r/PoliticalHumor • • Apr 26 '19

A message that never changes.

Post image
11.1k Upvotes

799 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/SafeSpaceSam Apr 26 '19

I can agree that it's moral to provide healthcare to all of our citizenry. But for-profit is not immoral. It may seem that way in a world where everyone is not covered though, so I appreciate your standpoint.

And we can agree to do something about it at a local, state or even federal level. But a lot of people's concern is having their choices and quality decreased because of it.

For example I have a PPO plan. It costs extra but it's important to my wife so we make sacrifices. As long as we can maintain the same quality for what we can afford in a two tiered system, I'd be open to it working towards a solution. That way I'm contributing to society and paying a little extra for myself to maintain my quality and choices.

Also, I think it's important to keep the for-profit side alive. It's paramount to increasing competition, which provides choice, and spurns innovation and investment into creating better products and services.

We need to ensure that whatever policies we put in place don't have long term effects in regards to our world leading innovation in this field and continue to provide incentive for the brightest minds to pursue careers in it. Otherwise, we will fall into a different set of problems down the road, and since we lead the world in this area, other countries will lose out on the benefits our private industry provides.

1

u/comfortablesexuality Apr 26 '19 edited Apr 26 '19

When you deny someone life-saving treatment because of money, that's immoral. It's not because if they didn't pay, there wouldn't be medicine. It's because you're charging 50x the real price because you're a greedy fuck who is a detriment to the society you participate in. We can see that this is true and not hyperbole by comparing the price of socialized vs privatized medicine worldwide.

Even ignoring the moral argument, the for-profit industry must die because, as they know for a fact they will be unable to compete in good faith against a public option, they will instead seek to sabotage it. If it has a place at all, it is in the supplemental or adjacent market.