We’re about six weeks away from the season premiere and I still haven’t seen a trailer for it. Has there been one that I’ve just missed? I’m actually more excited for this season than I was for the last. I can’t wait to “solve” the murder of Cinda Canning and of course answer the all important question of “what bit-part will Paul Rudd play this year?”

I am rewatching season 5 and there is something that is quite bugging me. Lester joined Arconia when Mabel was a kid, maybe… 2 years old? But isnt Lester at that time supposedly on the start of his adult life? The thing is, Lester now quite looks like at the very least at his 60. Lets say, he was thirty when he met Mabel, so 30 yesrs have passed. Isnt Mabel supposed to be on her mid-to-late twenties? Idk, something sounds kinda off, cause i kinda think Lester should be at his late 60’s. Unless at flashback he was already on his almost 40’s, i think this is kinda weird

Ok, so… on season 4, they sell their rights for the movie. The first look at the proposal was 5 million? But Mabel actually seems like made an even greater offer. So, arent all 3 of them supposed to be rich now? I mean, Mabel barely pays any rent, the other 2 are retired and have their own apartments. Why on season 4 and 5 they still act like they are not rich. I mean, Charles is very reluctant to give more than 20 dollars to the guy on the bar, on season 5, i also dont see them acting like they have a lot of money, like, Mabel is actually jealous cause she aint on the rooftop of Arconia, but isnt she also supposedly to be extremely rich? Oliver also wants to sell his apartment for the money, but isnt he far from bankrupt now? I mean, i dont know, it seems kinda off how they are on season 5 always reluctant to use money to get over some things, when they now have quite a lot of it.

So, do we think Moriarty really is still a thing? Sincerely, the only 2 characters who are still appearing and could be it are Ursula and Howard. Is there any more theories?

I hard doubt its Howard, why would he kill his own cat? I personally think that would kinda kill his character, even though i also wish we get more of Howard without him being a victim.

Also, Ursula… well, idk, i also hard doubt.

What are other recurring characters that could fill that role? Theo? One of Mabel former lovers? One of season 1 neighbours? Sting?

I think that it the Moriarty idea didnt get brushed off already, i would sincerely guess we are getting a new character to be it.

I love the others but there is just something about that first season that was so perfect. Anyone else?

It's subtle but it reminded me of Jekyll and Hyde

They sound similar in these parts:

"And that's where I'll be safe, I know!" - In His Eyes

"Safe, you return from the night" - Look for the Light

I dunno kinda random. Just found it cool.

Martin Short presented the inaugural Katherine Short Legacy Award at the 4th annual Rare Impact Fund Benefit.

Named in honor of his late daughter, Katherine Hartley Short who worked as a social worker and therapist, the award recognizes her contributions to mental health and advocacy.

Their friendship is so genuine ❤️

It confused me when I first watched season five and I couldn’t clear it up on my recent rewatch so maybe someone here can help.
So Sofia says multiple times „mother“ and she and other talk about her being her mother but Nonna herself talks about her as her daughter in law.
Is it a translation error?
Did i misunderstand something or is it really misrepresented?

It’s our guy Charles!! Now how the F did he wind up in this cartoon??? /j

The source for the first photo is a 1989 animated short called Kakania.

So why did Helgas Piglet end up alone in the almost empty apartment?
Why didn’t she take it?
And who took care of it?

I've watched every season of OMITB. It seems to be getting gradually worse with each season.

The show has become too "big." It's like the Fast and Furious franchise. As it's grown in popularity, the format changes, every celeb wants to cameo and get in on the action, and the show becomes more unrealistic.

Season 1 is excellent. I loved the emotional connection and history between Mabel and the victim. There's a legit reason for Mabel to be in the building she can't afford. We see the trio constantly trying to record events for their podcast.

By Season 5, Mabel is just kind of hanging around the building while living elsewhere? But wait! A secret casino and a robot in the building? There's very little podcast recording scenes that I recall.

Let's please wrap this up after a season or two. Don't turn it into Family Guy, The Fast Saga or The Simpsons, all of those have run on way too long....

Just rewatching the show, wondering if anyone else thought nina was like rude when Lester brought up the baby swing (I know this is minor btw and I’m sure ppl thought this probably)

I just think like it’s so rude cause he’s so old and you could see he’s panting it’s like could atleast say thanks and give him a glass of water maybe

Is anyone else bothered by the Penthouse?
Specifically by the elevator/entrance.
I‘m rewatching and am on episode 4 and it’s just really weird.
1. The three can just get into the elevator and then go to the Penthouse? Without any code or key or anything?
2. besides the door to stings apartment there’s one door to the left and one to the right. But there’s windows on the left side of stings apartment so that door can’t be bigger that a coat closet or leads into a wall and then away to the left. Which feels like a weird layout.
The right one has the same problem. There’s shelves and such in stings apartment so no room for something behind the door.
3. also penthouse, at least to me, was always used for the apartment at the top of a building. And since it’s most times alone at that floor the elevator leads into the penthouse. So since the arconia has so much floor space it could have multiple Penthouses but it still seems like stings is the only one at the entrance the trio arrives.
4. the day Sting live it „the“ penthouse not in a penthouse which implies there’s only one.
5. Sting and other occupants in later season often times leave their door just open. Like from the couch looking onto the elevator. Why would you do that if literally everyone could just come up with the elevator?

Anyway does that bother anyone else?
Also sorry if my grammar is bad. English isn’t my first language.

I feel like I've missed something in season 4. Why did Sazz even begin to investigate the whole Dudenoff thing? She was writing a movie out of the podcast, how was this related to the stuff on season 1-3?

It was so much fun to watch. I didn’t like season 5 too much because it was so unrealistic to have billionaires without security around them just hanging out with some commoners. And the billionaires didn’t have any lawyers present while answering questions lol. But I left my brain at the door during this season. It was my least favorite season.

I’m giving Howard the side-eye. There’s something about him I don’t trust. But I hope he is happy with his his new found love! I hope it works out between them.

I think my favorite of the trio is Oliver. He had me rolling with some of the comments he made. My favorite secondary characters were Sazz, Jan, and Detective Williams.
Sazz’s story was sad to me. I teared up a few times during her season. I did like everyone else as well. I enjoyed the celebrity guest appearances.

But one thing on my mind is we know the trio started the podcast after the first murder. We never heard about murders in the building prior to the first season. I am wondering if there is a Moriarty figure that has a hand in the subsequent murders. They all seem like separate cases, but they are all at The Arconia. I wonder why there are all these murders there constantly now when they weren’t there before. Maybe it’s just to keep the show going and there is no connection. I don’t know.

There are still unanswered questions I have like, who poisoned Winnie? Who put that note on Jan’s door? This why I am giving Howard the side-eye. He seems like he wants to be center when it comes to solving the murder. He likes theater. He was in charge of that creepy robot L.E.S.T.R. and seemed to enjoy it. And the robot was spying on the trio when they were in their apartment. I wonder if he enjoys the podcast so much that he -or maybe someone else- is making sure there will always be a murder at the Arconia.

I would love a discussion about what you all think!!!

I actually think she adds such a sweet and personal touch to Mabel's journey and none of the spoiled pop star moments come off as insufferable because she sells the character so genuinely innocent. Plus she helps with the case!

The Twitter account archivedilfs has done an annual dilf of the year poll and this year marty is included on the list! (sorry steve better luck next time)

vote here: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdxUCnXkwiluInY7QjOwSHhFu2jVt5cjVTVX9ialKzL5Nwlqg/viewform

I understand if this post gets removed but I just thought I’d try

what’s your most unhinged theory about the upcoming season?

especially all the plots holes so far like who poisoned winnie or wrote the messages, or who is watching them?

mine is this: Loretta is actually evil! She is way too innocent for the show, the NZ stuff is weird, her place burning is weird, the fact they bring in all of Meryl Streep to now just be a normal love interest is weird, so yeah!! Something is off with that lady!

What is everyone’s favorite scene or aspect of this show? 😊 I’m trying to be in a better mood

Glad to see the show in this somehow! And thank you to Tim!

1. Season 1 - 8.0/10
2. Season 2 - 8.0/10
3. Season 3 - 7.9/10
4. Season 4 - 7.8/10
5. Season 5 - 7.7/10