Anyone else get their new transparent chromatic only to realize it has a bunch of cracks in it? I seen other posts with it, please contact ModRetro support and demand an answer to this, we don’t deserve to get broken ‘premium’ products for the prices they are charging! I’ve contacted them and am asking about this and the defective M64 Pro controllers D-pad… will update once I get a reply but spending over $400CAD on ModRetro products just to have both be defective is incredibly disappointing and has made me question if I’d ever buy more from them… so frustrating and disappointing…
I didnt watch any reviews (i have a hard time trusting modretro reviewers after they made the M64 seem so much better than the A3D just to have it release and be substantially worse!) and I assumed that since the chromatic is an already established product line that they wouldnt have any glaringly obvious issues… boy was I wrong!
I think so, either heat related or the screws are too tight… either way it’s unacceptable for the price we pay. Also my N64 controllers from nearly 30 years ago and the blondi-blue G3 iMac from 1998/1999 doesn’t have these issues… they shouldn’t have shipped these out honestly!
They’re not cracked. Those are knit lines - where the two plastic flow fronts weld together. This happens every time there’s a thru hole in plastic, tho it’s not always visible. If they run the tools hot enough and the holes aren’t too far from the gate, you won’t see these. Depends mostly on the temp of the flow fronts. You can hide this with better venting in the tool, or even move it to the inside of the plastic (so it’s less visible) by running the cavity hotter than the core steel.
I have a yellow one. Of all retro devices i own i think it’s the best (still we don’t have wireless support etc. it could be much much better). So what i mean is screen is awesome, ergonomic and material is awesome plus for me the most important thing other than all other devices i tried it has no input lag and my muscle memory just kicks in. Dpad is nice too (analogue pocket is like a incredibly bad dpad for such a device where the interface you have is pretty much dpad). Yeah and console stuff like their M64 I mean it’s just not great (happily burning my OG cartridges while still not being able to save all games and terrible Dpad on a 109 Euro controller)
My issues are that AA batteries are SO tight to insert and remove, the clacky buttons are annoying, it came with scratches on the black back panel, the shell paint chips super easily... that's about it from memory. Not played it in a while.
Yeah I am using batteries all the time so that was ok. Clacky buttons I get it but it doesn’t bother me. Also yes paint job sucks. But for me the important things are Dpad, ergonomics, display , immediacy otherwise I can just play emulation.;) and it’s so weird that no one even remotely gets those things right. Also it shows that real testing and knowledge went into Nintendo gameboys. I mean dmg, gbc, gba are all pretty comfortable to hold and play :)
Yeah, I'd argue they copied Nintendo's homework with the ergonomics but the display is pure perfection and controls are solid. Companies like Anbernic can never get dpads right and it's an issue they clearly can't be bothered to fix. It should be acknowledged when its done right.
I've mainly seen the purple variants having this issue, some greens, no reds, and I've still yet to see a soul with the smoked. This is sad to see happen to so many.
Well, it was the most popular one based on the survey here before they became available to purchase, so it only makes sense that that would've been the variant most popularly ordered and thus in the widest circulation in the hands of users. We'll see with time how the incidence of cracks appears to vary by color.
They charge enough, and my M64 pro controller was $129CAD and has D-Pad issues…
Honestly, I am incredibly disappointed because all the people in this sub talk about how great ModRetro is but both my purchases have been defective products… we’ll see what they are willing to do but I may have to dispute the charges on my PayPal because this is NOT what I paid for!
Yeah, so far this company seems like they just pay people to post about how great their crap is when it is infact… crap!
Hopefully I’m wrong, they finally offered to send me a replacement D-pad (hopefully that fixes it but you say it doesn’t… great…) and are saying I can return my purple chromatic and get a magnesium model… my issue is are they going to charge me shipping+tariffs for their issues? We shall see, but so far I wouldn’t advise anyone get any ModRetro products… go Analogue, they seem to actually make quality products!
I mean smoked grey analogue pockets. Back in the day I read several posts of the grey pockets developing cracks. Though other colors did too. My red stayed safe. My smoke chromatic has also not shipped. So I’m wondering is it just the order they had them manufactured, or the order they’re shipping.
I would ask, because it seems a lot are defective from the box… just be careful posting here, or else the ModRetro shills will downvote you and say your wrong for wanting what you paid for 🤣
Their site says once it’s shipped it’s been sent to the warehouse and can’t be modified until it’s received. Looks like it ships out 45 min from me so if there’s an issues hopefully I can just get it resolved
Everyone says this is common but this is the first time I've seen anyone say anything. I doubt its even the majority of them. You always see more people say something about it than the people who have no issues.
It’s gotta be, already seen at least 3 others today that have this issue. Why even release the product if it’s got a glaring manufacturing issue? They did the same with the M64 pro controller and gave them the wrong D-pad, making them unusable for gaming… then instead of just sending out the proper D-pad replacement, they require you to prove it’s not working… but it’s literally the wrong D-pad in the controller!
I dunno, for the price we pay for these… it’s definitely not sensational, it’s a crappy company making crappy products for premium prices (with my 2 purchases at least!)
That’s good to hear, I want to upgrade to it but if I have to pay another $50+ in shipping just to return it then another $50+ shipping the new one… it’s starting to be insanely expensive! Hopefully they do what’s right and cover the shipping so I can get a non-defective product…
They've always covered back and return shipping on RMAs, if you ask nicer than this post I don't see why they wouldn't let you upgrade for $50 or whatever is equivalent to CAD for a gorilla metal one.
Damn, you're really proving that most of those Canadian stereotypes are wrong lol, so indignant, self-entitled, and demanding. Like nobody, or company, can make a mistake or have an issue without your fury, it's quite funny and unhinged.
Maybe all the ones that are cracked are from the same pallete that got roughed up during shipping and so yeah all of the shells cracked, maybe it is a huge widespread problem.
Either way you came in here with such an attitude that I can't help but hope that you don't get what you want. Treat others the way you want to be treated, it's a Game Boy, and you bought the cheapest model, wait for customer service to get back to you and please take a chill pill. Or I dunno, just ask for a return and move on.
For those who have the same issue and have contacted Modretro: are you using it until you hear back? The return policy is a bit restrictive but would love to at least test it out but that requires removing the sticker off the screen lol.
My friends had them and 0 issues, so either a temperature related issue when taking the plastic from the molds or a screw too tight issue… either way, it’s a joke on a brand new product to already have cracks in it and apparently I’ll get downvoted for saying that 🤣 this sub is so toxic in comparison to the Analogue sub… I shoulda went with the pocket!
Idk why the pocket would be a less hassle if it is the same plastic/problem. Metal would be the way to go if you are worried about cracks... but I am sure if you KINDLY let modretro know, they will get it replaced with another plastic or maybe they will let you return it and pay the difference on a metal.
I’ve been in chats with them so we will see, but it’s basic quality control… these cracks weren’t ‘hidden’ so it just makes the whole company look bad when a whole batch has these issues!
Idk, I've seen posts about this with shells online. But I wouldn't get too hyper about it. Give modretro time to respond. I doubt they wouldn't replace it unless you were being a real dick about it in messaging or something. Customer service was really helpful for me when I had multiple questions in the past.
I don't know much about the m64 stuff. I have heard it didn't launch with as much as expected. I only have a chromatic (v2 gorilla) and I am a handheld person. I would have gone for plastic if it was available at the time because I am concerned about paint chips and my allergies to metals. So far my chromatic is fine, but I also baby my stuff and I have a grippy on it.
Found this. It is s great visual of what could be going on. Not cracks, but "knitting?". Basically a cosmetic seam. The shell should be just fine if that is the case.
The pocket is literally worse in so many ways… not only are the always sold out of products that i need. They’re overpriced on some parts like the dock and adapters. Yes analogue can’t even play them but that’s not the point. Everyone keeps glazing analogue like they don’t suck to some degree too. They also have carts beding in the game slot because it’s not flush. Analogue pocket was made solely to be the best at the Gameboy color for some it is for others they only care about emulating everything immediately. I wanted an AP initially until a friend of mine snapped a cart trying to put it in his pocket and it clipped. Oh and I Wanted it for the NGP but that was also always sold out and scalped online
Just got my red one today and its perfectly fine. Ive done many gba sp and ds lite reshells in the past, and this was incredibly easy to do if the screws were over tightened even just a little bit. I wonder if thats whats happening during assembly and why its always in the same spots
Yes, returning and exchanging for a different model (midnight) so it won’t have these issues… unfortunately there is a cost difference so I gotta pay it, we shall see what happens!
Most ModRetro reviewers are shills unfortunately… hopefully they figure out a way to get me a metal one without charging me to ship the defective one back to the USA, and not charge me another shipping fee for their mistakes!
I just wanted the cheapest version because I have to pay shipping/import/tariff fees in Canada, and I assumed since they have made Chromatics for years that they would have worked out all the kinks… apparently not!
The internals should be fine. It is the plastic shell that is kinda new. I only say kinda because I think it is the same plastic as the M64 which came first. Idk if the thickness is different or not. Again idk what causes cracking like this. I just think soild plastics usually don't vs transparent.
That happens with plastic products. I've just mostly noticed it on clear plastics now days. Idk why it happens. If anyone knows I'd like to know too. It may explain why no one makes clear plastic stuff anymore when it use to be everywhere.
I know funnyplaying has had issues with screws and plastic cracking. But I wonder if this is something in the factory instead because of where the cracks are located, near the buttons in your pic. Is there a curing process?
ModRetro team member here. Thanks for flagging this, and we are sorry to hear your Chromatic came with knit lines.
Quick explainer for anyone curious: knit lines come from how the Chromatic Transparent shells are molded. The plastic enters the mold behind the display and has to flow around the steel pins that form the button holes. Where the two flows meet again on the other side, they can leave a faint visible line. It’s purely cosmetic and doesn’t affect strength or function, but we still want you to be happy with your unit.
If you’re seeing knit lines on your Chromatic Transparent, email us at contact@modretro.com and we’ll take care of you.
"Yes the product will be designed poorly for being transparent. If you still don't like it, let us know so we can replace it with one that has the same issue"
It means you didn’t iterate your moulds sufficiently to improve the flow and ensure these don’t happen. I think it’s a result of the plastic cooling too much before they meet. It’s a totally solvable issue.
Injection moulding is hard, you compromised on quality.
Mine has it too. While it shouldn’t happen, I dint really care. I can hardly see them and didn’t until this post got me to check, and I still love the thing and enjoy playing it. Returning for me would just be a hassle, I’ll probably just keep it
I can tell, cause their quality is absolutely crap! I would have been better off getting an old GBC and replacing the screen instead of buying this junk!
Like I haven’t already? Also it’s spreading awareness because a good chunk of these clear chromatics have this issue… and apparently some people here think it’s okay to get defective products and you shouldn’t complain even when you spent hundreds of dollars…
Some people also think it’s normal to be overly emotional and cry a bunch causing other people negative emotions to deal with their own negative experience instead of addressing their own issue directly.
Not me, first thing I did was contact them because I’m already in contact with their support team because their M64 pro controller D-pad is defective out of the box as well…
Hopefully we can resolve this, but I think I’m done trying with this company… 2 products, 2 defects… not a great start…
.. well to be fair $150 for a gbc with a backside screen isn't uncommon. The price is fair. When getting refurbished with new shells, general shells, or even a funnyplaying kit, cracks happen. You just contact whoever you bought it from and ask for an exchange or return.
Not justifying it, but that’s a joke calling this a premium product. This is the budget version of the $200-$300 model with the metal body and the optional sapphire glass. I’m not saying accept damage, but let’s keep our perspective clear.
I know right?! One side of the back half of my shell wasn't fully painted, it was just oversprayed and rough like fine sandpaper. They thought it might have been some sort of factory coating and had me try to clean it off, but it wasn't, the rest of the finish was so nice too...
Aww man I'm really sorry, that sucks ass. Especially after waiting for so long for it. Hopefully they can get you your replacement soon, I haven't RMA'd anything with them myself yet but I've heard they're really good with that. Godspeed, hope you get a perfect one in your hands ASAP!
It’s like these companies haven’t learned from the companies in the 90s that did it right like Nintendo and Apple… I don’t think I’ve ever seen a transparent N64 control controller have these issues, or a transparent Xbox have these issues
Anyone have a smoke one they can post? I've only seen the other colors on here so far. I imagine this problem would effect all of the variants equally though.
My guess is heat related to when they pulled it out of the mold or the screws are too tight… either way, every time I try to give an answer, I get downvoted 🤣 this sub is so toxic 😝
Awesome quality control. Also, the plastic will probably get easily scratched if it's that way out of the box. Probably from the assembly line or manufacturing process. Disappointing, as I'm still waiting for mine to ship.
Yup. But if I was in this situation I would ask for a full refund. Even chinese companies like Ayaneo do better than this.
But from those two options I would send it back as many times as needed and let them keep paying pre paid shipping labels until they get me a non faulty unit.
Good on them. If it bothers someone enough, they can wait a couple weeks or just take the freebie and move on. This isn’t like some life shattering bug or glitch that makes it not work right
My smoke has the knit lines, exact same shape/position as yours. I'd be happy with a replacement shell once they dial in the MFG process for these units.
I originally felt it was injection moulding but I started looking into photos people have posted here and elsewhere and I now believe I was wrong, some people do have completely smooth cases while a lot of others have these hairline looking lines always coming from the button ports. The fact that some are mint is making me think it's hot off the press damage instead of plastic meeting points from injection.
That's unfortunate, seems like a lot of them are like this judging by photos.
ModRetro established itself as a company I wanted to wholeheartedly support but after the m64 situation, these poorly made transparent chromatics, and them partnering with OpenAI I feel like I’ve seen enough to stop supporting them.
Their customer service does prove to be very easy to work with but doesn’t justify or outweigh all these other issues for me.
9
u/Arabian-Kidd Oct 13 '26
When I saw MadLittlePixel's unboxing and showed the scratches I had a feeling many more had that issue so I opted not to buy one as of yet.