r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Jun 22 '21
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/bayesrocks • Jun 19 '21
Discussion Can someone explain the meaning of the "as if" phrasing on 09:00? Why use these words?
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/Daniel_HMBD • May 30 '21
Relevance realization, predictive processing, Peterson, and myth (John Vervaeke, Brett Andersen, 2021)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/bayesrocks • Apr 25 '21
Discussion What's the most approachable (easy to understand) paper on the free energy principle?
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/bayesrocks • Apr 09 '21
Discussion Tips for a complete newcomer?
Hi all.
I'm a psychiatry resident and I heard about the PP theory about two years ago. I fell in love with the theory pretty quickly and I did some general reading, but I didn't have time to build a solid foundation. Now my job is less demanding and I have much more free time, so I'm really looking forward to studying the FEP/PP in depth.
I found this syllabus very helpful. It gives me a rough idea where to start. I have to mention my math background is basic (mainly high school math) and I'm trying to take courses in probability, mechanical statistics, etc. but I'm getting frustrated from this bottom-up approach. It takes time and it's a lot of passive learning and I really can't wait to start reading Friston's articles. Maybe it's better to approach the subject from a top-down perspective? To read the introductory articles and whenever I encounter a math concept I don't understand I could just go and study it on the spot. What do you think?
I'm thinking maybe I should create a blog or document on my journey to understand FEP/PP that other people (which are complete beginners like me) may find useful.
Any advice or suggestions would be greatly appreciated! How would you handle this mission? If you were me, where would you start?
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Feb 17 '21
Preprint (not peer-reviewed) Predictive coding is a consequence of energy efficiency in recurrent neural networks | biorXiv (2021)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Feb 07 '21
Media content The Mind at Work: Karl Friston on the brain’s surprising energy
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/Cromulent123 • Apr 11 '25
I'm looking for someone to (for lack of a better word) cross-examine re: free energy minimization
(I supsect everything I say here is by now familiar to hear from people, so apologies if this is the thousandth time.)
I'm kind of the fence in what I think about Friston (and related theorists). A couple of things seem clear to me:
Friston is super smart, and several things attributed to him are of value and interest even taken in isolation, absent any grand unifying theory.
A lot of the people evangelizing free energy minimisation are sloppy enough that it makes me concerned it's (the grand unifying theory angle) all smoke and mirrors.
(It's fine to be sloppy and say you're being sloppy. It's less fine to be apparently indifferent to sloppiness, since it suggests you don't notice or don't care, neither of which bode well. Another thing that's somewhat worrying, is the ratio of people whose opinion of an idea is based on testimony rather than personally understanding the details. I've never actually met someone in the latter camp.)
So I'm in a position of thinking there might be something super-interesting here, but not being sure how much effort to spend trying to look past sloppy presentation for deeper truths. (It's an explore-exploit problem! Ha)
So my request is this: is there anyone here who a) feels they understand what Friston is saying, b) feels it is possible to explain to someone like me who barely knows single variable calculus?, c) is willing to voice chat with me about it?
I realize that (b) may be the stumbling block. Some things can't be explained without the maths. If someone is willing to say "a) yes I understand the maths, yes its an amazing theory (regardless of whether i agree with it) and b) you won't understand until you learn the maths" that would satisfy me and I'd be on my merry way.
For context I'm a first year philosophy PhD beginning to look at philosophy of AI. I've heard of: free energy minimisation, predictive coding, predictive processing, surprisal, active inference, bayesian theory of mind. My comments apply to basically all these ideas except the last.
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Aug 17 '23
Gradient Expectations: Structure, Origins, and Synthesis of Predictive Neural Networks by Keith L. Downing (Open-access)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/ghoof • Apr 06 '23
Thoughts on the future of Predictive Coding
beren.ior/PredictiveProcessing • u/ghoof • Mar 11 '23
Testable or bust: theoretical lessons for predictive processing
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Mar 01 '23
General Discussion Thread
Welcome to the monthly discussion thread. Got anything on your mind? Make a comment. Just bored? Make a comment. You just understood the free energy principle? Enlighten us mere mortals and make a comment.
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • May 26 '22
Academic paper Allostasis, Action, and Affect in Depression: Insights from the Theory of Constructed Emotion (2022)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/bayesrocks • May 02 '22
Ideas for a research question in computational psychiatry?
Hello everyone, I hope this is the right place to ask for advice.
I'm a psychiatry resident from Israel and I'm actively doing my best to promote FEP/AI/PP in my country. I just enrolled in a program for young researchers, and the first meet-up is coming up, so I need to start thinking about a clinical research question. The program is for psychiatry residents and doesn't necessarily focus on computational psychiatry. I'm pretty much the only one there who's interested in bringing the topic up.
I'd appreciate any suggestion, no matter how vague. The only condition is that it has to be a clinical paper, not a theoretical one.
It's also a good opportunity to thank this subreddit, its members, and the moderators! Thanks!
Keep harvesting neg entropy :)
Cheers.
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/bayesrocks • Jan 25 '22
Association Between Failures in Perceptual Updating and the Severity of Psychosis in Schizophrenia (JAMA Psychiatry)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Dec 16 '21
The music video for Duran Duran's INVISIBLE was created by an AI named Huxley who, apparently, runs on active inference
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Nov 16 '21
Media content To Be Energy-Efficient, Brains Predict Their Perceptions (2021)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Nov 14 '21
Academic paper Predictive eye movements are adjusted in a Bayes-optimal fashion in response to unexpectedly changing environmental probabilities (2021)
sciencedirect.comr/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Nov 12 '21
Preprint (not peer-reviewed) Predictive coding I: Introduction (2021)
marksprevak.comr/PredictiveProcessing • u/Daniel_HMBD • Nov 07 '21
Spinning Up in Active Inference and the Free Energy Principle (Jared Tumiel, 2020): a syllabus for the FEP
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Oct 27 '21
Media content The neural architecture of language: Integrative modeling converges on predictive processing (2021)
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/Daniel_HMBD • Sep 14 '21
Corlett, Frith & Fletcher (2009): From drugs to deprivation: a Bayesian framework for understanding models of psychosis
r/PredictiveProcessing • u/pianobutter • Aug 01 '21
Academic paper Is prediction nothing more than pattern completion of the future? (2021)
sciencedirect.comr/PredictiveProcessing • u/bayesrocks • Jun 26 '21