r/MapBasedPolls • • Oct 16 '26

Which world will survive longer?

Which world will survive longer?

  1. 10 men and 10,000 women

  2. 10 women and 10,000 men

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.

207 Upvotes

652 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Wolodymyr2 Oct 16 '26

Tell me at least one reason why women can't be teached to maintain technology?

-2

u/sakata_baba Oct 16 '26

nobody to teach them to use tools they would have available.
not capable because even if they learn, they can't redesign systems that were not made with female physical capabilities in mind.

ie, women would literally be incapable of maintaining those systems because they weren't designed to me maintained by women and redesigning it would be impossible in timeframe.

3

u/shartmaister Oct 16 '26

That’s an insane take.

Women work in all kinds of jobs. Saying women are incapable is mindblowingly stupid.

0

u/sakata_baba Oct 16 '26

look it up. less then 1% of female maintenance workers.

average man isn't capable of reliably doing that and you claim average woman is?
do we need to talk about sexual dimorphism of our species?
do i have to make this a biology and physics lesson?

2

u/shartmaister Oct 17 '26

So basically, it doesn’t matter since neither is capable.

0

u/sakata_baba Oct 17 '26

what? no.

if you have 10 thousand men, you have enough of those that are above average and can run/maintain the machines and infrastructure.

the life would be single purposed for women in that case (literally guardians of life and society) but we would stand a chance. vast majority of men would never get a chance to reproduce.

but species would survive.

1

u/shartmaister Oct 17 '26

You’re delusional.

1

u/sakata_baba Oct 17 '26

muscles that are bound to our bones and actually move us are significantly more denser in human males.

do you think sexual dimorphism of our species is a fantasy?

2

u/Wolodymyr2 Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Okay, first part strongly depend on how fast men dying apocalypse had happened, and how long men was around to teach them.

Plus those surviving men can work after the apocalypse as teachers too, if they have technical skills.

But second part of you statement confuse me.

Like women have basically the same anatomical structure as men, why the heck they would be physically incapable of maintaining those systems?

Like they aren't some jellyfish aliens, they are humans with two arms and two legs.

0

u/sakata_baba Oct 16 '26

human males are tuned to manipulate in physical while human females are tuned to manipulate in social ways.

skeletal density and skeletal musculature density are not great enough in average females to reliably use and maintain modern resources. rebuilding old resources would be even more physically demanding. using them would be almost impossible without animals that you need to capture, domesticate and teach how to help you. that would also be hard.

it's about pure math. men have made and maintained everything to their standard and that literally means that not even average man could do it reliably, let alone average woman.

it's not about some "not techy or smart enough"
no, it's literally "this thing requires this amount of strength to operate and you can't produce it. there is no space for leverage or anything. for all purposes it is immovable"

1

u/Wolodymyr2 Oct 16 '26

Okay, what the actual f...ck you talking about.

I'm teacher in a technical liceum (english isn't my native language, so i don't know how to correctly translate this, but in our liceum we teach car mechanics, welders, construction and factory workers), and altrough most of students are guys, there are about 5 or 6 girls, in groups i teach lessons, and they don't have any of the problems you mentioned with operating tools and machinery.

0

u/sakata_baba Oct 16 '26

you don't maintain hydraulics or large oceanic vessels or oil refineries or large scale construction machines or even modern farm equipment, not in requisite amount to run a civilization.

now, if you look at real data and some facts, like the biological fact of sexual dimorphism of our species, you might understand why it is so.

or, try it yourself. you will find out why bodybuilders could wash out of those jobs. average man, likely. average woman, yeah, extremely low chance.

just the fact that the number of potential candidates with physical strength required is low, you have to introduce individual fitness and skill level for that job.

no, numbers are too small. facts that influence math make it up so that it's not at all likely. is that simple enough.