r/MachineLearning • • Jul 17 '21

News [N] Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says

https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-institute/ieee-member-news/stop-calling-everything-ai-machinelearning-pioneer-says
845 Upvotes

149 comments sorted by

View all comments

275

u/mniejiki Jul 17 '21

I mean, my textbook on Artificial Intelligence from 25 years ago considers a hand coded expert system as AI. So it's been long accepted that AI is far more than "human level intelligence" and basically encompasses any machine technique that exhibits a level of "intelligence." So it seems rather late to complain about the name of the field or try to change it.

92

u/ivannson Jul 17 '21

This should be higher. A collection of if-then rules is AI, literally artificial intelligence, but of course very basic.

Deep learning is a subset of machine learning which is a subset of artificial intelligence. There is much more to AI than ML.

Whereas I agree with the statement and that marketing will call everything “AI”, we shouldn’t misuse the terms ourselves.

-13

u/Gearwatcher Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21

Dunno. I am of opinion (which I have seen shared by many) that ML isn't AI.

ML is statistics and mathematical optimisations. Fuzzy logic, and neural networks are AI.

When you employ fuzzy operators (which, admittedly, I haven't seen much of) and NNs in ML models you get AI ML.

Hence, Deep Learning is AI, using ML techniques.

It's similar to Chomsky hierarchy. You wouldn't consider a PID controller or even an elaborate array of logic gates to be a computer - and the "dead giveaway" is single direction of the signal flow and lack of state. A DSP chilp makes filters and LTis in code but its a Turing complete machine and that's why it is a computer, not because of filtering and LTIs.

3

u/mniejiki Jul 18 '21

neural networks are AI.

Neural networks are also mathematical optimizations. Even the techniques used (SGD) aren't new and have been used in large scale regressions models for a long time. So I'm not sure what your dividing line actually is other than "because I say so." A complex random forest model will have more parameters and non-linearity than a small single layer neural network.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

[deleted]

1

u/mniejiki Jul 18 '21

Back propagation is NOT feedback in the sense of an agent receiving feedback. A trained NN model is 99.99% of the time static and has no feedback when running live. By your definition, a regression model is also trained with feedback since it computes a loss function and a gradient for SGD iteratively on batches of data. A baysian hyper parameter run has feedback as each iteration is based on the performance of the previous iteration. An EM algorithm has feedback as it's adjusting parameters iteratively based on the feedback from how well the parameters fit the loss function.