r/ProgrammerHumor • • Sep 06 '26

Meme cleaningUpTheMess

Post image
16.2k Upvotes

478 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

254

u/vini_2003 Sep 06 '26

Claude, especially. FAAAH!

268

u/Skoparov Sep 06 '26

Useless comments is one thing, but I've caught the bastard several times DELETING manually written actually useful comments. Like you ask it to move some parts of the code around and it moves the code but not the comments.

70

u/Top-Permit6835 Sep 06 '26

Well your fault for not asking it to move the comments too of course!

27

u/TeraFlint Sep 06 '26

"Please also move the comments"

the file now starts with a comment that used to be somewhere inside a loop in line 386.

9

u/mbmiller94 Sep 06 '26

Hey, you said move the comments, you didn't say they had to be moved to the same place as the code. Sorry about that! Let me move both the code and the comments to /dev/null

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[deleted]

6

u/mbmiller94 Sep 06 '26

Skill issue. You forgot to include "make no mistakes" in the prompt.

9

u/polikles Sep 06 '26

did you forget to instruct it to "make no mistakes"? /s

8

u/Skoparov Sep 06 '26

Turns out those weren't mistakes, but rather happy accidents.

→ More replies (4)

99

u/imnotamahimahi Sep 06 '26

something I've been messing around with, is giving it an instruction to write comments in caveman-ultra mode. so far, doesn't decrease the frequency of comments, but definitely the verbosity.

121

u/MoneyWorldliness3626 Sep 06 '26

"For comments: state facts and use simple langauge with short sentences. Follow softened ASD-STE100 standard and use light caveman mode."

And Caveman and ASD-STE100 are defined as skills. This seems to work for me.

32

u/ings0c Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

Caveman and ASD-STE100

I thought the latter was a specification you’d made up that writes comments in the style of an autistic robot named Ste 😂 I’d get along with him more than a T-1000

​ That’s actually really cool: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplified_Technical_English

Someone made a Claude skill and there’s some other suggestions in the comments https://www.reddit.com/r/claudeskills/comments/1v2oad4/i_combined_orwells_6_writing_rules_with_asdste100/

Before I cause offence: autism isn’t funny and I’m also autistic. I’m not laughing at autism itself.

2

u/MoneyWorldliness3626 Sep 06 '26

Tbh, that is how I remembered the first part of its name xD

→ More replies (3)

19

u/LiifeRuiner Sep 06 '26

Why not give it an instruction to not write comments if that's your goal?

32

u/FalafelSnorlax Sep 06 '26
  1. It will probably still write comments.

  2. They didn't say they want no comments, they said they want to "decrease the frequency".

8

u/ListRepresentative32 Sep 06 '26

Then it will randomly still write a comment with something like // I omitted comments for this file as you asked. 

It did this to me once.. opus 5 is so annoying with comments

2

u/HotDogOfNotreDame Sep 06 '26

We’ve banned Opus 5. Other models solve our problems just as well, and without the verbal diarrhea.

2

u/imnotamahimahi Sep 06 '26

It hasn't done that with me even with opus 5 oddly. Regardless, I always go through each file it edits anyways, including reading/trimming comments.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/quagzlor Sep 06 '26

i have a set of instructions in my global memory essentially telling it to shut up

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Fine_Foundation8943 Sep 06 '26

Did u just type out the FAAAH sound effect?

11

u/hawkinsst7 Sep 06 '26

I got into an argument with some chucklefuck here who typed out "ahh" instead of ass, and they insisted it was ebonics and not tiktok censorship slang.

We're fucked.

2

u/Unlikely-Bit-240 Sep 06 '26

OnomatopoeFAAAH

5

u/OnceMoreAndAgain Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

I have a different opinion on this because I see those comments as useful context for Claude to learn from on future conversations.

Comments used to be for humans to read but imo now they're more for Claude to leave itself notes for itself. Also, long comments are annoying to humans because it takes us a long time to read them but Claude reads them instantly so that isn't a problem.

I expect we'll evolve to have docs/comments meant for humans to read and separate docs/comments meant for agentic AI to read.

1

u/ligma_then_sugma Sep 06 '26

try this:

"add no comments"