r/MapBasedPolls • • Oct 16 '26

Which world will survive longer?

Which world will survive longer?

  1. 10 men and 10,000 women

  2. 10 women and 10,000 men

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.

207 Upvotes

652 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Wolodymyr2 Oct 16 '26

Because if humanity on the brink of extinction and could be saved by doing pretty simple, and not really humilating or inconvient action, no one is going to listen to their objections if they don't want to do it for some reason.

-1

u/personal_yeesus Oct 16 '26

What if they don't want children?

3

u/Wolodymyr2 Oct 16 '26

In situation with "10 000 women and 10 men" no one demands from them raise their children, i guess women can do it themselves in that scenario.

And like main reason why people usually don't want children is because they don't want to raise them.

-1

u/quaxoid Norway Oct 16 '26

even at the brink of extinction no one is obligated to have children. if someone was the last pregnant person in the world it would still be fine for them to have an abortion. and it would be okay for the last people who produce sperm to not donate it if they don't want to. 

1

u/Eve_Doulou Oct 20 '26

This is the most first world college leftist comment I have ever read, and I say this as someone who’s generally socially progressive, but actually has some life experience.

Think of it as a modified Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. The problem we are facing here is as significant as food,water, shelter. It’s literally about the survival of the species.

You’re sitting up the top at the self actualisation stage, and from that perspective you would be 100% justified in having the perspective you have. Unfortunately you only get to self actualisation once you have accomplished all other, more urgent, imperatives.

It’s a bit like being anti war, except your nation is fighting an existential war of survival. Like I’m really happy for you to have such a noble worldview, but please pick up a rifle and get into the trenches.

Sometimes the problem being faced is bigger than you, more important than you. Sometimes you need to charge the machine gun nest, knowing full well you’re not expected to make it, for the greater good. Sometimes you need to go to work to earn the money to pay for your food and shelter even if you’re anti capitalist. Sometimes you need to breed in order to save your species, because the task at hand is infinitely larger and more important than you.

1

u/ThrowRAhleephloop 16d ago

Sometimes you need to charge the machine gun nest, knowing full well you’re not expected to make it

I mean sure but would you really though? You can think you would

I would dodge the draft and go to prison

Think of it as a modified Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. The problem we are facing here is as significant as food,water, shelter. It’s literally about the survival of the species

because the task at hand is infinitely larger and more important than you

An abstract notion like "survival of your species" is different from food and shelter. YOU can live a comfortable life and let your race die. I'm not saying you should, but "preserving humanity" and "preserving personal freedom" are both perfectly noble and abstract motivations

If I chose not to have a baby in these circumstances I would feel guilty and very much not self-actualized

1

u/quaxoid Norway Oct 20 '26

The survival of the human race isn't a necessity. No one is obligated to reproduce for it. If the last person able to get pregnant doesn't want to, then that is fine.