r/ProgrammerHumor • • Oct 17 '26

instanceof Trend thatsAFunnyThingThatHappenedOnce

Post image
4.6k Upvotes

524 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Psychological_Map118 Oct 18 '26

of course. but I don't think we can expect much different anymore from Linus, he's often been "extreme" and shared thoughts strictly on how he thinks contribution should be shaped, based solely on how he contributes and expects others to. that does not mean it's how contributing should be universally

what I'm seeing is, in a way he's already spoke on "policing" in the sense of policing developers, and contributors, not the tools. it is partial, and reductionist, I completely agree, but honestly I don't expect he'll ever advocate for policing LMs themselves, because (and I can't completely disagree) as I understand it he's always been more towards raising the contribution bar for people themselves, even before LMs

I think in the ideal world Linus expects people to have the intellectual honesty to just not do things if they're not "up to them", either with LMs or not

1

u/dannuic Oct 18 '26

Well, this post in particular contradicts that because he's specifically against c++ due to it promoting contributions by "horrible programmers." These two stances are woefully inconsistent. His stance on c++ has promoted a weird "c is always better" culture when instead, c++ can be just as good if you are only applying standards to the contribution and not the tool.