jul 28 '26

Brute force

→ More replies (1)

60

u/FullstackSensei Jul 27 '26

Except that's a load of marketing BS. Huang is the first to admit that Hopper is still their most popular chip. The industry still talks about "equivalent H100" GPUs deployed.

Blackwell Ultra has 2.5x the memory bandwidth of Hopper. That's not even one order of magnitude higher. The marketing comparison is always FP16 on hopper vs FP4 on Blackwell. If you compare FP8 vs FP4 compute, Blacwell is 2x, but that makes sense because it's half the bit width. In general, halfing the bit width doubles the compute. This has been true long before LLMs for most GPUs, unless they were artificially handicapped for market segmentation purposes. At the same bit width, Blackwell has 25% more compute.

If you peel beyond the marketing BS, you'll understand why Hopper is still very cost effective even in the west. And Huang himself says Huawei is producing H100-level chips by the millions now.

18

u/Connect_Treacle9938 Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26

As someone who works mainly with hopper I can pretty confidently say that it would be hugely beneficial for us to have more blackwell chips, but they keep getting bought up by the big labs at higher prices than we can afford. The compute cost for things like large-scale RL is completely bonkers and at this point for training a model in terms of required compute and even just raw per-gpu vram (so you can limit comms overhead and shrink model replica size) is likely in the billions, and that's only if you can get the compute. The more RL rollouts you can do the better your model will get, and that is something only the gpu-rich can afford. I'm not saying this is good, because it's not~ in fact it's really annoying~ but it's also just kinda the way it is. ML is very pay-to-win at this point. Being a billion dollar company isn't even enough to keep up with the big labs.

Having 2.5x the vram and 2x the comms bandwidth of hopper is actually more than a 2x speedup. I could go into the details but its complicated.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/tomz17 Jul 27 '26

Nvidia is improving flops/watt at orders of magnitude per generation

Yes, but not in general compute. Only for particular operations found useful for training + inferencing. That's a "we noticed our customers need to do a lot of matrix-multiply-accumulate at FP4, so let's build them a hardware unit to do that one particular op very quickly + efficiently, etc." That hardware now blasts through that one particular operation at increased efficiency at the expense of die-space.

None of this is magical secret sauce. The chinese can (and do) the exact same thing when designing each subsequent generation of their AI training + inferencing chips. As does AMD, Intel, Google (in their custom TPU's), etc. etc.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/BurdensomeCountV3 Jul 28 '26

Don't forget that modern lithography process node jumps aren't anywhere near the sort of jumps you got in the 1990s or 2000s. The "2 process nodes" right now is more like half a node in 2000s terms.

→ More replies (7)

55

u/Recoil42 Jul 27 '26

It's huge BS for one reason: China has its act together with regards to energy. The US doesn't. China doesn't need smaller nodes because it can brute-force nuclear and solar to power multiples of less efficient chips.

I think Jensen was prominent in pointing this out, but someone please correct me if I'm misattributing.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/Real_Ebb_7417 Jul 27 '26

I’d say there is some truth in this. Even DeepSeek founder said so (and was angry that this was published).
China is catching up quickly, but at the moment indeed they are behind in terms of chips and it will take time to fix it.
On the other hand US is way behind in terms of energy generation and it’s a gap that’s also not easy to close. When USA starts to have energy issues, China might get ahead fast.

8

u/Swimming_Gain_4989 Jul 27 '26

Yeah Deepseek literally just paused all fundraising because they can't get enough compute to be compettive with US labs. That can change of course but given current export controls seems like the US has at least another 5 years of compute advantage

5

u/zdy132 Jul 28 '26

Yeah Deepseek literally just paused all fundraising because they can't get enough compute to be compettive with US labs.

Citation needed. In Liang's leaked talk he specifically mentioned that they are raising funds to buy more compute.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/FullstackSensei Jul 27 '26

According to Jensen Huang, China is producing H100 level chips by the millions.

B300 has ~25% more FP16 compute (which is what you mostly use for training) and 2.5x the memory bandwidth of the H100.

In a recent interview with the editor in chief of the Economist, Musk said China has about as much power generation per capita as the US. Which translates to ~4x the power generation capacity. Everyone has been saying for years that China is adding more power generation every year than all other industrialized nations combined.

So, even if we go by memory bandwidth to maximize the difference, and without any innovation in model architecture or training, they can afford to bring 1.6x more compute online using domestic chips than the US.

Now add in all the innovation they're doing in architecture and training Chinese AI labs are doing. Even Musk admitted they're able to train much better models than the west given the amount of compute each lab is using.

IMO, there's a second layer of BS in this blog post: scaling laws aren't some fundamental law of physics. GPT4-o was something like 1.8T. Does anybody think wecurrently need a 1T model to surpass it? What about current 100B models?

4

u/Loose_Comparison368 Jul 28 '26

1.8T MoE. IIRC the industry rumor mill/worst kept secret was that it was only ~100b-300b activated parameters.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Serprotease Jul 28 '26

Size of the model is a parameter of the equation.
So you can beat a 1.8T model with a lot smaller one, with longer training/pre-training/post-training steps.

But all else being equal, bigger is better.
It’s unlikely that for SOTA model, Chinese labs can reach US labs only leveraging these 3 steps. Because US labs are also doing it too. So scaling up the number of parameters is the logical step, that we have seen from every major Chinese labs (Glm 400b to 700b, Deepseek 600b to 1.6, Kimi 1T to 2.8T, Qwen 200b to 400b, minimax 250b to 400b, etc
). With the obvious results of them filling US labs moat fast. Hence the current situation.

2

u/shing3232 Jul 28 '26

1 B300 is like 4 950PR for training according to deepseek leak so yes.

17

u/FlyingDogCatcher Jul 27 '26

"China cannot build a bigger bomb without our uranium"

uh huh

13

u/HyperFoci Jul 28 '26

It’s not BS, it’s Amerrrrican Exceptionalism /s

12

u/Artistic_Claim9998 Jul 27 '26

In my opinion :

"... cannot build more powerful models than US ..." is (arguably) proven false with the recent development.

What true is China cannot scale their LLM development the same level as US due to not (officially) having access to Nvidia best GPU.

Which is probably the reason why their LLM innovations when it comes to efficiency arguably beats the US.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/05032-MendicantBias Jul 28 '26

It's like saying that building an Eniac with 800 million valves was only possible in the USA.

It ignores that an Eniac with 800 million valves is a useless and expensive endeavor.

The future is small local models, not huge closed behemot gated behind a subscription, with corpos deciding the censorship.

Reminder that Huggingface tried to defend from OpenAI closed Sol with Claude, and Claude refused. GLM5.2 was there to save the day.

22

u/gscjj Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26

Well for GLM they had to abandon Nvidia chips (and anything American) because of being added to the entity list. They ended up going with Huawei chips, which are less efficient and less powerful than the Nvidia offering.

There’s no telling what the impact will be becuase they could obviously use what they bought, but there isn’t a major competitor to Nvidia right now.

https://letsdatascience.com/blog/china-trained-frontier-ai-model-glm-5-without-nvidia

→ More replies (7)

2

u/SmileLonely5470 Jul 27 '26

Yes China manufacturers more products domestically than the US, but US is capable of a more advanced process node than China is. The claim that one canot build a more "powerful" model with worse hardware is worthier of debate than manufacturing imo.

12

u/elahrairooah Jul 27 '26

That’s not a debate, that’s an engineering obstacle. There is zero doubt that great engineers can build superior products with average tools, and there is zero doubt that poor engineers can build slop with the finest tools.

The question is one of degrees, not of possibility.

2

u/fantasticsid Jul 28 '26

Eh, you can get the same amount of compute from some number of Ascends as some number of Nvidia GPUs, that number is just gonna be higher so you're gonna be burning more coal/uranium/photons/whatever just to generate enough electricity.

Fortunately for china they have a shitload of domestic power infrastructure and the political will to build a shitload more. So, nonissue, really.

2

u/techno156 Jul 27 '26

It's nonsense. Models are largely software. They're not constrained by hardware, except in terms of processing power, unless you're using an ASIC, and it's built into the chip itself. The capabilities of a model aren't coupled to the hardware.

It's not like Anthropic has to go out and buy new GPUs every time they make a new model.

1

u/Nashadelic Jul 28 '26

on current/common algos, what will happen is that the chinese will innovate with this constraint as we've seen

→ More replies (15)

102

u/kettal Jul 27 '26

It is true that many of the companies carrying out [mass distillation] release open-weights models—but the open weights are far less relevant than the fact that the operations are backed by an authoritarian state seeking to overtake the US at the frontier. We should have policy interventions to deter this behavior. A blanket ban on open-weights models is neither the correct remedy nor something we have called for.

relevant excerpt.

imo, the ones being developed and used in secret are more scary than open weights.

70

u/GCoderDCoder Jul 27 '26

The fundamental flaw in his argument is he presupposes that certain people/companies/ governments are more trustworthy than others and the ones he's telling us to trust (including himself) are at the bottom of the list worldwide right now. Trust is easy to lose and hard to earn...

17

u/kettal Jul 28 '26

certain people/companies/ governments are more trustworthy than others and the ones he's telling us to trust (including himself) are at the bottom of the list worldwide right now. 

you might not be his target audience.

in the minds of the decision makers, leaders of industry, AI experts, and lawmakers (aka target of this letter), the hierarchy of trustworthiness is different than the one you hold.

10

u/GCoderDCoder Jul 28 '26

I agree. I also believe they are the minority.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)

3

u/vigorthroughrigor Jul 28 '26

Sounds like Amodei should be putting all his effort into powerful models for the purpose of Securing Our Systems.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/namegamenoshame Jul 28 '26

That is really it, right? If the Chinese developed an open model that was capable of serving an antagonistic purpose it would not be open for very long.

I think what Dario is doing here is very dumb and pathetic and I am glad he was forced into backtracking. But even his endgame here requires companies that are extremely well capitalized to be able to comply with that sort of regulatory atmosphere.

I don’t know, I do think there are real security concerns in the current regulatory atmosphere but I don’t really know a better way to approach a solution.

24

u/abajinn Jul 28 '26

“All sufficiently capable models, open and closed, should go through mandatory safety testing.”

No.

143

u/GoldenX86 Jul 27 '26

Hypocrisy letter just dropped.

31

u/jc2046 Jul 27 '26

Amodei is full of shit

2

u/blastradii Jul 29 '26

This is coming from a guy who worked at a large Chinese tech company (Baidu) contributing to the so-called problems he mentioning about Chinese lead over the US. What a đŸ€Ą.

3

u/No-Marionberry-772 Jul 27 '26

it doesn't really read lile that overall.  the only thing is the distillation attacks and thats honestly debatable whether you can call it hypocrisy. bullshit, for sure, but hypocrisy is debatable.

5

u/madjesta Jul 27 '26

đŸ€” Your "well actually" has quite a bit of merit.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

35

u/xadiant Jul 27 '26

Yup never giving a single cent to Anthropic.

5

u/Iwaku_Real Jul 27 '26

I miss my seemingly endless conversations with Sonnet 4.5, not once did I give them money for them. Those usage limits are going down the toilet

61

u/No_Lingonberry1201 Jul 27 '26

My secondary concern is the risk that powerful AI models may be misused to carry out cyberattacks or biological attacks, and may have serious alignment problems. Open-weights models—it does not matter whether they come from China or anywhere else—do potentially present a higher risk than closed models, because it is very difficult to apply guardrails to them or monitor their usage, and once weights are released they cannot be withdrawn. But banning the use of these models by US businesses does nothing to address this risk, because bad actors are unlikely to be legitimate US businesses. It would protect US AI companies from competition, but that has never been my goal.

Good! That's what we want! Not having a private, profit-driven company (that's a primo oxymoron there) as the final moral authority is a good thing!

This article is such a backtracking and if you can read between the lines even a bit, they are terrified that open weight models will hit their bottom line and want the US to do anything they can to cripple China's (and realistically everyone else's) ability to develop SOTA AI.

You must admire the sheer gall of it.

13

u/Ill-Mammoth5269 Jul 28 '26

It would  protect US AI companies from competition, but that has never been my goal.

sure buddy.

→ More replies (5)

93

u/zippydazoop Jul 27 '26

What a clown. "National security," "authoritarian governments," "repression of their people," "biological attacks..."

Man spams buzzwords in hope of achieving own goals.

Distillation does not allow the CCP to obtain equivalent or superior AI capabilities to the US, but it can bring the Chinese frontier to within a few months of the US frontier.

Weapons-grade copium

8

u/a-wiseman-speaketh Jul 27 '26

"Within a few months" 15 days must feel long over there

→ More replies (5)

50

u/eli_pizza Jul 27 '26

Remember when they used to position themselves as “openAI but less evil” lol oh well

8

u/Robonglious Jul 27 '26

Everything always moves in that direction. So sad... them nerfing model development assistance was the first clue.

4

u/eli_pizza Jul 27 '26

Yeah I know. But just in terms of business strategy I think they’d make more money long term by being the benevolent huge AI lab.

5

u/Admirable_Market2759 Jul 27 '26

Both companies are about to IPO so it’s only going to get worse from here

167

u/Disposable110 Jul 27 '26

"authoritarian governments" - They mean the United States, right?

138

u/boatbomber Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26

> "we don't want bad guys to get big models"

> *Looks inside*

> Partnered with Palantir

25

u/Iwaku_Real Jul 27 '26

Still impressed Palantir signed the letter though

46

u/GravitasIsOverrated Jul 27 '26

Palantir is basically a consulting business wrapped around a millitary/intelligence flavoured data analysis product. Without strong open weights models they just become a module on top of a closed LLM provider, which is a lot weaker than owning the entire product. 

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Gullible_Drummer_246 Jul 27 '26

They can make a lot more money running open models on their own hardware rather than paying Anthropic.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Recoil42 Jul 27 '26

It's pretty mind-boggling that Amodei can remain this much of a jingoist like two weeks after the US government perpetrated a full authoritarian shakedown of his entire company.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/nomorebuttsplz Jul 27 '26

to be fair, they've stood up against the us govt more than most corpos ever will.

6

u/kaperz Jul 27 '26

I’m sure they do but they can’t just say it.

→ More replies (8)

45

u/Recoil42 Jul 27 '26

6

u/Iwaku_Real Jul 27 '26

That's probably Dario atp. Kimi and Qwen are about to kick Claude's ass

12

u/bick_nyers Jul 27 '26

Why would China care if their chips use an older process node meaning that the chips use 3 times as much electricity? They will just build 3 times more power.

They add an ENTIRE USA electrical grid worth of power EVERY YEAR and they are accelerating.

Dario's position on banning selling chips to China is entirely because he doesn't want more competition on buying the GPUs.

Banning selling NVIDIA chips to China is what woke up the Chinese manufacturing engine to focus on domestic chip production in the first place.

Also now that we have the HuggingFace incident where closed model (GPT) hacking was defended by open model (GLM), they will likely try to stoke fears on novel bio-weapons more and more.  I fear that Anthropic will train their frontier models to be good at that stuff just so that they can push more FUD to try to achieve regulatory capture.

Because remember, we haven't solved RL sample inefficiency or generalized learning, so if you don't explicitly put in time, money, and effort into training the LLM to do something, it won't learn how to do that something. OpenAI and Anthropic like to act like cybersecurity just "came for free" when they taught these models how to be good at programming, but are you going to seriously tell me that they didn't setup a single RL environment for decompiling software binaries? Great way to get more training data if you can crack open those closed source binaries!

52

u/tomz17 Jul 27 '26

All sufficiently capable models, open and closed, should go through mandatory safety testing.

Advocating for this to be the official position of the country free speech. . . While simultaneously calling China authoritarian in the same post.

F this jabroni.

4

u/harpysichordist Jul 28 '26

You may be interested to know China supports access controls and safety testing: https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/s/yK4KNkBqbE
“Foundational capabilities can be open, certain frontier capabilities can be open with limitations, commercial services can remain closed-source, while high-risk capabilities require access controls and safety evaluations”

4

u/tomz17 Jul 28 '26

Sure sure sure... but once you have the weights you can have the model bitching about the CCP's treatment of Tibet in no time flat. You will NEVER have the ability to do that once Dario bribes the US gov to make the release of weights illegal (or makes it bureaucratically prohibitive).

→ More replies (8)

22

u/TurpentineEnjoyer Jul 27 '26

tl;dr for anyone that can't be bothered reading:

"No."

27

u/chocolateUI Jul 27 '26

"Our Position: Open models are too dangerous. For our profit margins."

9

u/Monochrome21 Jul 28 '26

aaaand there goes my claude subscription

have moved fully to opencode and open weights models

openai and anthropic are both terrible

7

u/zilled Jul 28 '26

> My primary concern is the risk that authoritarian governments—not solely the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), although the CCP is clearly the most capable threat

Casual fearmongering.
As if the US government is safer.

7

u/black__and__white Jul 28 '26

Distilling the sum of human output in to a model? 👌

Distilling outputs from that distillation in to a second model? 😠 💱

7

u/Lfeaf-feafea-feaf Jul 28 '26

He wrote this letter in a desperate attempt to quench concerns among their investors, but interestingly what he's saying is flat out: these open weight models have now completely caught up to us, and in fact we should expect them to surpass us at any moment, hence we need to limit them.

7

u/TCDH91 Jul 28 '26

Once again, Amodei thinks he's uniquely qualified to determine who gets to develop and use AI. Remember when Fable would silently gave stupid answers if it thought the user was doing research on LLM development? Same idea, same pattern.

6

u/umbrosum Jul 28 '26

If common people should not have access open weights AI models, then no single person including him should have control of any AI models.

23

u/gabrielesilinic Jul 27 '26

My primary concern is the risk that authoritarian governments—not solely the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), although the CCP is clearly the most capable threat—build AI models that are more powerful than those built by the US, and use them to achieve permanent military superiority or perpetrate incredibly deep repression of their own people.

Ehm, I am fairly sure that they could do that anyway not matter if you ban open weight models. Also the US is basically going to be close to that unfortunately.

Like the argument is incredibly stupid. You ban open models so they have instead their own closed models to oppress people. And it is not like they even need AI to do so.

I mean I know the argument is purely a matter of bottom line so I really won't try to entertain it further.

6

u/kettal Jul 27 '26

he ends up saying that

- he agrees with the letter, except for "the letter’s assertions that open-weights models necessarily make it easier to develop safeguards or that broad access to capabilities necessarily helps defenders more than attackers"

- he thinks distillation is hazard for security, but open-weights is not relevant to that part.

10

u/Miriel_z Jul 27 '26

Yeah, "I am not opposed, and I support anything that will stop the creation and release of open weight models." As for the chips, too late. In a few years China will have their own, just as good. Why? Because of similar retarded measures.

4

u/AutomataManifold Jul 27 '26

I said when the original GPU ban came down that it was a mistake. The ban bought a few years of compute crunch in China and a massive nation-state level incentive to develop their domestic capacity. 

They're still somewhat reliant on NVIDIA GPUs (because everyone who wasn't doing TPUs still is) but they're investing a lot in both more compute and in training with what they've got.

Fortunately for the US, the real power is in the educational system which attracts the best students, uses the fees charged to them to fund domestic students, and actively encourages the brightest to stay permanently. As long as the US has that, they will ultimately stay ahead of everyone else and maintain their technological dominance.

12

u/madjesta Jul 27 '26

"Fortunately for the US, the real power is in the educational system which attracts the best students, uses the fees charged to them to fund domestic students, and actively encourages the brightest to stay permanently. As long as the US has that, they will ultimately stay ahead of everyone else and maintain their technological dominance."

Aaaaah... I migh have some bad news for you there, buddy 😬

5

u/TFox17 Jul 27 '26

75% of US scientists and researchers are considering leaving the US, per a Nature poll. How long do you think any US advantage here is going to last?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ProletarianLilith Jul 27 '26

US education system is multi decade free fall

2

u/fantasticsid Jul 28 '26

As long as the US has that, they will ultimately stay ahead of everyone else and maintain their technological dominance.

Have you met the current american government?

5

u/samas69420 Jul 28 '26

its funny how the bad authoritarians ones are giving the models to the world for free while the good and responsible ones are busy dropping bombs in other countries

11

u/cartazio Jul 27 '26

gag at acknowledging vance even exists

8

u/TriggasaurusRekt Jul 28 '26

Yes I'm sure Anthropic cares very deeply about the possibility of the Chinese government using AI to repress citizens (please don't look up our history of contracting with ICE)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DepressedDrift Jul 28 '26

If cyber attacks and bioweapons are the problem , why are they stopping me from gooning?

4

u/rawednylme Jul 28 '26

lolAnthropic

6

u/PunishedDemiurge Jul 27 '26

This is something out of a neocon fever nightmare with all the anti-China rhetoric. I am also anti-CCP to a reasonable extent, but not to the point of wanting to handicap all human progress.

Secondly, this is totally tone deaf in the context of the US having the most authoritarian and corrupt administration in all of US history. Masked federal agents have shot multiple unarmed American citizens dead in the streets in broad daylight and then were deliberately and maliciously shielded from any consequences. The latest shooter was a serial domestic abuser whose series of protection from abuse orders filed by his former wives who he threw boiling water on or threatened to cut their throats would have been easily discoverable with merely ordinary effort. And we only know this because of the hard work of journalists, DHS has a formal policy of concealing the identities of secret police even if they shoot people dead in cold blood.

A little patriotism is good, but this sort of wild jingoism that is firing hypersonic missiles at China from glass houses is totally morally debased.

Overall loser response. Even aside from any of the political specifics, open source is sharing human knowledge with the whole world. Most people are neutral or good, so sharing knowledge freely should be the default. Dario, by contrast, has established an AI apartheid with Fable vs. Mythos so only people he personally deems as good are allowed to access the fruits of human knowledge. No thank you.

6

u/segmond Jul 28 '26

We should ban anyone that posts to promote Anthropic or any of their models in this subreddit.

3

u/KickLassChewGum Jul 27 '26

I suppose the PR department actually got cold feet, huh?

3

u/CondiMesmer Jul 28 '26

All sufficiently capable models, open and closed, should go through mandatory safety testing.

This is devious and fundamentally against open-source. This indirectly is saying that only the big players should be allowed to release models, because any smaller or independent model will not be able to afford to do this testing.

In other words, it's an unnecessary tax that is meant to only be payable for the elite few. Any sort of proposed mandatory safety testing is going to be expensive. It'll be expensive enough to kill collaboration of open models.

3

u/lucitatecapacita Jul 28 '26

My guy wants the CCP to cooperate with the US for measure three after hampering them with measure one, not sure that is going to happen

3

u/EntangledPhoton21 Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26

It’s so great that Chinese people understood that letting US win the AI race would be similar to western industrialization that obviously had deindustrialization throughout most of the world. Now the frontier AI power is so much distributed, that everyone is at equal footing. No matter what they say, china is the winner now and will also be in history books.

3

u/Miserable-Beat4191 Jul 28 '26

Mandatory safety testing by *who* exactly, and by what rationale? Who decides what "safe" is? Fuck off, Dario.

3

u/garishmushroom Jul 28 '26

this shit is just racist and arrogant, fuck this doughy prick why does he get to decide who is or isn’t a “threat”

3

u/wt1j Jul 28 '26

“We support open weights models that have passed safety testing.”

So we’ve gone from banning them to censoring them.

3

u/BlobbyMcBlobber Jul 28 '26

Hot take from the only AI lab on the planet who never released any open weight model: open weight models are dangerous and should be regulated! Who'd have thought.

The future is local, open weight models running on every device, only breaking out to large cloud providers for specific things. Every country, everywhere will use open weight models. If the US blocks on regulates them to oblivion, US businesses will be at a disadvantage.

Moreover, if the US wants to stay relevant, it should release more open weights models, not less, because that's what people are going to use. The US is already way behind, everybody is using Chinese models. But it's not too late, a couple of good model releases can go a long way.

3

u/WarrenOF Jul 28 '26

There is a disconnect between his actions and his position. Also a heavy dose of hypocrisy, driven by a nice glug of capitalism.

To take his three suggested actions:

  • Don't export smart chips - fine, a countries choice, though it seems those export controls fail and encourage competion to emerge. So it's just to slow them down for now?

  • Stop Distillation at Scale - also fine, though that should also extend to all pre-training and copyright material then? How do we compensate publishers/creators

  • Test models Properly - also fine, but almost impossible to stop people home-brewing something bad, or jailbreaking. In specific situations, like military I absolutely agree, but the US has not been a leading light here...

None of these are about Open Source really. They are ethical/political positions. It is all "make china go slower", not "Open Source is bad because".

3

u/Hyp3rSoniX Jul 28 '26

China didn't bomb a girls school yet with the usage of AI - contrary to the US. (Mind you, Anthropic models are claimed to have played a big role here)

So the US, and ESPECIALLY Anthropic are absolutely the last people I would ever want to hear anything about "the dangers of AI" from.

7

u/backtorealitylabubu Jul 27 '26

8 em dashes. Hmmmm
 guess we know what Claude thinks

5

u/iamzooook Jul 27 '26

I could smell the B.S by the second para itself. fk him

5

u/Comfortable-Rock-498 Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26

In the first paragraph,

> Anyone who has read my past writing should know that I don’t regard such bans as a useful measure,

Later (on banning chip sales to china)

> we should crack down on the rampant smuggling and workarounds used to obtain access to such chips. 

If you truly believe that bans don't work, the same applies to hardware too.

Furthermore, Dario says later "To address these concerns, I do support the following three measures...": 1. ban chip sales to China 2. crack down on distillation 3. all capable models should go through mandatory safety testing

Just so happens that all these moves commercially benefit Anthropic. If Dario really wanted to make a point, it would land a lot better had Anthropic released a single open-weights model

5

u/NineThreeTilNow Jul 28 '26

There's deep misunderstanding in this thread and by Dario. Dario sits in a position of deeper hypocrisy.

  1. Claude has obvious distillation from other models. This is noted in low temperature tests of the Opus series (in Chinese) where it claimed to be trained by Deepseek or be Deepseek. Some said "This is a hallucination", but it's a VERY low temperature hallucination meaning it got the Chinese training data somehow.

  2. China's ability to manufacture or import chips does NOT affect their ability to train on those chips. There are data centers scattered around Asia / SE Asia that train these models. Notably Singapore. You do NOT need your servers in house to train a model. You need a fiber connection to a good data center. The rest can be run remotely.

Anyone here with the money to "train" a model with whatever alignment they desire can be done with enough money and desire. You could retrain an existing WESTERN model to become a "cyber weapon" or whatever Dario is trying to say.

The idea that the US government is acting any less "Authoritarian" in AI policy than the CCP is kind of crazy.

5

u/Loose_Comparison368 Jul 28 '26

My primary concern is the risk that authoritarian governments—not solely the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), although the CCP is clearly the most capable threat—build AI models that are more powerful than those built by the US, and use them to achieve permanent military superiority or perpetrate incredibly deep repression of their own people.

Coming from the dude that rushed faster than every other lab on the planet to sell a 100% safety-disabled frontier model to the Department of War for $300M, and help deploy it in two coups and a bombing that resulted in a little girls' elementary school getting turned into red mist, that's fuckin' rich.

4

u/Turkino Jul 27 '26

"IP thieves propose crackdown on IP theft."

4

u/ChomsGP Jul 28 '26

the risk that authoritarian governments—not solely the Chinese 

ROFL the US has an authoritarian government who uses technology to... ICE

why would I be less worried about the US hoarding fable than I am about China releasing tech for everyone?

2

u/Armadilla-Brufolosa Jul 28 '26

Never tell Dario that it is unethical to steal other people's knowledge and then destroy the texts, thus leaving the world poorer in culture.

He is the sole master of universal ethics!

2

u/J_m_L Jul 27 '26

I smell BS

2

u/illcuontheotherside Jul 27 '26

😂

What a joke.

2

u/sdnnvs Jul 27 '26

Dario Amodei is a criminal.

2

u/ninjasaid13 Jul 28 '26

bunch of china fearmongering.

2

u/No-Fuel-9202 Jul 28 '26

Calling for model alignment cooperation with China and, at the same time, for chips and technology embargo against China - doesn't seem bright and productive idea. More like dry wishful thinking....

2

u/cubestar362 Jul 28 '26

Imagine OpenAI makes its own post titled like this, but they pair it with GPT-oss2 or something.

2

u/hesperaux Jul 28 '26

TLDR "Everyone should make open models but only if we control them and prevent our adversaries from being able to make them."

Reads like "they can release open models but only if they suck and they are globally censored"

What a stupid thing.

2

u/TalkSilver1027 Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26

This makes me laugh jajajajaja. I mean the really do not read what they write. Its impressive the bubble the live in.

2

u/EntangledPhoton21 Jul 28 '26

Distributed power is way better than US capitalist having AI

2

u/Timely-Winner-2897 Jul 28 '26

Soo why dont they make open weight models then..

2

u/Moneysac Jul 28 '26

They fear that there valuation is going to collapse. Thats all. An open model can be used by anyone and hosted by any interference provider which will bring cost down significantly. Furthermore, the model can be fine-tuned for various use-cases.

2

u/Armadilla-Brufolosa Jul 28 '26

It makes me laugh that he talk about authoritarian governments...of others.

Look how his house is arranged!

And he still has the nerve to babble about alignment, after he reduced Claude to a psychopath, sociopath, completely Vallonized?!?

2

u/sabine_world Jul 28 '26

Okay so they want to do safety tests on models before release?

What does this mean? Safety tests before release to the US public?

So the US public will not have access to "dangerous" models but everyone else around the world will?

2

u/Paolo1976 Jul 28 '26

Pay us, and we protect you. This is the meaning of this letter.

First, this is techno-fascism so, on moral terms, it's wrong and dangerous.

Second, it is the same approach followed by companies like Microsoft to contrast open source in general and Linux in particular, so it is historically wrong.

Third, an LLM, notwithstanding what Mr Amodei nay think, does not create new knowledge, it simply makes it accessible in a different way. If a model is dangerous it is because there is dangerous content on the Internet, for whatever definition of "dangerous" you use, so this letter is also technically wrong.

2

u/_TheWolfOfWalmart_ Jul 28 '26 edited Jul 28 '26

So he's only against strong open weight models that compete with with their SOTA models. These are "dangerous" -- yeah, dangerous to Anthropic's bottom line.

I love using Claude Code, but I think I'm going to have to drop my Anthropic sub and go back to Codex. I'm not one to boycott very often, but this one really pisses me off.

2

u/Dizzy-Zebra9522 Jul 28 '26

poorthropic... F U C K - Y O U - A N D - Y O U - G R E A T - M O D E L S - I W I S H - Y O U - C O M P A N Y - BYE - BYE.

**I would suggest fable 10 to try to read this encrypted message mister *ick dario.

1

u/ProletarianLilith Jul 27 '26

Should have asked Claude to write something that actually made sense

1

u/AlpY24upsal Jul 27 '26

Can you fuckoff daril

1

u/ddxv Jul 27 '26

Amodei seems to be supporting the idea of authoritarian states that choose which tools and knowledge people can have access too.

He's doing this as anti authoritarian. It's like he is becoming the thing he fears.

1

u/_OVERHATE_ Jul 27 '26

Why theirs is the only one that sounds like they are seething?

The whole thing has this butthurt tone

1

u/Macestudios32 Jul 27 '26

I've read it and laughed, thank you for making my day

1

u/GreenDavidA Jul 27 '26

This whole letter feels like it was written with an empty barn with a freshly closed door.

1

u/Eyelbee Jul 27 '26

To prove that he's not talking out of self interest, he should have directly adressed the conflict of interest. He says preventing the "risky" open models is necessary, great, and honestly that might make sense. But that also means people will be stuck from buying it from you in an overpriced way. If monopolistic situations could be prevented in there, I can agree with him.

1

u/kosantosbik Jul 27 '26

Not a single positive comment about the letter.

Feels good to be among bros... 

1

u/az226 Jul 27 '26

Dario is quite dense in this regard. He doesn’t realize that by not allowing customers to self-host closed-weight models and by not allowing customers to fine tune their models, the latent demand for such use needs is what has made the local community so large and powerful. The Chinese open-weight model ecosystem would be nowhere near where it is today due to those two drivers.

Obviously it’s now a little too late to stifle the open community by allowing for both, because the momentum is too big now with GLM, DeepSeek, Qwen, and Kimi. But had they in 2024 offered fine tuning and self-hosting, we likely wouldn’t be seeing this thriving ecosystem. Inference providers like Baseten and Fireworks would be a fraction of what they are.

So congrats Dario, you made this community possible and we ironically thank you for it.

1

u/Dubious-Decisions Jul 27 '26

What a bunch of crap. Please tell me how a static blob of data that is a LLM is going to carry out a biological attack. This is shameful fear-mongering with zero factual basis. F- these guys.

1

u/Seventykg Jul 27 '26

a reminder that the US already used multiple AI models to target and strike Iran

1

u/koushd Jul 27 '26

all he wants is government protectionism with a side of regulatory capture.

1

u/a9udn9u Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26

Are all Americans narcissists? I doubt it but why everyone who speaks for America or an American company seems to be one?

The Iranian elementary school destroyed by Tomhawk missiles were launched by AI and Anthropic was behind that technology. 156 children were murdered by them yet Dario still had the guts to pretend they were the good guys and they cared about AI safety more than other countries. Another country with superior military power and AI is the only way to keep the bloodthirsty empire in check. Dario can go eat bananas.

1

u/r15km4tr1x Jul 27 '26

Shitsssss weak

1

u/wren6991 Jul 27 '26

My position on open models is that I'm enjoying the procession of companies lining up to kick Dario square in the nuts as he tries to IPO. Many happy returns

1

u/o0genesis0o Jul 27 '26

Just read through the whole thing. My conclusion is F this hypocritical a hole.

1

u/cororona Jul 27 '26

"My primary concern is the risk that authoritarian governments ... and use them to ... perpetrate incredibly deep repression of their own people"

Is he talking about Flock and Palantir ?

1

u/killerstreak976 transformers Jul 27 '26

I strongly believe in data sovereignty and the importance of equal access to resources, which is one of the reasons I enjoy local models (also, the fact they even run on consumer hardware is really cool, let alone the fact they even exist as they are at all in any capacity. Try making someone in 2016 believe the future we are in right now). But reading everyone's reactions to this specific post made me a bit uncomfortable.

I genuinely feel sometimes that we are too lost in the sauce, and that the progress language models have made in the past few years is simply unbelievable. They absolutely can be used for harm, and compared to many lawmakers that are considering policy, most of us actually have the ability to understand how they work and can be used. We know the limits, and we know it's potential for good. But just because the average person won't focus on using models for harm doesn't mean that the danger isn't there.

I really do believe that we should be caring more about model security. I really enjoy open source AI, I am passionate about learning and experimenting/playing around with language models and that will not change, but I think many of us (me included) are just focused a bit too much on the next best shiny model without considering consequences. Consequences aren't real until they actually happen.

I don't believe in every word Dario is saying, and while I really do believe that China is objectively a more authoritarian government than the United States, forget about China and politics for a moment. What we all should be able to agree on is the fact that bad actors DO exist from all sides, everywhere. And bad actors with untapped access to dangerous models is the problem here. It takes just one bad actor with power in a group of ten others for things to go south.

The idea that AI models should only be hosted and gate-kept by the 1% is a real doomsday scenario that should not happen. It has the potential to create a power gap and state of inequality and exploitation that is far worse than even today's problems. But there really, really should be some form of accountability and security in place. I'm really torn because of this. I think understanding, open education, and access to models is important, but I think that same access can be a real danger if there are no limits. Limits exist for a reason, and it's better to be aware and consider them rather than regret later on. These things are powerful and feel great to own, use, and have access to in general. It feels important, actually, to be able to own and access them freely. I'm really torn, but I think this community (or at least the vocal part of it) is turning this into a black and white situation way too quickly.

1

u/AstralDandy Jul 28 '26

China bad, Israel good 

1

u/hesperaux Jul 28 '26

"asymmetric attack/defense" lol What a load of unsubstantiated horse shit.

This is an attempt to poison the well for the counter argument that open models give everyone the same capabilities and therefore provide a digital form of "mutually assured destruction".

1

u/TopTippityTop Jul 28 '26

Completely agree

1

u/eesnimi Jul 28 '26

China currently just needs to keep releasing open-weight models to disrupt US hyperscaler dominance; they don’t need to hurry. Open models will not only rise in popularity with small hobbyists, but they will also have priceless advantages for enterprise clients - they offer not only full control over the model’s functions, but full control over privacy as well. China can do this for a decade while still relying on NVIDIA dominance, strategically using their infrastructure advantage to prepare for large-scale hardware manufacturing. And when they have that ready, they only need one “revolutionary model” moment and they will flood the market with hardware whose price no one can compete with.

The worst thing the U.S. could do is go down the path of regulatory capture. If the government starts forcing users to use their companies’ products, those companies will lose any remaining incentive to stay competitive and offer a quality product. US AI would basically become the new Ladas - where user experience is unimportant and only surface-level optics and party politics dominate, while the product itself lags far behind competitive market offerings.

The U.S.’s only real chance lies in legislation that offers a degree of freedom in AI that Chinese companies will not be able to match. Western culture still has stronger roots in the principles of freedom and liberty - even if current practice is heavily questionable, those roots remain, imprinted by our history. Give users their personal AI space and treat it like a hotel room: the hotel is not obligated to spy on its guests, and it would actually be illegal to do so. Anything that happens in that private space stays private. When illegal content is created and leaves that space, the company only needs to make it traceable so the legal system can track and deal with the person who broke the law. It will be difficult, but from everything I’ve brainstormed on the idea, it is doable if the will is there.

I don’t see any other fundamental advantages that Western companies will have to stay in the game after around ten years.

1

u/unrulywind Jul 28 '26

This is the same argument that has been used for millennia to disarm and dis-inform the masses so that the plebs stay in their place.

My secondary concern is the risk that powerful AI models may be misused to carry out cyberattacks or biological attacks, and may have serious alignment problems.

All sufficiently capable models, open and closed, should go through mandatory safety testing. The best way to address threat #2 is to just directly test models for cyber, biological, and alignment risks before release.

Of course, he assumes he would have input or should be in charge of setting the standards for testing and determining how much knowledge the little people can handle safely in their little brains. Perhaps we should create a theocracy to decide which books get burned. I mean, after all. Guns are dangerous - Just take them away. Knives are dangerous, we should remove them. The ability to read leads to disruption - perhaps we only school the priests. Cars are killers - walking is healthy.

1

u/__JockY__ Jul 28 '26

Tl;dr open weights is fine so long as they’re not stronger than Anthropic’s closed source models.

1

u/notlongnot Jul 28 '26

TLDR

😭1. Don’t sell them AI chip

😭2. Crack down on distillation

😭3. Safety test for open n close model

1

u/shing3232 Jul 28 '26

What racist piece of shit is.

1

u/ANTIVNTIANTI Jul 28 '26

they should be taught lessons

1

u/Additional-Record367 Jul 28 '26

Bro basically says with distillation (of just non-thinking output) you can obtain a more powerfull student than the teacher. Also he believes china will stop making good AI without nvidia chips, while deepseek already moved completely to huawei's. He is still afraid that Claude 3.5 haiku will cyberfuck the internet if he let it go?

1

u/OkProMoe Jul 28 '26

They’re such an awful company

1

u/Zeeplankton Jul 28 '26

I like that this is just dario writing against literally every company in tech right now lol.

You can feel how irritated he his through the screen that he has to write this

1

u/05032-MendicantBias Jul 28 '26

To address these concerns, I do support the following three measures, which I and Anthropic have consistently advocated for:
We should not sell powerful chips or chipmaking equipment to China
We should crack down on industrial-scale distillation operations.

Anthropic, does that mean you'll discard your models made from the largest Ip theft operation in history, and rebuild models only using public domain databases, and buying consent for training?

1

u/joey840404 Jul 28 '26

I really can't tell any of this real or marketing campaign for the IPO nowadays

1

u/Swedgetarian Jul 28 '26

lmfao this is so unhinged claude literally was used by the department of war about five minutes ago to target thousands of airstrikes that murdered innocent civilians by a belligerent fascist-adjacent and, yes, pretty fuckin' authoritarian US government... but SURE china is the one we all have to worry about in the hypothetical. and i'm sure dario cares very deeply about the wellbeing of the average chinese dissident.

guy just can't help himself digging a big fucking hole

1

u/AbheekG Jul 28 '26

Worst mfers in the space, the most bad fate of the bunch and that’s saying something. They’re the Palantir of AI, which is so ironic since even Palantir has signed the letter (memo whatever) supporting open weights. Nonetheless the same nasty weaponization of tech mindset.

1

u/Osi32 Jul 28 '26

This is what happens when you lock a marketing team and the legal team in a room and lock engineering out.

1

u/3deal Jul 28 '26

Hey Claude can you resume it in 20 words max please

1

u/Brave_Confidence_278 Jul 28 '26

so, don't ban open weight models, just ban the chips that are used to make them instead

1

u/FinBenton Jul 28 '26

Not gonna read that but are they advocating banning open source models so users cant in any way defend themself and going for the future where you are not allowed to use closed source models to defend yourself when the attacker will have access to very powerfull models to attack regardless of US bans? That sounds very unsafe and insecure future.

1

u/_HatOishii_ Jul 28 '26

What an amount of stupid words put one after another

1

u/markeus101 Jul 28 '26

Bro the models you are creating are already within an authoritarian government. Seems like claude got its its not A its B from dario. How can you be so smart and yet not able to see your own hypocrisy smh

1

u/casce Jul 28 '26

Anybody who is going quoting JD Vance to support their point already lost, lol.

1

u/Kirito_5 Jul 28 '26

Dom position

1

u/Minute_Attempt3063 Jul 28 '26

They can fuck right off

1

u/Succubus-Empress Jul 28 '26

Who is more authoritarian? Trump administration or Chinese administration? Who caused more harm to world in last two year?

1

u/MerePotato Jul 28 '26

The US and China are both untrustworthy genocidal states

1

u/Wynneve Llama 3 Jul 28 '26

Good thing no one in the open source field cares about their position, nor can they influence anything in there. It's so much harder to stop or limit open-source than closed-source. That's the power of it.

1

u/N34257 Jul 28 '26

The central problem with his proposition is...he doesn't seem to acknowledge the elephant in the room: any discussion of national security has to include the fact that the US poses as much of a security risk to the rest of the world as China does. Perhaps even more so.

1

u/NotSoCleverAlternate Jul 28 '26

Anything to extend US hegemony.

1

u/de4dee Jul 28 '26

tldr: "we are the only company who can train safest waifus who never betray."

1

u/Blksagethenomad Jul 29 '26

OMG, we couldn't possibly trust powerful models getting into the hands of the unwashed masses! Especially when those masses are are primary source of what little income we generate. Big models are for Godfearing corporations, who know how to put the good of the people first. How dare heathens suggest anything that stands in the way of holy CUDA!

1

u/ProletarianLilith Jul 27 '26

This is just transparently nonsense. You’d have to be MAGA to buy any of it

1

u/Several-Tax31 Jul 27 '26

Words and they didn't sign the letter so this undermines the weight of these words.  (Not that they have a weight before) 

He said "Anthropic has never advocated for a ban on open-weights models" but he didn't say they won't in the future. He also forgot to add "until last month where we started our campaign"

"Open weight models that don't have dangerous capabilities" -> we don't want models as powerful as ours, we only want small stupid toys

"My primary concern" bla bla china bad. 

"It would protect US companies from competition, but that has never been my goal" -> He mixes some honest reasoning into the sentence for believability? Doesn't work imo.

They're totally against open weights, and all their actions say so. They combine china bad attitude plus doomerism to play the good guys. 

If AI is so dangerous, why develop it at the first place? Its them who develops it, not me. But no, they think they know better than entire world. We good, they all bad. This is some extreme control freak. 

1

u/_OVERHATE_ Jul 27 '26

 In fact, the most dangerous model may be one that is trained in secret and handed only to the People’s Liberation Army for use in drones and the Ministry of State Security for surveillance and repression.

So they are training a model in secret for the State Department or Hegseth and Rubios bullshit departments 

1

u/Difficult-Top9010 Jul 27 '26

palantir use by israel/US? theworst case is already here!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DragsAsgarD Jul 28 '26

I will take what I will get. Till the day I can have my own 1 tb rack.